Updated for audio: As I noted below, out of all the fantastic stories written by author Lainey Davis, her Forging Series, and anything about the Pittsburg Fury hockey team and those fabulous Stags and their extended family are the best. And the best is the absolute best when it’s performed for you by talented narrators like Zoe Black and James Cassidy. Cassidy’s portrayal of Gunnar will have you laughing in the Prologue. He’s happy to “discover” Emerson first thing in the morning, and then he skillfully cycles through Gunnar’s wonder, bafflement, uncertainty, sometimes in a whispering voice that will just grab you. He’s the cocky hockey player, the devoted son and brother, and the fierce husband. And – he does accents!! Zoe Black’s performance of Emerson is spot on. Emerson is a complicated person and Black reveals all of it: the insecurity and resignation from constantly being devalued by her family, the uncertainty about her ability to forge her own future but also the strength as she proceeds to do so comes clearly through in Black’s performance, as does her growing affection for Gunnar, her yearning for the life she could have with him, and her sadness when she fears she’s going to ruin his life. A moving, entertaining story made even better through these two voice actors. I received an advance listening copy of Playing for Keeps from Home Cooked Books. I voluntarily leave this review; all opinions are my own.
Author Lainey Davis writes a wide variety of terrific stories, but one of my favorite series of hers is the Forging Series, all about Pittsburg Fury hockey and that fabulous Stag family. Playing for Keeps is the fourth book in the series, and I think it just may be my favorite to date.
Gunnar Stag is the rookie goalie for the Fury. Strong, cut, Stag handsome with the manners and sweetness all those brothers have under their sometimes cocky and crude behavior. But Gunnar? There’s just an extra layer of sweetness about him. He’s young and vibrant and as eager and excitable as a puppy. He’s just trying to stay healthy, play well and learn all he can to earn a permanent position on the Fury and have some no-strings fun during his downtime. His family name and connections have certainly helped get him where he is, but it’s up to him to keep that place. He saw how fleeting it could be when he witnessed his brother’s career-ending injury and he’s determined to make the most of his opportunity.
Emerson Saltzer has been brought up wrapped so tight in expectations and conditions and non-stop criticism that she can barely breathe. Her family is well-known, well-to-do, well-placed and she hasn’t wanted for a thing. But wait, has anybody – anybody at all – ever asked her what she wanted? That would be a big no. Her father is Charles Saltzer, renowned Conductor of the New York Symphony. Emerson has been tutored and trained and taught to be a musician. She loves making music, but wants to play whatever instrument she chooses, compose, play for fun. There is no fun allowed in The Laws of Charles Saltzer and her parents just keep trying to push her farther and farther into that box (prison) they’ve created for her. When her father catches her busking, playing her cello in the New Jersey Transit lobby in Penn Station he loudly berates her in public, humiliating her. Something in her snaps and she gets up and takes the first train she can catch, which just so happens to be going to Las Vegas.
Being berated is nothing new for Emerson; it’s the story of her life. Everything about her is wrong: her body, appetite, hair, clothes, wishes, everything is wrong and her mother and father are beyond cruel in telling her so. They’ve done everything for her and she should be grateful, she should stop embarrassing them, she should stop being so common. It never lets up. Leaving as she does seems to be the only answer. She doesn’t know where she’ll go or what she’ll do, but she can’t take another minute living the life she has been, the life she’s expected to live for the rest of that life.
Gunnar is in Vegas for a pre-season game. When the game’s over he and his brothers go to a small bar to discuss endorsements with their agent. Emerson is in that same bar, playing her cello for dinner guests. And then it happens . . . their eyes meet. Cue the music playing, birds flying, stars shining, fireworks bursting. Over the top, right, but pretty much the reaction they have to each other. And what begins with him pushing his way through the crowd to introduce himself leads to a few, maybe quite a few, drinks, some discussion about her next steps and the possibility of her going to Pittsburg with him as a roommate to avoid her family until her plans are made ends with them waking up in a hotel room in the morning – married. Neither one of them exactly remembers what they did – or more likely didn’t – do. Gunnar’s agent insists they stay married for a while to avoid negative publicity for him, and the roommate idea seems plausible under the circumstances. There’s plenty of room; she can figure out what to do next, he can save his reputation and continue his career. They’ll pretend to be married but will just be roommates, nothing more. Easy peasy.
Except for that giant elephant in the room called attraction. It gets harder and harder to fake it, especially when his parents and other relatives welcome her to the family so genuinely. When they are so comfortable together and have so much in common. When what starts as a fake life begins to feel like a what-if real life. One thing leads to another, they get closer and closer, but neither wants to stand in the way of the other’s dreams. His protective husband vibe kicks in, though, when her father actively sets out to destroy her. And for the first time in her life she feels cherished and wanted and valued and beautiful.
Playing for Keeps is the perfect next step in the series. All the Stag boys are handsome and sexy, can be rowdy and exuberant and impulsive, but they’ve been raised to value family, to be kind and generous, and to love. The rest of the characters are multi-dimensional and interesting, the plot solid, the pacing smooth, and each story unique and satisfying. Emerson and Gunnar’s journey to their HEA is sweet and funny, heartbreaking, frustrating and just a great read. They’re young and in love, with a flaming hot desire and some not-so-insignificant problems to deal with. And Gunnar is the very definition of cinnamon roll golden retriever. He is so caring and considerate and protective and never wants Emerson to doubt for a second how strong and capable she is and how much she’s loved. Thanks to author Lainey Davis for providing an advance copy of Playing for Keeps. I thoroughly enjoyed it, recommend you read the entire series and then get in line to see whose story is next. I voluntarily leave this review; all opinions are my own.