What do you think?
Rate this book
The Chosen Prince
From master storyteller Diane Stanley comes a spellbinding tale, based on Shakespeare's The Tempest , of two princes—one chosen, one lost—and a mysterious girl on a magical island, all caught in a great web of destiny. On the day of his birth, Prince Alexos is revealed to be the long-awaited champion of Athene. He grows up lonely, conscious of all that is expected of him. But Alexos discovers that being a champion isn't about fame and glory—it's about sacrifice and courage. Alexos follows the course of his destiny through war and loss and a deadly confrontation with his enemy to its shipwreck on a magical, fog-shrouded island. There he meets the unforgettable Aria, and faces the greatest challenge of his life.
368 pages, Hardcover
First published January 27, 2015
About the author
Diane Stanley
81 books182 followersDiane Stanley is an American children's author and illustrator, a former medical illustrator, and a former art director for the publisher G.P. Putnam's Sons. Born in 1943 in Abilene, Texas, she was educated at Trinity University (in San Antonio, TX) and at Johns Hopkins University. She is perhaps best known for her many picture-book biographies, some of which were co-authored by her husband, Peter Vennema. (source: Wikipedia)
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 67 reviews
January 8, 2015
***This review has also been posted on The Social Potato
Now that some of my rage has cooled off, I can say with certainty that this is by far one of the most disappointing books I’ve read this year. When I first saw it on Edelweiss, I was so excited! Greek Myth combined with Fantasy sounded like a dream and I was excited to dive in. I was let down on so many accounts, it’s not even funny. Although I imagine that if anyone had been watching me while I was reading the book, they might disagree.
For starters, this book has almost no elements of fantasy. It reads like historical fiction that’s set in a time when people still believed in the greek gods. That was slightly disappointing but I loved greek myth enough to let that one pass.
The POV this book was written in made it a lot harder for me to stick with the book. It’s written in 3rd person present tense which is just awkward. I kept on thinking it would change at some point but it didn’t and it just kept on throwing me off. At first, I felt like I wasn't being open enough to the idea of another POV and that it would become easier to read once I got used to it but I never did. I continued to look for things about this book that would make it stick out or would be even a shadow of what had been promised by the blurb.
The main character Alexos was actually pretty decent. I liked how he seemed to continue to push through in spite of all the misfortunes that befell him and while he was brave, smart, kind and giving, he also knew when he had to be a leader. Of course, sometimes I wish he would be a little bit more child-like considering he was just 13. Except when he wasn't. About half way through the book, there was a 7 year fast forward.
That really got me. What more was that the story wasn’t even being told from his POV anymore after that 7 year skip even though he was supposed to be the main character. A 20/21 year old main character for a middle grade book is a little awkward. What more was that this book some very predictable turns and there was a VERY AWKWARD romance thrown in that pissed me off so much. It’s not that the two characters weren’t compatible, it’s just that they don’t actually know each other. They meet and then BAM. Okay. I need to calm down a little because the romance still bothers me, as you can see quite clearly.
This book was lacking in the world building department as well. We are provided with the bare minimum which is basically some details on the gods that have any influence on the outcome of the story. We are thrown into a world with no other details which is why I said it read more like a historical book than fantasy. As someone who LOVES world building, I was heartbroken! Here we have such great potential yet it’s wasted. It’s barely brushed. I can only imagine the rich world that could have otherwise been created had the potential been utilized.
However, the worst thing about this book was the way in which the conflict was resolved. That broke my heart into pieces. It’s the kind of resolution you expect from picture books, not a novel. Not a novel where there is so much build up and the character goes through so much as a result of his ‘destiny’. We have a build up for nothing because when it comes down to the actual resolution, nothing happens. It’s like when you light a firecracker that you expect to explode but all you get is a tiny crackle.
Throughout the first 60%, I kept making excuses for the book because I expected to get better, I wanted it to get better. I wanted it to blow my mind. I wanted it to be everything it had promised. The last 40% opened my eyes and by the last couple of pages I was craughing and really just wanted the book to end. So much disappointment is not good for the soul.
One might attribute the simplicity of the book to the fact that it’s middle grade. I am obviously not the intended audience but if I had read this book in middle school, I would have been heartbroken because it would have made me realize that not all books are great (I never really read a bad book as a kid… yes I am boasting. A little bit. COME ON. My bubble has already been burst.). Plus, as a kid (and almost adult))who loved adventures , it would have bothered me that something that promised to be a fabulous adventure wasn’t one.
My childish aspirations aside, it's clear that I wasn't the intended audience but I don’t know who this book is aimed towards. I suggest that if you’re thinking about reading this one yourself, you may want to skip it unless childish is exactly what you’re looking for after being fed up of everything else.
Now that some of my rage has cooled off, I can say with certainty that this is by far one of the most disappointing books I’ve read this year. When I first saw it on Edelweiss, I was so excited! Greek Myth combined with Fantasy sounded like a dream and I was excited to dive in. I was let down on so many accounts, it’s not even funny. Although I imagine that if anyone had been watching me while I was reading the book, they might disagree.
For starters, this book has almost no elements of fantasy. It reads like historical fiction that’s set in a time when people still believed in the greek gods. That was slightly disappointing but I loved greek myth enough to let that one pass.
The POV this book was written in made it a lot harder for me to stick with the book. It’s written in 3rd person present tense which is just awkward. I kept on thinking it would change at some point but it didn’t and it just kept on throwing me off. At first, I felt like I wasn't being open enough to the idea of another POV and that it would become easier to read once I got used to it but I never did. I continued to look for things about this book that would make it stick out or would be even a shadow of what had been promised by the blurb.
The main character Alexos was actually pretty decent. I liked how he seemed to continue to push through in spite of all the misfortunes that befell him and while he was brave, smart, kind and giving, he also knew when he had to be a leader. Of course, sometimes I wish he would be a little bit more child-like considering he was just 13. Except when he wasn't. About half way through the book, there was a 7 year fast forward.
That really got me. What more was that the story wasn’t even being told from his POV anymore after that 7 year skip even though he was supposed to be the main character. A 20/21 year old main character for a middle grade book is a little awkward. What more was that this book some very predictable turns and there was a VERY AWKWARD romance thrown in that pissed me off so much. It’s not that the two characters weren’t compatible, it’s just that they don’t actually know each other. They meet and then BAM. Okay. I need to calm down a little because the romance still bothers me, as you can see quite clearly.
This book was lacking in the world building department as well. We are provided with the bare minimum which is basically some details on the gods that have any influence on the outcome of the story. We are thrown into a world with no other details which is why I said it read more like a historical book than fantasy. As someone who LOVES world building, I was heartbroken! Here we have such great potential yet it’s wasted. It’s barely brushed. I can only imagine the rich world that could have otherwise been created had the potential been utilized.
However, the worst thing about this book was the way in which the conflict was resolved. That broke my heart into pieces. It’s the kind of resolution you expect from picture books, not a novel. Not a novel where there is so much build up and the character goes through so much as a result of his ‘destiny’. We have a build up for nothing because when it comes down to the actual resolution, nothing happens. It’s like when you light a firecracker that you expect to explode but all you get is a tiny crackle.
Throughout the first 60%, I kept making excuses for the book because I expected to get better, I wanted it to get better. I wanted it to blow my mind. I wanted it to be everything it had promised. The last 40% opened my eyes and by the last couple of pages I was craughing and really just wanted the book to end. So much disappointment is not good for the soul.
One might attribute the simplicity of the book to the fact that it’s middle grade. I am obviously not the intended audience but if I had read this book in middle school, I would have been heartbroken because it would have made me realize that not all books are great (I never really read a bad book as a kid… yes I am boasting. A little bit. COME ON. My bubble has already been burst.). Plus, as a kid (and almost adult))who loved adventures , it would have bothered me that something that promised to be a fabulous adventure wasn’t one.
My childish aspirations aside, it's clear that I wasn't the intended audience but I don’t know who this book is aimed towards. I suggest that if you’re thinking about reading this one yourself, you may want to skip it unless childish is exactly what you’re looking for after being fed up of everything else.
June 2, 2015
Anyone who has given this book a poor rating didn't really get into the themes of this heart-wrenching tale.
I received this book from a friend online who agreed to review it via Netgalley, but didn't quite connect with the story. That said, I have no connection to the author, publisher, or anyone involved in its production.
The bad: It was told in a formal and somewhat distant tone. (Omniscient present tense.) I've never read a book from that perspective and the way it was narrated periodically pulled me out of the story. I can see where it might be off-putting to potential readers. I'll admit to questioning if I should continue on. There was even a point 1/4 to 1/3 of the way through the book where I debated putting it down because of a tear-inducing plot twist...but when a book actually draws tears, I know I'm invested in the characters.
The good: So often we read about people who are just struggling to get by with whatever morals they happen to possess. It's rare we read about someone who is truly and honestly trying to be good in every way possible. I suppose that's what won me. Alexos is very human, like each of us, but he realistically suppresses all dark urges to lash out in favor of doing what's right. His struggle is near-tangible. He is exactly the kind of role model middle grade readers should be following, especially in the day of self-interest and self-preservation.
Another fault of our society is a resort to violence in place of mercy and tolerance. Both extremes were brought to the forefront through story conflicts. What was perfectly illustrated was the difference a little more kindness and understanding makes on those who are perceived even as enemies. I found myself softening through the story and questioning if I ever behaved too rashly with others.
So there you have it. The merits shine through. There is a happy ending, but only after significant struggles and heart ache. Is the story perfect? By no means--but as an avid reader, I submit that there is no such thing as a perfect story. I love this one for its heart and courage to perpetuate strong morals. If you have a gripe with that, I don't know what to tell you. Go take a happy pill.
Content warning: unkindness and a war backdrop.
I received this book from a friend online who agreed to review it via Netgalley, but didn't quite connect with the story. That said, I have no connection to the author, publisher, or anyone involved in its production.
The bad: It was told in a formal and somewhat distant tone. (Omniscient present tense.) I've never read a book from that perspective and the way it was narrated periodically pulled me out of the story. I can see where it might be off-putting to potential readers. I'll admit to questioning if I should continue on. There was even a point 1/4 to 1/3 of the way through the book where I debated putting it down because of a tear-inducing plot twist...but when a book actually draws tears, I know I'm invested in the characters.
The good: So often we read about people who are just struggling to get by with whatever morals they happen to possess. It's rare we read about someone who is truly and honestly trying to be good in every way possible. I suppose that's what won me. Alexos is very human, like each of us, but he realistically suppresses all dark urges to lash out in favor of doing what's right. His struggle is near-tangible. He is exactly the kind of role model middle grade readers should be following, especially in the day of self-interest and self-preservation.
Another fault of our society is a resort to violence in place of mercy and tolerance. Both extremes were brought to the forefront through story conflicts. What was perfectly illustrated was the difference a little more kindness and understanding makes on those who are perceived even as enemies. I found myself softening through the story and questioning if I ever behaved too rashly with others.
So there you have it. The merits shine through. There is a happy ending, but only after significant struggles and heart ache. Is the story perfect? By no means--but as an avid reader, I submit that there is no such thing as a perfect story. I love this one for its heart and courage to perpetuate strong morals. If you have a gripe with that, I don't know what to tell you. Go take a happy pill.
Content warning: unkindness and a war backdrop.
October 20, 2015
I really enjoyed this book. The world building intrigued me--it felt very real. I also enjoyed the unusual voice of the characters. They talk in a very formal way, because they're nobility and this is the way they've learned to speak, but the antics of young boys still show through.
I also loved the themes and symbolism. Like The Chronicles of Narnia, there are some great Christian symbolism and teachings that are woven so well into the narrative that they don't interrupt the story.
After reading this book, I'm definitely going to look up the other titles by this author.
I also loved the themes and symbolism. Like The Chronicles of Narnia, there are some great Christian symbolism and teachings that are woven so well into the narrative that they don't interrupt the story.
After reading this book, I'm definitely going to look up the other titles by this author.
March 23, 2015
This review is also available on my blog, Read Till Dawn.
I . . . really don't know if I liked this book. I suppose if I have to think so hard the answer is "no," but it just isn't that simple. On one hand, I loved it. It was deep, moving, and meaningful, with a lovable main character and an emotionally manipulative plot. On the other hand, I spent most of the book semi-loathing said main character, because I didn't know if I could bring myself to love someone who had done what he did. I both empathized with and despised Alexos, and my stomach twisted (and still twists right now, actually) at the horrible event that happens a third of the way into the book.
On the other hand, I loved Alexos for how much his father and the gods put him through. He never really gets a childhood, loses his ability to walk correctly to a summer sickness that sounds a lot like polio, and is practically cast aside by his ruthless father after becoming crippled. Despite all this (and perhaps even because of some of it), he is strong, good, and kind, wishing for nothing more than to make his kingdom a better place. I only wish a certain event had not happened, or at least not happened the way it did, because I could have really, really, loved Alexos for everything he went through. As it was, I couldn't help feeling (horrible as it sounds) like perhaps he deserved everything that happened to him. If I read the book again now I would probably like it a lot better, but I still hate The Chosen Prince for the way it utterly horrified me just far enough in that I couldn't stop reading, but early enough that I spent the majority of the book miserable.
A lot of the other reviews I've read of this book complain about the narration, which is third person present, calling it clumsy and distracting. The only times I had any trouble with it were when something was being talked about in past tense. I'm so used to reading third person in past tense that I had a hard time remembering that when say, the narration talks about what Alexos did, it's talking about something that happened before the scene I'm currently reading. This was a relatively minor issue, though, and overall it worked fine for me. Props to Stanley for trying something new!
I absolutely love Diane Stanley's Silver Bowl trilogy, and her standalone Bella at Midnight is a fun fairy tale retelling that isn't wonderful, but isn't horrible. This, however, almost feels like a different author wrote it altogether, and I don't think I'm as big a fan of this author as I am of the other. I do love The Chosen Prince, but I also hate it. And I don't think I'll be recommending it to anyone any time soon, just because I don't want to be the one to recommend something so horrifying, but I can't really give a very good warning about it without spoiling the whole story. So if you're deciding whether or not to read it, I can't really help you. I'm sorry!
I . . . really don't know if I liked this book. I suppose if I have to think so hard the answer is "no," but it just isn't that simple. On one hand, I loved it. It was deep, moving, and meaningful, with a lovable main character and an emotionally manipulative plot. On the other hand, I spent most of the book semi-loathing said main character, because I didn't know if I could bring myself to love someone who had done what he did. I both empathized with and despised Alexos, and my stomach twisted (and still twists right now, actually) at the horrible event that happens a third of the way into the book.
On the other hand, I loved Alexos for how much his father and the gods put him through. He never really gets a childhood, loses his ability to walk correctly to a summer sickness that sounds a lot like polio, and is practically cast aside by his ruthless father after becoming crippled. Despite all this (and perhaps even because of some of it), he is strong, good, and kind, wishing for nothing more than to make his kingdom a better place. I only wish a certain event had not happened, or at least not happened the way it did, because I could have really, really, loved Alexos for everything he went through. As it was, I couldn't help feeling (horrible as it sounds) like perhaps he deserved everything that happened to him. If I read the book again now I would probably like it a lot better, but I still hate The Chosen Prince for the way it utterly horrified me just far enough in that I couldn't stop reading, but early enough that I spent the majority of the book miserable.
A lot of the other reviews I've read of this book complain about the narration, which is third person present, calling it clumsy and distracting. The only times I had any trouble with it were when something was being talked about in past tense. I'm so used to reading third person in past tense that I had a hard time remembering that when say, the narration talks about what Alexos did, it's talking about something that happened before the scene I'm currently reading. This was a relatively minor issue, though, and overall it worked fine for me. Props to Stanley for trying something new!
I absolutely love Diane Stanley's Silver Bowl trilogy, and her standalone Bella at Midnight is a fun fairy tale retelling that isn't wonderful, but isn't horrible. This, however, almost feels like a different author wrote it altogether, and I don't think I'm as big a fan of this author as I am of the other. I do love The Chosen Prince, but I also hate it. And I don't think I'll be recommending it to anyone any time soon, just because I don't want to be the one to recommend something so horrifying, but I can't really give a very good warning about it without spoiling the whole story. So if you're deciding whether or not to read it, I can't really help you. I'm sorry!
June 5, 2020
I really enjoyed this middle grade novel. The second half is a very interesting retelling of Shakespeare’s The Tempest, and also a very fascinating exploration of the nature of forgiveness and guilt. This was one of the best books I have read that really explored in depth the nature of forgiveness from so many angles. The story is interesting as well, but it was the ideas that I enjoyed most. That and the main character is such an inspiring role model of someone overcoming a very hard lot in life (sudden onset of disabilities).
August 22, 2023
I’m very glad that I continued reading this book through it’s plodding, frustrating beginning. The second-half was engrossing, original, and very exciting. With on-point mythological references and engaging characters, the author painted a beautiful picture of life’s challenges, emotions, and the importance of forgiveness. Highly recommended.
April 29, 2026
What an absolute gem! Absolutely loved this middle grade novel and wonder how I didn't find it sooner.
May 19, 2022
I really enjoyed this book. Maybe it was because I read it after The Girl Who Looked Beyond the Stars, but it was still really good.
January 18, 2018
Fairytale retellings are one of my favorite genres, so it was interesting to read this one based on Greek mythology and Shakespeare's "The Tempest".
Other reviewers mention being pulled out of the story by the the 3rd person, present tense point of view, and I agree that it was kind of awkward at times. But I liked the way the characters' stories interconnect, and I enjoyed the characters. This book has themes of doing the right thing / doing your best even when bad things happen to you, using your talents and resources make the world better, love of friends and family and the effect it has on them, and forgiveness.
Some reviewers complain about the heavy deus ex machina, but I would say it fits, since it's basically a Greek myth, and the whole plot is supposed to be Athene's big scheme. She is constructing a play for Zeus, and the characters in the story are also Athene's characters in the drama she creates.
Other reviewers mention being pulled out of the story by the the 3rd person, present tense point of view, and I agree that it was kind of awkward at times. But I liked the way the characters' stories interconnect, and I enjoyed the characters. This book has themes of doing the right thing / doing your best even when bad things happen to you, using your talents and resources make the world better, love of friends and family and the effect it has on them, and forgiveness.
Some reviewers complain about the heavy deus ex machina, but I would say it fits, since it's basically a Greek myth, and the whole plot is supposed to be Athene's big scheme. She is constructing a play for Zeus, and the characters in the story are also Athene's characters in the drama she creates.
August 11, 2017
Wow. A truly breathtaking story of forgiveness and mercy. Of war and sacrifice. And ultimately striving to do what's right. You can't help but fall in love with every single character you find in these pages. Incredibly eye-opening and heart-expanding, leaving you changed and able to look into yourself and the way you treat others. This book bumped itself up to the top of my favorites list with absolute ease. A must read. I'm stunned. Wow.
February 2, 2017
This was a great read! Set in Ancient Greece, the kingdom of Arcoferra has been cursed by Zeus. Alexos has been chosen by Athena to be the champion who saves them. But what qualities make a true champion? Great discussion starter: strength vs. weakness, wisdom vs. foolishness, greatness vs. goodness, mercy vs. justice, forgiveness and sacrifice.
July 18, 2015
Loved it, it was such an amazing story of sacrifice and courage that my book hangover lasted a lot longer than usual.
December 7, 2017
The book I read was "The Chosen Prince" and it was written by Diane Stanley. The publisher for this book was HarperCollins Publishers and it was published in 2015. I wanted to read this book at first because I tend to enjoy books with fantasy and when reading the introductory portion on the back of the book, I wanted to read more and find out more about the context about that particular portion of the book. The themes I found throughout this book include: "Over time, people and/or their opinions can change" and "Sometimes you have to put your feet in another person's shoes to understand their viewpoint and perspective for a situation."
This story's plot comes to a compromise once everyone hears about how Alexos was the one who left Teo to his "death." Moreover, the context shows us, Athena did make the land on purpose, for the purpose of meeting Pyratos and making his wrongs right to his uncle, resulting in more than just forgiveness. An example of the theme for Prince Alexos was how he was burdened and expected of so much, he was depressed, leading to the “death” of his brother, Teo, the newly pronounced heir. But once his father died and he had lots and lots of time, he felt guilty and wanted to die in his brother’s place. Another example for Aria was how she was mad and wanted to kill Alexos for taking so much away Teo, but once she knew how it felt to be in his shoes, she understood the reasoning for his actions and even started to feel bad for him. An example for Teo was how he looked up so much to his brother, Alexos, but when being led to what should have been his death, but instead an island that Athena prepared for him, realized his feelings when he meets with him later. He gets so mad at Alexos for what Alexos did in the past, he “kicks at his brother-two, three, four times, aiming most especially at his legs” but changed once more and forgives Alexos for his past actions.
To conclude, the theme is shown clearly through the characters as well as the plot as three examples of characters that were Alexos, Aria and Teo as well as the plot that showed how even some people who used to friends with Alexos had an altogether confused state or just could not believe what they heard, while on the other hand, some characters who thought Alexos was a bad person, forgived him or looked from his perspective, figuratively and literally, and felt like how it would feel to be like Alexos. I think this book would be good for all middle school students as it does not use any explicit words although the book does have a brief kissing part in the end as well as a deep emotional parts especially when Alexo's thought are exhibited in the text. I thought this book would have been better if there was more action in it. Although, there was a lot of text that was deep, especially when Alexo’s thoughts were shown to the reader, which made it emotional especially when he lets go of the rope handle to the boat that is inhabited by his brother, not even knowing. The deep parts make the reader really feel and go into the book which I very much enjoyed. This book was a great read which I enjoyed reading. It was different than your classic fairytale fantasy. This book had a more serious and formal tone and described very well using just the right words.
This story's plot comes to a compromise once everyone hears about how Alexos was the one who left Teo to his "death." Moreover, the context shows us, Athena did make the land on purpose, for the purpose of meeting Pyratos and making his wrongs right to his uncle, resulting in more than just forgiveness. An example of the theme for Prince Alexos was how he was burdened and expected of so much, he was depressed, leading to the “death” of his brother, Teo, the newly pronounced heir. But once his father died and he had lots and lots of time, he felt guilty and wanted to die in his brother’s place. Another example for Aria was how she was mad and wanted to kill Alexos for taking so much away Teo, but once she knew how it felt to be in his shoes, she understood the reasoning for his actions and even started to feel bad for him. An example for Teo was how he looked up so much to his brother, Alexos, but when being led to what should have been his death, but instead an island that Athena prepared for him, realized his feelings when he meets with him later. He gets so mad at Alexos for what Alexos did in the past, he “kicks at his brother-two, three, four times, aiming most especially at his legs” but changed once more and forgives Alexos for his past actions.
To conclude, the theme is shown clearly through the characters as well as the plot as three examples of characters that were Alexos, Aria and Teo as well as the plot that showed how even some people who used to friends with Alexos had an altogether confused state or just could not believe what they heard, while on the other hand, some characters who thought Alexos was a bad person, forgived him or looked from his perspective, figuratively and literally, and felt like how it would feel to be like Alexos. I think this book would be good for all middle school students as it does not use any explicit words although the book does have a brief kissing part in the end as well as a deep emotional parts especially when Alexo's thought are exhibited in the text. I thought this book would have been better if there was more action in it. Although, there was a lot of text that was deep, especially when Alexo’s thoughts were shown to the reader, which made it emotional especially when he lets go of the rope handle to the boat that is inhabited by his brother, not even knowing. The deep parts make the reader really feel and go into the book which I very much enjoyed. This book was a great read which I enjoyed reading. It was different than your classic fairytale fantasy. This book had a more serious and formal tone and described very well using just the right words.
December 13, 2018
When I heard this book was a blend of Greek myth and the Tempest, I was intrigued.
Really enjoyed it leading up to the climax, but then the conflict seemed to be very conveniently solved in just a matter of some pages and several conversations. (I listened to the audiobook while driving, and there was a point when I even said aloud, "Well, that was convenient.") It seemed like most of the book was just leading up to a rather simple resolution. Still, the characters were interesting, as the worldbuilding, and perhaps the somewhat cheesy resolution will resonate with middle-grade readers, which is the intended audience.
Really enjoyed it leading up to the climax, but then the conflict seemed to be very conveniently solved in just a matter of some pages and several conversations. (I listened to the audiobook while driving, and there was a point when I even said aloud, "Well, that was convenient.") It seemed like most of the book was just leading up to a rather simple resolution. Still, the characters were interesting, as the worldbuilding, and perhaps the somewhat cheesy resolution will resonate with middle-grade readers, which is the intended audience.
February 14, 2018
...This is one of the best stories about love, mercy, anger, pain, and forgiveness that I've ever heard in my life. Despite being in the theme of Greek mythology, it actually has a real strong Christian message in it. XD Not sure if intended or not, but WOW. With the amount of hate that's in the world today, the world needs to read this book and wake up. Love is important, but for forgiveness is also just as equally important, and I think that's something the world needs better practice with.
Highly recommended.
PG 10+ for mild violence and some awkward kissing. 8)
Highly recommended.
PG 10+ for mild violence and some awkward kissing. 8)
January 18, 2025
I loved this Greek Mythology fantasy for ages 8-12. I really loved the reader, too--Robertson Dean. Great voice and great job. This was so romantic, in both senses of the word. Sometimes I wondered if the first half was a bit slow and sad for the age group, but I LOVED how it ended! And it was such a great message. The gods and goddesses are real in this story, but we don't actually see or hear them. Their will determines what happens to create the outcome. I wish Athene was in charge here. Sigh.
November 20, 2022
I felt that this was a wonderful retelling of Shakespeare's The Tempest, in a very accessible way for children and others who may not understand Shakespeare. The themes of forgiveness and mercy are beautifully drawn. The characters and emotions were very realistic and believable. I thoroughly enjoyed this book and recomment it to anyone.
December 4, 2020
I really pushed to read this one - mythology is not my jam, quite honestly - at least it wasn't in the past. However, maybe things are changing! Now I want to read every single word Diane Stanley has ever written. What a beautiful tale of redemption, forgiveness and love.
January 25, 2023
An interesting book! I really enjoyed reading it, but I think it is best to read like you would a Greek Myth. If you read it more like a novel, the narration can be confusing and the characters hard to understand.
August 22, 2024
This is a middle grade fiction book with an interesting storyline, good lessons on forgiveness, and a single swear word that makes it unrecommendable. I grow increasingly frustrated by the inclusion of swear words in books written for children.
CC: Greek gods & godesses, one swear word, death
CC: Greek gods & godesses, one swear word, death
June 12, 2017
Stanley combines ancient Greek mythology with Shakespeare's: "The Tempest."
Since the original play features mythological figures the story line
fits.
Since the original play features mythological figures the story line
fits.
July 25, 2017
DNF at 30%.
February 12, 2018
I wish there was a second book.
May 17, 2020
I loved this book! its very deep and emotional. made me cry!
August 30, 2025
My favorite kind of book -- grounded in faith in a living God (Athena here), and rich in the life affirming lessons of nobility, love, sacrifice, loyalty, and redemption from human weakness.
April 2, 2026
Kinda lost me with the time skip. Felt like there was a whole book missing in between the beginning and the climax.
February 23, 2015
Originally reviewed at http://www.shaelit.com/2015/02/review...
Oh, book. How shall I discuss you? On the one hand, I enjoyed you, and you did some pretty awesome things. But on the other hand, parts of you were just not good. Let's discuss.
The Chosen Prince is primarily about Alexos, a prince and the presumed hero of Athene. According to signs at his birth, Alexos is supposed to end the never-ending war that's plagued his country. Of course, with great power, blah blah blah, so poor Alexos feels the weight of his destiny every second of his life. He is expected to be unrealistically mature in all things, perfect in every way, a general to inspire his classmates but also set apart. He's a miserable kid, and I felt pretty awful for him. The only truly bright spot in his life is his little brother, the universally adored younger prince, Teo. What a sweet little munchkin.
Okay, so, I can't really talk about the plot. I honestly remember more about the Wishbone version of The Tempest rather than the original Shakespeare, and I don't want to risk ruining anything for anyone. But a THING happens to poor Alexos, and it just about broke my heart. Well, two things, really, but the first one just made me generally sad while the second made me gasp on the train. Great heavens to betsy.
I wanted so badly to adore this book. I did in parts, like during the aforementioned THINGS, the lovely history of Alexos's world (complete with a curse straight from Zeus!), or during the bro moments between Alexos, Leander, and Peles. The characters themselves are pretty neat, and I would love to see what could be done with them by, say, Megan Whalen Turner. Dig right in there! Gimme some depth and heartache! But sadly, I did not get what I wanted.
First of all, the present tense kept bumping me straight out of the story. I don't know why, but I think the story would have been better in the past tense. Also, the narrator is extremely omniscient and indulges in far too much telling over showing. ("He rises from the stool now. She marvels at his maneuvers..." etc.) Every time I tried to dig into the characters, the telling pushed me back. Also distancing? The preaching. Holy wow. Granted, a lot of classic fables were made to impart a moral, but man, this one lays it on pretty thick. Suliman, sweetheart that he is, is preachy as all get-out, and the ending is one slopping spoonful of morality. Also, there are some disgustingly convenient plot points that I just can't deal with. I don't know if they were in the original work (I suspect some were, but hopefully not all), but honestly. It is okay to deviate from the source material when writing a retelling, especially if the source material includes a literal deus ex machina in the form of visions in the fog. Yeesh. There are other things, too, but you can see those in the "Subtracted" section at the bottom of this review.
I wish I had a magic wand. Or Athena's favor. Something that I could use to boop this manuscript on its figurative nose and magically give it the depth and technique it deserves. I guess I should have skipped this retelling and gone straight to Shakespeare. Poor, poor Alexos.
Favorite Non-Spoilery Quotes:
Points Added For: The relationships between Alexos, Teo, Leander, Peles, and Suliman. All quite sweet. Love the history lesson at the beginning of the book, too.
Points Subtracted For: Present tense, an intrusively omniscient narrator, poor wording (I really don't think four-year-old Teo would think of anyone as "gaunt, wizened, and brooding"), far too much preaching, weird time jumps, a weak romance, and irritatingly convenient plot devices.
Good For Fans Of: Greek myths, The Tempest, stories with morals
Notes For Parents: Death, attempted murder, physical violence against a female, one kiss.
Note: I received a review copy of this title from the publisher for review consideration.
Oh, book. How shall I discuss you? On the one hand, I enjoyed you, and you did some pretty awesome things. But on the other hand, parts of you were just not good. Let's discuss.
The Chosen Prince is primarily about Alexos, a prince and the presumed hero of Athene. According to signs at his birth, Alexos is supposed to end the never-ending war that's plagued his country. Of course, with great power, blah blah blah, so poor Alexos feels the weight of his destiny every second of his life. He is expected to be unrealistically mature in all things, perfect in every way, a general to inspire his classmates but also set apart. He's a miserable kid, and I felt pretty awful for him. The only truly bright spot in his life is his little brother, the universally adored younger prince, Teo. What a sweet little munchkin.
Okay, so, I can't really talk about the plot. I honestly remember more about the Wishbone version of The Tempest rather than the original Shakespeare, and I don't want to risk ruining anything for anyone. But a THING happens to poor Alexos, and it just about broke my heart. Well, two things, really, but the first one just made me generally sad while the second made me gasp on the train. Great heavens to betsy.
I wanted so badly to adore this book. I did in parts, like during the aforementioned THINGS, the lovely history of Alexos's world (complete with a curse straight from Zeus!), or during the bro moments between Alexos, Leander, and Peles. The characters themselves are pretty neat, and I would love to see what could be done with them by, say, Megan Whalen Turner. Dig right in there! Gimme some depth and heartache! But sadly, I did not get what I wanted.
First of all, the present tense kept bumping me straight out of the story. I don't know why, but I think the story would have been better in the past tense. Also, the narrator is extremely omniscient and indulges in far too much telling over showing. ("He rises from the stool now. She marvels at his maneuvers..." etc.) Every time I tried to dig into the characters, the telling pushed me back. Also distancing? The preaching. Holy wow. Granted, a lot of classic fables were made to impart a moral, but man, this one lays it on pretty thick. Suliman, sweetheart that he is, is preachy as all get-out, and the ending is one slopping spoonful of morality. Also, there are some disgustingly convenient plot points that I just can't deal with. I don't know if they were in the original work (I suspect some were, but hopefully not all), but honestly. It is okay to deviate from the source material when writing a retelling, especially if the source material includes a literal deus ex machina in the form of visions in the fog. Yeesh. There are other things, too, but you can see those in the "Subtracted" section at the bottom of this review.
I wish I had a magic wand. Or Athena's favor. Something that I could use to boop this manuscript on its figurative nose and magically give it the depth and technique it deserves. I guess I should have skipped this retelling and gone straight to Shakespeare. Poor, poor Alexos.
Favorite Non-Spoilery Quotes:
"Well, the goddess Athene is, as you know, famously merciful and kind. And I think she must have looked down on me that day—so tiny and defenseless, you know, with all that hard work ahead of me—and felt pity in her heart. So she changed her mind and gave me one gift after all. What do you suppose it was?"
"It was you, Teo. The goddess gave me you."
Points Added For: The relationships between Alexos, Teo, Leander, Peles, and Suliman. All quite sweet. Love the history lesson at the beginning of the book, too.
Points Subtracted For: Present tense, an intrusively omniscient narrator, poor wording (I really don't think four-year-old Teo would think of anyone as "gaunt, wizened, and brooding"), far too much preaching, weird time jumps, a weak romance, and irritatingly convenient plot devices.
Good For Fans Of: Greek myths, The Tempest, stories with morals
Notes For Parents: Death, attempted murder, physical violence against a female, one kiss.
Note: I received a review copy of this title from the publisher for review consideration.
December 18, 2015
From the elation on reading the synopsis for this title, and thinking I had found a wonderful book for middle-grade readers, with elements based on The Tempest. Diane Stanley sets herself a task that, sadly, is insurmountable with this title.
From awkward perspective in third-person present tense, to little to no fantasy and a protagonist / hero that is in his 20’s and yet unbelievably immature, I didn’t see The Tempest or find myself remotely reminded of it in this inconsistent and unlikely tale.
Firstly – this reads as historical fiction, with very little elements to explain the ‘why’, and the only fantastical moment comes from a belief in the Greek Gods of old. Early on, Alexos was rather compelling, if far too old in his approach than a 13 year old should be. Then we fast forward 7 or so years – and it is a 20 something character who manages to devolve in maturity to a sub 9 year old at times – the arc for his character progression and development was off, so much so that most of the second half of the book seemed to be another person with a different start entirely. Then to throw in a romance (not every story needs one) that was best described as unnecessary and at worst awkward, well – she lost me. My last hope was for the ending –would it make sense and ‘feel’ appropriate.
And it didn’t. I was disappointed in the simplistic “and they all lived happily ever after” tone and simplicity of the ending. Kids are capable of processing grey areas, understanding conflict and how to find resolution. Sadly, the ending is a pat on the head and a thank you for coming, rather than a leave you smiling and able to dream of the world for days to come. World-building was shortchanged to the detriment of the story, and nothing felt quite “complete”. From an amazing premise to the disappointment of the reality, I’d be hard pressed to pick up another of this author’s titles.
I received an eArc copy of the title from the publisher via Edelweiss for purpose of honest review. I was not compensated for this review: all conclusions are my own responsibility.
From awkward perspective in third-person present tense, to little to no fantasy and a protagonist / hero that is in his 20’s and yet unbelievably immature, I didn’t see The Tempest or find myself remotely reminded of it in this inconsistent and unlikely tale.
Firstly – this reads as historical fiction, with very little elements to explain the ‘why’, and the only fantastical moment comes from a belief in the Greek Gods of old. Early on, Alexos was rather compelling, if far too old in his approach than a 13 year old should be. Then we fast forward 7 or so years – and it is a 20 something character who manages to devolve in maturity to a sub 9 year old at times – the arc for his character progression and development was off, so much so that most of the second half of the book seemed to be another person with a different start entirely. Then to throw in a romance (not every story needs one) that was best described as unnecessary and at worst awkward, well – she lost me. My last hope was for the ending –would it make sense and ‘feel’ appropriate.
And it didn’t. I was disappointed in the simplistic “and they all lived happily ever after” tone and simplicity of the ending. Kids are capable of processing grey areas, understanding conflict and how to find resolution. Sadly, the ending is a pat on the head and a thank you for coming, rather than a leave you smiling and able to dream of the world for days to come. World-building was shortchanged to the detriment of the story, and nothing felt quite “complete”. From an amazing premise to the disappointment of the reality, I’d be hard pressed to pick up another of this author’s titles.
I received an eArc copy of the title from the publisher via Edelweiss for purpose of honest review. I was not compensated for this review: all conclusions are my own responsibility.
November 19, 2015
School Library Journal
★ 12/01/2014
Gr 5–8—Stanley's newest fantasy, set in ancient Greece, is a bittersweet delight. Prince Alexos learns early that being the champion of a goddess does not make for an easy life. Alexos is destined to bring about reconciliation between battling gods, Athene and Zeus, if he can survive a childhood filled with near-impossible challenge and little joy, except for his love of running and his little brother Teo. However, by the age of 12, even these are lost to him. As he struggles to regain the use of his legs and recover from causing the death of his beloved brother, Alexos learns from a wise mentor, develops relationships with people from all levels of society, and becomes a force for good. At the same time, he is comforted by visions of his brother in the land of the dead, living an idyllic life with a new father and sister. However, the protagonist soon learns that all is not as it seems. Alexos is a strong character, capable of accepting and adapting to change, even as he struggles with heartbreak and almost insurmountable odds. Other characters—especially the court physician Suliman and Teo's new sister Aria—are equally well done. The language is lyrical and accessible, and the end is satisfying in the extreme.—Mara Alpert, Los Angeles Public Library
This would be a good next read for students who are fans of the Percy Jackson series. It is a very engaging story, billed as being inspired by Shakespear's The Tempest. It is a little difficult to accept the main character as aging 7 years just past the halfway point in the book. Overall, a G+ on the PPS scale.
★ 12/01/2014
Gr 5–8—Stanley's newest fantasy, set in ancient Greece, is a bittersweet delight. Prince Alexos learns early that being the champion of a goddess does not make for an easy life. Alexos is destined to bring about reconciliation between battling gods, Athene and Zeus, if he can survive a childhood filled with near-impossible challenge and little joy, except for his love of running and his little brother Teo. However, by the age of 12, even these are lost to him. As he struggles to regain the use of his legs and recover from causing the death of his beloved brother, Alexos learns from a wise mentor, develops relationships with people from all levels of society, and becomes a force for good. At the same time, he is comforted by visions of his brother in the land of the dead, living an idyllic life with a new father and sister. However, the protagonist soon learns that all is not as it seems. Alexos is a strong character, capable of accepting and adapting to change, even as he struggles with heartbreak and almost insurmountable odds. Other characters—especially the court physician Suliman and Teo's new sister Aria—are equally well done. The language is lyrical and accessible, and the end is satisfying in the extreme.—Mara Alpert, Los Angeles Public Library
This would be a good next read for students who are fans of the Percy Jackson series. It is a very engaging story, billed as being inspired by Shakespear's The Tempest. It is a little difficult to accept the main character as aging 7 years just past the halfway point in the book. Overall, a G+ on the PPS scale.
February 1, 2015
I liked this story- although there was a time I thought it was similar to another story I had read, but couldn't quite recall which one it was- the idea of them being on a special island and learning- growing, etc.
The story of Alexos is sad, but one in which I am inspired by his greatness and carrying on even despite all of the things he suffered. I am amazed at how well he was able to understand others, to put himself as humble when he was the prince. He suffered a lot, I hope that he has a chance at happiness, but the idea at the end of the book in which, he was supposed to die, made me worry that perhaps there might be another story that would be more sad. For someone to overcome the unloved childhood, the pressures of being perfect, the one joy in life- running taken away- the hardships of making friends and then having him do the unspeakable thing he did- the remorse would have killed many- his story reminds me of Job in the Bible- everything was taken away and yet he carried on- so too with Alexos, his mother, his father, his legs, his brother, the hardships of being a leader- thank goodness for Suliman and Peles. One would hope that Leander would come around after he was told the truth, because he was indeed a good friend. The Greek Gods being a part of this story make it a good read, one with a lot of sadness, but also one that shows remarkable greatness. I liked her other stories as well- good for 10 and up.
The story of Alexos is sad, but one in which I am inspired by his greatness and carrying on even despite all of the things he suffered. I am amazed at how well he was able to understand others, to put himself as humble when he was the prince. He suffered a lot, I hope that he has a chance at happiness, but the idea at the end of the book in which, he was supposed to die, made me worry that perhaps there might be another story that would be more sad. For someone to overcome the unloved childhood, the pressures of being perfect, the one joy in life- running taken away- the hardships of making friends and then having him do the unspeakable thing he did- the remorse would have killed many- his story reminds me of Job in the Bible- everything was taken away and yet he carried on- so too with Alexos, his mother, his father, his legs, his brother, the hardships of being a leader- thank goodness for Suliman and Peles. One would hope that Leander would come around after he was told the truth, because he was indeed a good friend. The Greek Gods being a part of this story make it a good read, one with a lot of sadness, but also one that shows remarkable greatness. I liked her other stories as well- good for 10 and up.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 67 reviews