⭐⭐⭐⭐⭒
Funny, life-affirming, and just lovely all around, this book explores the unplanned and unexpected that makes life worth living. Though Lark's story is the centerpiece here and arguably the most interesting, the novel follows three interconnected women at crossroads in their respective lives. Lots of reflective work goes on for all the women around central themes many people can relate to, including how to pick up the pieces after loss and sustaining a long-term relationship through ups and downs. The overriding message for all the stories is ultimately that life is unexpected and no matter your age, there are always possibilities for good things to come your way. It's hard not to love the idea that while change is inevitable, good things can happen anytime if you are open to them.
As a romance reader foremost, I was especially drawn to Lark's story, as she is the main character and the one with the most conventionally romantic arc. It does take quite a while though to get to the romance, and at times, I felt a bit bogged down in the tragedy she experienced when she lost her long-time love to cancer. We know Justin dies in the early chapters as we witness her picnicking at his grave site and constantly reminiscing over memories of their happy times together. Her personal loss spills over into her professional life in the first chapters too since she struggles in her role as an oncology resident after med school. She doesn't have the professional objectivity needed for this job and is subsequently booted out and sent over to work as an ER physician.
Thankfully, the book sends us Lorenzo as a much-needed reprieve from the depression threatening to settle over Lark's story. Lorenzo, aka Dr. Satan, is horrible; he lives up to his name as the brilliant but detestable superstar of Boston's medical world, but he is also one of those unexpected people who can come into a life and truly upend it in complicated ways. Lark reluctantly agrees to provide cover for him as a date at a family event to persuade his dying granny that he has a potential partner in life. But it's the domino effect of how one thing can lead to another in life, and before Lark knows it, she is enmeshed with Lorenzo's big, sprawling, raucous family, including his younger and charismatic brother. I bought completely into the family dynamics, and Lark's attempts to pretend-date a well-known misanthrope is funny as we see everyone struggle to understand her attraction to him. Two brothers with a complicated history, one sad and lonely young woman trying to move forward with her life - their messy triangle was riveting reading.
The entire novel though is sprawling in the best of ways, and Lark, her mom Ellie, and her landlord Joy all have their own fully developed stories that draw you in and make the book come alive. I couldn't wait to read their stories every night. I did have some misgivings around the canonizing of Justin as this figure of perfect goodness. Given how complicated so many characters are here, Justin's depiction felt shallow. He tragically succumbs to cancer at a terribly young age, and therefore his life is unfairly cut short. But other than that, he isn't really allowed much character development, and I did think the novel spends far too much time on the lost love rather than the much more dynamic and engaging romantic life waiting for Lark as she negotiates a relationship with two charismatic brothers.
I really did not know how this book would end, but I can happily say that it does so magnificently and in fairness to all the characters here. One of my favorite books this year!