What do you think?
Rate this book
Smallhope & Pennyroyal #1
The Ballad of Smallhope and Pennyroyal
Meet your favourite new partners-in-crime in 2024’s most hilarious time-travel caper
450 pages, Paperback
First published September 12, 2024
About the author
Jodi Taylor
100 books5,596 followersJodi Taylor is the internationally bestselling author of the Chronicles of St Mary's series, the story of a bunch of disaster prone individuals who investigate major historical events in contemporary time. Do NOT call it time travel! She is also the author of the Time Police series - a St Mary's spinoff and gateway into the world of an all-powerful, international organisation who are NOTHING like St Mary's. Except, when they are.
Alongside these, Jodi is known for her gripping supernatural thrillers featuring Elizabeth Cage together with the enchanting Frogmorton Farm series - a fairy story for adults.
Born in Bristol and now living in Gloucester (facts both cities vigorously deny), she spent many years with her head somewhere else, much to the dismay of family, teachers and employers, before finally deciding to put all that daydreaming to good use and write a novel. Over twenty books later, she still has no idea what she wants to do when she grows up.
Alongside these, Jodi is known for her gripping supernatural thrillers featuring Elizabeth Cage together with the enchanting Frogmorton Farm series - a fairy story for adults.
Born in Bristol and now living in Gloucester (facts both cities vigorously deny), she spent many years with her head somewhere else, much to the dismay of family, teachers and employers, before finally deciding to put all that daydreaming to good use and write a novel. Over twenty books later, she still has no idea what she wants to do when she grows up.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 474 reviews
August 2, 2024
ARC received in exchange for an honest review.
Smallhope and Pennyroyal, the mysterious time travelling bounty hunters of the St Mary's and Time Police series, are back with an origin story. I loved learning about how the pair met and came to be partners in crime, and also seeing a lot of the infamous escapades of past adventures from their perspective. The storyline is fast paced and unrelenting, making this an easy and enjoyable read that grabs the reader from the start, enticing them with stalking peacocks and complicated families, and not letting go.
If there's one thing that Jodi Taylor excels in, it's making loveable and villainous characters and this story is no different. Amelia and Pennyroyal are a great dynamic pair, similar in many ways in their loneliness when first they meet, yet coming to mutually respect each other and grow together. They're a bit morally grey, taking no prisoners, but they're good at their core. Pennyroyal remains as enigmatic as ever though. The same cannot be said for the villain of the story, who I eagerly waited in anticipation for their downfall. And when it came, it did not disappoint.
I wouldn't really recommend reading this if you're unfamiliar with the St Mary's and Time Police series as this is filled with spoilers for those stories. However, if you're wanting to jump in feet first and aren't bothered about the previous books, this might be a good introduction to these characters.
I always know I'm in good hands with Jodi Taylor, who never lets me down in providing a rollicking good time.
Smallhope and Pennyroyal, the mysterious time travelling bounty hunters of the St Mary's and Time Police series, are back with an origin story. I loved learning about how the pair met and came to be partners in crime, and also seeing a lot of the infamous escapades of past adventures from their perspective. The storyline is fast paced and unrelenting, making this an easy and enjoyable read that grabs the reader from the start, enticing them with stalking peacocks and complicated families, and not letting go.
If there's one thing that Jodi Taylor excels in, it's making loveable and villainous characters and this story is no different. Amelia and Pennyroyal are a great dynamic pair, similar in many ways in their loneliness when first they meet, yet coming to mutually respect each other and grow together. They're a bit morally grey, taking no prisoners, but they're good at their core. Pennyroyal remains as enigmatic as ever though. The same cannot be said for the villain of the story, who I eagerly waited in anticipation for their downfall. And when it came, it did not disappoint.
I wouldn't really recommend reading this if you're unfamiliar with the St Mary's and Time Police series as this is filled with spoilers for those stories. However, if you're wanting to jump in feet first and aren't bothered about the previous books, this might be a good introduction to these characters.
I always know I'm in good hands with Jodi Taylor, who never lets me down in providing a rollicking good time.
September 16, 2024
I'm a stingy witch when it comes to ratings so, hurray, a 5 star. No surprise it's Jodi Taylor.
Smallhope and Pennyroyal have popped up in Taylor's ST. Mary's and Time Police series as extra spice to the broth. S & P are a combination of Jeeves & Wooster with a dash of Cole Porter sophistication, always humorous and so cool. The Ballad of Smallhope and Pennyroyal, their origin story, is a much more poignant and serious tone.
I'm not going to get into it all but essentially we see it primarily from the perspective of Lady Smallhope and what drove her to become a time traveling bounty hunter, excuse me , recovery agent and how she meets Pennyroyal. We do get Pennyroyal as well, but the majority of reflection is Smallhope.
Numerous references to Taylor's other series, but Doctor Who, the Beatles. Can't help but think that's where Uncle Albert came from.
I'm blown away once again by Jodi Taylor!!! I need a margarita now.
Smallhope and Pennyroyal have popped up in Taylor's ST. Mary's and Time Police series as extra spice to the broth. S & P are a combination of Jeeves & Wooster with a dash of Cole Porter sophistication, always humorous and so cool. The Ballad of Smallhope and Pennyroyal, their origin story, is a much more poignant and serious tone.
I'm not going to get into it all but essentially we see it primarily from the perspective of Lady Smallhope and what drove her to become a time traveling bounty hunter, excuse me , recovery agent and how she meets Pennyroyal. We do get Pennyroyal as well, but the majority of reflection is Smallhope.
Numerous references to Taylor's other series, but Doctor Who, the Beatles. Can't help but think that's where Uncle Albert came from.
I'm blown away once again by Jodi Taylor!!! I need a margarita now.
December 30, 2024
The best scene came less than 50 pages from the end. Getting to this point was a pleasure though.
We all know
A wonderful, action-laden romp through all kinds of historical periods and places, but most importantly, this is about good old-fashioned revenge (working it out, taking it, what it does to you both physically and emotionally)! Amelia's family (mostly her in-laws) are THE WORST. I couldn't wait for them to get theirs.
Once again, I opted for the audio version because Zara Ramm was reading this one as well and once again, I didn't regret my choice at all. The woman is a wizard!
It didn't hurt that I have had a crush on Pennyroyal since the first time he made an appearance. *swoons* What can I say? Cold eyes (of any colour), competence in any tricky situation, loyalty, brains, a wicked sense of humour ... how could he not appeal to me, whether he really is a psychopath or not?! ;P
Great standalone entry in the time travel themed books by this author and it's nice seeing them coming together.
August 29, 2024
I have to say I enjoyed this latest Jodi Taylor more than most of the others I've read (bear in mind I've not ventured into the Time Police series yet).
Not because it is funnier - it's as much of a giggle-fest as the others, not because the storyline is better - because all Taylor's stories are clever and well-plotted and not because the characters are better - I love Max and Markham (and even Leon at times) just as much as Smallhope and Pennyroyal.
The sole reason is that there's only sloppy stuff right at the end. I'm afraid, despite it being part of the plot, I get very bored with the sex scenes in the St Mary's books - purely personal taste.
Anyway, in this novel we get an in depth introduction to our two eponymous heroes who, apparently, pop up in various previous books. Both the characters are funny and intelligent and their exploits are excellent. I do love a bit of comedy revenge. It takes us through their initial meeting to their collaboration and beyond.
It's very amusing and has a good, varied plot line that I really looked forward to reading - in fact I rationed myself because I was enjoying it so much. This is the first Taylor I've read rather than listened to but as Zara Ramm is the narrator for the audiobook I'd listen to that too.
This is an excellent addition to the St Mary's/Time Police stable and I'd highly recommend it.
Thankyou very much to Netgalley and Headline for the advance review copy.
Not because it is funnier - it's as much of a giggle-fest as the others, not because the storyline is better - because all Taylor's stories are clever and well-plotted and not because the characters are better - I love Max and Markham (and even Leon at times) just as much as Smallhope and Pennyroyal.
The sole reason is that there's only sloppy stuff right at the end. I'm afraid, despite it being part of the plot, I get very bored with the sex scenes in the St Mary's books - purely personal taste.
Anyway, in this novel we get an in depth introduction to our two eponymous heroes who, apparently, pop up in various previous books. Both the characters are funny and intelligent and their exploits are excellent. I do love a bit of comedy revenge. It takes us through their initial meeting to their collaboration and beyond.
It's very amusing and has a good, varied plot line that I really looked forward to reading - in fact I rationed myself because I was enjoying it so much. This is the first Taylor I've read rather than listened to but as Zara Ramm is the narrator for the audiobook I'd listen to that too.
This is an excellent addition to the St Mary's/Time Police stable and I'd highly recommend it.
Thankyou very much to Netgalley and Headline for the advance review copy.
January 5, 2025
I LOVE Jodi Taylor. For some reason (haven't sussed it out yet), I've been determined not to like Smallwood and Pennyroyal. Well. Color my opinion changed! I did recall each previous time we've met the duo, in the Chronicles of St. Mary's and The Time Police series as well, but she's included a handy little guide in her afterword, in case you missed anything.
I got teary-eyed when she revealed, right after he died, who Uncle Albert was. Then I almost laughed out loud when Pennyroyal played Caroline about that Smart Dust. (There were plumbers here, so I couldn't be seen to be laughing all by myself, you understand.)
I got teary-eyed when she revealed, right after he died, who Uncle Albert was. Then I almost laughed out loud when Pennyroyal played Caroline about that Smart Dust. (There were plumbers here, so I couldn't be seen to be laughing all by myself, you understand.)
January 10, 2026
Smashingly brilliant.
Words to live by: “when things are bad, make them worse” lol
Words to live by: “when things are bad, make them worse” lol
August 2, 2024
I’m such a big fan of Jodi Taylor and her Time Police series. When a friend advised she saw this new novel on NetGalley, I was super excited and had to request it. I wasn’t disappointed.
Smallhope & Pennyroyal make sporadic appearances in some of Taylor’s other books. Always intriguing but not around long enough to learn too much about them, they are the enigmatic Scarlet Pimpernels of the Time Police world. Until now. The Ballad of Smallhope and Pennyroyal covers their back story & it’s everything that Time Police fans would expect. Let’s start from the top.
The prose was engaging as ever, putting you through all sorts of emotions. It went from funny to exciting in the blink of an eye. The speech was always spot on too - I never felt that a character said something that was jarring.
In terms of setting, this was again great - almost a halfway house world between the really futuristic Time Police & the modern world. However, it’s the characterisation where this book really shone. I particularly loved Smallhope who was so well-rounded. She showed so many emotions and all rang true. She is the sort of lady a lot of us real women wish we were inside.
As with the rest of Jodi Taylor’s books, I really enjoyed this one. Thank you to the author, publishers & NetGalley for access to this arc in return for an honest (if slightly gushing!) review 🤣
Smallhope & Pennyroyal make sporadic appearances in some of Taylor’s other books. Always intriguing but not around long enough to learn too much about them, they are the enigmatic Scarlet Pimpernels of the Time Police world. Until now. The Ballad of Smallhope and Pennyroyal covers their back story & it’s everything that Time Police fans would expect. Let’s start from the top.
The prose was engaging as ever, putting you through all sorts of emotions. It went from funny to exciting in the blink of an eye. The speech was always spot on too - I never felt that a character said something that was jarring.
In terms of setting, this was again great - almost a halfway house world between the really futuristic Time Police & the modern world. However, it’s the characterisation where this book really shone. I particularly loved Smallhope who was so well-rounded. She showed so many emotions and all rang true. She is the sort of lady a lot of us real women wish we were inside.
As with the rest of Jodi Taylor’s books, I really enjoyed this one. Thank you to the author, publishers & NetGalley for access to this arc in return for an honest (if slightly gushing!) review 🤣
December 30, 2024
This was fun, just as I always expected from Jodi, but it was also a lovely backstory into Smallhope and Pennyroyal. I highly recommend this one if you have read the St Mary’s and Tome Police series as there’s crossover with many of the characters and events of those. I still think this works as a standalone too as it’s an introduction right from the start of these characters’ lives.
I have to say the relationship between the two MCs grew on me more and more and gradually as it went on. I definitely think they’re fun at the start, but by the end of the book I cared a lot for them, which was really surprising and fun.
In the end, I wish there was more of this. I think it’s only a standalone for now, but I could see a million adventures with these two so if Jodi writes more I will pick it up for sure.
As always, a solid 4*s and love everything she writes!
I have to say the relationship between the two MCs grew on me more and more and gradually as it went on. I definitely think they’re fun at the start, but by the end of the book I cared a lot for them, which was really surprising and fun.
In the end, I wish there was more of this. I think it’s only a standalone for now, but I could see a million adventures with these two so if Jodi writes more I will pick it up for sure.
As always, a solid 4*s and love everything she writes!
August 29, 2024
* I received a free e-ARC via NetGalley in return for my honest review*
I liked this book but it wasn't what I expected. I found it to be simultaneously too similar and too dissimilar to the author's previous works. Too similar in that the main characters felt very like Max and Leon. A beautiful fiery redhead who defends those she loves and a quiet, capable man with a mysterious past. On a couple of occasions Amelia even mentioned what Max would have said if she were there. Too dissimilar in that it was less of a light read than your typical St Mary's book. Violence happens in those books but it is generally a little vague as opposed to the more detailed descriptions in this book. It doesn't happen every time but enough to make it not feel like a light read. There was also more explicit language than usual. I found that without the buffer of any real trips to the past (my usual highlight of a St Mary's book) this was quite a bleak read at times. Especially the ending for the main baddie. There was the humour you would expect from a Jodi Taylor book but it wasn't enough to outweigh the other events.
Characters are divided into the usual clear cut goodies and baddies but they don't feel properly fleshed out. Not even Pennyroyal who is one of the title characters. Maybe there is another book in the works from his point of view but I never felt we got to know him beyond discovering the fridging trope of his motivation. We do learn about Smallhope but other than being informed about the years passing I didn't notice any character development over the circa 16+ years she was away with Pennyroyal.
To get the most out of this book it would be best to be up to date with the St Mary's and Time Police books. It references events from both those series that will make more sense to you if you have read the other books first and will avoid spoilers. I'm not quite sure why the references were included though as we didn't really get to see events from the point of view of Smallhope and Pennyroyal it's mostly just a recounting or a brief mention of events. Maybe it was intended to show how the different timelines fit together but it felt like a wasted opportunity.
If you love the author's writing style full of characters that are witty, sarcastic and sometimes a little odd then this book could definitely be for you. The plot is encumbered a little by all the references to events in other books but still flies along pretty fast.
A book I liked but left me disappointed because I wanted to love it.
I liked this book but it wasn't what I expected. I found it to be simultaneously too similar and too dissimilar to the author's previous works. Too similar in that the main characters felt very like Max and Leon. A beautiful fiery redhead who defends those she loves and a quiet, capable man with a mysterious past. On a couple of occasions Amelia even mentioned what Max would have said if she were there. Too dissimilar in that it was less of a light read than your typical St Mary's book. Violence happens in those books but it is generally a little vague as opposed to the more detailed descriptions in this book. It doesn't happen every time but enough to make it not feel like a light read. There was also more explicit language than usual. I found that without the buffer of any real trips to the past (my usual highlight of a St Mary's book) this was quite a bleak read at times. Especially the ending for the main baddie. There was the humour you would expect from a Jodi Taylor book but it wasn't enough to outweigh the other events.
Characters are divided into the usual clear cut goodies and baddies but they don't feel properly fleshed out. Not even Pennyroyal who is one of the title characters. Maybe there is another book in the works from his point of view but I never felt we got to know him beyond discovering the fridging trope of his motivation. We do learn about Smallhope but other than being informed about the years passing I didn't notice any character development over the circa 16+ years she was away with Pennyroyal.
To get the most out of this book it would be best to be up to date with the St Mary's and Time Police books. It references events from both those series that will make more sense to you if you have read the other books first and will avoid spoilers. I'm not quite sure why the references were included though as we didn't really get to see events from the point of view of Smallhope and Pennyroyal it's mostly just a recounting or a brief mention of events. Maybe it was intended to show how the different timelines fit together but it felt like a wasted opportunity.
If you love the author's writing style full of characters that are witty, sarcastic and sometimes a little odd then this book could definitely be for you. The plot is encumbered a little by all the references to events in other books but still flies along pretty fast.
A book I liked but left me disappointed because I wanted to love it.
November 11, 2024
3.5 Time Traveling Spin-Off Stars
Smallhope and Pennyroyal have been staple side characters in the Chronicles of St Mary's books for about half of the series. They are extremely interesting side characters in that story and I can see why Jodi Taylor wanted to share their origin story starting twenty years ago up to the current time in the primary series. But, I don't think this is something you will understand and enjoy as much without having read The Chronicles of St. Mary's.
Smallhope could have had a different life completely if her brother had married someone better and she didn't get caught up with Pennyroyal and whisked away through time to have their own adventures. She was set to run the family estate for her soft hearted brother but destiny and boy from the future had different ideas.
I enjoyed this origin story. The dynamic between Smallhope and Pennyroyal has been so much fun to read in the original series. They have over twenty years of working together and it was a lot of fun to see how they started out, got caught up with the time police and eventually solved Smallhope's family drama as well.
My only complaint is since I read all of the original section there is a part of the book that is a little repetitive as it goes through a montage of events that we have experienced in The Chronicles of St. Mary's from Smallhope's PoV. That said I completely loved the beginning and the ending there was just a small section in the middle I got a little board.
This has Jodi Taylor's classic humor throughout the story and I enjoyed the banter between Smallhope and Pennyroyal throughout the book. She is one of my favorite authors for cheeky humor.
Narration
If you have listened to any of Jodi Taylor's books then you are familiar with Zara Ramm. She is fantastic in any of the books by Jodi Taylor and always captures the humor and fun of the characters, events and dialogue. This was another great listen by the accomplished narrator who just understands the timing needed to pull off the humor in this story. I was also so glad that she is also the narrator for the Chronicles of St. Mary's so there was a continuity of the voices for all the characters from that series. I was able to listen at my usual 1.5x speed.
Performance: ★★★★★
Character Separation: ★★★★★
Diction: ★★★★
Pacing/Flow: ★★★★★
Sound Effects: none
Smallhope and Pennyroyal have been staple side characters in the Chronicles of St Mary's books for about half of the series. They are extremely interesting side characters in that story and I can see why Jodi Taylor wanted to share their origin story starting twenty years ago up to the current time in the primary series. But, I don't think this is something you will understand and enjoy as much without having read The Chronicles of St. Mary's.
Smallhope could have had a different life completely if her brother had married someone better and she didn't get caught up with Pennyroyal and whisked away through time to have their own adventures. She was set to run the family estate for her soft hearted brother but destiny and boy from the future had different ideas.
I enjoyed this origin story. The dynamic between Smallhope and Pennyroyal has been so much fun to read in the original series. They have over twenty years of working together and it was a lot of fun to see how they started out, got caught up with the time police and eventually solved Smallhope's family drama as well.
My only complaint is since I read all of the original section there is a part of the book that is a little repetitive as it goes through a montage of events that we have experienced in The Chronicles of St. Mary's from Smallhope's PoV. That said I completely loved the beginning and the ending there was just a small section in the middle I got a little board.
This has Jodi Taylor's classic humor throughout the story and I enjoyed the banter between Smallhope and Pennyroyal throughout the book. She is one of my favorite authors for cheeky humor.
Narration
If you have listened to any of Jodi Taylor's books then you are familiar with Zara Ramm. She is fantastic in any of the books by Jodi Taylor and always captures the humor and fun of the characters, events and dialogue. This was another great listen by the accomplished narrator who just understands the timing needed to pull off the humor in this story. I was also so glad that she is also the narrator for the Chronicles of St. Mary's so there was a continuity of the voices for all the characters from that series. I was able to listen at my usual 1.5x speed.
Performance: ★★★★★
Character Separation: ★★★★★
Diction: ★★★★
Pacing/Flow: ★★★★★
Sound Effects: none
December 1, 2024
Love love. Of course.
July 31, 2026
Finished reading: July 30th 2026
"We would get to know St Mary’s better in the future, but at that point in our lives, we regarded them as just a bunch of unstable but not too dangerous eccentrics who could be safely ignored. As I said to Pennyroyal later, the august firm of Smallhope and Pennyroyal didn’t get much wrong, but when we did, it turned out to be a doozy."
REVIEW
June 29, 2024
Thank you to netgalley and the publishers for this review copy. Having already preordered a signed copy from Jodi Taylor’s website, I was eagerly awaiting its release. To say I was delighted at receiving an early ARC would be an understatement. I have always been intrigued by Smallhope and Pennyroyal in their earlier appearances in Taylor’s novels but never thought they would get their own novel. I actually didn’t realise this was a novel, I assumed it was more like one of her Christmas novellas, until I downloaded this ARC. To any fan of Taylor’s this book is a must read and explores the background of these characters beautifully. I hope we continue to see them pop up in future novels as I desperately what to know what happens next in their adventures.
October 21, 2024
I didn't know I needed an origin story of Smallhope and Pennyroyal until now.
Anyone who follows my reviews likely already knows that I think Jodi Taylor is a criminally underrated author, and her St. Mary's series is a criminally underrated sci-fi/fantasy series. I love her characters, creativity, history, and unmatched humour that pours from her stories. I read each new release typically within weeks of their release. Oh, I also interviewed Jodi on my (now defunct) Booktube channel (watch it here: https://youtu.be/fq6gMxUQSg0). All that to say... I'm not unbiased when I come to a new Jodi Taylor novel, especially one set in the St. Mary's universe. And suffice it to say, this one blew my socks off.
Smallhope and Pennyroyal are time-traveling bounty hunters who show up in a number of the St. Mary's escapades. For a long time now, they have been a duo shrouded in mystery, zipping in and out all along the timeline, often to lend a helping hand in the most dire of circumstances. The Ballad of Smallhope and Pennyroyal is a completely unexpected tale of their origins, first meetings, forming of their partnership, point-of-view adventures with the St. Mary's crew, and even beyond. Halfway through, I expected the book just to be an origin story, but then we started doing some time jumps (and I don't just mean along the timeline). This book is, in many ways, the complete unabridged story of Smallhope and Pennyroyal, beginning with a teenage Smallhope and a 23-year-old Pennyroyal and concluding some twenty years later, AFTER any point we've been in the mainline narrative of St. Mary's and Time Police.
Although we do get some time travel, history is not the focus in Ballad. This is a story focused on relationships, and it is all the better for it.
I would certainly not recommend this book to people who have not read The Chronicles of St. Mary's and The Time Police. You will miss so much if you haven't read the series to date. However, if you are a fan of the series and know the characters and its history, this is a brilliant entry in the metaverse. Honestly, it is probably Top 3 material for the world that Jodi has so wittingly created.
Anyone who follows my reviews likely already knows that I think Jodi Taylor is a criminally underrated author, and her St. Mary's series is a criminally underrated sci-fi/fantasy series. I love her characters, creativity, history, and unmatched humour that pours from her stories. I read each new release typically within weeks of their release. Oh, I also interviewed Jodi on my (now defunct) Booktube channel (watch it here: https://youtu.be/fq6gMxUQSg0). All that to say... I'm not unbiased when I come to a new Jodi Taylor novel, especially one set in the St. Mary's universe. And suffice it to say, this one blew my socks off.
Smallhope and Pennyroyal are time-traveling bounty hunters who show up in a number of the St. Mary's escapades. For a long time now, they have been a duo shrouded in mystery, zipping in and out all along the timeline, often to lend a helping hand in the most dire of circumstances. The Ballad of Smallhope and Pennyroyal is a completely unexpected tale of their origins, first meetings, forming of their partnership, point-of-view adventures with the St. Mary's crew, and even beyond. Halfway through, I expected the book just to be an origin story, but then we started doing some time jumps (and I don't just mean along the timeline). This book is, in many ways, the complete unabridged story of Smallhope and Pennyroyal, beginning with a teenage Smallhope and a 23-year-old Pennyroyal and concluding some twenty years later, AFTER any point we've been in the mainline narrative of St. Mary's and Time Police.
Although we do get some time travel, history is not the focus in Ballad. This is a story focused on relationships, and it is all the better for it.
I would certainly not recommend this book to people who have not read The Chronicles of St. Mary's and The Time Police. You will miss so much if you haven't read the series to date. However, if you are a fan of the series and know the characters and its history, this is a brilliant entry in the metaverse. Honestly, it is probably Top 3 material for the world that Jodi has so wittingly created.
December 8, 2025
A welcome and entertaining addition to the St Mary’s and Time Police series. The story of Smallhope and Pennyroyal does a good job of bringing more connection and character to the weaving together of the two series. I hope we get more from their perpectives. I really hated for this one to be over.
October 1, 2024
Absolutely fantastic! 5 stars!
Smallhope and Pennyroyal are an indescribable team and I can't express how outstanding their story was.
More books in this spin off are needed. Immediately. Pretty please!
Smallhope and Pennyroyal are an indescribable team and I can't express how outstanding their story was.
More books in this spin off are needed. Immediately. Pretty please!
January 1, 2025
5 stars
This book is a significant one for me in several ways. For one, it is the very last book I needed to hit my 2024 reading goal of 50 books. It was a wild few weeks but we made it. Also, it is officially my 300th distinct book (excluding rereads) that I’ve logged on Goodreads, almost all of which were the result of me thinking it might not be so bad to try out a fiction book again one fateful day in 2020 lockdown.
And finally, the completion of this book means I am officially caught up in the St. Mary’s universe. I started back in 2021 after a friend swore the Chronicles of St. Mary’s was a fantastic (and criminally underrated) series. 14 St. Mary’s novels (and hopefully still counting), 5 Time Police novels (and definitely still counting), 24 short stories across the two series, and this standalone novel later, I’m just so overwhelmed with how much I love these books. They will now be engrained in my life forever. I will savor new releases to come (please live and write forever, Jodi Taylor). I will reread the series for years and years and years.
Anyway, this book was great! A nice origin story about Lady Amelia Smallhope and her mysterious butler Pennyroyal. It feels much like a gift to the fans, as we get to fill in the blanks of how these two recovery agents (read: bounty hunters) have intertwined themselves with history and the future. We also get a handful of Easter eggs that are sooooo interesting to ponder. As such, this is definitely one that should be read after all previously published St. Mary’s and Time Police novels, otherwise the reader will miss many references.
So if you’re not on the bandwagon yet, there’s room for you here.
And the clock just struck midnight on 2025 as I wrote this. Cheers!
▌5.0 —One of the best I've ever read. Will be burned into my brain. Couldn't care less about weaknesses (if any). Would recommend to everyone and their mother.
4.5 —Loved this read. Will remember it fondly. Few weaknesses. Would recommend to anyone.
4.0 —Enjoyed this read. Will remember it fondly. Minor weaknesses. Would recommend to fans of the genre.
3.5 —Somewhat enjoyed this read. Might be memorable. Notable weaknesses. Would recommend to fans of the genre.
3.0 —Somewhat enjoyed this read. Not very memorable. Notable weaknesses. Would recommend to people who like similar books.
2.5 —Neutral or Underwhelming read. Not very memorable. Significant weaknesses. Would recommend to people who like similar books.
2.0 —Underwhelming or unenjoyable read. Not very memorable or memorable for the wrong reasons. Significant weaknesses. Might recommend to people who like similar books.
1.5 —Unenjoyable read. Not very memorable or memorable for bad reasons. Major weaknesses. Probably wouldn't recommend.
1.0 —Awful read. Memorable for bad reasons. No significantly redeeming qualities. Would never recommend.
0.5 —I wish I never wasted minutes of my life on this trash. I would go out of my way to convince others not to read it.
This book is a significant one for me in several ways. For one, it is the very last book I needed to hit my 2024 reading goal of 50 books. It was a wild few weeks but we made it. Also, it is officially my 300th distinct book (excluding rereads) that I’ve logged on Goodreads, almost all of which were the result of me thinking it might not be so bad to try out a fiction book again one fateful day in 2020 lockdown.
And finally, the completion of this book means I am officially caught up in the St. Mary’s universe. I started back in 2021 after a friend swore the Chronicles of St. Mary’s was a fantastic (and criminally underrated) series. 14 St. Mary’s novels (and hopefully still counting), 5 Time Police novels (and definitely still counting), 24 short stories across the two series, and this standalone novel later, I’m just so overwhelmed with how much I love these books. They will now be engrained in my life forever. I will savor new releases to come (please live and write forever, Jodi Taylor). I will reread the series for years and years and years.
Anyway, this book was great! A nice origin story about Lady Amelia Smallhope and her mysterious butler Pennyroyal. It feels much like a gift to the fans, as we get to fill in the blanks of how these two recovery agents (read: bounty hunters) have intertwined themselves with history and the future. We also get a handful of Easter eggs that are sooooo interesting to ponder. As such, this is definitely one that should be read after all previously published St. Mary’s and Time Police novels, otherwise the reader will miss many references.
So if you’re not on the bandwagon yet, there’s room for you here.
And the clock just struck midnight on 2025 as I wrote this. Cheers!
▌5.0 —One of the best I've ever read. Will be burned into my brain. Couldn't care less about weaknesses (if any). Would recommend to everyone and their mother.
4.5 —Loved this read. Will remember it fondly. Few weaknesses. Would recommend to anyone.
4.0 —Enjoyed this read. Will remember it fondly. Minor weaknesses. Would recommend to fans of the genre.
3.5 —Somewhat enjoyed this read. Might be memorable. Notable weaknesses. Would recommend to fans of the genre.
3.0 —Somewhat enjoyed this read. Not very memorable. Notable weaknesses. Would recommend to people who like similar books.
2.5 —Neutral or Underwhelming read. Not very memorable. Significant weaknesses. Would recommend to people who like similar books.
2.0 —Underwhelming or unenjoyable read. Not very memorable or memorable for the wrong reasons. Significant weaknesses. Might recommend to people who like similar books.
1.5 —Unenjoyable read. Not very memorable or memorable for bad reasons. Major weaknesses. Probably wouldn't recommend.
1.0 —Awful read. Memorable for bad reasons. No significantly redeeming qualities. Would never recommend.
0.5 —I wish I never wasted minutes of my life on this trash. I would go out of my way to convince others not to read it.
May 28, 2025
I loved it. of course I loved it. 17 year old Smallhope was not something I thought I needed but it made me love her even more
oh and I cried a lil
oh and I cried a lil
December 26, 2025
I have read multiple books by Caimh McDonnell and Terry Pratchett and Jodi Taylor is right there with them, witty, funny and a joy to read. What a talented writer! I know she started writing after her 60s but what a way to be visionary and modern in her thinking and delivery of innovative plots.
Appropriately named a ballad, this is a story of two misfits and their adventures and quest for justice. The stories are funny, heartwarming and heartbreaking. The plot and multiple sub plots were interesting and gripping, the characters were multidimensional and they will stay with me for a very long time. This book was probably the best surprise of 2025. I am awaiting patiently for the next installment of this riveting series, meanwhile Chronicles of St. Mary will have to suffice. I really need to hear what’s next in both main characters lives, their personal struggles as well as their fabulous time travel.
Appropriately named a ballad, this is a story of two misfits and their adventures and quest for justice. The stories are funny, heartwarming and heartbreaking. The plot and multiple sub plots were interesting and gripping, the characters were multidimensional and they will stay with me for a very long time. This book was probably the best surprise of 2025. I am awaiting patiently for the next installment of this riveting series, meanwhile Chronicles of St. Mary will have to suffice. I really need to hear what’s next in both main characters lives, their personal struggles as well as their fabulous time travel.
August 31, 2024
Rating: 4.5/5
I have previously read a couple of Jodi Taylor's traditional Christmas novellas, but never a full length novel by her. I enjoyed the shorter versions and was impressed with the author's writing style, but I was reticent about reading anything else from the "Chronicles of St Mary's" or "Time Police" without going back to the very beginning of the series. So, when I saw this origin story featuring Smallhope and Pennyroyal, I thought it may offer me the ideal opportunity to read a full-length Jodi Taylor novel without feeling that I was missing out on essential background information by dropping in mid-series - and I am very glad that I did.
At no point while I was reading "The Ballad of Smallhope and Pennyroyal" did I ever feel that I was in any way disadvantaged by not being well acquainted with Jodi Taylor's other related works. The story is extremely well-structured and the storytelling abilities of the author are sublime. Were it not for the time travelling elements, this could could quite easily be an example of the type of emotionally engaging dramatic fiction that classic authors such as Hardy, Dickens and Hugo used to produce back in the 19th century. There is drama, witty humour, romance, intrigue, social commentary and ample helpings of adventure and compelling plot developments throughout. Jodi Taylor draws the reader into the world of the two key protagonists wonderfully well. It is fair to say that the audience will likely feel better acquainted with Smallhope rather than the more enigmatic Pennyroyal, but that is, I am sure, a deliberate ploy on the part of the author as well as a consequence of the story being written predominantly from the viewpoint of Smallhope. This is a joy to read and should appeal to anyone who admires quality literary fiction of any genre.
Many thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for supplying an ARC in return for an honest review.
I have previously read a couple of Jodi Taylor's traditional Christmas novellas, but never a full length novel by her. I enjoyed the shorter versions and was impressed with the author's writing style, but I was reticent about reading anything else from the "Chronicles of St Mary's" or "Time Police" without going back to the very beginning of the series. So, when I saw this origin story featuring Smallhope and Pennyroyal, I thought it may offer me the ideal opportunity to read a full-length Jodi Taylor novel without feeling that I was missing out on essential background information by dropping in mid-series - and I am very glad that I did.
At no point while I was reading "The Ballad of Smallhope and Pennyroyal" did I ever feel that I was in any way disadvantaged by not being well acquainted with Jodi Taylor's other related works. The story is extremely well-structured and the storytelling abilities of the author are sublime. Were it not for the time travelling elements, this could could quite easily be an example of the type of emotionally engaging dramatic fiction that classic authors such as Hardy, Dickens and Hugo used to produce back in the 19th century. There is drama, witty humour, romance, intrigue, social commentary and ample helpings of adventure and compelling plot developments throughout. Jodi Taylor draws the reader into the world of the two key protagonists wonderfully well. It is fair to say that the audience will likely feel better acquainted with Smallhope rather than the more enigmatic Pennyroyal, but that is, I am sure, a deliberate ploy on the part of the author as well as a consequence of the story being written predominantly from the viewpoint of Smallhope. This is a joy to read and should appeal to anyone who admires quality literary fiction of any genre.
Many thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for supplying an ARC in return for an honest review.
January 6, 2025
DNF. I'm a huge fan of time travel novels so was looking forward to this. Unfortunately, I loathed the author's style; there's a constant effort at being quirky and making cutesy remarks that put me off to the extent that I cldn't tolerate it. Quirky has it's place, and I generally like off the wall observations but not when they come at the expense of the story and characters, as they do here. After only a few pages, I started to dread every diversion--and they were usually completely irrelevant. The housemaid is mentioned in passing, and we have to get a story about her; I imagine if a character looked to see what time it is, we'd get a quirky story about the guy that made the clock. I'm sorry, but I just don't care. To me, the book read as a series of twee digressions and observations that were often pointless. I get that the author is popular and there are a lot of 5 star reviews for this book so she's obviously doing something right, but she's not for me.
October 23, 2025
My favourite book I’ve read in 2025! Jodi Taylor at this point I honestly believe can write anything and do it superbly! Those familiar with The Time Police and St Mary’s will have come across Smallhope and Pennyroyal previously and this novel provides their backstory (as well as nicely filling in some sections from the other series from their point of view). What works really well however is even if you’re not yet familiar with Jodi Taylor’s writing this works as a stand alone novel (though is guaranteed to make you want to read the rest of her books afterwards). Full of drama, suspense, wit and wonderful Easter eggs and one liners, a brilliant read!
September 14, 2024
At last! Answers and adventures
Smallhope (aka Lady Amelia) and Pennyroyal, her so-called butler (partner in bounty hunting and related shenanigans) have been fascinating characters popping up in the adventures of Max from St. Mary's. Finally, they get their own story! Find out how they met and embarked on their career and so much more.
You could enjoy this story without having read any of the St. Mary's and Time Police novels, as enough background is provided and those entities make passing appearances. However, it will be even more enjoyable if you have read them, seeing various scenes from Smallhope and Pennyroyal 's point of view.
Smallhope (aka Lady Amelia) and Pennyroyal, her so-called butler (partner in bounty hunting and related shenanigans) have been fascinating characters popping up in the adventures of Max from St. Mary's. Finally, they get their own story! Find out how they met and embarked on their career and so much more.
You could enjoy this story without having read any of the St. Mary's and Time Police novels, as enough background is provided and those entities make passing appearances. However, it will be even more enjoyable if you have read them, seeing various scenes from Smallhope and Pennyroyal 's point of view.
May 19, 2026
I thoroughly enjoyed the entire Chronicles of St Mary's series, including every previous appearance of Smallhope & Pennyroyal, so I was delighted that they got their own novel. I was not disappointed!
December 13, 2024
Entertaining, though the episodic plot means that there's little sustained tension. As with any time-travelling book, the logical holes don't bear dwelling on. This would have been a better book with fewer plots (the bookending "Caroline" one would have been nearly sufficient on its own) and more romance. As it is, a platonic relationship that lasts 15 years requires more than a chapter's worth of overlaid romance to be convincing. I get that romance isn't Jodi Taylor's schtick, but without that sort of glue, this is just a series of unsatisfactory glimpses of several books happening elsewhere.
July 1, 2024
I didn't know about this book until I saw it on netgalley, and the excitement was real. Pennyroyal and Smallhope are two characters I love and their story does not disappoint.
We start off with Smallhope telling us her background and how she came to meet Pennyroyal. I love how she gets carried away with funny little stories while she tells the main story. Her anecdotes strengthen the characters and make her, and her history very real. I really enjoyed getting to know her more.
The sarcasm to it is brilliant, and I got sucked into Jodi Taylor's style of writing quickly and easily. You can tell straight away that it's part of the St. Mary's franchise.
Amelia is such a brilliant character, and reading how she had to become the strong person we all know and love was incredibly satisfying. Pennyworth is such a distinctive character and I could tell who he was before we knew his name. I loved seeing how they first met, and the first margarita.
Their relationship clicked from the beginning, is very genuine, and has some really wholesome moments that made me laugh out loud too many times to count. An unlikely friendship that worked from the get go. I really hope we see more of them again. A brilliant book, with great humour and an ending that makes you wish for more.
We start off with Smallhope telling us her background and how she came to meet Pennyroyal. I love how she gets carried away with funny little stories while she tells the main story. Her anecdotes strengthen the characters and make her, and her history very real. I really enjoyed getting to know her more.
The sarcasm to it is brilliant, and I got sucked into Jodi Taylor's style of writing quickly and easily. You can tell straight away that it's part of the St. Mary's franchise.
Amelia is such a brilliant character, and reading how she had to become the strong person we all know and love was incredibly satisfying. Pennyworth is such a distinctive character and I could tell who he was before we knew his name. I loved seeing how they first met, and the first margarita.
Their relationship clicked from the beginning, is very genuine, and has some really wholesome moments that made me laugh out loud too many times to count. An unlikely friendship that worked from the get go. I really hope we see more of them again. A brilliant book, with great humour and an ending that makes you wish for more.
August 18, 2025
This was superb!
It’s the origin story of Lady Amelia Smallhope and her ‘butler’ Pennyroyal, who occasionally turn up in The Time Police series and The Chronicles of St. Mary’s both by Jodi Taylor.
This basically tells the story of how they met, and ended up becoming bounty hunters, sorry recovery agents for the Time Police and doing other jobs for the highest bidder. They’re great characters, and the story is full of Jodi Taylor’s signature wit and very clever timey wimey plots.
Zara Ramm’s narration was perfect as expected.
Highly recommended if you’re looking for a series full of adventure, fun and time travel, but be warned you should really read the St. Mary’s books and the Time Police series first, as they’re all connected and there are definitely spoilers!
Book 20 of 20 Books of Summer 2025
It’s the origin story of Lady Amelia Smallhope and her ‘butler’ Pennyroyal, who occasionally turn up in The Time Police series and The Chronicles of St. Mary’s both by Jodi Taylor.
This basically tells the story of how they met, and ended up becoming bounty hunters, sorry recovery agents for the Time Police and doing other jobs for the highest bidder. They’re great characters, and the story is full of Jodi Taylor’s signature wit and very clever timey wimey plots.
Zara Ramm’s narration was perfect as expected.
Highly recommended if you’re looking for a series full of adventure, fun and time travel, but be warned you should really read the St. Mary’s books and the Time Police series first, as they’re all connected and there are definitely spoilers!
Book 20 of 20 Books of Summer 2025
August 5, 2025
I'm going to start out by saying I wasn't aware that these characters were from The Chronicles of St Mary's series, which I have never heard of and thought this was a total stand alone book.
This is definitely not a stand alone and I'm sure it's great for the people who have read The Chronicles of St Mary's but as a person who has not, it really didn't make much sense. I thought the whole point was revenge but then we took a left turn and it was all about time travel and the revenge wasn't mentioned at all for quite awhile. It wasn't bad but it just seemed like filler until you get to the last 100 pages or so. Again if you are a fan of the series I'm sure it was great but would not recommend as a stand alone.
This is definitely not a stand alone and I'm sure it's great for the people who have read The Chronicles of St Mary's but as a person who has not, it really didn't make much sense. I thought the whole point was revenge but then we took a left turn and it was all about time travel and the revenge wasn't mentioned at all for quite awhile. It wasn't bad but it just seemed like filler until you get to the last 100 pages or so. Again if you are a fan of the series I'm sure it was great but would not recommend as a stand alone.
July 24, 2026
I just loved this. 😍😍
I think from the St. Mary’s books I didn’t realize how young Smallhope & Pennyroyal were. But goodness I loved learning their back stories!
On a reread: Smallhope’s voice is so much like Max’s from St. Mary’s, it took me out of the story a little bit a few times.
I think from the St. Mary’s books I didn’t realize how young Smallhope & Pennyroyal were. But goodness I loved learning their back stories!
On a reread: Smallhope’s voice is so much like Max’s from St. Mary’s, it took me out of the story a little bit a few times.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 474 reviews