What do you think?
Rate this book
Hecate Cavendish #2
The Cathedral of Lost Souls
Book two in the Hecate Cavendish series from New York Times bestselling author Paula Brackston - a magic infused series about an eccentric and spirited young woman who can see ghosts.
Hereford, England 1881.
The adventure continues! After the fire and the tumultuous events in the cathedral library, Hecate is determined never again to come so close to losing the beloved mappa mundi. She has shown herself to be the greatest threat to the Essedenes and their plans and they will stop at nothing to be rid of her. With the help of her
archeologist father, and the support of the redoubtable and loyal Inspector Winter, she must take the fight to her enemies.
But the numbers of Embodied Spirits are growing with terrifying speed, and an atmosphere of violence and danger has taken hold of the ancient city of Hereford. Hecate dare not trust anyone beyond her inner circle, no matter how benevolent they might seem. Nor will she risk the lives of those she loves ever again. The goddess Hekate has called her to action. She must draw upon all her gifts, and the assistance of her family of ghostly allies, if the city is not to be lost to darkness forever.
Hereford, England 1881.
The adventure continues! After the fire and the tumultuous events in the cathedral library, Hecate is determined never again to come so close to losing the beloved mappa mundi. She has shown herself to be the greatest threat to the Essedenes and their plans and they will stop at nothing to be rid of her. With the help of her
archeologist father, and the support of the redoubtable and loyal Inspector Winter, she must take the fight to her enemies.
But the numbers of Embodied Spirits are growing with terrifying speed, and an atmosphere of violence and danger has taken hold of the ancient city of Hereford. Hecate dare not trust anyone beyond her inner circle, no matter how benevolent they might seem. Nor will she risk the lives of those she loves ever again. The goddess Hekate has called her to action. She must draw upon all her gifts, and the assistance of her family of ghostly allies, if the city is not to be lost to darkness forever.
297 pages, Kindle Edition
First published November 11, 2025
93 people are currently reading
5295 people want to read
About the author
Paula Brackston
26 books5,267 followersPaula Brackston (aka PJ Brackston)is the New York Times bestselling author of The Witch's Daughter, The Winter Witch, and The Midnight Witch(2014).
Paula has an MA in Creative Writing from Lancaster University, and is a Visiting Lecturer for the University of Wales, Newport. In 2007 Paula was short listed in the Creme de la Crime search for new writers. In 2010 her book 'Nutters' (writing as PJ Davy) was short listed for the Mind Book Award, and she was selected by the BBC under their New Welsh Writers scheme.
https://www.youtube.com/c/PaulaBracks...
Paula lives in Wales with her partner and their two children.
Paula has an MA in Creative Writing from Lancaster University, and is a Visiting Lecturer for the University of Wales, Newport. In 2007 Paula was short listed in the Creme de la Crime search for new writers. In 2010 her book 'Nutters' (writing as PJ Davy) was short listed for the Mind Book Award, and she was selected by the BBC under their New Welsh Writers scheme.
https://www.youtube.com/c/PaulaBracks...
Paula lives in Wales with her partner and their two children.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 95 reviews
December 7, 2025
3 5 stars
Thanks to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press for access to this title. All opinions expressed are my own.
Having enjoyed The Haunting of Hecate Cavendish, there was no hesitation that I would request the second title in the series. Hereford, England, 1881, is where our story begins, and it picks up where we left off in book 1. Having lost the man she loved and almost her own life, Hecate has resolved to continue fighting her enemies with the help of her understanding father and Inspector Winter.
Great characters, solid storyline, and good pacing made this an enjoyable read. I do have to admit that I loved book 1 just a little bit more than this one.
Publication Date 11/11/25
Goodreads Review 03/12/25
Thanks to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press for access to this title. All opinions expressed are my own.
Having enjoyed The Haunting of Hecate Cavendish, there was no hesitation that I would request the second title in the series. Hereford, England, 1881, is where our story begins, and it picks up where we left off in book 1. Having lost the man she loved and almost her own life, Hecate has resolved to continue fighting her enemies with the help of her understanding father and Inspector Winter.
Great characters, solid storyline, and good pacing made this an enjoyable read. I do have to admit that I loved book 1 just a little bit more than this one.
Publication Date 11/11/25
Goodreads Review 03/12/25
September 27, 2025
I'll be honest that I would have read "The Cathedral of Lost Souls" just for the beautiful cover alone. This is the second book and it was a good follow up to the first. In this novel, Hecate comes to understand her power a little more. She is also still grieving for the loss of her fiance. However there are more Embodied Spirits than ever and she must figure out who is creating them and how to stop them. Hecate is also trying to protect those close to her and afraid to get close to others. She does find a potential new love interest who also has the ability to see ghosts.
This book had lots of action, ghosts, and mystery. I found that some of my questions about her powers were answered in this book. She also becomes even stronger in this novel than she was in the first. The best parts were the ghosts and a special friend she picked up along the way. This is a great blend of historical fiction, magic, and a strong female protagonist. I highly recommend this story if you are a fan of historical fiction with magic blended in. I do recommend reading the first novel though before reading this one. It also has a beautiful cover that will make you want to pick it up and read it. I look forward to reading more in this series.
Thank you to St. Martin's Press and NetGalley for this ARC.
This book had lots of action, ghosts, and mystery. I found that some of my questions about her powers were answered in this book. She also becomes even stronger in this novel than she was in the first. The best parts were the ghosts and a special friend she picked up along the way. This is a great blend of historical fiction, magic, and a strong female protagonist. I highly recommend this story if you are a fan of historical fiction with magic blended in. I do recommend reading the first novel though before reading this one. It also has a beautiful cover that will make you want to pick it up and read it. I look forward to reading more in this series.
Thank you to St. Martin's Press and NetGalley for this ARC.
June 24, 2025
This was a good conclusion to the story. Still loved the characters and the story itself.
October 9, 2025
Paula Brackston's Hecate Cavendish series continues with this second book, which centers around a woman who possesses the ability to see ghosts. The narrative skillfully expands upon the events of 'The Haunting of Hecate Cavendish', making it an effective sequel.
While it is possible to read this book as a standalone, reading the first installment in the series beforehand is advisable.
Throughout the story, Hecate exhibits increased confidence in her powers and gifts, ultimately allowing her to triumph over the Embodied Spirits. This
enchanting fairy tale, featuring an array of magical creatures and exploring universal conflict between good and evil, is truly exceptional.
Despite occasional slow pacing, the book earned a five-star rating from me. My thanks go to NetGalley and the publisher for providing an advance review copy in exchange for an honest review.
While it is possible to read this book as a standalone, reading the first installment in the series beforehand is advisable.
Throughout the story, Hecate exhibits increased confidence in her powers and gifts, ultimately allowing her to triumph over the Embodied Spirits. This
enchanting fairy tale, featuring an array of magical creatures and exploring universal conflict between good and evil, is truly exceptional.
Despite occasional slow pacing, the book earned a five-star rating from me. My thanks go to NetGalley and the publisher for providing an advance review copy in exchange for an honest review.
November 11, 2025
So this is book #2.
I was a bit disappointed after finishing book #1. Not because it didn’t end well, but I was just upset. Not sure if I’m on my own with this thought, but it is what it is…
Then, we begin book #2… and there is hope!
So, although it did not fix what happened, it gave another option… and I’ll leave it at that. 😉
Hecate is back and is getting better at figuring out and even wielding her Magicks or powers or gifts… whatever you’d like to call them. And now, she has a few people she feels she can trust with what is going on with her…
It is definitely NOT easy, or all sunshine and roses…but it is hard earned knowledge and power with happiness and grief too…
There are a lot of ups and downs, and some outright sad/tragic scenes… but, it is another terrific installment! And, I felt like I got just a little bit of closure!
If you like Magicks and witches and other-worldly powers, please keep your eyes 👀 open for this one. It releases in just a couple of days on 11/11/25!!
#TheCathedralOfLostSouls by @PaulaBrackston and narrated nicely by @MarisaCalin.
4 bright, soulful stars for me! 🌟🌟🌟🌟
Thanks so much to @NetGalley and @MacmillanAudio for an ALC of the audiobook in exchange for an honest review.
You can find my reviews on: Goodreads,
Instagram: @BookReviews_with_emsr and/or
My Facebook Book Club: Book Reviews With Elaine
Thanks so much for reading! And if you ‘liked’ my review, please share with your friends, & click ‘LIKE’ below… And, let me know YOUR thoughts if you read it!! 📚⭐️
I was a bit disappointed after finishing book #1. Not because it didn’t end well, but I was just upset. Not sure if I’m on my own with this thought, but it is what it is…
Then, we begin book #2… and there is hope!
So, although it did not fix what happened, it gave another option… and I’ll leave it at that. 😉
Hecate is back and is getting better at figuring out and even wielding her Magicks or powers or gifts… whatever you’d like to call them. And now, she has a few people she feels she can trust with what is going on with her…
It is definitely NOT easy, or all sunshine and roses…but it is hard earned knowledge and power with happiness and grief too…
There are a lot of ups and downs, and some outright sad/tragic scenes… but, it is another terrific installment! And, I felt like I got just a little bit of closure!
If you like Magicks and witches and other-worldly powers, please keep your eyes 👀 open for this one. It releases in just a couple of days on 11/11/25!!
#TheCathedralOfLostSouls by @PaulaBrackston and narrated nicely by @MarisaCalin.
4 bright, soulful stars for me! 🌟🌟🌟🌟
Thanks so much to @NetGalley and @MacmillanAudio for an ALC of the audiobook in exchange for an honest review.
You can find my reviews on: Goodreads,
Instagram: @BookReviews_with_emsr and/or
My Facebook Book Club: Book Reviews With Elaine
Thanks so much for reading! And if you ‘liked’ my review, please share with your friends, & click ‘LIKE’ below… And, let me know YOUR thoughts if you read it!! 📚⭐️
October 28, 2025
Thank you to NetGalley, St. Martin’s Press, and Paula Brackston for the ARC in exchange for my honest review.
The Cathedral of Lost Souls picks up with Hecate Cavendish as she continues to balance her life as the Cathedral’s assistant librarian and as Hekate’s chosen one. This book dives deeper into her grief and how she learns to move forward while managing her very unusual circumstances.
I really love Hecate as a character—she’s smart, brave, and just the right amount of quirky. Her phantom friends add such a fun and heartfelt layer to the story. That said, I did wish some of the side characters had more depth. The world is rich and imaginative, but the pacing felt a little uneven for me. Some parts dragged or included details that didn’t feel essential, which made it hard to stay fully pulled in at times.
There are definitely moments that shine—beautiful, emotional scenes that reminded me why I love fantasy like this—but they were a bit few and far between. I think some of the slower parts might be setting things up for a possible book three, but it still made the story feel a bit heavy in spots.
This is my first series by Paula Brackston, so maybe her pacing just runs slower than I’m used to, but that ended up being my biggest struggle. Still, I really enjoyed the world, the magic, and Hecate’s journey overall.
If you enjoy slower, more reflective fantasy stories with a strong and captivating main character, The Cathedral of Lost Souls is worth picking up.
The Cathedral of Lost Souls picks up with Hecate Cavendish as she continues to balance her life as the Cathedral’s assistant librarian and as Hekate’s chosen one. This book dives deeper into her grief and how she learns to move forward while managing her very unusual circumstances.
I really love Hecate as a character—she’s smart, brave, and just the right amount of quirky. Her phantom friends add such a fun and heartfelt layer to the story. That said, I did wish some of the side characters had more depth. The world is rich and imaginative, but the pacing felt a little uneven for me. Some parts dragged or included details that didn’t feel essential, which made it hard to stay fully pulled in at times.
There are definitely moments that shine—beautiful, emotional scenes that reminded me why I love fantasy like this—but they were a bit few and far between. I think some of the slower parts might be setting things up for a possible book three, but it still made the story feel a bit heavy in spots.
This is my first series by Paula Brackston, so maybe her pacing just runs slower than I’m used to, but that ended up being my biggest struggle. Still, I really enjoyed the world, the magic, and Hecate’s journey overall.
If you enjoy slower, more reflective fantasy stories with a strong and captivating main character, The Cathedral of Lost Souls is worth picking up.
September 16, 2025
Thanks to NetGalley and St Martins Press for access to this eARC in exchange for an honest review. I initially chose this arc due to the book cover. It is such a pretty cover and I was intrigued. I did not realize it was the second book in a series at first and so I went back and read Haunting of Hecate Cavendish first. I felt that the themes and characters in both books were well written. I just didn’t love the writing style. The first half of the book seemed to drag but once I got to about 50% it picked up. Overall a satisfying conclusion to the series.
October 29, 2025
Special thanks to NetGalley and the publisher for a free, electronic ARC of this novel received in exchange for an honest review.
Expected publication date: November 11, 2025
Paula Brackston’s second novel in “The Haunting of Hecate Cavendish” series, “The Cathedral of Lost Souls” has our protagonist, Hecate Cavendish, continuing her adventures in 1881 England, working as a librarian’s assistant in the haunted cathedral library. In this iteration, Hecate is grieving the loss of her fiancé, John, who died tragically while saving Hecate’s younger brother. The library is in need of repairs after falling victim to a fire, and Hecate (and her ghostly counterparts) are determined to put the library back to the way it was, and take out the evil that tried to destroy it once and for all.
“Cathedral” is one of those novels that should be read after reading “Haunting”. Unlike many others of its kind, the plot of the Cavendish series picks up where the first left off, so not reading its predecessor will dampen the enjoyment of the novel overall and lead to readers confusion. The characters from “Haunting” are present in this novel, too (even Hecate’s ghostly friends), which I was glad to see, as they are entertaining and sassy and added a much-needed element of humour to the plot.
This novel has Hecate, along with her father and the police inspector, on the hunt for the bodies of townspeople that have been infiltrated by dark forces, called “The Essedenes”, before the evil spirits can take over the whole town and wreak havoc. Brackston’s novel is full of magic, with paranormal and supernatural elements, with a relatable and heartbreakingly honest protagonist.
Although the focus of the novel is on the obliteration of the evil spirits and all of the magical elements, there is a charming romance component that will no doubt reappear in future novels in the series. Although grieving her beloved John, Hecate begins to fall for a local artisan, who will no doubt send her strait-laced mother right over the edge, and I look forward to seeing how this plays out.
I have been honoured to read Brackston’s series, “The Little Shop of Found Things”, as well as her previous Hecate Cavendish novel, and I was excited to be taken away into the enchanted world of Hecate once again. I am a sucker for female protagonists who rebel against convention and Hecate fits this bill. Alongside her sweet relationship with her family and her love of books, I formed an instant connection with her and I can’t wait to see what she gets up to next.
Expected publication date: November 11, 2025
Paula Brackston’s second novel in “The Haunting of Hecate Cavendish” series, “The Cathedral of Lost Souls” has our protagonist, Hecate Cavendish, continuing her adventures in 1881 England, working as a librarian’s assistant in the haunted cathedral library. In this iteration, Hecate is grieving the loss of her fiancé, John, who died tragically while saving Hecate’s younger brother. The library is in need of repairs after falling victim to a fire, and Hecate (and her ghostly counterparts) are determined to put the library back to the way it was, and take out the evil that tried to destroy it once and for all.
“Cathedral” is one of those novels that should be read after reading “Haunting”. Unlike many others of its kind, the plot of the Cavendish series picks up where the first left off, so not reading its predecessor will dampen the enjoyment of the novel overall and lead to readers confusion. The characters from “Haunting” are present in this novel, too (even Hecate’s ghostly friends), which I was glad to see, as they are entertaining and sassy and added a much-needed element of humour to the plot.
This novel has Hecate, along with her father and the police inspector, on the hunt for the bodies of townspeople that have been infiltrated by dark forces, called “The Essedenes”, before the evil spirits can take over the whole town and wreak havoc. Brackston’s novel is full of magic, with paranormal and supernatural elements, with a relatable and heartbreakingly honest protagonist.
Although the focus of the novel is on the obliteration of the evil spirits and all of the magical elements, there is a charming romance component that will no doubt reappear in future novels in the series. Although grieving her beloved John, Hecate begins to fall for a local artisan, who will no doubt send her strait-laced mother right over the edge, and I look forward to seeing how this plays out.
I have been honoured to read Brackston’s series, “The Little Shop of Found Things”, as well as her previous Hecate Cavendish novel, and I was excited to be taken away into the enchanted world of Hecate once again. I am a sucker for female protagonists who rebel against convention and Hecate fits this bill. Alongside her sweet relationship with her family and her love of books, I formed an instant connection with her and I can’t wait to see what she gets up to next.
November 3, 2025
The Cathedral of Lost Souls is an enchanting gaslight fantasy inviting the reader into a world of magic, myth, and mystery.
The story picks up immediately after the dramatic ending of The Haunting of Hecate Cavendish. While mourning the tragic loss of her fiancé, and busy with repairs to the cathedral library after a dangerous spellbook set it ablaze, Hecate must also contend with the growing number of malevolent spirits running amok in Hereford. It will take all of her courage and newfound power as a follower of the goddess Hekate to banish the evil that threatens her city and her loved ones.
I found that the story alternated between fast-paced action and slower side quests that might be setting up future events in the series. Brackston's writing is atmospheric and cinematic, full of vivid descriptions but also informed by impeccable research. Her books often include intriguing historical artifacts, and I felt inspired to explore pictures of both the Mappa Mundi and apothecary's belts online.
Hecate is an unconventional and sensitive young woman, able to see and communicate with ghosts or "lost souls." The loyal and compassionate friendships that she forges with the spirits in the cathedral are truly heartwarming, as is Hecate's bond with her mythic guardians from the map. I loved seeing her grow in confidence and skill as she developed her magical abilities, learning to rely less on book taught spells and more on her own intuition.
I was also touched by Hecate's close relationship with her father and the trust placed in her by Inspector Winters. In a time when women's rights and roles in society were quite limited, it is refreshing to see Hecate's intelligence and independence being encouraged by the men around her.
Overall this is an engaging and well written story that will appeal to both historical fiction and fantasy readers. I look forward to more of Hecate's adventure as the series continues!
The story picks up immediately after the dramatic ending of The Haunting of Hecate Cavendish. While mourning the tragic loss of her fiancé, and busy with repairs to the cathedral library after a dangerous spellbook set it ablaze, Hecate must also contend with the growing number of malevolent spirits running amok in Hereford. It will take all of her courage and newfound power as a follower of the goddess Hekate to banish the evil that threatens her city and her loved ones.
I found that the story alternated between fast-paced action and slower side quests that might be setting up future events in the series. Brackston's writing is atmospheric and cinematic, full of vivid descriptions but also informed by impeccable research. Her books often include intriguing historical artifacts, and I felt inspired to explore pictures of both the Mappa Mundi and apothecary's belts online.
Hecate is an unconventional and sensitive young woman, able to see and communicate with ghosts or "lost souls." The loyal and compassionate friendships that she forges with the spirits in the cathedral are truly heartwarming, as is Hecate's bond with her mythic guardians from the map. I loved seeing her grow in confidence and skill as she developed her magical abilities, learning to rely less on book taught spells and more on her own intuition.
I was also touched by Hecate's close relationship with her father and the trust placed in her by Inspector Winters. In a time when women's rights and roles in society were quite limited, it is refreshing to see Hecate's intelligence and independence being encouraged by the men around her.
Overall this is an engaging and well written story that will appeal to both historical fiction and fantasy readers. I look forward to more of Hecate's adventure as the series continues!
December 1, 2025
The Cathedral of Lost Souls is the sequel to The Haunting of Hecate Cavendish. This book picks up directly where the first novel left off. Hecate still has not utterly defeated her enemy. Her enemy is silently waiting for the time to stir up trouble. This time Hecate Cavendish is determined to destroy her enemy before it can hurt those she loves. Therefore, Hecate Cavendish must use her own powers to save her town.
Hecate has grown from the first novel. I like how Hecate has become more independent and self-determined. She is also very intelligent and was able to recognize the evil happenings that were occurring in her town. Hecate was a very strong protagonist. She was not a damsel in distress. Therefore, I found her to be more endearing than the first novel! I wanted her to have her own happy ending!
Overall, this book is about grief, love, and friendship. The message of this book is to be confident in yourself. I like all of the characters in the novel. They definitely have grown on me from the first book. I love Hecate’s friendship with Inspector Winter. I also love Hecate’s relationship with her father. I did not care for the romance and found it underwhelming. I hope that there will be another book in this series because a few aspects in the novel were left unresolved. Nevertheless, I enjoyed The Cathedral of Lost Souls more than The Haunting of Hecate Cavendish! It was very fast-paced and action-packed! I could hardly put it down! I recommend this book for fans of Emily Wilde’s Encyclopedia, The Witch of Painted Sorrows, and The Keys of the Watchmen!
(Note: I read an ARC copy of this book in courtesy of Netgalley.)
Hecate has grown from the first novel. I like how Hecate has become more independent and self-determined. She is also very intelligent and was able to recognize the evil happenings that were occurring in her town. Hecate was a very strong protagonist. She was not a damsel in distress. Therefore, I found her to be more endearing than the first novel! I wanted her to have her own happy ending!
Overall, this book is about grief, love, and friendship. The message of this book is to be confident in yourself. I like all of the characters in the novel. They definitely have grown on me from the first book. I love Hecate’s friendship with Inspector Winter. I also love Hecate’s relationship with her father. I did not care for the romance and found it underwhelming. I hope that there will be another book in this series because a few aspects in the novel were left unresolved. Nevertheless, I enjoyed The Cathedral of Lost Souls more than The Haunting of Hecate Cavendish! It was very fast-paced and action-packed! I could hardly put it down! I recommend this book for fans of Emily Wilde’s Encyclopedia, The Witch of Painted Sorrows, and The Keys of the Watchmen!
(Note: I read an ARC copy of this book in courtesy of Netgalley.)
November 15, 2025
THE CATHEDRAL OF LOST SOULS is now available and was such a fun listen. I was impressed with how Hecate became an even stronger character and the mix of history, action, and magic was excellent. Although grieving, she really comes to understand herself and has something to work towards…a quest to figure out who is creating all these spirits and how to put an end to it. I was enchanted with everything about this one, most especially the love interest that arises.
Both stories in this series have the most beautiful covers and I was relieved to listen to them back-to-back, since there are questions answers and a satisfaction in observing the full potential and development of the characters and plot. Loved it!
*I received a complimentary copy. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own and were voluntarily given.*
Both stories in this series have the most beautiful covers and I was relieved to listen to them back-to-back, since there are questions answers and a satisfaction in observing the full potential and development of the characters and plot. Loved it!
*I received a complimentary copy. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own and were voluntarily given.*
July 17, 2025
Despite the fact that this is a clean read must continue on to find out the ending with the help from a few friendly ghosts, engrossing magic and the mythical map in the cathedral library.
October 16, 2025
Another bestseller from the hands and mind of an amazing author!!!!!!!!!! I love this magical series and every book written by Paula Brackston. If you haven't read her books yet, I implore you. fellow readers, go out and check her books out!!!!!!!!
November 16, 2025
Thank you to St Martin’s Press and NetGalley for the free e-arc!
Sequel to The Haunting of Hecate Cavendish, this follows Hecate in her continued fight against the Essedenes or Embodied Spirits. Although I loved the first book, this one fell a little flat for me. I loved the first one where she learned so much about herself, her abilities, and about the war between good and evil. This one felt less like exciting as the main focus was on finishing the fight and the revelations didn’t feel quite as big.
Sequel to The Haunting of Hecate Cavendish, this follows Hecate in her continued fight against the Essedenes or Embodied Spirits. Although I loved the first book, this one fell a little flat for me. I loved the first one where she learned so much about herself, her abilities, and about the war between good and evil. This one felt less like exciting as the main focus was on finishing the fight and the revelations didn’t feel quite as big.
November 8, 2025
Enjoyed this advanced reader copy immensely! As a big fan of historical fiction, I love learning of these treasures that exist in our world today being used as the backdrop for fiction. Hoping to someday see the cathedral and its library in person, loved the vivid picture painted Throughout the book. Great character development, and I loved that the book takes us to a good conclusion, but still leaves just a whisper of a possibility of this becoming a trilogy.
November 19, 2025
The Cathedral of Lost Souls is the second book in Paula Brackston's historical science fiction Hecate Cavendish series. I loved the first book, and I was thrilled to be back in the world of Hecate and her friends in Hereford, England in 1881. The prior book ended with some death and destruction, and I just had to see how our brave heroine would overcome the fiends who were trying to steal souls. I admit the book was very slow in the middle, and I did get a little bored. However, the last part of the book made every second spent reading worthwhile.
After the fire and the turbulent events in the cathedral library, Hecate is determined to keep her beloved Mappa Mundi safe. She has turned out to be the greatest threat to the Essendenes and their evil plans and they will do everything they can to be rid of her. With the help of her archaeologist father and loyal Inspector Winter, she will take the fight to her enemies. However, the numbers of Embodied Spirits are growing with horrifying speed, and danger and violence has taken hold of Hereford. Hecate cannot trust anyone beyond her inner circle, no matter how benign they appear. Neither will she risk the lives of those she loves. The goddess Hekate has called her child and apostle Hecate to action. She must use all of her gifts and the help of her family and ghostly allies to keep their home from being lost to darkness.
If you haven't read the previous book, this synopsis may confuse you a bit. Let me explain a few things to make it easier. The Essedenes are an ancient tribe of cannibals that use people to summon spirits from the dead. These Resurgent Spirits hunt for new hosts, who would become Embodied Spirits. Trust me, once you get into the story you'll be able to keep things straight. What I found absolutely fascinating is that the Mappa Mundi is an actual relic! It is a medieval European map of the world that depicts Christian knowledge, history and knowledge. And the most famous example? The Hereford Mappa Mundi! It's a 13th century map in the Hereford Cathedral. It's knowing things like this that truly brings the story to life. Seriously, do a little research and you will be captivated! But back to the book... Hecate previously discovered that she was named after the goddess Hekate, who has granted our heroine gifts to help her battle the evil that has come to Hereford. She lost her betrothed John, a vicar, in the violence that occurred in the cathedral, and Hecate is still grieving. She knows there is still danger in Hereford, as there is an increase in the Embodied Spirits in the city. Hecate is a great character; she's terrified of what's going on, but she will do the goddess's bidding and is willing to lose her life in order to save her friends and family. I was happy to see Hecate's father Edward featured in this book as well; he's a kind and caring father, but he trusts his daughter to be able to handle herself, and understands what may happen to his beloved child. Inspector Winter is one of the very few who knows what's happening, and he also trusts Hecate with what she must do. Brother Michael and Corporal Gregory, two of the deceased souls who reside in the cathedral library, were back again, and would do all they could to assist Hecate. There was a new character, Gil Wheatley, who was repairing the cathedral windows; it was obvious he was absolutely taken with Hecate, and it seemed that Hecate was also feeling the attraction between them. (A little soon after your betrothed's death, Hecate!) A character by the. name of Tiberius comes to Hereford, and he will make your skin crawl. It was a great story, though the middle of the book rather dragged on for me, but it was worth it for the exciting last part of the book! Nothing was left hanging at the end of this book, which makes me wonder if this series is ending. However, I do hope it will continue, as I would hate to no longer visit Hecate and her family and friends again. I'm hoping the introduction of Gil will bring new stories to Hereford, as he seems to share the same ability as Hecate (I see dead people!). I'd love to see this series continue.
I received an ARC of this book courtesy of the publisher and NetGalley. I received no compensation for my review, and all thoughts and opinions expressed are entirely my own.
After the fire and the turbulent events in the cathedral library, Hecate is determined to keep her beloved Mappa Mundi safe. She has turned out to be the greatest threat to the Essendenes and their evil plans and they will do everything they can to be rid of her. With the help of her archaeologist father and loyal Inspector Winter, she will take the fight to her enemies. However, the numbers of Embodied Spirits are growing with horrifying speed, and danger and violence has taken hold of Hereford. Hecate cannot trust anyone beyond her inner circle, no matter how benign they appear. Neither will she risk the lives of those she loves. The goddess Hekate has called her child and apostle Hecate to action. She must use all of her gifts and the help of her family and ghostly allies to keep their home from being lost to darkness.
If you haven't read the previous book, this synopsis may confuse you a bit. Let me explain a few things to make it easier. The Essedenes are an ancient tribe of cannibals that use people to summon spirits from the dead. These Resurgent Spirits hunt for new hosts, who would become Embodied Spirits. Trust me, once you get into the story you'll be able to keep things straight. What I found absolutely fascinating is that the Mappa Mundi is an actual relic! It is a medieval European map of the world that depicts Christian knowledge, history and knowledge. And the most famous example? The Hereford Mappa Mundi! It's a 13th century map in the Hereford Cathedral. It's knowing things like this that truly brings the story to life. Seriously, do a little research and you will be captivated! But back to the book... Hecate previously discovered that she was named after the goddess Hekate, who has granted our heroine gifts to help her battle the evil that has come to Hereford. She lost her betrothed John, a vicar, in the violence that occurred in the cathedral, and Hecate is still grieving. She knows there is still danger in Hereford, as there is an increase in the Embodied Spirits in the city. Hecate is a great character; she's terrified of what's going on, but she will do the goddess's bidding and is willing to lose her life in order to save her friends and family. I was happy to see Hecate's father Edward featured in this book as well; he's a kind and caring father, but he trusts his daughter to be able to handle herself, and understands what may happen to his beloved child. Inspector Winter is one of the very few who knows what's happening, and he also trusts Hecate with what she must do. Brother Michael and Corporal Gregory, two of the deceased souls who reside in the cathedral library, were back again, and would do all they could to assist Hecate. There was a new character, Gil Wheatley, who was repairing the cathedral windows; it was obvious he was absolutely taken with Hecate, and it seemed that Hecate was also feeling the attraction between them. (A little soon after your betrothed's death, Hecate!) A character by the. name of Tiberius comes to Hereford, and he will make your skin crawl. It was a great story, though the middle of the book rather dragged on for me, but it was worth it for the exciting last part of the book! Nothing was left hanging at the end of this book, which makes me wonder if this series is ending. However, I do hope it will continue, as I would hate to no longer visit Hecate and her family and friends again. I'm hoping the introduction of Gil will bring new stories to Hereford, as he seems to share the same ability as Hecate (I see dead people!). I'd love to see this series continue.
I received an ARC of this book courtesy of the publisher and NetGalley. I received no compensation for my review, and all thoughts and opinions expressed are entirely my own.
November 12, 2025
I received a complimentary ARC copy of The Cathedral of Lost Souls (Hecate Cavendish #2) by Paula Brackston from Net Galley and St. Martin’s Press to read and give an honest review.
In Paula Brackston’s second entry in Hecate Cavendish series, “The Cathedral of Lost Souls”, we pick up in 1881, Hereford, as a grieving Hecate, returns to her job as a librarian’s assistant in the haunted cathedral library. Hecate is now grappling with the loss of her fiancé, John, who tragically sacrificed himself in book one and the plot picks up where the first left off. Hecate is trying to find justice and I was happy to see the return of Hecate’s ghostly friends, who added a found family vibe to the plot offering their continued support. We see Hecate and her ghostly co-workers determined to restore the library after the fire, while simultaneously working to defeat the evil souls that tried to destroy it.
This time, Hecate’s journey sees her, her father, and the police inspector on the hunt for the bodies of townspeople taken over by dark forces, known as “The Essedenes,” in an effort to stop them before they can completely take over the town. Growing into her power, Hecate exhibits increased confidence in her gifts, ultimately giving the centuries old Essedenes the ultimate challenge.
Brackston’s novel is brimming with paranormal and supernatural elements, featuring the array of magical creatures living in the antique map and delving into the conflict between good and evil with her friends by her side including the goddess herself.
I love this series and as a fan of Brackston I have come to love her characters. As always Brackston creates authentic and relatable protagonists even in a fantasy setting and Hecate is definitely one; I am a sucker for female protagonists who fight for those they love, and Hecate embodies this perfectly! I formed an instant connection with her, especially alongside her commitment to her family and of course her love of books.
While the focus is on the destruction of the evil spirits and all the magical elements, there is a charming romance blossoming that will no doubt reappear in future novels. Despite grieving her beloved John, Hecate begins to fall for an artisan tasked to repair the cathedral windows, who has more in common with her than she realizes ultimately helping her feel less alone with her abilities.
I loved this entry it was a page-turning read, captivating the reader with such an intriguing protagonist, brilliantly bookish plot and gothic atmosphere. In the series the author as is her style, has woven a rich tapestry of a plot intertwining mystery, magic, heartbreak, fantasy and romance so much so that I did not want to put it down. The protagonist, Hecate (named after the Goddess) is intelligent, sassy, courageous and empathetic in addition to the incredible multifaceted secondary characters who all seemed to have a place in the story.
Although slow in spots, this enchanting fairytalesque story is well written and definitely earned a five-star rating in my opinion. I loved Brackston’s previous novel, however, was disappointed with the way the cliffhanger was written but she more than redeemed herself in my eyes with this entry in the series. I can’t wait to read more of Hecate’s adventures. I highly recommend!
In Paula Brackston’s second entry in Hecate Cavendish series, “The Cathedral of Lost Souls”, we pick up in 1881, Hereford, as a grieving Hecate, returns to her job as a librarian’s assistant in the haunted cathedral library. Hecate is now grappling with the loss of her fiancé, John, who tragically sacrificed himself in book one and the plot picks up where the first left off. Hecate is trying to find justice and I was happy to see the return of Hecate’s ghostly friends, who added a found family vibe to the plot offering their continued support. We see Hecate and her ghostly co-workers determined to restore the library after the fire, while simultaneously working to defeat the evil souls that tried to destroy it.
This time, Hecate’s journey sees her, her father, and the police inspector on the hunt for the bodies of townspeople taken over by dark forces, known as “The Essedenes,” in an effort to stop them before they can completely take over the town. Growing into her power, Hecate exhibits increased confidence in her gifts, ultimately giving the centuries old Essedenes the ultimate challenge.
Brackston’s novel is brimming with paranormal and supernatural elements, featuring the array of magical creatures living in the antique map and delving into the conflict between good and evil with her friends by her side including the goddess herself.
I love this series and as a fan of Brackston I have come to love her characters. As always Brackston creates authentic and relatable protagonists even in a fantasy setting and Hecate is definitely one; I am a sucker for female protagonists who fight for those they love, and Hecate embodies this perfectly! I formed an instant connection with her, especially alongside her commitment to her family and of course her love of books.
While the focus is on the destruction of the evil spirits and all the magical elements, there is a charming romance blossoming that will no doubt reappear in future novels. Despite grieving her beloved John, Hecate begins to fall for an artisan tasked to repair the cathedral windows, who has more in common with her than she realizes ultimately helping her feel less alone with her abilities.
I loved this entry it was a page-turning read, captivating the reader with such an intriguing protagonist, brilliantly bookish plot and gothic atmosphere. In the series the author as is her style, has woven a rich tapestry of a plot intertwining mystery, magic, heartbreak, fantasy and romance so much so that I did not want to put it down. The protagonist, Hecate (named after the Goddess) is intelligent, sassy, courageous and empathetic in addition to the incredible multifaceted secondary characters who all seemed to have a place in the story.
Although slow in spots, this enchanting fairytalesque story is well written and definitely earned a five-star rating in my opinion. I loved Brackston’s previous novel, however, was disappointed with the way the cliffhanger was written but she more than redeemed herself in my eyes with this entry in the series. I can’t wait to read more of Hecate’s adventures. I highly recommend!
November 10, 2025
Hereford, England, 1881.
Continued from Book 1, we follow Hecate after the loss of her fiancé, who supported her with her mission to discover who is behind raising all the embodied spirits and how they got access to the book locked in the cathedral library. There are only a few people who have access, and none of those people seem like they would be so evil as to assist in this madness. Hecate is their most significant threat to not completing the task, and now she is down one of the few people who know her secret: that she can communicate with the dead, and that she is a daughter of Hecate, given her powers, like many before her, to stop this madness.
Being able to see and speak with the dead is a gift that Hecate takes seriously and adores all the ghosts in the cathedral (well, except one who is rude, but it seems out of jealousy). One person that she desperately wanted to see, but also wished she wouldn't, was her fiancé, John. The spirits who stay have unfinished business, and she wanted John to be able to move on, but she also wanted to see him, to speak with him once again. Then again, she would not be able to move on either if she saw him every day.
Now that the evil entity knows who she is and that she has the power to stop them, she must be careful and have her spirit and map friends help her on her mission to stop it once and for all. She meets a young man her own age who reminds her of John, but he also possesses the same gift as she does, except he cannot see or interact with the creatures on the map. It is nice to be able to discuss such a gift with another, as the few people who know of hers do not fully understand. She does not involve him in her mission, though, since that is what got John killed, and she doesn't want to endanger anyone else on this dangerous quest. The evil entity has already hurt and killed people she cares for, and it will do anything to get what it wants.
It was a no-brainer that I would love this audiobook. The narrator is like an instant calming sound for me, and this world, set back in time, is lovely. For people who know the typical books I read, my love for this book may come as a surprise, but I have been reading Paula's books for some time, and I have just come to love her writing. It's beautiful, descriptive, and flowery in a way I enjoy, which is ironic since I typically don't like that in other books. Paula is the exception for me.
Thank you to Netgalley and Macmillan Audio for an advanced copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. I was humbled to be chosen, as I have fangirled over Paula's books for many years and believe they have helped me take reading and reviewing books I love more seriously.
Continued from Book 1, we follow Hecate after the loss of her fiancé, who supported her with her mission to discover who is behind raising all the embodied spirits and how they got access to the book locked in the cathedral library. There are only a few people who have access, and none of those people seem like they would be so evil as to assist in this madness. Hecate is their most significant threat to not completing the task, and now she is down one of the few people who know her secret: that she can communicate with the dead, and that she is a daughter of Hecate, given her powers, like many before her, to stop this madness.
Being able to see and speak with the dead is a gift that Hecate takes seriously and adores all the ghosts in the cathedral (well, except one who is rude, but it seems out of jealousy). One person that she desperately wanted to see, but also wished she wouldn't, was her fiancé, John. The spirits who stay have unfinished business, and she wanted John to be able to move on, but she also wanted to see him, to speak with him once again. Then again, she would not be able to move on either if she saw him every day.
Now that the evil entity knows who she is and that she has the power to stop them, she must be careful and have her spirit and map friends help her on her mission to stop it once and for all. She meets a young man her own age who reminds her of John, but he also possesses the same gift as she does, except he cannot see or interact with the creatures on the map. It is nice to be able to discuss such a gift with another, as the few people who know of hers do not fully understand. She does not involve him in her mission, though, since that is what got John killed, and she doesn't want to endanger anyone else on this dangerous quest. The evil entity has already hurt and killed people she cares for, and it will do anything to get what it wants.
It was a no-brainer that I would love this audiobook. The narrator is like an instant calming sound for me, and this world, set back in time, is lovely. For people who know the typical books I read, my love for this book may come as a surprise, but I have been reading Paula's books for some time, and I have just come to love her writing. It's beautiful, descriptive, and flowery in a way I enjoy, which is ironic since I typically don't like that in other books. Paula is the exception for me.
Thank you to Netgalley and Macmillan Audio for an advanced copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. I was humbled to be chosen, as I have fangirled over Paula's books for many years and believe they have helped me take reading and reviewing books I love more seriously.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
October 29, 2025
The Cathedral of Lost Souls is a fantastic follow up to the first book, The Haunting of Hecate Cavendish.
It's the year 1881 in Hereford, England and not long after the tumultuous events that occurred at the cathedral library at the end of book one. Hecate is determined to never again come so close to losing the treasured mappa mundi. Now that the Essedenes know Hecate is their greatest threat, their plans to get rid of her are in full swing. With her father and Inspector Winter close by her side, Hecate is determined to conquer the Essedenes and end their terrible rule once and for all.
Due to the number of Embodied Spirits growing with terrifying speed, the atmosphere in Hereford is one of violence and dancer. Hecate knows she can't trust anyone besides her inner circle and she is determined not to put the lives of her loved ones at risk yet again. Hecate calls upon the goddess Hekate to aid her in her quest, and draws upon her gifts and her family of ghost allies to ensure the city is not lost to darkness for good.
This book was just as enchanting as the first one. I love Hecate's determination and strong spirit! Paula Brackston has created a true heroine in Hecate.
As with the first book, I loved learning more about the Essedenes, mappa mundi, and the chained library. Brackston creates vivid descriptions of Hereford, the Essedenes, and the map and library. It feels like you are right there with Hecate, her father, and the ghosts. Both of these books peaked my curiosity and caused me to do a bit of research of my own into these real life places, things, and people.
Brackston does a fantastic job of building suspense and mystery in this book. We meet a couple of new characters and it's hard to determine if they can be trusted or not due to Brackston's careful writing. She keeps the reader guessing until the end trying to determine if Hecate will be able to defeat the Essedenes once and for all and how she will do it.
Wonderful book!
It's the year 1881 in Hereford, England and not long after the tumultuous events that occurred at the cathedral library at the end of book one. Hecate is determined to never again come so close to losing the treasured mappa mundi. Now that the Essedenes know Hecate is their greatest threat, their plans to get rid of her are in full swing. With her father and Inspector Winter close by her side, Hecate is determined to conquer the Essedenes and end their terrible rule once and for all.
Due to the number of Embodied Spirits growing with terrifying speed, the atmosphere in Hereford is one of violence and dancer. Hecate knows she can't trust anyone besides her inner circle and she is determined not to put the lives of her loved ones at risk yet again. Hecate calls upon the goddess Hekate to aid her in her quest, and draws upon her gifts and her family of ghost allies to ensure the city is not lost to darkness for good.
This book was just as enchanting as the first one. I love Hecate's determination and strong spirit! Paula Brackston has created a true heroine in Hecate.
As with the first book, I loved learning more about the Essedenes, mappa mundi, and the chained library. Brackston creates vivid descriptions of Hereford, the Essedenes, and the map and library. It feels like you are right there with Hecate, her father, and the ghosts. Both of these books peaked my curiosity and caused me to do a bit of research of my own into these real life places, things, and people.
Brackston does a fantastic job of building suspense and mystery in this book. We meet a couple of new characters and it's hard to determine if they can be trusted or not due to Brackston's careful writing. She keeps the reader guessing until the end trying to determine if Hecate will be able to defeat the Essedenes once and for all and how she will do it.
Wonderful book!
November 6, 2025
The Cathedral of Lost Souls is the second book in Paula Brackston's Hecate Cavendish series, and picks up shortly after the heartbreaking end of the first book, with the funeral for Hecate's fiancé, John.
I would not recommend reading this book before reading the first in the series since the story is a true sequel to that book.
The story starts out rather slowly, as Hecate picks up the pieces of her life, and returns to the Cathedral to work in the library, and to recommence her task of learning about the threat of the Essedenes and how to defeat them. Even with the slow pacing in the beginning, the tension kept building to the point that there were times when I almost didn’t want to continue due to the amount of dread I was feeling. At around the halfway point, the story really picked up and before I knew it the story was at an end.
There were a few things in the novel that I felt were unnecessary to the story, the main ones being the return of John’s ghost, and the introduction of a new love interest. The new love interest felt like it was too soon after the events in the previous book, and he didn’t seem to serve any real purpose in the story. Similarly John’s ghost really seemed to have no point, other than to make Hecate feel conflicted about her feelings.
I am a bit confused about whether or not this book concludes the series since the story felt complete at the end.
The Cathedral of Lost Souls is filled with adventure, magic, danger, and a few emotional moments that brought tears to my eyes. Despite the slow start, The Cathedral of Lost Souls was a great read and I would recommend it to lovers of fantasy or historical fiction with magical elements.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
I would not recommend reading this book before reading the first in the series since the story is a true sequel to that book.
The story starts out rather slowly, as Hecate picks up the pieces of her life, and returns to the Cathedral to work in the library, and to recommence her task of learning about the threat of the Essedenes and how to defeat them. Even with the slow pacing in the beginning, the tension kept building to the point that there were times when I almost didn’t want to continue due to the amount of dread I was feeling. At around the halfway point, the story really picked up and before I knew it the story was at an end.
There were a few things in the novel that I felt were unnecessary to the story, the main ones being the return of John’s ghost, and the introduction of a new love interest. The new love interest felt like it was too soon after the events in the previous book, and he didn’t seem to serve any real purpose in the story. Similarly John’s ghost really seemed to have no point, other than to make Hecate feel conflicted about her feelings.
I am a bit confused about whether or not this book concludes the series since the story felt complete at the end.
The Cathedral of Lost Souls is filled with adventure, magic, danger, and a few emotional moments that brought tears to my eyes. Despite the slow start, The Cathedral of Lost Souls was a great read and I would recommend it to lovers of fantasy or historical fiction with magical elements.
I received an advance review copy for free, and I am leaving this review voluntarily.
November 11, 2025
***I received an ARC from Net Galley in exchange for my honest review
In book 2 of the Hecate Cavendish series, Hecate is still reeling from the loss of her fiance, and she is determined never again to come so close to losing the beloved mappa mundi. The cathedral is still being repaired after the fire, and the numbers of Embodied Spirits are growing with terrifying speed. Violence is spreading because of it, and Hecate dare not trust anyone beyond her inner circle, no matter how benevolent they might seem. She has shown herself to be the greatest threat to the Essedenes and their plans and they will stop at nothing to be rid of her. With the help of her
archeologist father, and the support of the redoubtable and loyal Inspector Winter, she must take the fight to her enemies .She must draw upon all her gifts, and the assistance of her family of ghostly allies, if the city is not to be lost to darkness forever.
I have enjoyed both books in this series equally. If you haven't read the first book, The Haunting of Hecate Cavendish, I would suggest you read that one first, so that you will fully enjoy this book, and won't be lost. I love Hecate - she is smart and brave. I enjoy her use of the mappa mundi, and how she can bring things like Griffins out of the map and into the actual library. I also love her interactions with the ghosts that reside in the library. It was so sad when her fiance was still up there playing music for her ears only. The battle against the Embodied Spirits was exciting, and had me on the edge of my seat. I can't wait to see what awaits Hecate next!
In book 2 of the Hecate Cavendish series, Hecate is still reeling from the loss of her fiance, and she is determined never again to come so close to losing the beloved mappa mundi. The cathedral is still being repaired after the fire, and the numbers of Embodied Spirits are growing with terrifying speed. Violence is spreading because of it, and Hecate dare not trust anyone beyond her inner circle, no matter how benevolent they might seem. She has shown herself to be the greatest threat to the Essedenes and their plans and they will stop at nothing to be rid of her. With the help of her
archeologist father, and the support of the redoubtable and loyal Inspector Winter, she must take the fight to her enemies .She must draw upon all her gifts, and the assistance of her family of ghostly allies, if the city is not to be lost to darkness forever.
I have enjoyed both books in this series equally. If you haven't read the first book, The Haunting of Hecate Cavendish, I would suggest you read that one first, so that you will fully enjoy this book, and won't be lost. I love Hecate - she is smart and brave. I enjoy her use of the mappa mundi, and how she can bring things like Griffins out of the map and into the actual library. I also love her interactions with the ghosts that reside in the library. It was so sad when her fiance was still up there playing music for her ears only. The battle against the Embodied Spirits was exciting, and had me on the edge of my seat. I can't wait to see what awaits Hecate next!
November 24, 2025
Let me start by saying that the cover art for this series is absolutely stunning. Now, on to the brilliance that is the final book in the Hecate Cavendish duology.
This installment is atmospheric, beautiful, and completely binge-worthy. Hecate’s growth was so satisfying to witness; her journey toward understanding who she is and embracing her power felt like an actual payoff. The introduction of the new male lead and love interest, along with the reveal of his abilities, was wonderfully done. I’ll admit I was a little worried near the end of book one and the beginning of book two that Hecate would spend the entire story in mourning, but the shift in direction was handled with care. The appearance of a new guardian spirit wasn’t unexpected if you’ve read book one; however, the manner of their departure and just how gentle and docile they were took me by surprise.
There were several moments when I felt sure I had predicted the outcome, only for the story to shift in a way that made me pause, rethink, and eagerly keep reading. I love when a book does that!
I was absolutely not ready to leave this world. Paula Brackston did a phenomenal job crafting these characters and building a world that feels so rich and alive. I especially loved the incorporation of real historical elements and how clear it was that getting those details right mattered deeply to the author.
Thank you to NetGalley, St. Martin’s Press, and Paula Brackston for the ARC of this final duology installment, and for allowing me to share my honest review of my reading experience.
This installment is atmospheric, beautiful, and completely binge-worthy. Hecate’s growth was so satisfying to witness; her journey toward understanding who she is and embracing her power felt like an actual payoff. The introduction of the new male lead and love interest, along with the reveal of his abilities, was wonderfully done. I’ll admit I was a little worried near the end of book one and the beginning of book two that Hecate would spend the entire story in mourning, but the shift in direction was handled with care. The appearance of a new guardian spirit wasn’t unexpected if you’ve read book one; however, the manner of their departure and just how gentle and docile they were took me by surprise.
There were several moments when I felt sure I had predicted the outcome, only for the story to shift in a way that made me pause, rethink, and eagerly keep reading. I love when a book does that!
I was absolutely not ready to leave this world. Paula Brackston did a phenomenal job crafting these characters and building a world that feels so rich and alive. I especially loved the incorporation of real historical elements and how clear it was that getting those details right mattered deeply to the author.
Thank you to NetGalley, St. Martin’s Press, and Paula Brackston for the ARC of this final duology installment, and for allowing me to share my honest review of my reading experience.
November 14, 2025
3,5/5
A solid and satisfying conclusion to a lovely series!
I had loved the first volume. The heroine and her ghostly friends were endearing. The cathedral's library was a perfect setting. It was an enchanting blend of cozy and supernatural, all in a historical setting.
Here, the characters are established, so the book focused mostly on the fight against the Essedenes. Hecate grew even more as a heroine, strengthening her connection with her goddess and becoming a courageous leader. There were many action scenes at the end. The ending was beautiful and satisfying.
The only thing I didn't like is that there were no other active/important female character apart from Hecate. All the people who help her are men (save for the goddess) and her mother is a swallow stereotype. Thankfully, our protagonist isn't dependent on them and drives the plot forward.
I totally recommend this series if you want something cozy, enchanting, but with real stakes! It deserves more love.
A solid and satisfying conclusion to a lovely series!
I had loved the first volume. The heroine and her ghostly friends were endearing. The cathedral's library was a perfect setting. It was an enchanting blend of cozy and supernatural, all in a historical setting.
Here, the characters are established, so the book focused mostly on the fight against the Essedenes. Hecate grew even more as a heroine, strengthening her connection with her goddess and becoming a courageous leader. There were many action scenes at the end. The ending was beautiful and satisfying.
The only thing I didn't like is that there were no other active/important female character apart from Hecate. All the people who help her are men (save for the goddess) and her mother is a swallow stereotype. Thankfully, our protagonist isn't dependent on them and drives the plot forward.
I totally recommend this series if you want something cozy, enchanting, but with real stakes! It deserves more love.
October 12, 2025
Cathedral of Lost Souls is a beautifully written novel that grips the reader from the opening chapter and doesn’t let go. The author masterfully blends suspense, emotion, and a touch of the supernatural into a story that feels both thrilling and deeply human. Every page carries an undercurrent of mystery and heart that keeps you eagerly turning to the next.
The true brilliance of this book lies in its remarkable characters. Each soul—living or departed—is portrayed with warmth, compassion, and emotional depth. Their intertwined stories evoke genuine feeling, and the relationships that stretch across time and mortality are handled with exquisite sensitivity. You’ll find yourself caring deeply for every one of them.
The pacing is seamless, with just the right balance between heart-pounding suspense and quiet, reflective moments. Each twist feels earned, each revelation satisfying. It’s the kind of novel you want to savor slowly, yet can’t resist reading late into the night.
Ultimately, Cathedral of Lost Souls is a moving testament to the endurance of love and the redemptive power of the human spirit. It’s both haunting and hopeful—a rare combination that lingers long after the final page. A truly unforgettable read that shines with five-star brilliance.
The true brilliance of this book lies in its remarkable characters. Each soul—living or departed—is portrayed with warmth, compassion, and emotional depth. Their intertwined stories evoke genuine feeling, and the relationships that stretch across time and mortality are handled with exquisite sensitivity. You’ll find yourself caring deeply for every one of them.
The pacing is seamless, with just the right balance between heart-pounding suspense and quiet, reflective moments. Each twist feels earned, each revelation satisfying. It’s the kind of novel you want to savor slowly, yet can’t resist reading late into the night.
Ultimately, Cathedral of Lost Souls is a moving testament to the endurance of love and the redemptive power of the human spirit. It’s both haunting and hopeful—a rare combination that lingers long after the final page. A truly unforgettable read that shines with five-star brilliance.
November 15, 2025
A sincere thank you to @paulabrackston and @stmartinspress for the #gifted book, and to @macmillan.audio #MacAudio2025 for the equally #gifted audiobook.
This is the second installment in the Hecate Cavendish series, and it was nothing short of extraordinary.
Hecate continues to impress as a strong and formidable woman, ready to confront the dark spirits looming over her community. I am captivated by her dynamic relationship with her archaeologist father and her remarkable ability to share her visions. It's inspiring to see how Inspector Winters places his trust in her during a time when women's rights and roles were so limited. Hecate's intelligence and independence shine through, significantly supported by the men in her life.
While mourning her beloved John, Hecate unexpectedly finds herself drawn to a local artist, a relationship that is sure to provoke her mother. This unexpected romance added a delightful twist to the story.
The narrator deserves accolades for her exceptional portrayal of the characters. Her accent drew me into Hecate's world, and her ability to express a range of emotions brought the intensity of Hecate’s struggles to life.
For those who cherish mystical forces entwined with historical fiction, this book is an unmissable gem!
This is the second installment in the Hecate Cavendish series, and it was nothing short of extraordinary.
Hecate continues to impress as a strong and formidable woman, ready to confront the dark spirits looming over her community. I am captivated by her dynamic relationship with her archaeologist father and her remarkable ability to share her visions. It's inspiring to see how Inspector Winters places his trust in her during a time when women's rights and roles were so limited. Hecate's intelligence and independence shine through, significantly supported by the men in her life.
While mourning her beloved John, Hecate unexpectedly finds herself drawn to a local artist, a relationship that is sure to provoke her mother. This unexpected romance added a delightful twist to the story.
The narrator deserves accolades for her exceptional portrayal of the characters. Her accent drew me into Hecate's world, and her ability to express a range of emotions brought the intensity of Hecate’s struggles to life.
For those who cherish mystical forces entwined with historical fiction, this book is an unmissable gem!
November 30, 2025
“I will play for you often so that you know you are not alone.”
I enjoyed this follow up to The Haunting of Hecate Cavendish. Hecate has learned from her past challenges and is determined to do what she can to thwart the Essedenes. She is also very much at a crossroads in her personal life—cling to the past or embrace a possible future. I really like her support system that’s a hodgepodge of her living family, her ghostly friends, and the creatures of the mappa mundi. I appreciate how the story as a whole embraces actual historical pieces and builds an entire fictional world and backstory around those elements.
This series takes an interesting perspective. It’s a historical mystery of sorts with fantastical elements like ghosts and incantations. It also takes place in Hereford Cathedral (an actual historical place in the UK) and incorporates real-life elements like its chained library and mappa mundi. Respect is paid to both the Christian God and other deities like Hecate. Most books I’ve read take an “either-or” approach to magic and religion, so I found it intriguing to read a story that blends the two together.
NOTE: This is book 2 in the Hecate Cavendish series. It is necessary to read the series in order. Book 1 is The Haunting of Hecate Cavendish.
I enjoyed this follow up to The Haunting of Hecate Cavendish. Hecate has learned from her past challenges and is determined to do what she can to thwart the Essedenes. She is also very much at a crossroads in her personal life—cling to the past or embrace a possible future. I really like her support system that’s a hodgepodge of her living family, her ghostly friends, and the creatures of the mappa mundi. I appreciate how the story as a whole embraces actual historical pieces and builds an entire fictional world and backstory around those elements.
This series takes an interesting perspective. It’s a historical mystery of sorts with fantastical elements like ghosts and incantations. It also takes place in Hereford Cathedral (an actual historical place in the UK) and incorporates real-life elements like its chained library and mappa mundi. Respect is paid to both the Christian God and other deities like Hecate. Most books I’ve read take an “either-or” approach to magic and religion, so I found it intriguing to read a story that blends the two together.
NOTE: This is book 2 in the Hecate Cavendish series. It is necessary to read the series in order. Book 1 is The Haunting of Hecate Cavendish.
July 16, 2025
📚 Book Review: The Cathedral of Lost Souls by Paula Brackston
Thank you to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press for the chance to read this hauntingly atmospheric ARC! 🖤
I dove into The Cathedral of Lost Souls without realizing it was a sequel—my mistake, not the author’s. That said, I was pleasantly surprised by how well the narrative stood on its own. Even without prior knowledge from book one, I never felt lost in the story. For that reason alone, this deserves a full ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐—it's rare that a sequel welcomes new readers so seamlessly!
I was fully swept into the storyline, though I did find it a bit quick how the main character connected romantically with someone new. 🤷 Still, it didn’t pull me out of the immersive pace, and the overall reading experience was quick, engaging, and deeply enjoyable.
Highly recommend for fans of gothic mysteries with emotional depth and lyrical writing. Brackston knows how to weave soul and suspense with elegance! 🕯️✨
ARCReview #TheCathedralOfLostSouls #PaulaBrackston #NetGalleyReads #StMartinsPress #GothicFiction #BookRecommendation #Bookstagram #FiveStarRead #MoodyReads #DarkAndLovely
Thank you to NetGalley and St. Martin's Press for the chance to read this hauntingly atmospheric ARC! 🖤
I dove into The Cathedral of Lost Souls without realizing it was a sequel—my mistake, not the author’s. That said, I was pleasantly surprised by how well the narrative stood on its own. Even without prior knowledge from book one, I never felt lost in the story. For that reason alone, this deserves a full ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐—it's rare that a sequel welcomes new readers so seamlessly!
I was fully swept into the storyline, though I did find it a bit quick how the main character connected romantically with someone new. 🤷 Still, it didn’t pull me out of the immersive pace, and the overall reading experience was quick, engaging, and deeply enjoyable.
Highly recommend for fans of gothic mysteries with emotional depth and lyrical writing. Brackston knows how to weave soul and suspense with elegance! 🕯️✨
ARCReview #TheCathedralOfLostSouls #PaulaBrackston #NetGalleyReads #StMartinsPress #GothicFiction #BookRecommendation #Bookstagram #FiveStarRead #MoodyReads #DarkAndLovely
September 6, 2025
The Cathedral of Lost Souls is one of those rare books that doesn’t just tell a story, it creates an atmosphere you can almost breathe in. From the very first chapter, it wraps you in shadow, silence, and the heavy weight of history. It’s gothic, yes, but not in a way that feels overdone; instead, it’s haunting in a quiet, deliberate way that lingers with you even after you’ve put it down.
The prose is beautiful without being dense, every sentence feels carefully chosen, carrying both elegance and an undercurrent of unease. The world feels layered and alive, as though the cathedral itself is as much a character as anyone who walks its halls. And while the book touches on grief, faith, and the search for meaning, it never feels heavy-handed. Instead, those themes rise naturally, making the story feel intimate and universal all at once.
This isn’t a book you rush through. It’s the kind you sink into, letting the mood and mystery wash over you. By the time I turned the final page, I felt both unsettled and deeply satisfied—a perfect blend for readers who love stories that echo long after they’re finished.
A stunning, unforgettable read.
The prose is beautiful without being dense, every sentence feels carefully chosen, carrying both elegance and an undercurrent of unease. The world feels layered and alive, as though the cathedral itself is as much a character as anyone who walks its halls. And while the book touches on grief, faith, and the search for meaning, it never feels heavy-handed. Instead, those themes rise naturally, making the story feel intimate and universal all at once.
This isn’t a book you rush through. It’s the kind you sink into, letting the mood and mystery wash over you. By the time I turned the final page, I felt both unsettled and deeply satisfied—a perfect blend for readers who love stories that echo long after they’re finished.
A stunning, unforgettable read.
November 12, 2025
This is the perfect continuation of this series.
Everything from the plot, tone of voice, and tropes were the same as the last book, but it was a new story. The fast paced, action packed, paranormal thriller with a hesitant romance in a regency period that wasn’t focused on the ton or the desire to find a husband was both refreshing and entertaining. But the extremely dry tones and what could be argued as historical accuracy for the way that people were viewed and judged kept me from truly enjoying this story, but those same elements would definitely appeal to specific readers, so to each their own.
🎙️: Single narration, but it’s really well done and the narrator is fun to listen to with her accent and perfectly timed inflections.
❌🌶️: This is a surprisingly clean story for a cozy romance, theirs death and mystery but no foul language or steamy scenes. (Murder is all good and fun but let’s not get crazy with consentual relationships and vocabulary, come on somethings are really dangerous y’al.)
Paranormal Thriller
Magic & Witches
Who Done It Mystery
Ancient Evils
Librarian Amatuer Slueth
Regency Period
Everything from the plot, tone of voice, and tropes were the same as the last book, but it was a new story. The fast paced, action packed, paranormal thriller with a hesitant romance in a regency period that wasn’t focused on the ton or the desire to find a husband was both refreshing and entertaining. But the extremely dry tones and what could be argued as historical accuracy for the way that people were viewed and judged kept me from truly enjoying this story, but those same elements would definitely appeal to specific readers, so to each their own.
🎙️: Single narration, but it’s really well done and the narrator is fun to listen to with her accent and perfectly timed inflections.
❌🌶️: This is a surprisingly clean story for a cozy romance, theirs death and mystery but no foul language or steamy scenes. (Murder is all good and fun but let’s not get crazy with consentual relationships and vocabulary, come on somethings are really dangerous y’al.)
Paranormal Thriller
Magic & Witches
Who Done It Mystery
Ancient Evils
Librarian Amatuer Slueth
Regency Period
November 16, 2025
Paula Brackston is the only author that I have actually completed a series. I have read all of her books in The Found Things series. I am now working on her new Hecate Cavendish series. I read her first book in the series, The Haunting of Hecate Cavendish and now this book which is second in the series.
The author gives you a little bit of back story, so you can read this as a standalone novel, however I would definitely encourage you to read the first book first. Because even with the little bit of backstory, she starts this novel on the ground running. There is no downtime, you are sucked into the story from the very beginning.
In this story, we are back again with Hecate in 1881. The Embodied Spirits are growing and Hecate must use her powers and the powers from her namesake goddess to battle them. With the help of her father, some friendly spirits, and a local constable, she is ready to go to battle.
I just love these stories. I love the way the author writes her fantasy, it’s cozy yet exciting. It’s fast paced, with humor, and plenty of twists and turns. Highly recommend. I received an ARC of the book.
The author gives you a little bit of back story, so you can read this as a standalone novel, however I would definitely encourage you to read the first book first. Because even with the little bit of backstory, she starts this novel on the ground running. There is no downtime, you are sucked into the story from the very beginning.
In this story, we are back again with Hecate in 1881. The Embodied Spirits are growing and Hecate must use her powers and the powers from her namesake goddess to battle them. With the help of her father, some friendly spirits, and a local constable, she is ready to go to battle.
I just love these stories. I love the way the author writes her fantasy, it’s cozy yet exciting. It’s fast paced, with humor, and plenty of twists and turns. Highly recommend. I received an ARC of the book.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 95 reviews