The JFK Conspiracy: The Secret Plot to Kill Kennedy―and Why it Failed by Brad Meltzer and Josh Mensch is a nonfiction narrative history that blends political history with a true-crime setup: the failed 1960 assassination attempt on President-elect John F. Kennedy by Richard Pavlick. On paper, it sounds like a deep dive into a little-known plot and the man behind it. In reality, I was somewhat disappointed, because the book ended up feeling more like a broad history lesson on JFK and Jackie than an in-depth exploration of Pavlick or the conspiracy itself. I kept wanting more psychological insight into who Pavlick was and what made him tick. That said, I did appreciate the authors’ honesty about both the positives and the negatives of Jack and Jackie—they don’t treat either one as a flawless icon.
The person who intrigued me most going in was Richard Pavlick, this lone white supremacist who came close to changing history before Kennedy was even inaugurated. The book does cover his actions, movements, and the basics of his life, but for me the treatment felt a bit shallow. The authors offer a hypothesis about what drove him, but it never really gets under his skin. I kept wondering, What made him that way? What in his past shaped this level of hatred and obsession? If you’re looking for a deep psychological profile of Pavlick, this may not fully scratch that itch.
Where the book spends a lot more time is on JFK and Jackie themselves: their backgrounds, family, politics, and the world they were stepping into. It often reads less like a focused true-crime narrative and more like a compact Kennedy biography, with the assassination plot threaded through it. That wasn’t exactly what I expected, but if you enjoy Kennedy history, there is plenty here—campaign details, public image versus private life, and the early days of their marriage in the spotlight.
One thing I did like was the authors’ candor. They’re willing to show both the glamour and the mess. They don’t shy away from Jack’s flaws or Jackie’s more complicated sides, and that balanced approach made them feel more human and less like polished myths. I also found the storytelling style easy to follow—very readable, almost like a thriller in spots—so the book never felt dry, even when it veered away from Pavlick.
Overall, I’d probably land around 3 stars. If you’re picking this up expecting a tightly focused, in-depth study of Richard Pavlick and his motivations, you may come away a bit let down, like I did.
But if you’re interested in a fast, accessible slice of JFK/Jackie history with a failed assassination plot woven through it—and you don’t mind that the Kennedy story often takes center stage—this could still be a worthwhile read.