What do you think?
Rate this book
All We Were Promised
Goodreads Choice Award
Nominee for Readers' Favorite Debut Novel (2024)A housemaid with a dangerous family secret conspires with a wealthy young abolitionist to help an enslaved girl escape, in volatile pre-Civil War Philadelphia.
The rebel . . . the socialite . . . and the fugitive. Together, they will risk everything for one another in this “beguiling story of friendship, deception, and women crossing boundaries in the name of freedom” (Lisa Wingate, #1 New York Times bestselling author of The Book of Lost Friends).
Philadelphia, 1837. After Charlotte escaped from the crumbling White Oaks plantation down South, she’d expected freedom to feel different from her former life as an enslaved housemaid. After all, Philadelphia is supposed to be the birthplace of American liberty. Instead, she’s locked away playing servant to her white-passing father, as they both attempt to hide their identities from slavecatchers who would destroy their new lives.
Longing to break away, Charlotte befriends Nell, a budding abolitionist from one of Philadelphia’s wealthiest Black families. Just as Charlotte starts to envision a future, a familiar face from her past reappears: Evie, her friend from White Oaks, has been brought to the city by the plantation mistress, and she’s desperate to escape. But as Charlotte and Nell conspire to rescue her, in a city engulfed by race riots and attacks on abolitionists, they soon discover that fighting for Evie’s freedom may cost them their own.
The rebel . . . the socialite . . . and the fugitive. Together, they will risk everything for one another in this “beguiling story of friendship, deception, and women crossing boundaries in the name of freedom” (Lisa Wingate, #1 New York Times bestselling author of The Book of Lost Friends).
Philadelphia, 1837. After Charlotte escaped from the crumbling White Oaks plantation down South, she’d expected freedom to feel different from her former life as an enslaved housemaid. After all, Philadelphia is supposed to be the birthplace of American liberty. Instead, she’s locked away playing servant to her white-passing father, as they both attempt to hide their identities from slavecatchers who would destroy their new lives.
Longing to break away, Charlotte befriends Nell, a budding abolitionist from one of Philadelphia’s wealthiest Black families. Just as Charlotte starts to envision a future, a familiar face from her past reappears: Evie, her friend from White Oaks, has been brought to the city by the plantation mistress, and she’s desperate to escape. But as Charlotte and Nell conspire to rescue her, in a city engulfed by race riots and attacks on abolitionists, they soon discover that fighting for Evie’s freedom may cost them their own.
384 pages, Paperback
First published April 2, 2024
634 people are currently reading
53326 people want to read
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 1,369 reviews
February 17, 2024
All We Were Promised is a fascinating look at Philadelphia in the pre-Civil War years. Told from the perspective of three young Black women, it encompasses Nell, a member of the elite Black society; Charlotte, a runaway living in the city; and Evie, a slave looking to escape her southern mistress visiting the northern city. The three women are all fully developed and I appreciated that Lattimore fairly presented the risks each faced, especially Charlotte.
The story points out how precarious the lives of all Blacks were in the town. Pennsylvania might have been a free state, but it had a variety of loopholes to allow southern owners to bring their slaves north. And those that were free still faced bigotry and violence. Lattimore does a great job of putting the reader in the time and place. It’s obvious she’s done her research. And her book meets my standard for historical fiction - I learned something about the subject being covered.
The story deals with the risks people are willing to take for others, on both large and small scales. For example, the women quickly learn that the Philadelphia Female Anti-Slavery Society is all talk and no action. Flip side, Charlotte is forced to confront what risks she’ll take to help Evie.
Other themes include classism, passing as white and the limited roles of women.
What starts off at a languorous pace picks up as the ending approaches. I was totally taken in and couldn’t wait to see how things would resolve.
An excellent book and this one is going on my “best of 2024” list.
My thanks to Netgalley and Random House/Ballantine for an advance copy of this book.
The story points out how precarious the lives of all Blacks were in the town. Pennsylvania might have been a free state, but it had a variety of loopholes to allow southern owners to bring their slaves north. And those that were free still faced bigotry and violence. Lattimore does a great job of putting the reader in the time and place. It’s obvious she’s done her research. And her book meets my standard for historical fiction - I learned something about the subject being covered.
The story deals with the risks people are willing to take for others, on both large and small scales. For example, the women quickly learn that the Philadelphia Female Anti-Slavery Society is all talk and no action. Flip side, Charlotte is forced to confront what risks she’ll take to help Evie.
Other themes include classism, passing as white and the limited roles of women.
What starts off at a languorous pace picks up as the ending approaches. I was totally taken in and couldn’t wait to see how things would resolve.
An excellent book and this one is going on my “best of 2024” list.
My thanks to Netgalley and Random House/Ballantine for an advance copy of this book.
April 14, 2024
4.25⭐️
“As the self-proclaimed cradle of liberty, Philadelphia was already a city of broken promises, with accommodationists straining to silence antislavery speech and Southerners shuttling their very much not-at-liberty slaves in and out of the city’s borders. Where abolitionists were concerned, it was fast becoming a city of broken contracts as well.”
Set in 1837 All We Were Promised by Ashton Lattimore is a captivating novel that sheds light on the activism, the politics, the socio-economic and racial divide in the pre-Civil War Philadelphia. Though Pennsylvania was a “free state” with an active free Black community, racial tensions were high, bigotry and rioting prevalent, with laws that protected Southern slave owners passing through. A combination of fact and fiction, the immersive narrative features several prominent activists and abolitionists from that era and references true events like the burning of Pennsylvania Hall ( 1938) by an anti-abolitionist mob. The author is unflinching in her depiction of bigotry, cruelty and racially motivated violence.
The narrative is shared from the perspectives of three women :
Charlotte is a housemaid and former runaway who is forced to hide her truth – a secret that could upend the lives her father has built for himself, though her life is not what would have hoped for in a “free state”. Nell is the daughter of an affluent Black family who is motivated to do more for those in need of assistance. She is disillusioned when she faces resistance while appealing to the Philadelphia Female Antislavery Society to approve a committee that would play a more active role in aiding runaway slaves. Nell and Charlotte are friends, but she is unaware of Charlotte’s past. They frequently attend Antislavery Society meetings together– a secret Charlotte keeps from her father, fully aware that he would rather she stay within the confines of their home.
Charlotte is forced to confront her past when she sees Evie, an enslaved sixteen-year-old in Philadelphia with her mistress Kate, in the market. Kate was the wife of the man who owned Charlotte and her father and Evie took Charlotte’s place after they ran away. Evie knows the kind of life that awaits her and is desperate to escape, She approaches Charlotte for help and Charlotte agrees. But Charlotte knows that she alone would not be able to help Evie and enlists Nell’s help to formulate a plan.
Revolving around themes of friendship, sacrifice and courage, this is a thought-provoking story with well-written characters (even the unlikable ones). The romantic track was subtle and skillfully woven into the primary narrative. The author brilliantly captures Nell’s idealism, Charlotte’s vulnerability and Evie’s desperation - three young women from different circumstances with stories that intersect – shared experiences that enable them to gain perspective, face harsh realities and find their own voices. As they embark on their individual journeys, it is evident that the road ahead will not be easy, but we will want them to succeed. I did feel that certain aspects of the story could have been explored further, but overall, I thought this was a promising debut and look forward to reading more from this author in the future.
The Author’s Note is well-written and informative and definitely enriches the overall reading experience.
Many thanks to Random House Publishing Group - Ballantine for the digital review copy via NetGalley. All opinions expressed in this review are my own. This novel was published on April 2, 2024.
Connect with me! ✏ Instagram ✏ My Blog ✏ The StoryGraph
“As the self-proclaimed cradle of liberty, Philadelphia was already a city of broken promises, with accommodationists straining to silence antislavery speech and Southerners shuttling their very much not-at-liberty slaves in and out of the city’s borders. Where abolitionists were concerned, it was fast becoming a city of broken contracts as well.”
Set in 1837 All We Were Promised by Ashton Lattimore is a captivating novel that sheds light on the activism, the politics, the socio-economic and racial divide in the pre-Civil War Philadelphia. Though Pennsylvania was a “free state” with an active free Black community, racial tensions were high, bigotry and rioting prevalent, with laws that protected Southern slave owners passing through. A combination of fact and fiction, the immersive narrative features several prominent activists and abolitionists from that era and references true events like the burning of Pennsylvania Hall ( 1938) by an anti-abolitionist mob. The author is unflinching in her depiction of bigotry, cruelty and racially motivated violence.
The narrative is shared from the perspectives of three women :
Charlotte is a housemaid and former runaway who is forced to hide her truth – a secret that could upend the lives her father has built for himself, though her life is not what would have hoped for in a “free state”. Nell is the daughter of an affluent Black family who is motivated to do more for those in need of assistance. She is disillusioned when she faces resistance while appealing to the Philadelphia Female Antislavery Society to approve a committee that would play a more active role in aiding runaway slaves. Nell and Charlotte are friends, but she is unaware of Charlotte’s past. They frequently attend Antislavery Society meetings together– a secret Charlotte keeps from her father, fully aware that he would rather she stay within the confines of their home.
Charlotte is forced to confront her past when she sees Evie, an enslaved sixteen-year-old in Philadelphia with her mistress Kate, in the market. Kate was the wife of the man who owned Charlotte and her father and Evie took Charlotte’s place after they ran away. Evie knows the kind of life that awaits her and is desperate to escape, She approaches Charlotte for help and Charlotte agrees. But Charlotte knows that she alone would not be able to help Evie and enlists Nell’s help to formulate a plan.
Revolving around themes of friendship, sacrifice and courage, this is a thought-provoking story with well-written characters (even the unlikable ones). The romantic track was subtle and skillfully woven into the primary narrative. The author brilliantly captures Nell’s idealism, Charlotte’s vulnerability and Evie’s desperation - three young women from different circumstances with stories that intersect – shared experiences that enable them to gain perspective, face harsh realities and find their own voices. As they embark on their individual journeys, it is evident that the road ahead will not be easy, but we will want them to succeed. I did feel that certain aspects of the story could have been explored further, but overall, I thought this was a promising debut and look forward to reading more from this author in the future.
The Author’s Note is well-written and informative and definitely enriches the overall reading experience.
Many thanks to Random House Publishing Group - Ballantine for the digital review copy via NetGalley. All opinions expressed in this review are my own. This novel was published on April 2, 2024.
Connect with me! ✏ Instagram ✏ My Blog ✏ The StoryGraph
January 20, 2025
This is a notable historical fiction debut about abolition in pre-Civil War Philadelphia in 1837, focusing on the lives of three women , two of whom are runaway slaves. It’s complicated to get one slave freed with the help of another runaway and a well to do black woman . These are strong female characters whose determination, caring and sense of moral duty makes an impact . Reminiscences of life on a plantation and the present hold on this young girl raise fears of being sent back south and present a tense atmosphere.
It’s well written and I appreciated how the author in her note puts the events in the novel in historic context illustrating how well researched it is . She also gives the reader one of the things in the author’s note that I love to read about - the inspiration for the story. I’ll be watching for what Ashton Lattimore does next .
I received an advanced copy from Ballantine Books through NetGalley. Life happens and I’m late in getting to this , but glad I finally did.
It’s well written and I appreciated how the author in her note puts the events in the novel in historic context illustrating how well researched it is . She also gives the reader one of the things in the author’s note that I love to read about - the inspiration for the story. I’ll be watching for what Ashton Lattimore does next .
I received an advanced copy from Ballantine Books through NetGalley. Life happens and I’m late in getting to this , but glad I finally did.
March 8, 2024
Charlotte, Nell, and Evie are three young black women in Philadelphia, 1837.
They are caught up in the uncertainty of a supposedly free, pre civil war state.
They come from different scenarios… Nell is from a wealthy established family.. Charlotte had run north with her father from a southern plantation .. Evie, still being held as a slave.
They are brought together during this time of a crossroad of slavery and independence … and it comes to an urgent escape plan to set Evie free.
It’s a great debut!
Thank you to Netgalley and Random House Publishing-Ballantine for the ARC!
They are caught up in the uncertainty of a supposedly free, pre civil war state.
They come from different scenarios… Nell is from a wealthy established family.. Charlotte had run north with her father from a southern plantation .. Evie, still being held as a slave.
They are brought together during this time of a crossroad of slavery and independence … and it comes to an urgent escape plan to set Evie free.
It’s a great debut!
Thank you to Netgalley and Random House Publishing-Ballantine for the ARC!
February 22, 2025
4/5
- Omg this book is reminding me sooo much of the bureaucracy we see now. The fact that there are a million and one committees for the abolitionist groups, but no one wants to do anything overt. “Changing hearts and minds” in a palatable way seems to be the only thing they care about.
- Loved how this book was told from three different perspectives. I usually get a bit confused, but this story was written in the best way! I do wish there was a tad more dialogue, but I loved it overall.
- This would be the perfect book for a book club. There were so many important topics in this book that would be great to discuss with a group!
- Omg this book is reminding me sooo much of the bureaucracy we see now. The fact that there are a million and one committees for the abolitionist groups, but no one wants to do anything overt. “Changing hearts and minds” in a palatable way seems to be the only thing they care about.
- Loved how this book was told from three different perspectives. I usually get a bit confused, but this story was written in the best way! I do wish there was a tad more dialogue, but I loved it overall.
- This would be the perfect book for a book club. There were so many important topics in this book that would be great to discuss with a group!
March 21, 2024
I was excited to find this book set in the 1830s with a unique premise. Unfortunately, it was difficult to finish. I was disappointed by the modern feel of the novel, especially the characters' attitudes and speech patterns. The prose was not only too modern but very simplistic and repetitive, almost as though the book was written for a middle grade audience. It was difficult to feel a connection to any of the characters. A third of the way through the book, they are all still insipidly moaning about how they need to formulate a plan. Sadly, this book never delivers on the thrilling story that the description promises, and it certainly doesn't transport the reader to the early 19th century.
My copy received through NetGalley. Opinions are my own.
My copy received through NetGalley. Opinions are my own.
July 6, 2024
Set in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania - Pre-Civil War
Did I see Charlotte in the market?
Is that really Evie?
Both Charlotte and Evie had been slaves at the same plantation in a Southern state.
Charlotte escaped with her father, and they now live freely in Philadelphia but are hiding a secret.
Charlotte’s father, a business owner who can pass as a white man, and Charlotte playing his housekeeper live freely hoping their secret will be kept.
It seems as if Charlotte’s father cares only about himself, his business, and his success. I felt sorry for Charlotte and the restrictions her father kept on her.
Evie came to Philadelphia with Kate her mistress, but she desperately wants to be free and not go back to the South with Kate after she marries.
Evie seemed disgusted with everything and abandoned by Charlotte, and I felt bad for her too.
Charlotte becomes friends with Nell, a well-to-do black woman who is trying to help Charlotte get Evie out of Philadelphia, but when Charlotte disappears from Nell's life, she becomes worried.
Can Charlotte and her new friend Nell help Evie now that Charlotte has disappeared? If they do find a way to help Evie, will it compromise their lives?
An excellent, well-researched but heartbreaking historical fiction read with endearing characters you will connect with and tension that will have your heart pounding when evil characters come on the scene. 5/5
Thank you to the publisher for a copy of this book. All opinions are my own.
Did I see Charlotte in the market?
Is that really Evie?
Both Charlotte and Evie had been slaves at the same plantation in a Southern state.
Charlotte escaped with her father, and they now live freely in Philadelphia but are hiding a secret.
Charlotte’s father, a business owner who can pass as a white man, and Charlotte playing his housekeeper live freely hoping their secret will be kept.
It seems as if Charlotte’s father cares only about himself, his business, and his success. I felt sorry for Charlotte and the restrictions her father kept on her.
Evie came to Philadelphia with Kate her mistress, but she desperately wants to be free and not go back to the South with Kate after she marries.
Evie seemed disgusted with everything and abandoned by Charlotte, and I felt bad for her too.
Charlotte becomes friends with Nell, a well-to-do black woman who is trying to help Charlotte get Evie out of Philadelphia, but when Charlotte disappears from Nell's life, she becomes worried.
Can Charlotte and her new friend Nell help Evie now that Charlotte has disappeared? If they do find a way to help Evie, will it compromise their lives?
An excellent, well-researched but heartbreaking historical fiction read with endearing characters you will connect with and tension that will have your heart pounding when evil characters come on the scene. 5/5
Thank you to the publisher for a copy of this book. All opinions are my own.
March 30, 2024
4.5 stars.
Any reader searching for a compelling story about pre-Civil War abolitionists and the struggle of fugitive slaves will definitely want to read this debut novel. The author shares a great deal of important historical information, and readers will gain a better understanding of the turbulent quest for freedom and acceptance.
This intense and thought-provoking story highlights the fictional lives of three young Black women in Philadelphia in 1837. Each must weigh their commitment to their cause and their family while facing the possibility of danger around every corner.
Nell is the daughter of well-to-do parents who are part of Philadelphia's free Black upper class. She is an active member of the women's Antislavery Society but is disillusioned by their activities, which mostly consist of an abundance of meetings, speeches, bake sales, and fundraising. Nell's new friendship with Charlotte soon ends up plunging her into aiding and abetting a fugitive slave.
Charlotte and her father are secretly runaways from a plantation in Maryland. He passes as white and sets up a woodworking shop in the city, while keeping his daughter home as a servant in hopes of furthering his growth and acceptance into Philadelphia society. Unbeknownst to her father, Charlotte is sneaking out of the house to meet with Nell at Antislavery Society meetings.
Everyone's lives are upended when Evie, a young slave who was like a sister to Charlotte at the plantation, shows up in Philly with their widowed mistress. Reuniting with Charlotte causes jealousy and fuels Evie's desire to escape her demanding owner and slavery. Will Charlotte help Evie find freedom while risking her own?
As I read about this riveting course of events, I was emotionally torn by the tension, anxiety, and hazard involved in not knowing who could be trusted while trying to engineer an escape. Great risk was involved with no guarantee of success.
The author's note at the end of this book should definitely not be missed. This book contains a wealth of research and facts about this period in history. I would recommend this to all avid historical fiction fans and general fiction fans alike.
My sincere thanks to Random House Publishing Group-Ballantine Books for giving me the opportunity to read a digital ARC of this book through NetGalley. All opinions expressed are my own.
Any reader searching for a compelling story about pre-Civil War abolitionists and the struggle of fugitive slaves will definitely want to read this debut novel. The author shares a great deal of important historical information, and readers will gain a better understanding of the turbulent quest for freedom and acceptance.
This intense and thought-provoking story highlights the fictional lives of three young Black women in Philadelphia in 1837. Each must weigh their commitment to their cause and their family while facing the possibility of danger around every corner.
Nell is the daughter of well-to-do parents who are part of Philadelphia's free Black upper class. She is an active member of the women's Antislavery Society but is disillusioned by their activities, which mostly consist of an abundance of meetings, speeches, bake sales, and fundraising. Nell's new friendship with Charlotte soon ends up plunging her into aiding and abetting a fugitive slave.
Charlotte and her father are secretly runaways from a plantation in Maryland. He passes as white and sets up a woodworking shop in the city, while keeping his daughter home as a servant in hopes of furthering his growth and acceptance into Philadelphia society. Unbeknownst to her father, Charlotte is sneaking out of the house to meet with Nell at Antislavery Society meetings.
Everyone's lives are upended when Evie, a young slave who was like a sister to Charlotte at the plantation, shows up in Philly with their widowed mistress. Reuniting with Charlotte causes jealousy and fuels Evie's desire to escape her demanding owner and slavery. Will Charlotte help Evie find freedom while risking her own?
As I read about this riveting course of events, I was emotionally torn by the tension, anxiety, and hazard involved in not knowing who could be trusted while trying to engineer an escape. Great risk was involved with no guarantee of success.
The author's note at the end of this book should definitely not be missed. This book contains a wealth of research and facts about this period in history. I would recommend this to all avid historical fiction fans and general fiction fans alike.
My sincere thanks to Random House Publishing Group-Ballantine Books for giving me the opportunity to read a digital ARC of this book through NetGalley. All opinions expressed are my own.
June 21, 2024
I’m impressed this was a debut novel. The writing was great! The three main characters had distinct voices and personalities. This is a difficult, but important time to read about and I liked hearing from three different perspectives. I’m excited to see what the author produces next.
April 5, 2024
Ashton Lattimore is a new author for me. I chose to read this book because the description sounded like it dealt with the abolitionist movement and the fight for freedom.
Description:
Philadelphia, 1837. After Charlotte escaped from the crumbling White Oaks plantation down South, she’d expected freedom to feel different from her former life as an enslaved housemaid. After all, Philadelphia is supposed to be the birthplace of American liberty. Instead, she’s locked away playing servant to her white-passing father, as they both attempt to hide their identities from slavecatchers who would destroy their new lives.
Longing to break away, Charlotte befriends Nell, a budding abolitionist from one of Philadelphia’s wealthiest Black families. Just as Charlotte starts to envision a future, a familiar face from her past reappears: Evie, her friend from White Oaks, has been brought to the city by the plantation mistress, and she’s desperate to escape. But as Charlotte and Nell conspire to rescue her, in a city engulfed by race riots and attacks on abolitionists, they soon discover that fighting for Evie’s freedom may cost them their own.
My Thoughts:
This book was enlightening for me as it is the first I've read during the pre-Civil War time period that was not set in what is considered the "deep south". The setting here is Philadelphia, Pennsylvania and many Blacks are free. Just a bit further south the environment at the time would be totally different. There are still major prejudices and segregation here though. I found the political standing of the abolitionists at this time to be brave considering the atmosphere in the city. Obviously, they were inviting trouble. The story of Charlotte and her father, as well as Evie was heartbreaking. It was easy to hate Kate for her role here. Sometimes I found the book a bit slow, but I felt it a good portrayal of what was happening during this time period.
Thanks to Random House Publishing Group - Ballantine through Netgalley for an advance copy.
Description:
Philadelphia, 1837. After Charlotte escaped from the crumbling White Oaks plantation down South, she’d expected freedom to feel different from her former life as an enslaved housemaid. After all, Philadelphia is supposed to be the birthplace of American liberty. Instead, she’s locked away playing servant to her white-passing father, as they both attempt to hide their identities from slavecatchers who would destroy their new lives.
Longing to break away, Charlotte befriends Nell, a budding abolitionist from one of Philadelphia’s wealthiest Black families. Just as Charlotte starts to envision a future, a familiar face from her past reappears: Evie, her friend from White Oaks, has been brought to the city by the plantation mistress, and she’s desperate to escape. But as Charlotte and Nell conspire to rescue her, in a city engulfed by race riots and attacks on abolitionists, they soon discover that fighting for Evie’s freedom may cost them their own.
My Thoughts:
This book was enlightening for me as it is the first I've read during the pre-Civil War time period that was not set in what is considered the "deep south". The setting here is Philadelphia, Pennsylvania and many Blacks are free. Just a bit further south the environment at the time would be totally different. There are still major prejudices and segregation here though. I found the political standing of the abolitionists at this time to be brave considering the atmosphere in the city. Obviously, they were inviting trouble. The story of Charlotte and her father, as well as Evie was heartbreaking. It was easy to hate Kate for her role here. Sometimes I found the book a bit slow, but I felt it a good portrayal of what was happening during this time period.
Thanks to Random House Publishing Group - Ballantine through Netgalley for an advance copy.
April 11, 2025
A lot happens in this pre-civil war consideration of free Black citizens of Philadelphia, former slaves passing for white, and how their continuing relationships with family who cannot pass for white can hold them back. . .
A reader is put in the middle of all the layers of complication in this story of Charlotte, her father Jack, surprise visitors that bring back the past, and a fierce abolitionist who has passion for her work, but needs more understanding in order to gain ground in her fight. A well-told tale, that kept me interested.
*A sincere thank you to Ashton Lattimore, Random House Publishing Group - Ballentine, and NetGalley for an ARC to read and review independently.*
A reader is put in the middle of all the layers of complication in this story of Charlotte, her father Jack, surprise visitors that bring back the past, and a fierce abolitionist who has passion for her work, but needs more understanding in order to gain ground in her fight. A well-told tale, that kept me interested.
*A sincere thank you to Ashton Lattimore, Random House Publishing Group - Ballentine, and NetGalley for an ARC to read and review independently.*
March 3, 2024
A novel of historical fiction finely executed with plenty of historical facts that will send you seeking to verify the events in the novel. It’s always gratifying to learn actual factual matters have indeed taken place but you were unaware until coming across a great piece of work, fiction no less, that enlightens and broadens your knowledge base while doing it wrapped inside an engaging story teeming with intrigue.
The takeaway for me was the obvious research that went into the crafting of this tale, and the important dialogue we get from and between three women on different rungs of the social ladder. The themes of action vs. support, sacrifice vs. unity, truth vs. deceit. It’s all there, and though the novel starts slowly it builds to a crescendo and along the way your heart will quicken with anticipation and expectation. How will it all shake out in the end? Thank you to Ballantine Books and Netgalley for an DRC! Novel drops in April. Kudos on your debut Ms. Lattimore.
The takeaway for me was the obvious research that went into the crafting of this tale, and the important dialogue we get from and between three women on different rungs of the social ladder. The themes of action vs. support, sacrifice vs. unity, truth vs. deceit. It’s all there, and though the novel starts slowly it builds to a crescendo and along the way your heart will quicken with anticipation and expectation. How will it all shake out in the end? Thank you to Ballantine Books and Netgalley for an DRC! Novel drops in April. Kudos on your debut Ms. Lattimore.
Read
May 1, 2024This was excellent
April 7, 2024
Heartbreaking with relatable endearing characters. ALL WE WERE PROMISED has a truly, UNIQUE storyline exploring pre-Civil War Black society in 1837 Philadelphia; -the city that represents the Birthplace of Freedom. This story entails the lives of three Black women; -Charlotte, Nell and Evie, each from varying backgrounds. Charlotte and Nell plan to help youngest girl Evie escape from her white owner. On her own, Evie flees, with Charlotte and Nell only to be kidnapped due to a mixup by hired slave-catchers. You see, there’s a kinship between Evie and Charlotte. Both were slaves on the same southern plantation.. plus another startling secret.. Charlotte’s fathers’ life is at risk if his “secret” is ever discovered. I love how the author wrote with specific detail providing a very thorough look into each of these women’s lives. I never really knew until reading this about the danger in Philadelphia that free Blacks faced. Racial division. Hordes of angry whites protesting abolition including the beatings or deaths of Black citizens. And the real burning of Pennsylvania Hall. Did you know that Black women were key factors in the city’s abolitionist cause and in the building of Pennsylvania Hall. They each had a voice, and combined, they let it be heard. Powerful. What a fascinating debut! I highly recommend it. Ashton Lattimore has also included an authors note detailing the books inspiration and her research. 5 stars — Pub. 4/2/24
I received a copy from the publisher through NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
I received a copy from the publisher through NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
April 14, 2024
A well-written novel about Pennsylvania in the mid 1800’s pre Civil war and involves 3 different black women all at different stages of freedom. One, a free socialite, trying to help the abolitionist movement with her family’s power and wealth. Another, who works as a housemaid but carries a big secret. And the last, an enslaved young girl who comes to Pennsylvania for a few months. These three women meet together to help free the third gal. Very much enjoyed this novel which exposes the times of the mid 1800’s in the north US.
April 14, 2024
2.5 stars. The plot of this book is quite interesting - set in "free" Philadelphia in the 1830's, it follows the story of three young women at different points of freedom - Nell, a born free black woman, Charlotte, a former runaway slave now free by Philadelphia law, and Evie, a current slave to the same owner once shared by Charlotte. The whole story is the ins and outs of 1800's Northern politics along with an effort to free Evie entirely.
I really liked the characters, each similar while drastically different, which even as someone who cannot relate to the situation, I found myself able to relate to each of them as characters. They also all 'come together' within the story which is a favorite troupe of mine, personally. Even supporting characters were interesting and necessary to hold up this story.
That being said, it was quite dry over all. A lot of unneeded description over and over became a bit redundant. Also, there were a lot of minor plot points which never really went anywhere. They weren't very necessary to the story over all, so it just kind of felt like "why?" A good portion of the book felt a little as if the author was just trying to make the book longer. I had to push through a good majority of this book in order to finish it and it had a hard time keeping my attention.
I really liked the characters, each similar while drastically different, which even as someone who cannot relate to the situation, I found myself able to relate to each of them as characters. They also all 'come together' within the story which is a favorite troupe of mine, personally. Even supporting characters were interesting and necessary to hold up this story.
That being said, it was quite dry over all. A lot of unneeded description over and over became a bit redundant. Also, there were a lot of minor plot points which never really went anywhere. They weren't very necessary to the story over all, so it just kind of felt like "why?" A good portion of the book felt a little as if the author was just trying to make the book longer. I had to push through a good majority of this book in order to finish it and it had a hard time keeping my attention.
December 23, 2023
Ashton Lattimore's first novel is an excellent combination of thorough historical research and good storytelling. She narrates the story in the voices of three main characters: Nell, the daughter of a well-to-do family of free Blacks who had lived in the city for generations; Charlotte/Carrie, a young woman who escaped with her father from enslavement on a Maryland tobacco plantation; and Evie, a still-enslaved young woman brought to Philadelphia by her mistress. Three women from very different circumstances come together at a time when the fever of abolition was running high in the city, but also up against an equally fervent push from those who wished to see the "peculiar institution" continue.
Based on the true story of the Philadelphia Female Anti-Slavery Society, and the 1838 convention of anti-slavery advocates at Pennsylvania Hall, this is a moving and suspenseful story that is sure to have readers rooting for these young protagonists, as they each learn from the others important truths about themselves as well as their place in this country's history.
Thank you to the publisher and #NetGalley for providing me with a free ARC in exchange for an objective review. #AllWeWerePromised
Based on the true story of the Philadelphia Female Anti-Slavery Society, and the 1838 convention of anti-slavery advocates at Pennsylvania Hall, this is a moving and suspenseful story that is sure to have readers rooting for these young protagonists, as they each learn from the others important truths about themselves as well as their place in this country's history.
Thank you to the publisher and #NetGalley for providing me with a free ARC in exchange for an objective review. #AllWeWerePromised
February 8, 2024
Ashton Lattimore’s 𝘈𝘭𝘭 𝘞𝘦 𝘞𝘦𝘳𝘦 𝘗𝘳𝘰𝘮𝘪𝘴𝘦𝘥 is a fascinating look at pre-Civil War Philadelphia. Set in the late 1830s, the historical fiction novel follows three young black women as they fight for change: Nell, a social activist from a elite local family; Charlotte, a runaway slave posing as a housemaid to her white-passing father; and Evie, a slave traveling with her mistress from Maryland. At this time, slavery was outlawed in the North, but there were areas where white visitors were allowed to bring their slaves with them under certain rules. Further complicating the landscape were class divides among free black people. Though the action is a bit slow at times, 𝘈𝘭𝘭 𝘞𝘦 𝘞𝘦𝘳𝘦 𝘗𝘳𝘰𝘮𝘪𝘴𝘦𝘥 is an interesting glimpse of racism and classism in the U.S. during this period as well as a valuable exploration of the importance of active civil engagement. 3.75 stars rounded up. Thank you to Ballantine Books and NetGalley for an advance reader copy in exchange for an honest review.
February 21, 2024
I received this book from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
1837 Philadelphia. A young [Black] housemaid, Charlotte, has a secret. She conspires with Nell, a wealthy young [Black} abolitionist to help Evie, an enslaved girl, escape.
Historical fiction, well researched, but... There are many interesting details regarding life in Philadelphia--especially for the wealthy black enclave, the abolitionist/anti-slavery movement, and the building of Philadelphia Hall.
A story of friendship, deception, family, slavery.
Pennsylvania was a free state--BUT there were enough loopholes to allow southern slave owners to bring their slaves north--witness the predicament of Evie with Kate [an interesting backstory].
I so wanted to love this book!I However, it never really grabbed me [although it was a fast, easy read [save for the grim subject matter/slavery/man's inhumanity to man]. I kept plowing through. Forgive me, but I found it somewhat lacking in literary merit--the prose was [to me] quite pedestrian--it never captured me and I like when prose takes my breath away! And, always a disconnect for me--"mush", an obvious trajectory [in a couple of instances], and a neat and tidy ending [no spoiler from me].
Also I found it a bit unbelievable although I credit Charlotte for her "growth" that she changed from a very timid woman to one with great fortitude in a relatively short period.
Question: why do the driver's for one of the white slavers have Greek names--Odysseus and Achilles?
Be sure to read the Author's Notes.
In the distinct minority. Solid 3.
1837 Philadelphia. A young [Black] housemaid, Charlotte, has a secret. She conspires with Nell, a wealthy young [Black} abolitionist to help Evie, an enslaved girl, escape.
Historical fiction, well researched, but... There are many interesting details regarding life in Philadelphia--especially for the wealthy black enclave, the abolitionist/anti-slavery movement, and the building of Philadelphia Hall.
A story of friendship, deception, family, slavery.
Pennsylvania was a free state--BUT there were enough loopholes to allow southern slave owners to bring their slaves north--witness the predicament of Evie with Kate [an interesting backstory].
I so wanted to love this book!I However, it never really grabbed me [although it was a fast, easy read [save for the grim subject matter/slavery/man's inhumanity to man]. I kept plowing through. Forgive me, but I found it somewhat lacking in literary merit--the prose was [to me] quite pedestrian--it never captured me and I like when prose takes my breath away! And, always a disconnect for me--"mush", an obvious trajectory [in a couple of instances], and a neat and tidy ending [no spoiler from me].
Also I found it a bit unbelievable although I credit Charlotte for her "growth" that she changed from a very timid woman to one with great fortitude in a relatively short period.
Question: why do the driver's for one of the white slavers have Greek names--Odysseus and Achilles?
Be sure to read the Author's Notes.
In the distinct minority. Solid 3.
April 21, 2024
Another I have to thank NetGalley for putting on my radar, but in the end I listened to the excellent audiobook. I'm not especially fond of Civil War stories, but this is pre-Civil War Philadelphia and gave an interesting perspective on slaves vs free Blacks during this time. We have a slave visiting from Maryland with her master, a father/daughter couple who had escaped that same master and are living free, and the privileged, respected free Black society of the time. Don't skip the Authors Notes which explained what inspired her. I didn't expect her to mention Jean Valjean and his daughter.
A noteworthy debut, to say the least.
A noteworthy debut, to say the least.
April 20, 2024
Two and a half stars. The dialogue was too modern. This also seemed like it should have been marketed as YA.
November 21, 2023
I learned so much from this novel and have shared my thoughts with the author, which is a gift: There is a beautiful recovery of the narratives of free Black people in Philadelphia circa 1837 in All We Were Promised. Those narratives illuminate, too, the stark contrast of enslaved Black people continuing to struggle for freedom decades before the end of the Civil War. There is lovely sisterhood, a touch of romance and details of how Black women organized long before anyone gave them credit to improve their lives and the lives of their families.
March 28, 2024
I have received this ARC from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
All We Were Promised was such an interesting book. It was so interesting that I tried my very best to devour it all slowly. If slowly means less than two days, then yes, I succeeded. In this wonderful book, you will meet Nell, Charlotte, and Evie. They are three women who are set to change the world's views on freedom and slavery. One was born into a wealthy black family; one was a runaway slave and has been hiding for about four years; and one is desperately seeking answers about her family members and yearning to be free herself.
Together, they all have the same goal, but it will not be easy.
Throughout the book, secrets come and go, and it's easy to spot people that one shouldn't trust. I honestly really enjoyed getting to know our three main ladies, but it hurt my heart to see them hurting. Especially when Evie felt abandoned but didn't know what was going on with Charlotte. Charlotte was carrying what seemed like the weight of the world with the secrets of her past life, and she didn't know who she could or couldn't trust with certain information. Then there's Nell, who just wanted the Philadelphia Female Antislavery Society to do more—so much more.
They each take risks to make the world a better place, not only for themselves but also for the upcoming future. Along the way, we definitely met side characters that would be forever welcomed to family gatherings, dinners, and holidays. As well as characters we would never want to see again. The city and its people could be downright violent and extremely racist, but these three held their heads up high with pride. Why do you ask? Well, they saw what freedom could and would look like and just knew things had to be better.
In the end, it all fell on a bittersweet note for me. With the fighting and buildings set on fire towards the end, I just wanted to learn more information about Evie's family. I'm glad that everyone is safe or on their way out of town, but I just wanted a bigger glimpse of happiness for them. The battle has just begun, and I'm hoping this author will write another book set in this time period, but from the point of view of the other ladies we've met along the way.
Or maybe from some people we haven't met yet.
All We Were Promised was such an interesting book. It was so interesting that I tried my very best to devour it all slowly. If slowly means less than two days, then yes, I succeeded. In this wonderful book, you will meet Nell, Charlotte, and Evie. They are three women who are set to change the world's views on freedom and slavery. One was born into a wealthy black family; one was a runaway slave and has been hiding for about four years; and one is desperately seeking answers about her family members and yearning to be free herself.
Together, they all have the same goal, but it will not be easy.
Throughout the book, secrets come and go, and it's easy to spot people that one shouldn't trust. I honestly really enjoyed getting to know our three main ladies, but it hurt my heart to see them hurting. Especially when Evie felt abandoned but didn't know what was going on with Charlotte. Charlotte was carrying what seemed like the weight of the world with the secrets of her past life, and she didn't know who she could or couldn't trust with certain information. Then there's Nell, who just wanted the Philadelphia Female Antislavery Society to do more—so much more.
They each take risks to make the world a better place, not only for themselves but also for the upcoming future. Along the way, we definitely met side characters that would be forever welcomed to family gatherings, dinners, and holidays. As well as characters we would never want to see again. The city and its people could be downright violent and extremely racist, but these three held their heads up high with pride. Why do you ask? Well, they saw what freedom could and would look like and just knew things had to be better.
In the end, it all fell on a bittersweet note for me. With the fighting and buildings set on fire towards the end, I just wanted to learn more information about Evie's family. I'm glad that everyone is safe or on their way out of town, but I just wanted a bigger glimpse of happiness for them. The battle has just begun, and I'm hoping this author will write another book set in this time period, but from the point of view of the other ladies we've met along the way.
Or maybe from some people we haven't met yet.
August 12, 2025
ayyyeeee, i copy-edited this for an old publishing internship. so cool to see it out in the world!
March 29, 2024
DNF at 55% (my first of the year)
🥴
I tried so hard to finish this ARC, but I just couldn’t keep going. After reading 23 of this 43 chapter novel, I let myself put it down. This book wasn’t terrible, but I do not currently have the patience for repetitive writing for the sake of dragging out a story that could have easily been told in 25 chapters.
🤷🏻♀️
I do love that this book tackles a time and topic that I rarely see in historical fiction novels. It is set in pre-Civil War Philadelphia and is told from the POV of three young Black women from varying societal classes. Had this book received the benefit of a heavy handed editor, and been trimmed down about a dozen or so chapters, it would have been great! As it is, I became bored and frustrated. I’ll not rate this one less than 3 stars though. I think that a more patient reader who loves historical fiction could very much enjoy this book.
🫠
Thank you to NetGalley and Ballantine Books for a free digital ARC in exchange for my honest review.
🥴
I tried so hard to finish this ARC, but I just couldn’t keep going. After reading 23 of this 43 chapter novel, I let myself put it down. This book wasn’t terrible, but I do not currently have the patience for repetitive writing for the sake of dragging out a story that could have easily been told in 25 chapters.
🤷🏻♀️
I do love that this book tackles a time and topic that I rarely see in historical fiction novels. It is set in pre-Civil War Philadelphia and is told from the POV of three young Black women from varying societal classes. Had this book received the benefit of a heavy handed editor, and been trimmed down about a dozen or so chapters, it would have been great! As it is, I became bored and frustrated. I’ll not rate this one less than 3 stars though. I think that a more patient reader who loves historical fiction could very much enjoy this book.
🫠
Thank you to NetGalley and Ballantine Books for a free digital ARC in exchange for my honest review.
August 25, 2024
An historical fiction based on some true moments, taking place in the 1830's Philadelphia.
Revolves around 3 young black women, each from different backgrounds- Nell, a daughter of a well established family in Philadelphia, Charlotte who we learn her background over time & Evie, a slave who is visiting with her Missus/slave owner in Philadelphia but from the south.
There are secrets & twists & turns & some historical facts which I knew nothing about.
I felt Charlotte was the least understood as she had things she could not or was not ready to share & it made her vulnerable & misunderstood.
It was a very well researched story, showing the turmoil in "free" Philadelphia.
Thank you Ballantine Books for this advance copy in exchange for an honest review.
Revolves around 3 young black women, each from different backgrounds- Nell, a daughter of a well established family in Philadelphia, Charlotte who we learn her background over time & Evie, a slave who is visiting with her Missus/slave owner in Philadelphia but from the south.
There are secrets & twists & turns & some historical facts which I knew nothing about.
I felt Charlotte was the least understood as she had things she could not or was not ready to share & it made her vulnerable & misunderstood.
It was a very well researched story, showing the turmoil in "free" Philadelphia.
Thank you Ballantine Books for this advance copy in exchange for an honest review.
November 26, 2024
3.5 stars. This one was recommended to me so I grabbed the audiobook from my library and jumped in. This is a historical fiction that takes place in Philadelphia in pre-Civil War (1837).
As the author’s notes shares, this book and story are told to shine a light on the often overlooked agency and ingenuity of the Black women and men who helped shape Philadelphia and the abolitionist movement during the pre-civil war period of American history. In the story we follow 3 women and their struggles and journeys (Charlotte, Nell, and Evie). Charlotte is a formerly enslaved woman who became a runaway with her father and they escaped to Pennsylvania, Nell was born into a free family who has lived her entire life in Philadelphia and has more of a privileged life than others. She is active in the Women’s Anti-Slavery Society. It was interesting reading about Philadelphia during this time and what was happening
in this self-proclaimed “cradle of liberty” city.
The story, history, and time period was interesting. I did find the writing to be a bit slow and tedious to get through at times though, so that is why it is definitely more of a 3.5 star read for me. I believe this is the author’s debut, so I’d be interested to pick up more from them in the future!
As the author’s notes shares, this book and story are told to shine a light on the often overlooked agency and ingenuity of the Black women and men who helped shape Philadelphia and the abolitionist movement during the pre-civil war period of American history. In the story we follow 3 women and their struggles and journeys (Charlotte, Nell, and Evie). Charlotte is a formerly enslaved woman who became a runaway with her father and they escaped to Pennsylvania, Nell was born into a free family who has lived her entire life in Philadelphia and has more of a privileged life than others. She is active in the Women’s Anti-Slavery Society. It was interesting reading about Philadelphia during this time and what was happening
in this self-proclaimed “cradle of liberty” city.
The story, history, and time period was interesting. I did find the writing to be a bit slow and tedious to get through at times though, so that is why it is definitely more of a 3.5 star read for me. I believe this is the author’s debut, so I’d be interested to pick up more from them in the future!
March 10, 2024
Thanks to NetGalley and Random House Publishing Group - Ballantine for my ARC in exchange for my honest review. This book will be published April 2, 2024.
This historical fiction takes us back to Philadelphia in 1837. The three main characters are Nell, hey buddy, abolitionist from one of Philadelphia wealthiest families, Charlotte, who has fled slavery, but is living a lie, and Evie, who is left behind and continues to be a slave. The friendship and determination amongst these three young women is inspiring and beautiful.
I think this is the first book. I’ve read set in this time and I did learn quite a few things about slavery and the Philadelphia Female Anti-Slave Society.
Kudos to the author for a realistic portrayal of the challenges faced during this time. It’s a fantastic debut novel. It was interesting to find out in the authors note that the entire book was based upon a lyric from the musical Les Mis.
This historical fiction takes us back to Philadelphia in 1837. The three main characters are Nell, hey buddy, abolitionist from one of Philadelphia wealthiest families, Charlotte, who has fled slavery, but is living a lie, and Evie, who is left behind and continues to be a slave. The friendship and determination amongst these three young women is inspiring and beautiful.
I think this is the first book. I’ve read set in this time and I did learn quite a few things about slavery and the Philadelphia Female Anti-Slave Society.
Kudos to the author for a realistic portrayal of the challenges faced during this time. It’s a fantastic debut novel. It was interesting to find out in the authors note that the entire book was based upon a lyric from the musical Les Mis.
January 22, 2024
Wow! This was a compelling and powerful read about the abolitionist movement of 1837 in Philadelphia. It focuses on the lives of three disparate women of color: a runaway slave, a young slave and a freeborn woman. The historical research which went into its telling is vast and spot on. The writing is smart, evocative and rich. The characters are well and and carefully developed. The setting of scene is exquisitely rendered. Ms. Lattimore's understanding of the law is apparent in the telling. It's truly difficult to imagine this being a debut novel; it's just that good.
Charlotte (formerly Carrie) is a young former slave who several years previously, fled a Maryland plantation with her father (who comfortably passes as a white man) and settled in Philadelphia. To keep up her father's charade as he establishes himself as a fine furniture maker, Charlotte presents herself as her father's maid. She bristles against the restraint of her lot in life, especially when her father forbids her being out in public, for her own safety, of course. For a free woman, she doesn't feel very free. She becomes friends with Nell, an altruistic freeborn woman with aspirations of making a difference in the world, specifically, raising funds in support of anti-slavery legislation and petitioning congress to make those necessary changes. But when called on by Charlotte to help a young slave girl break free from her mistress, how far is Nell really willing to go? Afterall, it's illegal to aid a slave in their flight for freedom.
If well written historical fiction appeals, then this may well be an excellent choice for you.
I am grateful to Ballantine Books for having provided a complimentary uncorrected e-book of this story. Their generosity, however, has not influenced this review - the words of which are mine alone.
Publisher: Ballantine Books
Publication date: April 2, 2024
Number of Pages: 352
ISBN: 978-0593600153
Charlotte (formerly Carrie) is a young former slave who several years previously, fled a Maryland plantation with her father (who comfortably passes as a white man) and settled in Philadelphia. To keep up her father's charade as he establishes himself as a fine furniture maker, Charlotte presents herself as her father's maid. She bristles against the restraint of her lot in life, especially when her father forbids her being out in public, for her own safety, of course. For a free woman, she doesn't feel very free. She becomes friends with Nell, an altruistic freeborn woman with aspirations of making a difference in the world, specifically, raising funds in support of anti-slavery legislation and petitioning congress to make those necessary changes. But when called on by Charlotte to help a young slave girl break free from her mistress, how far is Nell really willing to go? Afterall, it's illegal to aid a slave in their flight for freedom.
If well written historical fiction appeals, then this may well be an excellent choice for you.
I am grateful to Ballantine Books for having provided a complimentary uncorrected e-book of this story. Their generosity, however, has not influenced this review - the words of which are mine alone.
Publisher: Ballantine Books
Publication date: April 2, 2024
Number of Pages: 352
ISBN: 978-0593600153
May 8, 2024
3.5. It took me awhile to get into this one, but once I did, it was an enjoyable read. I loved that this story took place in Philadelphia and the reasons for that choice. The beginning is definitely slow and there is a fair amount of repetition before it picks up. The majority of ~action~ takes place in the last third but worth reading to get there. Overall, All We Were Promised doesn’t read like a debut novel and has a strong ending and author’s note.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 1,369 reviews