⭐️ 3.5/5 — Prickly tutor meets golden boy jock → instant chemistry + unexpected sweetness 💞
🌶 2/5 — Soft simmer, cozy heat without the burn ❤️
Okay, so… I went in expecting your typical campus fluff, but this one had a little extra charm. The banter was cute, the chemistry hit right away, and honestly? The dimpled jock completely stole the show for me. It’s not earth-shattering, but it’s sweet, easy to binge, and gave me exactly the cozy college romance vibes I was craving. 🥰
🥍👓 The MCs 🥍👓
Logan — Smart, a little insecure, with those glasses and that overthinking brain that never quits. He’s convinced he’s too nerdy, too much, not enough—classic “doesn’t see his own worth” vibes. Watching him get flustered was half the charm. 👓
Josh — Lacrosse bro, bi, surprisingly soft-hearted. Yeah, he had his “dumb jock” moments, but the way he straight-up said he wanted to date Logan instead of playing games? Damn refreshing. Confident, funny, and lowkey a sweetheart. 🥍
🍔💞 Poodly-Doo, Burgers, and Boner 🍔💞
Quote:
Logan: “You know we’re not supposed to eat in here.”
Josh: “I once saw a guy lay out the equivalent of a Thanksgiving spread. He legit had a whole turkey leg. No one said poodly-doo, so I think it’ll be okay. There are only what, ten people up here right now, and three of them are eating too. Besides, I brought you one.” Logan: “I’m fine.”
Josh: “You sure? Cheeseburger with the works, including hot sauce but no mayo.”
Logan: “How do you know that’s what I always get?”
Josh: “That group project. We were in Saitha’s dorm one night and we ordered food, remember?”
Logan: “Good memory. I’m not hungry. Let’s get started.”
Josh: (raises his voice) “Anyone want a Goldberg Burger, hot—“
Logan: “Shhh! Fine. I’ll take it.”
Josh: (grins) “You’re welcome.”
God, I didn’t know what it was about him that made it so fun to rile him up. Well, I sort of did, and it made me feel a little like a playground bully trying to pick on him, but none of it was mean-spirited. At least, I didn’t think it was, and I guess he was okay with it, too, because seconds later, he was savaging that burger like he hadn’t eaten in a week, while I tried to ignore what the gloss of burger grease on his lips was doing to my cock.
---
💭 The second Josh dropped “poodly-doo,” I lost it. 🤣 But also??? The way he remembered Logan’s exact burger order from months ago?? That’s boyfriend behavior in disguise. 🥹😍
💭 And let’s be real—Logan demolishing that burger while Josh tries not to pop a boner? That’s romance, baby. 😏😌💖
🌶💦 Don’t Judge Me on That One Nut 🌶💦
Quote:
Logan: “You’re annoyingly cocky sometimes.”
Josh: “You’re annoyingly sexy.”
[cue: nipple biting, groaning, pants half-off, cocks grinding like their lives depend on it]
Josh: “Oh fuck—” (nuts in two seconds)
Josh: (horrified) “I can last longer, I swear.”
Logan: (laughing and chuckling against Logan’s chest) 😂
💭 Messy, clumsy, uncontrollable, and hot. Nothing polished, nothing rehearsed—just two guys wrecking each other for the first time and finding out it’s everything they didn’t know they needed. 😚💕
💭 Realistic fumbling sex over porn-star perfection every damn time. 🤌🏻✨️🙂↕️
📝 TLDR 📝
Pick this up if you’re into:
🎓💘 College romance vibes (tutor x athlete)
🌈🥍 Bi, dimpled jock who knows what he wants
👓🤭 A slightly grumpy but adorable nerd losing the fight against attraction
🔥☕ Low spice but juuust enough heat to keep you warm at night
💞🥰 Light angst, a bundle of insecurities, and a sweet HFN that’ll leave you smiling
-
Quotes:
He was all casual cool-guy as he spoke, the outside of his thigh leaning against the table, his other hand draped around a tray weighed down with a giant baked potato. How the hell he could make carrying a baked potato look sexy was beyond me.
-
“What the hell was that?” Jesse squinted in my direction with obvious disapproval.
“Saying hello to someone.” Nate offered obliviously. “I believe they’re referred to as social skills.”
“Nooooo, I’m asking Logan. Hot Lacrosse Guy was trying to be nice. When a guy that hot is trying to be nice, you be nice back—even if they’re a slacker—not squeeze a water bottle like you wish it was his neck. That’s in the gay playbook of life, for fuck’s sake.”
I definitely didn’t wish the water bottle was Josh’s neck. In fact, there was a horrible split second where I’d wondered how the thickness of his cock might measure up. “No it’s not. I’m not going to be nice to some slacker jock just because he’s hot.”
-
He jolted as I spread his cheeks. “Wha—” he stuttered into a whisper as I knelt and buried my face between his spread thighs, flicking my tongue over his hole and tasting him. ”Oh fuck, no one’s ever… I haven’t... Jesus.”
“Is this okay?”
“Yesssss. I want it, Logan. Fuck, I want it bad. I swear I’m gonna rub a hole through your mattress.”
-
“Holy fuck.”
“I’m not sure there was anything holy about that.”
-
“God, I’m such an idiot sometimes.”
“Hey now, don’t go stealing my title. I prefer to be the resident dumbass.”
“You’re most definitely not a dumbass.”
“Then I guess we’ve both got insecurities to work on.”
-
“So exactly how cute do you find Sam?”
“Are you serious? Are you having a rare moment of insecurity, Joshua?”
“I’ve already forgotten what he looks like. Funny how that happens when I’m around you.”
“I was just fishing.”
“Well, you caught me. You keep catching me over and over, and I wouldn’t change it for anything.”
-
⚠️ Detailed spoiler below ⛔️
RC and MCs:
🥍👓 MM, strict top/bottom
🥍👓 Joshua Pickett aka Josh yo and Logan Jenkins yo
🥍👓 Josh: Part of the Lacrosse team in the U's athletic program
🥍👓 Logan: -
🥍👓 Josh: Top, straight to bi, wavy chestnut curly hair, lean built, broad shoulders, over 6ft, dimples,
🥍👓 Logan: Bottom, gay, floppy dark hair, silvery-hazel eyes, glasses with stylish navy plastic frames, sharp nose
Genre and tropes:
🥍👓 MM contemporary romance
🥍👓 New adult
🥍👓 College romance
🥍👓 Enemies-to-lovers
🥍👓 Grumpy/sunshine
🥍👓 Jock/nerd
🥍👓 Opposites attract
🥍👓 Forced proximity
🥍👓 Bi-awakening
🥍👓 First times
🥍👓 Pet names: -
Safety info:
🥍👓 Angst: Low
🥍👓 OPD: Logan had one date with Chet, but it didn’t go anywhere. No further on-page details about the date.
🥍👓 Cheating/sharing: No
🥍👓 Third act breakup: No
🥍👓 Ending: HFN
🥍👓 Epilogue: Yes (10 months later)
🥍👓 POV: Dual, 1st person
🥍👓 Series structure: Interconnected standalone
Spice and kinks:
Frotting, rimming, finger fucking, blowjob, condom, anal sex
CW/TW:
Explicit sexual content, alcohol consumption