What do you think?
Rate this book
Sebastian St. Cyr #19
What Cannot Be Said
A seemingly idyllic summer picnic ends in a macabre murder that echoes a pair of slayings fourteen years earlier in this riveting new historical mystery from the USA Today bestselling author of Who Cries for the Lost .
July 1815: The Prince Regent’s grandiose plans to celebrate Napoléon’s recent defeat at Waterloo are thrown into turmoil when Lady McInnis and her daughter Emma are found brutally murdered in Richmond Park, their bodies posed in a chilling imitation of the stone effigies once found atop medieval tombs. Bow Street magistrate Sir Henry Lovejoy immediately turns to his friend Sebastian St. Cyr, Viscount Devlin, for help with the investigation. For as Devlin discovers, Lovejoy’s own wife and daughter were also murdered in Richmond Park, their bodies posed in the same bizarre postures. A traumatized ex-soldier was hanged for their killings. So is London now confronting a malicious copyist? Or did Lovejoy help send an innocent man to the gallows?
Aided by his wife, Hero, who knew Lady McInnis from her work with poor orphans, Devlin finds himself exploring a host of unsavory characters from a vicious chimney sweep to a smiling but decidedly lethal baby farmer. Also coming under increasing scrutiny is Sir Ivo McInnis himself, along with a wounded Waterloo veteran—who may or may not have been Laura McInnis’s lover—and a charismatic young violinist who moonlights as a fencing master and may have formed a dangerous relationship with Emma. But when Sebastian’s investigation turns toward man about town Basil Rhodes, he quickly draws the fury of the Palace, for Rhodes is well known as the Regent’s favorite illegitimate son.
Then Lady McInnis’s young niece and nephew are targeted by the killer, and two more women are discovered murdered and arranged in similar postures. With his own life increasingly in danger, Sebastian finds himself drawn inexorably toward a conclusion far darker and more horrific than anything he could have imagined.
July 1815: The Prince Regent’s grandiose plans to celebrate Napoléon’s recent defeat at Waterloo are thrown into turmoil when Lady McInnis and her daughter Emma are found brutally murdered in Richmond Park, their bodies posed in a chilling imitation of the stone effigies once found atop medieval tombs. Bow Street magistrate Sir Henry Lovejoy immediately turns to his friend Sebastian St. Cyr, Viscount Devlin, for help with the investigation. For as Devlin discovers, Lovejoy’s own wife and daughter were also murdered in Richmond Park, their bodies posed in the same bizarre postures. A traumatized ex-soldier was hanged for their killings. So is London now confronting a malicious copyist? Or did Lovejoy help send an innocent man to the gallows?
Aided by his wife, Hero, who knew Lady McInnis from her work with poor orphans, Devlin finds himself exploring a host of unsavory characters from a vicious chimney sweep to a smiling but decidedly lethal baby farmer. Also coming under increasing scrutiny is Sir Ivo McInnis himself, along with a wounded Waterloo veteran—who may or may not have been Laura McInnis’s lover—and a charismatic young violinist who moonlights as a fencing master and may have formed a dangerous relationship with Emma. But when Sebastian’s investigation turns toward man about town Basil Rhodes, he quickly draws the fury of the Palace, for Rhodes is well known as the Regent’s favorite illegitimate son.
Then Lady McInnis’s young niece and nephew are targeted by the killer, and two more women are discovered murdered and arranged in similar postures. With his own life increasingly in danger, Sebastian finds himself drawn inexorably toward a conclusion far darker and more horrific than anything he could have imagined.
384 pages, Paperback
First published April 16, 2024
378 people are currently reading
6306 people want to read
About the author
C.S. Harris
23 books3,023 followersCandice Proctor, aka C.S. Harris and C.S. Graham, is the bestselling, award-winning author of more than a dozen novels including the Sebastian St. Cyr Regency mystery series written under the name C.S. Harris, the new C.S. Graham thriller series co-written with Steven Harris, and seven historical romances. She is also the author of a nonfiction historical study of the French Revolution. Her books are available worldwide and have been translated into over twenty different languages.
Candice graduated Phi Beta Kappa, summa cum laude with a degree in Classics before going on to earn an MA and Ph.D. in history. A former academic, she has taught at the University of Idaho and Midwestern State University in Texas. She also worked as an archaeologist on a variety of sites including a Hudson's Bay Company Fort in San Juan Island, a Cherokee village in Tennessee, a prehistoric kill site in Victoria, Australia, and a Roman cemetery and medieval manor house in Winchester, England. Most recently, she spent many years as a partner in an international business consulting firm.
The daughter of a career Air Force officer and university professor, Proctor loves to travel and has spent much of her life abroad. She has lived in Spain, Greece, England, France, Jordan, and Australia. She now makes her home in New Orleans, Louisiana, with her husband, retired Army officer Steve Harris, her two daughters, and an ever-expanding number of cats.
Candice graduated Phi Beta Kappa, summa cum laude with a degree in Classics before going on to earn an MA and Ph.D. in history. A former academic, she has taught at the University of Idaho and Midwestern State University in Texas. She also worked as an archaeologist on a variety of sites including a Hudson's Bay Company Fort in San Juan Island, a Cherokee village in Tennessee, a prehistoric kill site in Victoria, Australia, and a Roman cemetery and medieval manor house in Winchester, England. Most recently, she spent many years as a partner in an international business consulting firm.
The daughter of a career Air Force officer and university professor, Proctor loves to travel and has spent much of her life abroad. She has lived in Spain, Greece, England, France, Jordan, and Australia. She now makes her home in New Orleans, Louisiana, with her husband, retired Army officer Steve Harris, her two daughters, and an ever-expanding number of cats.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 395 reviews
May 10, 2024
This used to be my favorite English historical mystery series. Unfortunately, it is another mediocre installment. While the author does her due diligence with historical accuracies for the time period, this murder didn't suck me in until the very end.
If you've made it this far in the series, you'll know quite a few of the crimes deal with taboos. I won't say this was the worst one yet, but it made for a very interesting story in the end. What will you do to protect those you love? How far will you go?
We made it the entire book with only a passing glance at Devlin's heritage. Do we consider it a done deal after the last book? Are we supposed to have forgotten, after it was made such a big deal?
I am glad they changed narrators. Davina's voice makes me sleepy.
🎧 Thank you to NetGalley and Recorded Books
If you've made it this far in the series, you'll know quite a few of the crimes deal with taboos. I won't say this was the worst one yet, but it made for a very interesting story in the end. What will you do to protect those you love? How far will you go?
We made it the entire book with only a passing glance at Devlin's heritage. Do we consider it a done deal after the last book? Are we supposed to have forgotten, after it was made such a big deal?
I am glad they changed narrators. Davina's voice makes me sleepy.
🎧 Thank you to NetGalley and Recorded Books
July 21, 2024
I have listened to each book on audio as published and enjoyed the reader for this volume. I rate the historical writing of Harris as 4* I love history and the Napoleonic era, and its leader is fascinating. The plot did not fare as well with me. I struggled to make any headway with the clues (or lack of them) to find out who the killer is for 80% of the book so this is a 2* for the mystery. The last 20% was a twist never in 100 years would I have seen coming and it just felt disconnected from the previous pages. I like when there is family intrigue as part of the storyline, and this was lacking in this volume. I rate the book as a 3* for above reasons.
July 7, 2024
This is the nineteenth book in this great series and I have enjoyed every single one of them.
What Cannot Be Said opens in London in 1815. The murder of an upper-class Lady and her daughter in Richmond Park means that Sebastian is asked to help the police in their enquiries, as the upper class were not willing to be interviewed by just anyone. Even Sebastion is warned off when his investigations lead him too close to the Royal family. Hero plays a great role in this book interviewing the women who are involved in the case.
There is the usual informative historical background. Napoleon has just been captured and is awaiting his fate. Some serious social issues of the time are explored - child chimney sweeps, baby farms, work houses and more. It was not a good time be poor. There is also a rather surprising ending.
Beautifully written as this series always is. I am already looking forward to #20. Will Sebastion get his girl?
What Cannot Be Said opens in London in 1815. The murder of an upper-class Lady and her daughter in Richmond Park means that Sebastian is asked to help the police in their enquiries, as the upper class were not willing to be interviewed by just anyone. Even Sebastion is warned off when his investigations lead him too close to the Royal family. Hero plays a great role in this book interviewing the women who are involved in the case.
There is the usual informative historical background. Napoleon has just been captured and is awaiting his fate. Some serious social issues of the time are explored - child chimney sweeps, baby farms, work houses and more. It was not a good time be poor. There is also a rather surprising ending.
Beautifully written as this series always is. I am already looking forward to #20. Will Sebastion get his girl?
September 12, 2024
4.5
One of my favorite installments in this solid Regency-era mystery series, the book opens with a tragic picnic and sadly continues to add victims to the list.
We see a side of Lovejoy not seen before, one of the strengths of this book. We also meet several families hiding generational secrets and madness. Add a few new unsavory characters and you’ve got another great story!
While I’m not sure justice is always served, I do appreciate how Devlin bends justice to his will at times!!
(Reviewed 8/9/24)
One of my favorite installments in this solid Regency-era mystery series, the book opens with a tragic picnic and sadly continues to add victims to the list.
We see a side of Lovejoy not seen before, one of the strengths of this book. We also meet several families hiding generational secrets and madness. Add a few new unsavory characters and you’ve got another great story!
While I’m not sure justice is always served, I do appreciate how Devlin bends justice to his will at times!!
(Reviewed 8/9/24)
March 24, 2024
the setup…
It’s the summer of 1815 and London is preparing to celebrate Napoleon’s defeat at Waterloo. But when Lady McInnis and her sixteen-year old daughter are found murdered in Richmond Park, London is in full upset. Even more bizarre is the position in which they were found…their bodies posed in the same way as another woman and her daughter were fourteen years ago. That woman and child were Bow Street Magistrate Sir Henry Lovejoy’s wife and daughter. Their murderer was captured and hanged so did they execute the wrong man or is this a cruel copycat? Lovejoy enlists the help of Viscount Devlin, Sebastian St. Cyr.
the heart of the story…
I love being back in the world of Sebastian St. Cyr again and this time the case is not only strange but heartbreaking. As Sebastian begins his investigation, he discovers that Laura McInnis was an even bigger social activist regarding the plight of poor children than what his wife Hero has taken on. She created a host of enemies in the process, high and low born, as well as her own husband. I was all over the place with good suspects and viable theories, assembling clues cleverly…and still missed it. This was great stuff.
the bottom line…
As with every book in this series, the historical aspects are just as intriguing as the mystery at the forefront. The dire situation of poor children was beyond heartbreaking and the indifference during that time was painful. It was a vicious cycle that spanned decades, unfortunately. It was the backdrop of the story, along with a frightening look at some of the so-called “therapies” for mental illness. It’s an extraordinary story with an explosive twist. Sebastian faced quite a few threats, including one from his father-in-law. The political intrigue is palpable, the stage set for the next story. And, there’s plenty on the personal front. This series is one of the finest of the genre.
Posted on Blue Mood Café
(Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for my complimentary copy. All opinions are my own.)
It’s the summer of 1815 and London is preparing to celebrate Napoleon’s defeat at Waterloo. But when Lady McInnis and her sixteen-year old daughter are found murdered in Richmond Park, London is in full upset. Even more bizarre is the position in which they were found…their bodies posed in the same way as another woman and her daughter were fourteen years ago. That woman and child were Bow Street Magistrate Sir Henry Lovejoy’s wife and daughter. Their murderer was captured and hanged so did they execute the wrong man or is this a cruel copycat? Lovejoy enlists the help of Viscount Devlin, Sebastian St. Cyr.
the heart of the story…
I love being back in the world of Sebastian St. Cyr again and this time the case is not only strange but heartbreaking. As Sebastian begins his investigation, he discovers that Laura McInnis was an even bigger social activist regarding the plight of poor children than what his wife Hero has taken on. She created a host of enemies in the process, high and low born, as well as her own husband. I was all over the place with good suspects and viable theories, assembling clues cleverly…and still missed it. This was great stuff.
the bottom line…
As with every book in this series, the historical aspects are just as intriguing as the mystery at the forefront. The dire situation of poor children was beyond heartbreaking and the indifference during that time was painful. It was a vicious cycle that spanned decades, unfortunately. It was the backdrop of the story, along with a frightening look at some of the so-called “therapies” for mental illness. It’s an extraordinary story with an explosive twist. Sebastian faced quite a few threats, including one from his father-in-law. The political intrigue is palpable, the stage set for the next story. And, there’s plenty on the personal front. This series is one of the finest of the genre.
Posted on Blue Mood Café
(Thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for my complimentary copy. All opinions are my own.)
May 16, 2024
A favored series and I want to thank the author for her consistently, well developed historical, mystery series. This is number seventeen and they are as fresh and intrigues as they were at the beginning. I have followed, grown older with Sebastian St. Cyr, through danger, heartbreaks, secrets exposed, the search for his mother. Now he is happily married, with two sons and a child n the way, when once again he is asked to assist in a murder investigation. A mother and child murdered and many suspects to interview. The conclusion was for me very unexpected.
There is also historical references present in all the novels in this series. In this one Napoleon has once again been captured and the government is trying to figure out what to do with him.
Brilliant series.
There is also historical references present in all the novels in this series. In this one Napoleon has once again been captured and the government is trying to figure out what to do with him.
Brilliant series.
July 15, 2024
3.5 Stars Rounded up because I love this series.
What Cannot Be Said is the 19th book in this series.
The History - It is July 1815. Napoleon has been defeated at Waterloo. How will the British Crown choose to contain him? The abuse of the apprentice system, especially of children from orphanages and workhouses, is given scrutiny. As is the practice of farming babies out to women away from town who would deliberately starve or quietly kill them. The treatment of mental illness during this time period is also given a brief look.
The Mystery - A woman and her daughter are murdered while on a picnic in Richmond Park, their bodies posed in imitation of those found on medieval tombs. Once again, Lord Devlin is called in to assist in the investigation. As usual, there are a lot of twists and turns, two more bodies, and a few attacks on our hero before the culprit is identified.
The Characters - This installment covers more of Sir Henry Lovejoy's backstory, and I witness him grappling with his conscience about a past murder. There are also brief appearances by other regulars in the series.
Harris continues to highlight the social theme of class--of privilege and inequality.
Publication 2024
What Cannot Be Said is the 19th book in this series.
The History - It is July 1815. Napoleon has been defeated at Waterloo. How will the British Crown choose to contain him? The abuse of the apprentice system, especially of children from orphanages and workhouses, is given scrutiny. As is the practice of farming babies out to women away from town who would deliberately starve or quietly kill them. The treatment of mental illness during this time period is also given a brief look.
The Mystery - A woman and her daughter are murdered while on a picnic in Richmond Park, their bodies posed in imitation of those found on medieval tombs. Once again, Lord Devlin is called in to assist in the investigation. As usual, there are a lot of twists and turns, two more bodies, and a few attacks on our hero before the culprit is identified.
The Characters - This installment covers more of Sir Henry Lovejoy's backstory, and I witness him grappling with his conscience about a past murder. There are also brief appearances by other regulars in the series.
Harris continues to highlight the social theme of class--of privilege and inequality.
Publication 2024
January 22, 2024
I say it every year, but it’s true. A series on its 19th book that has maintained the quality level throughout is so impressive. While I did find this story to be very bleak and dark, the suspense and storytelling is top-notch, and I so enjoy coming back into Sebastian‘s world with every new installment.
It’s just another great read in a great series. In one sense, I want to say you kind of know what you’re going to get going in - a great story centered around Sebastian and a rich group of supporting characters, but on the other hand, every story is unique and engaging, and it never feels like anything gets repeated.
I can’t recommend this series enough. It is so well done and still going strong.
It’s just another great read in a great series. In one sense, I want to say you kind of know what you’re going to get going in - a great story centered around Sebastian and a rich group of supporting characters, but on the other hand, every story is unique and engaging, and it never feels like anything gets repeated.
I can’t recommend this series enough. It is so well done and still going strong.
May 20, 2024
A woman and her daughter are shot dead while enjoying a pleasant picnic in the park. Aspects of the murder tie the crime to a previous murder, for which the convicted killer was executed. Is this a copycat, or was the wrong person executed? Were the victims targeted, or was this a random killing? Sebastian St. Cyr and his wife Hero assist the police in their investigation.
Other murders occur, but they are almost secondary to the author’s interest in Napoleon’s recent defeat and a variety of social issues, including domestic abuse, mental illness and its treatment, child labor, child abuse, opium addiction and the treatment of orphans. I actually found these social issues more interesting than the murders, and I was not at all satisfied with the resolution of the murders. Sebastian and Hero had to be the two most woke people in the 19th century (they definitely had 21st century sensibilities), so it seemed out of character that they would be ok with the sort of justice meted out at the end.
I have not read any of the other books in this series, but since I am not particularly interested in the backstories of the detectives in a mystery, this book worked for me as a standalone, but you may prefer to start at the beginning of the series. The book held my interest, but I don’t feel compelled to read more of the series. The narrator of the audiobook did an adequate job, but she was not good with male voices.
I received a free copy of this audiobook from the publisher.
Other murders occur, but they are almost secondary to the author’s interest in Napoleon’s recent defeat and a variety of social issues, including domestic abuse, mental illness and its treatment, child labor, child abuse, opium addiction and the treatment of orphans. I actually found these social issues more interesting than the murders, and I was not at all satisfied with the resolution of the murders. Sebastian and Hero had to be the two most woke people in the 19th century (they definitely had 21st century sensibilities), so it seemed out of character that they would be ok with the sort of justice meted out at the end.
I have not read any of the other books in this series, but since I am not particularly interested in the backstories of the detectives in a mystery, this book worked for me as a standalone, but you may prefer to start at the beginning of the series. The book held my interest, but I don’t feel compelled to read more of the series. The narrator of the audiobook did an adequate job, but she was not good with male voices.
I received a free copy of this audiobook from the publisher.
April 22, 2024
Nineteen books into this series and every installment is still an absolute banger. Once again, Sebastian and Hero start a book working on their own and wind up collaborating as the threads of their work become entwined. The plotting is masterful.
Hero is writing articles about children at workhouses and apprenticeships. Sebastian is helping Lovejoy with a murder that seems like a copy cat of the murder of his wife and daughter...or did the wrong person get hanged for the earlier crime and the murderer is back? At the same time, Hero's step-mother/cousin seems to be trying to encourage conflict between Hero and her father. Jarvis is threatening Sebastian, as usual, because one of the Prince Regent's illegitimate sons might be involved in the murder. Oh, and Napoleon has been defeated and his fate is being debated - will he go back to the Bourbons, allowed to live in England, or sent to exile?
I loved the audiobook of this - the narrator was fantastic and did a great job with the large cast of characters.
Hero is writing articles about children at workhouses and apprenticeships. Sebastian is helping Lovejoy with a murder that seems like a copy cat of the murder of his wife and daughter...or did the wrong person get hanged for the earlier crime and the murderer is back? At the same time, Hero's step-mother/cousin seems to be trying to encourage conflict between Hero and her father. Jarvis is threatening Sebastian, as usual, because one of the Prince Regent's illegitimate sons might be involved in the murder. Oh, and Napoleon has been defeated and his fate is being debated - will he go back to the Bourbons, allowed to live in England, or sent to exile?
I loved the audiobook of this - the narrator was fantastic and did a great job with the large cast of characters.
April 27, 2024
So many murders, so many suspects, at times it was difficult keeping track of the different characters. That is my main compliant about listening to the audio versions of these books. The narrator, Amy Scanlon, did an excellent job and added to the listening experience. As is usual with this series, Harris shows us the social upheaval of the time. Issues covered in this story include the treatment of mental illness, the protection of the upper classes and the dreadful state of those children left orphaned. Hero best not turn her back on her stepmother, that one is a real snake. C.S. Harris is a wonderful author who crafts stories that are gripping and make the Regency times real. Her characters and plots are meticulously researched and written. The storyline flows and always has a twist you can never see coming. There is a bit of a cliffhanger at the end, and I will definitely be waiting for the next book.
On a lazy summer day in July 1815 in Richmond Park, the sound of gunfire rings out across a quiet park. A mother, Laura, Lady McInnis, and her daughter, Emma, are shot, and their bodies posed to echo another murder from fourteen years ago. For Bow Street magistrate Sir Henry Lovejoy this is a chilling reminder of the death of his wife and daughter and Sir Henry knows he needs his friend, Sebastian St. Cyr, Viscount Devlin, to help unravel this murder.
Soon a very pregnant Hero is looking into the charity work that Lady McInnis was involved in and hoping to find the identity of the killer in someone who simply wanted to silence her. Being warned off this pursuit by her mother-in-law, Hero is left to wonder why. Sebastain follows a trail that leads in many different directions including to a chimney sweep using young children in his nasty business, a Waterloo veteran who loved Laura, a farmer and his wife who take in orphaned babies who die under mysterious circumstances. So many suspects including the widower, Sir Ivo McInnis and the illegitimate son of the Prince Regent. Both of whom Sebastian has been warned not to involve in this case.
When the niece and nephew of Lady McInnis, who were with her in Richmond Park on that day, are attacked as well as two other young women being found dead and poised, Sebastain is forced to consider a motive that is both terrifying and unconceivable.
My thanks to the Publisher and Author for providing a complimentary audio Advanced Reader Copy (ARC) of this novel via NetGalley. This is my fair, honest and personal review. All opinions are mine alone and were not biased in any way.
On a lazy summer day in July 1815 in Richmond Park, the sound of gunfire rings out across a quiet park. A mother, Laura, Lady McInnis, and her daughter, Emma, are shot, and their bodies posed to echo another murder from fourteen years ago. For Bow Street magistrate Sir Henry Lovejoy this is a chilling reminder of the death of his wife and daughter and Sir Henry knows he needs his friend, Sebastian St. Cyr, Viscount Devlin, to help unravel this murder.
Soon a very pregnant Hero is looking into the charity work that Lady McInnis was involved in and hoping to find the identity of the killer in someone who simply wanted to silence her. Being warned off this pursuit by her mother-in-law, Hero is left to wonder why. Sebastain follows a trail that leads in many different directions including to a chimney sweep using young children in his nasty business, a Waterloo veteran who loved Laura, a farmer and his wife who take in orphaned babies who die under mysterious circumstances. So many suspects including the widower, Sir Ivo McInnis and the illegitimate son of the Prince Regent. Both of whom Sebastian has been warned not to involve in this case.
When the niece and nephew of Lady McInnis, who were with her in Richmond Park on that day, are attacked as well as two other young women being found dead and poised, Sebastain is forced to consider a motive that is both terrifying and unconceivable.
My thanks to the Publisher and Author for providing a complimentary audio Advanced Reader Copy (ARC) of this novel via NetGalley. This is my fair, honest and personal review. All opinions are mine alone and were not biased in any way.
October 16, 2023
Harris keeps you guessing until the end once again as Sebastian and Hero try and solve the murder of a mother and her daughter in a case where we finally get the story of what happened to Lovejoy’s family. I truly love this series.
April 20, 2024
I listened to this as an audiobook and it was narrated by Amy Scanlon. She was an excellent choice and I enjoyed it very much. It was a historical regency mystery was interesting and the ending was great. The author definitely has a special talent for writing this time period. I found the characters intriguing and the experience was delightfully charming and mysterious. It was written as a stand-alone in case you’re wondering.
Thanks RB media via NetGalley.
Thanks RB media via NetGalley.
November 16, 2023
This story was one of the darker ones in the series. The resolution was insidious, and the reader is not left with a feeling of optimism at the end. I also was disappointed by the lack of character development. However, I thought this story showcased the true nature of absurdity and human darkness. I would not like all of the books to be like this one, though, in spite of the story’s strengths.
May 23, 2024
What Cannot Be Said (SebastianSt. Cyr, #19) by C.S. Harris was the first book that I had the privilege of reading in this riveting murder mystery series. Based on my own experience, What Ccannot Be Said can be read as a stand-alone book. I had no problem identifying and keeping track of the characters or the plot of this book even though I had not any of the prior books. It took place in July of 1815, corresponding with Napoleon’s defeat at Waterloo. This was not a time period that I tend to read about that often but I found it intriguing and quite interesting. The roles of the women that lived during this time were clearly defined and restricted regardless of their intelligence or ambitions. There were a few exceptions but not many. I listened to the audiobook of What Cannot Be Said that was narrated by Amy Scanlon. She gave an excellent narration and distinguished clearly between characters. Amy Scanlon is becoming a favorite narrator for me.
On a beautiful day, a mother, Lady McInnis and her sixteen year old daughter, Emma, along with the younger son and daughter of her husband’s first wife set off on a picnic to Richmond Park. Not long after their arrival, Lady McInnis and Emma were discovered by some brothers who had been in the park. They had heard what they thought might have been a gun shot so they went to investigate the noise they heard. They were not at all prepared for what they saw. Lady McInnis and Emma had not only been, what appeared to be, murdered but they were laid out in an eerily familiar pose.
Years ago, Sir Henry Lovejoy had witnessed a very similar scene. Someone had killed his wife and child and had their bodies posed in a very similar way. When Sir Henry Lovejoy arrived at the scene of the crime, he was transported back in time to the deaths of his wife and child. This case was too close and familiar for Sir Henry Lovejoy to investigate unbiasedly so he sought the help of his good friend, Sebastian St. Cyr. Viscount Devlin. He trusted Sebastian to thoroughly investigate this case and determine who was responsible for this horrific crime. Long ago, when Sir Henry Lovejoy’s wife and child were murdered, a man had been charged, convicted and killed for the murders. Could the wrong man have been convicted and sentenced to death? Is it possible that the wrong man had paid for a crime that he did not commit? These questions hung heavily on Sir Henry Lovejoy’s mind now, all these years later. Over the course of several weeks, two more young women were found murdered in the same manner. Sebastian had several suspects but no concrete evidence as to who committed these tragic murders. Will Sebastian be able to gather enough evidence to prove who was responsible for murdering these defenseless women before anymore women could be subjected to this form of needless violence? Sebastian was determined to do just that.
C.S. Harris masterfully portrayed the many ways young orphaned children were often mistreated, exploited and abused during this time period by greedy and corrupt men and women. Many young boys were lured and then forced to become chimney sweeps. It was a very dangerous and dreaded occupation that young children were subjected to perform. It was of no consequence to the men in charge if any of these children lost their lives while they performed the tasks involved.
The other topic that C.S. Harris researched extensively and brought to light in What Cannot Be Said was baby farming. I had read about baby farming in a previous book I had read. Some women were willing to foster babies that were born out of wedlock or look after babies that needed looking after while their parents worked for a good profit. Unfortunately, many of these women who fostered or looked after these babies were not very reputable. Sometimes the babies were sold to other families who wanted a baby but were unable to have one of their own. This was often accomplished without the consent or knowledge of the babies parents. It was common practice for these foster mothers to drug the babies in their care with Ludlum so that the babies that were in their charge slept for longer periods of time and also ate less. In some instances, babies were even killed and then their deaths were covered up. It was a thriving business for some during the 1800’s.
Sebastian’s wife, Hero, was very active in trying to improve the lives of these defenseless orphans. Hero, a strong, independent and intelligent woman in her own right, was instrumental in helping her husband with the murder investigation. Sebastian respected his wife for her intelligence and valued her opinions. This was not how most men felt about the women during this time period. It was refreshing to see how Sabastian and Hero respected each other in their marriage.
What Cannot Be Said by C.S. Harris was a well done historical fiction murder mystery that reflected the time period well. The ending was a complete surprise but well done. I enjoyed the cast of characters presented in this book. In the future, I hope to read some of the previous books in this series and I will look forward to reading new ones as well. I really enjoyed listening to the audiobook of What Cannot Be Said and highly recommend it.
Thank you to Recorded Books for allowing me to listen to the audiobook of What Cannog Be Said by C.S. Harris through Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
On a beautiful day, a mother, Lady McInnis and her sixteen year old daughter, Emma, along with the younger son and daughter of her husband’s first wife set off on a picnic to Richmond Park. Not long after their arrival, Lady McInnis and Emma were discovered by some brothers who had been in the park. They had heard what they thought might have been a gun shot so they went to investigate the noise they heard. They were not at all prepared for what they saw. Lady McInnis and Emma had not only been, what appeared to be, murdered but they were laid out in an eerily familiar pose.
Years ago, Sir Henry Lovejoy had witnessed a very similar scene. Someone had killed his wife and child and had their bodies posed in a very similar way. When Sir Henry Lovejoy arrived at the scene of the crime, he was transported back in time to the deaths of his wife and child. This case was too close and familiar for Sir Henry Lovejoy to investigate unbiasedly so he sought the help of his good friend, Sebastian St. Cyr. Viscount Devlin. He trusted Sebastian to thoroughly investigate this case and determine who was responsible for this horrific crime. Long ago, when Sir Henry Lovejoy’s wife and child were murdered, a man had been charged, convicted and killed for the murders. Could the wrong man have been convicted and sentenced to death? Is it possible that the wrong man had paid for a crime that he did not commit? These questions hung heavily on Sir Henry Lovejoy’s mind now, all these years later. Over the course of several weeks, two more young women were found murdered in the same manner. Sebastian had several suspects but no concrete evidence as to who committed these tragic murders. Will Sebastian be able to gather enough evidence to prove who was responsible for murdering these defenseless women before anymore women could be subjected to this form of needless violence? Sebastian was determined to do just that.
C.S. Harris masterfully portrayed the many ways young orphaned children were often mistreated, exploited and abused during this time period by greedy and corrupt men and women. Many young boys were lured and then forced to become chimney sweeps. It was a very dangerous and dreaded occupation that young children were subjected to perform. It was of no consequence to the men in charge if any of these children lost their lives while they performed the tasks involved.
The other topic that C.S. Harris researched extensively and brought to light in What Cannot Be Said was baby farming. I had read about baby farming in a previous book I had read. Some women were willing to foster babies that were born out of wedlock or look after babies that needed looking after while their parents worked for a good profit. Unfortunately, many of these women who fostered or looked after these babies were not very reputable. Sometimes the babies were sold to other families who wanted a baby but were unable to have one of their own. This was often accomplished without the consent or knowledge of the babies parents. It was common practice for these foster mothers to drug the babies in their care with Ludlum so that the babies that were in their charge slept for longer periods of time and also ate less. In some instances, babies were even killed and then their deaths were covered up. It was a thriving business for some during the 1800’s.
Sebastian’s wife, Hero, was very active in trying to improve the lives of these defenseless orphans. Hero, a strong, independent and intelligent woman in her own right, was instrumental in helping her husband with the murder investigation. Sebastian respected his wife for her intelligence and valued her opinions. This was not how most men felt about the women during this time period. It was refreshing to see how Sabastian and Hero respected each other in their marriage.
What Cannot Be Said by C.S. Harris was a well done historical fiction murder mystery that reflected the time period well. The ending was a complete surprise but well done. I enjoyed the cast of characters presented in this book. In the future, I hope to read some of the previous books in this series and I will look forward to reading new ones as well. I really enjoyed listening to the audiobook of What Cannot Be Said and highly recommend it.
Thank you to Recorded Books for allowing me to listen to the audiobook of What Cannog Be Said by C.S. Harris through Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.
May 2, 2024
4.5 Stars, rounded up to 5 because I love Devlin and Hero, and the series.
A few thoughts:
I liked that we got to spend more time with Sir Henry Lovejoy. His anguish over the possibility that he had helped hang an innocent man was so real. His conversation with Devlin near the end of the book had me in tears.
I liked that Hero was more closely involved in Devlin's investigation. This time she's an active participant instead of someone who happens to have helpful info.
I enjoyed this author's version of a real person. Damion Pitcairn was modeled on Joseph Bologne, le Chevalier de Saint-Georges, whom I had already encountered in another author's work. Likewise, when Devlin warns Pitcairn about Bow Street's spy master Stafford, I had another a-ha moment, having already 'met' Stafford, courtesy of yet another author. Oh my, my fictional London is getting very crowded!
I had only one quibble about the rather dramatic climax and its aftermath--I am still worrying about young Thisbe. Her mother is dead, as is her sister, and her father leaves a whole lot to be desired as a sympathetic person. What's to become of her?
I am eagerly awaiting the next book. I need to know what happens next with Devlin, Hero, the family and friends.
A few thoughts:
I liked that we got to spend more time with Sir Henry Lovejoy. His anguish over the possibility that he had helped hang an innocent man was so real. His conversation with Devlin near the end of the book had me in tears.
I liked that Hero was more closely involved in Devlin's investigation. This time she's an active participant instead of someone who happens to have helpful info.
I enjoyed this author's version of a real person. Damion Pitcairn was modeled on Joseph Bologne, le Chevalier de Saint-Georges, whom I had already encountered in another author's work. Likewise, when Devlin warns Pitcairn about Bow Street's spy master Stafford, I had another a-ha moment, having already 'met' Stafford, courtesy of yet another author. Oh my, my fictional London is getting very crowded!
I had only one quibble about the rather dramatic climax and its aftermath--I am still worrying about young Thisbe. Her mother is dead, as is her sister, and her father leaves a whole lot to be desired as a sympathetic person. What's to become of her?
I am eagerly awaiting the next book. I need to know what happens next with Devlin, Hero, the family and friends.
September 20, 2024
If you follow this series you will know already how good it is. If not this is not the book to start with. It was as always very good but at #19 there is so much history of these characters that I would recommend starting at least in the first few books. The author follows a formula in these mysteries following the Vicount Sebastian St. Cyr as he works to solve the latest murder in London in the early years of the 1800's.
This story begins with the death of a mother and daughter, both shot while at a picnic. From the beginning the reader is unsure who was the planned victim and was the second merely an innocent or were both meant to be killed. It makes for many possibilities and backstory which this author does so well. Woven in, is the current events of this time concerning Napoleon following his defeat at Waterloo. The mystery is a good one but this lacked as much of the historical events of the time as I have come to expect in this series. Still I found once started I was totally engaged and was intrigued to keep listening . This audio was narrated very well by Amy Scanlon. I still miss the voice of Davina Porter who narrated the first 16 books in this series and came to be the voice of these characters to me.
Harris never disappoints. I was glad I also had a print copy of the book as the audio did not have the author's note that is found in the print and gives a review and explanation of the historical references used and the historical facts of the time which adds much to the story.
This story begins with the death of a mother and daughter, both shot while at a picnic. From the beginning the reader is unsure who was the planned victim and was the second merely an innocent or were both meant to be killed. It makes for many possibilities and backstory which this author does so well. Woven in, is the current events of this time concerning Napoleon following his defeat at Waterloo. The mystery is a good one but this lacked as much of the historical events of the time as I have come to expect in this series. Still I found once started I was totally engaged and was intrigued to keep listening . This audio was narrated very well by Amy Scanlon. I still miss the voice of Davina Porter who narrated the first 16 books in this series and came to be the voice of these characters to me.
Harris never disappoints. I was glad I also had a print copy of the book as the audio did not have the author's note that is found in the print and gives a review and explanation of the historical references used and the historical facts of the time which adds much to the story.
May 21, 2024
C.S. Harris’ historically authentic Regency Era mystery series offering complex, fascinating characters, and intriguing gritty plots is still going strong nineteen ‘must read in order’ books later.
What Cannot Be Said is rife with Regency era social injustices: child labor, apprenticeship abuse, work houses, non-regulated baby farms, sadistic insane asylum treatments, racism, and plight of war casualties and their families. A murder mystery set against this backdrop was not just intriguing, but emotionally compelling.
When I thought the series was to end with the culmination of the Napoleonic War which has been marching apace through the series, I was in book reader devastation, but I was in raptures when Harris announced she would carry on a few more installments to the official end of the Regency Period. Most of all my excitement is due to more time spent with her original creation and possibly my favorite fictional character, Sebastian St. Cyr, and the regular cast of characters who have come along with him since the beginnings of the series.
In this latest, Harris ties the mystery to Sebastian’s friend, the Bow Street Magistrate, Sir Henry Lovejoy’s past when his beloved wife and daughter were murdered years before and a more recent copycat-style murder of Sebastian’s wife, Hero’s dear friend and social justice fighter, Lady McInnis and her daughter. The mystery is personal from the start and only grows more so as Sebastian and Sir Henry work the case and follow the evidence and witness accounts to the shocking end.
CS Harris has never balked at the personality and motive of her grisly murders or the murderer behind the deed. This is never so true as this installment when I had no idea who was behind it all until Sebastian’s intuition mulling over the facts of the case got me there for that stunning reveal.
In summary, What Cannot Be Said was an emotional heavy hitter and an amazing historical mystery story. I cannot recommend this series enough.
I rec'd an eARC from Netgalley to read in exchange for an honest review.
My full review will post at The Quill Ink 5.8.24.
What Cannot Be Said is rife with Regency era social injustices: child labor, apprenticeship abuse, work houses, non-regulated baby farms, sadistic insane asylum treatments, racism, and plight of war casualties and their families. A murder mystery set against this backdrop was not just intriguing, but emotionally compelling.
When I thought the series was to end with the culmination of the Napoleonic War which has been marching apace through the series, I was in book reader devastation, but I was in raptures when Harris announced she would carry on a few more installments to the official end of the Regency Period. Most of all my excitement is due to more time spent with her original creation and possibly my favorite fictional character, Sebastian St. Cyr, and the regular cast of characters who have come along with him since the beginnings of the series.
In this latest, Harris ties the mystery to Sebastian’s friend, the Bow Street Magistrate, Sir Henry Lovejoy’s past when his beloved wife and daughter were murdered years before and a more recent copycat-style murder of Sebastian’s wife, Hero’s dear friend and social justice fighter, Lady McInnis and her daughter. The mystery is personal from the start and only grows more so as Sebastian and Sir Henry work the case and follow the evidence and witness accounts to the shocking end.
CS Harris has never balked at the personality and motive of her grisly murders or the murderer behind the deed. This is never so true as this installment when I had no idea who was behind it all until Sebastian’s intuition mulling over the facts of the case got me there for that stunning reveal.
In summary, What Cannot Be Said was an emotional heavy hitter and an amazing historical mystery story. I cannot recommend this series enough.
I rec'd an eARC from Netgalley to read in exchange for an honest review.
My full review will post at The Quill Ink 5.8.24.
July 11, 2024
I have looked forward to each of the books in this series up to this 19th book. Regency period and well developed characters have kept me faithful through the years, but I did not enjoy this latest book and think I may be done now.
Library Loan
Library Loan
June 21, 2024
Enjoyed. At no point in the story did I notice jumping straight into book 19 of a series. Reading as a standalone is not a problem.
I did like the story. I don't see myself actively seeking the previous 18 books, however if placed in a position to read another one I certainly would take it.
This is GoodReads Giveaway Kindle book win and I am appreciative.
I did like the story. I don't see myself actively seeking the previous 18 books, however if placed in a position to read another one I certainly would take it.
This is GoodReads Giveaway Kindle book win and I am appreciative.
April 26, 2024
Thank you to my bookish friends who caught me up on the MC's very exciting background and dynamics between the recurring characters so that I could jump into this series this late in the game. The book was written so well and the characters so vivid that it was no problem at all to start here and I enjoyed this book and Sebastian and Hero so much! The writing swept me away and was almost addicting, the way I was lead along and could not stop (I finished this in under 24 hours). The historical setting of this book was wonderfully described and it was absolutely heartbreaking to read about what so many poor children were put through and how they were treated during this time! The way the clues came together and the final result were so perfectly shocking. I cannot wait for more!!
Note: the audiobook narration is perfection and I highly recommend it!
Note: the audiobook narration is perfection and I highly recommend it!
April 22, 2024
With a series as long running as this one, it’s not a surprise when some individual volumes are better than others. But Harris seems to be one of the unusual authors who manages to keep the quality high throughout. This installment has been a particularly good ‘un. I had trouble putting it down.
May 28, 2024
As in all of her books, C. S. Harris grabs you from the first page and won't let go. Sebastian St. Cyr is called to the site of two horrific murders in Richmond Park. Numerous suspects emerge from the ranks of the aristocrats down to the poor. Sebastian is threatened and attacked as he investigates, but he wont quit. Just when you think the case is solved, a new twist occurs.
April 26, 2024
Review originally posted at https://smexybooks.com/2024/04/review...
Whenever I’m asked for recommendations in the historical mystery genre this series is always the one that I end up recommending. It’s so well done, with a wonderful cast of characters and each new mystery still keeps me on the edge of my seat until its usual fiery conclusion. It never feels stale, I never get bored, and I’m always excited to see what comes next.
This entry into the series hits a bit too close to home for one member of the extended cast of characters as the discovery of the dead bodies of a mother and daughter eerily resembles the crime scene of Sir Henry Lovejoy’s wife and daughter 14 years before. Sebastian is called in on the case, and as he looks into the life and associations of Lady McInnis and her young daughter, his list of suspects on grows larger and more complex.
This case haunts Lovejoy as he must deal with the fact that he may have arrested the wrong man, who was ultimately convicted and hung. His tumultuous feelings and desire to find out what really happened all those years ago, lend an even more somber air over the investigation. I found this book to be one of the darker and more grim entries in the series, which is saying a lot.
Along with Sebastian, Hero makes her usual appearances, helping out where she can and interviewing subjects that Sebastian cannot. She is indispensable to any investigation, and I love her and her insights. Gibson is still fighting his dependance on opium, and readers are left with hope that his lover Alexi can finally help him break through the pain of his missing limb and addiction to the relief that opium provides with her unusual methods.
This is not a book you can read as a standalone, and I know nineteen books can be daunting when thinking of starting a new series, but just know that it is so worth it if you decide to jump in. The Sebastian St. Cyr series continues to be one of my absolute favorites in the genre, and I look forward to whatever comes next.
Grade- B+
Whenever I’m asked for recommendations in the historical mystery genre this series is always the one that I end up recommending. It’s so well done, with a wonderful cast of characters and each new mystery still keeps me on the edge of my seat until its usual fiery conclusion. It never feels stale, I never get bored, and I’m always excited to see what comes next.
This entry into the series hits a bit too close to home for one member of the extended cast of characters as the discovery of the dead bodies of a mother and daughter eerily resembles the crime scene of Sir Henry Lovejoy’s wife and daughter 14 years before. Sebastian is called in on the case, and as he looks into the life and associations of Lady McInnis and her young daughter, his list of suspects on grows larger and more complex.
This case haunts Lovejoy as he must deal with the fact that he may have arrested the wrong man, who was ultimately convicted and hung. His tumultuous feelings and desire to find out what really happened all those years ago, lend an even more somber air over the investigation. I found this book to be one of the darker and more grim entries in the series, which is saying a lot.
Along with Sebastian, Hero makes her usual appearances, helping out where she can and interviewing subjects that Sebastian cannot. She is indispensable to any investigation, and I love her and her insights. Gibson is still fighting his dependance on opium, and readers are left with hope that his lover Alexi can finally help him break through the pain of his missing limb and addiction to the relief that opium provides with her unusual methods.
This is not a book you can read as a standalone, and I know nineteen books can be daunting when thinking of starting a new series, but just know that it is so worth it if you decide to jump in. The Sebastian St. Cyr series continues to be one of my absolute favorites in the genre, and I look forward to whatever comes next.
Grade- B+
May 16, 2024
The latest Sebastian St. Cyr Mystery Novel.
The setting is in London, 1815 during the Regency Period.
Numerous murders have occurred throughout the city, and the Bow Street magistrate is baffled. There seems to be a connection to similar murders years before when a young man was tried, convicted and hanged for those killings.
Sir Henry Lovejoy, the Bow Street magistrate, has asked his long time friend, Sebastian St. Cyr for assistance. It was Lovejoy's evidence that sent that young soldier to the gallows for those murders, including Lovejoy's own wife and daughter.
This Mystery Novel includes portions of the history at the time. Napoleon has finally be sent into exile, and the Prince Regent is leading the life of a libertine. The future of the English Monarchy could be jeopardized because of this.
The setting is in London, 1815 during the Regency Period.
Numerous murders have occurred throughout the city, and the Bow Street magistrate is baffled. There seems to be a connection to similar murders years before when a young man was tried, convicted and hanged for those killings.
Sir Henry Lovejoy, the Bow Street magistrate, has asked his long time friend, Sebastian St. Cyr for assistance. It was Lovejoy's evidence that sent that young soldier to the gallows for those murders, including Lovejoy's own wife and daughter.
This Mystery Novel includes portions of the history at the time. Napoleon has finally be sent into exile, and the Prince Regent is leading the life of a libertine. The future of the English Monarchy could be jeopardized because of this.
January 5, 2026
Almost at book 20! Still keeping me engaged, this series.
In terms of our beloved cast… We learn more about Henry Lovejoy in this installment, as two women are murdered in a manner reminiscent of how he lost his wife and daughter. Small progress for Gibson as well.
The murders take us through unsavory parts of London, where poor orphans are terribly abused, to Prinny’s bastard, the scandals of a noble family and beyond. The author never lets us forget it was a terrible place for most everyone, 19th century England. I really enjoyed historical setting of this one, as well as the mystery - although I guessed the culprit fairly quickly this time around. I also appreciate politics was mostly in the background after the last few books, mostly there is talk of Napoleon being imprisoned and Jarvis’s machinations.
In terms of our beloved cast… We learn more about Henry Lovejoy in this installment, as two women are murdered in a manner reminiscent of how he lost his wife and daughter. Small progress for Gibson as well.
The murders take us through unsavory parts of London, where poor orphans are terribly abused, to Prinny’s bastard, the scandals of a noble family and beyond. The author never lets us forget it was a terrible place for most everyone, 19th century England. I really enjoyed historical setting of this one, as well as the mystery - although I guessed the culprit fairly quickly this time around. I also appreciate politics was mostly in the background after the last few books, mostly there is talk of Napoleon being imprisoned and Jarvis’s machinations.
July 3, 2024
Authors who want to have a very long running series could do worse than reading this one to see how to keep your quality up over nearly 20 books!!
May 20, 2024
This continues to be one of the best historical mystery series I’ve read. A great addition.
April 20, 2024
Another masterpiece !!
19th book in the series and still in love with the characters .. I cannot wait for the next one to be out [here we go for another year of waiting]
19th book in the series and still in love with the characters .. I cannot wait for the next one to be out [here we go for another year of waiting]
May 7, 2024
I am a very picky reader. I am hard on authors which I feel kind of bad about but I believe in being frank when writing a review. That being said, this book is fabulous IMO. I have read all of the St Cyr books and that’s because C S Harris is an excellent writer. Her characters are nuanced, her plots are interesting and she is historically accurate, which I love. I think she compares favourably to the great Anne Perry.
Other reviewers give you a blow by blow so I won’t bother with that. This book was a good follow up to the last one. It was a good story, lots of things going on and we find out more about Insp. Lovelace.
My only quibble is that I’d like Hero to have more of an equal partnership with Sebastian. I get tired of hearing she is pregnant, or just had a baby. I’m glad they are in love and have a healthy relationship, leading to lots of babies but could we please have a book where Hero gets to run around doing things, besides taking tea and going to society events? I guess that’s historically accurate but I’d be okay with bending the rules a bit you know?
Terrific book, well worth the money. Oh and be sure to book off a few hours of dedicated time so you can read it right through.
Other reviewers give you a blow by blow so I won’t bother with that. This book was a good follow up to the last one. It was a good story, lots of things going on and we find out more about Insp. Lovelace.
My only quibble is that I’d like Hero to have more of an equal partnership with Sebastian. I get tired of hearing she is pregnant, or just had a baby. I’m glad they are in love and have a healthy relationship, leading to lots of babies but could we please have a book where Hero gets to run around doing things, besides taking tea and going to society events? I guess that’s historically accurate but I’d be okay with bending the rules a bit you know?
Terrific book, well worth the money. Oh and be sure to book off a few hours of dedicated time so you can read it right through.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 395 reviews