Having read and love the traditional format of Alan Gratz’s Refugee, a Texas Bluebonnet award nominee in 2018, I was excited to see a graphic novel adaptation written by Gratz and illustrated by Syd Fini. Although it has been quite some time since I read the original, I believe the ordeals and loss endured by three young refugees from 1939 Germany, 1994 Cuba and 2015 Syria were captured just as clearly in the graphic novel and for those readers who are more visual, maybe even better than in the traditionally formatted novel.
Josef, a Jewish boy fleeing Germany, Hitler and the Nazis with family, Isabel, a young Cuban girl and her family seeking refuge from the poverty and brutal government of Fidel Castro, and Mahmoud and his family seeking freedom from war-torn Syria, all endure hardship on their journeys that reflect actual experiences of actual refugees and Gratz details this fact in his author’s note. The trials experienced by Josef, Isabel and Mahmoud, however, do not reveal as much of the history of their countries during this time as I remember from the novel but the necessity of their flight comes across loud and clear. Even with limited text, Gratz uses dialogue in an effective way and the illustrated panels go even farther in conveying fear, grief and desperation; in fact, until the very end, there is very little outside of those dire feelings but hope does come for all three as connections between are also revealed.
Excellent choice for graphic novel collections in libraries serving readers in grades 4 and up, especially if there is solid circulation in historical fiction. Text is free of profanity and sexual content. The violence experienced by the refugees is historically accurate but is not excessive and is appropriate for the target audience.
Thanks for the print arc, Scholastic and the 2025 Texas Library Association annual conference.