I want to preface this review by saying that I do really like Emma Kenny. My partner and I saw her on her live tour, of this very subject matter, just over a year ago. He had introduced me to her podcast, Bang to Rights, and I do enjoy listening to that (if enjoy is the right word). I can appreciate how much research she puts into the cases that she discusses, and I find that she always treats the cases, especially the victims, with respect. Admittedly, because of the subject matter, I can only take a few of her episodes at a time, before I need to go and listen to something completely different. So when I came to this book, I expected to find it interesting, well written, engaging and slightly stomach churning. So why the mediocre score, I hear you ask, well the few of you who may read this review, at least.
I think the first stumbling block for me was that I was expecting something a little different. The book has 15 chapters, each of which looks at one serial killer at a time. You are given some of their background, musings on why and how they became the horrific killers that they did. But in a strange sense, you don't feel as though you are discovering anything new about their psychopathy, and how these people can commit such heinous crimes one moment, whilst walking amongst us. To me, and maybe it is because I have listened to a lot of her podcasts, but each new case just felt like a repetition of the previous one. Perhaps I am being unkind, but there was something about this book which made it feel a little superficial to me. Constantly, I felt as though she was just skimming the surface. There is detail here - please be aware that there is quite detailed information about what these people did to others to satisfy their sadistic desires - but there seems to be little substance. Of the 15 cases, 5 deal with female serial killers but there was little meaningful exploration as to how female and male psychopathy can differ; for instance why are serial killers predominantly male?
I truly didn't expect to feel this conflicted toward this book. Whilst I felt that her podcasts flow very well, this book felt a little fragmented. Perhaps it is her writing style which jars for me, I honestly don't know.
With a heavy heart, this is 2.5 stars, rounded up.