Spiritual Themes
Overt spiritual content is light, aside from the characters being members of the Amish church. I did like one scene where a character is praying and determines to pray for God’s will — not just his own.
What I Liked
I really enjoy stories with a strong food emphasis, and I found the bakery setting to be highly appealing. It was delightful to read about the abundant French pastries, cookies, and strudel. There were also a few mentions of pizza (which was not one of the bakery’s offerings), which I consider to be an added bonus!
This is Blackburne’s third contribution to the Heart of the Amish series, and she makes a point to bring back the characters from the earlier installments. I am most intrigued by the slowly-developing relationship of two background characters. (As a note, readers will benefit from reading Blackburne’s installments consecutively, since they are set in the same community as her other books in the series).
I planned to read LIzzie’s Little Mouse because I’ve enjoyed the other title in the series. As such, I did not give much attention to the synopsis, nor did I realize that the book would be something of a mystery. With that said, I liked the mystery element in its departure from the standard arc of romantic Amish books. Lizzie’s bakery is located in a historical building, and I enjoyed how that setting framed the plot in terms of timeline and long-forgotten intrigue. The inclusion of a titular cat is also a unifying thread between the books, and I liked that Little Mouse has a more significant part to play in “her” book.
The female friendships in the book are sweet! Eliza and Jane (and I just realized why I kept thinking of Eliza Jane Wilder while reading! I only now connected that the girls have both her names– not just Eliza) are supportive and kind and also lend a touch of humor to the story. I enjoyed reading Jane’s knowing observations about Lizzie’s developing romance.
Lizzie’s friendship with John presents an interesting exploration of gender roles in the context of friendship. I feel that Lizzie raises an excellent point when she weighs John’s level of involvement in her life, considering that he is not a family member, nor is he her husband. I think that sometimes, Christian women can overextend the idea of masculine authority beyond the words of Scripture. We see fathers and husbands presented as “coverings” for women, but that does not mean women are called to come under the authority of all men, simply because of their gender.
Content Notes
I was a bit surprised by the frequent references to luck, including casual conversational use and comments about it being “fun” to pretend to believe in luck. There’s a similar approach to the concept of ghosts, with one character commenting that it’s fun to pretend, and Lizzie feeling unnerved by the history of her bakery, even though she doesn’t believe in ghosts.
There’s an interesting, but very brief, comment about Lizzie’s decision to bake French, New Orleans-style, pastries, rather than sticking with traditionally Amish fare. I think this could have been a valid point of discussion, but it’s undermined by the fact that the character making the claim is not from New Orleans, either.
Recommendation Status
French cuisine pairs nicely with a light mystery in Lizzie’s Little Mouse. Recommended for readers who enjoy Amish romance and historically-motivated intrigue.
Disclosure: I received a complimentary copy of the book from the publisher. Opinions expressed are my own.