Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book
Rate this book
Artorius and his team must race against time to thwart a looming clash between two ancient powers, navigating a treacherous landscape where their actions could rewrite history and spark a catastrophic conflict.

In a world where history can be rewritten at will, the threads of destiny intertwine in ways no one could have foreseen.

Years after their groundbreaking journey into the past, Artorius and his team stumble upon a devastating revelation: the Chinese government has dispatched five time-travelers and a trove of advanced technology back to 165 CE, during the waning days of the Han dynasty. While believed they were guiding Rome toward a new era of modernization and unity, the emergence of Chinese influence threatens to unravel everything they have fought for.

As whispers of innovation ripple through the ancient world, Artorius and his companions realize they are in a race against time—not just to protect their vision for a united future, but to prevent a catastrophic clash that could bring about nuclear war centuries sooner than they ever imagined.

With their own presence now at risk of exposure, they must navigate the treacherous waters of politics, technology, and culture in a world caught between two colossal powers. As the balance of history teeters on a knife's edge, loyalties will be tested, alliances forged, and the very fabric of fate will hang in the balance.

368 pages, Hardcover

First published July 1, 2025

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

S.M. Stirling

184 books1,679 followers
Stephen Michael Stirling is a French-born Canadian-American science fiction and fantasy author. Stirling is probably best known for his Draka series of alternate history novels and the more recent time travel/alternate history Nantucket series and Emberverse series.

MINI AUTO-BIOGRAPHY:
(personal website: source)

I’m a writer by trade, born in France but Canadian by origin and American by naturalization, living in New Mexico at present. My hobbies are mostly related to the craft. I love history, anthropology and archaeology, and am interested in the sciences. The martial arts are my main physical hobby.

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
393 (60%)
4 stars
177 (27%)
3 stars
64 (9%)
2 stars
13 (1%)
1 star
4 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 52 reviews
44 reviews
August 24, 2025
If you’re waiting for plot not just descriptions of technology you’ll be left wanting
Profile Image for Jonathan Koan.
992 reviews1,027 followers
October 5, 2026
S. M. Stirling has terrific ideas. That cannot be denied. But man,I just wish he would prioritize his pacing, characters, and story over his worldbuilding, rehashing, and his historical bona fides.

This book's premise is that our intrepid time-travelers are not alone. They were sent back to 165 AD and have been introducing new technology to the Roman Empire. But another group of time travelers has also returned back to 165 AD to China to introduce a Communist china 1800 years before it would actually arise. Our heroes must advance the Roman Empire in technology and conquered land even faster than anticipated in order to combat the growing Chinese threat.

This should be a slam dunk of an idea.

Instead, that story is only around 100-150 pages of the actual book. The rest of the book is characters reflecting on the technological changes, reflecting on the events of the previous books, the implications of hte changes in technology, or explaining the way society worked back in the second century. It has all the hallmarks of an author who gets too bogged down in their fantasy worldbuilding instead of the main focus, which is to tell a good story.

The characters are fine...but they don't really get any development. Instead, it's as I said earlier...its all about the 'worldbuilding'.

Unless you're super into the technology and historical implications of the book, I can't recommend it. If Stirling had handed the outline and ideas of the series to another author (say a Jason Cordova, Shami Stovall, or Kevin Anderson, someone who could focus on the story), then I think it would be significantly better. As is, just not that great.

That being said...darn it if there isn't an interesting hook for book 3. I might just check it out to see if Stirling lives up to the promise of the series.

But for now, this book is incredibly mixed. I'll give The Winds of Fate a 5 out of 10.
41 reviews
November 10, 2025
I have read a ton of Stirling, all the Emberverse, the Nantucket stuff, and even a few more sci-fi ones. This was by far the worst. It was just a constant digression into too much information about languages, geography, peoples, technology, etc. Every single comment or observation by a character leads to a long digression from a paragraph to a page long and stops any momentum or plot action. In fact, literally nothing happens plot wise until the last 20% of the book or so. It got hard to finish. I had high hopes for this series, and I’ll read the next one, but if the editor doesn’t step in and work hard to rein in Stirling’s desire to tell us everything thing he ever researched to write the book, I won’t finish it. Please for the sake of a great concept, get a hold on the digressions. Please!
Profile Image for Mieczyslaw Kasprzyk.
910 reviews158 followers
September 29, 2025
I have to admit that I didn't enjoy this as much as its predecessor but, don't get me wrong, it's still an entertaining and gripping read on the whole.
the problem with our Mr Stirling is that he loves to spend ages describing the innovative technology and processes used by our time travelling adventurers (he does this in his other books, especially in "The Change" series). Thankfully there is a very interesting story accompanying the technological bits. It turns out (and this isn't a spoiler) that the nasty Chinese have also sent a team back in time and now it looks like our brave Romano-Americans have to save the world from the evil asiatics whose intentions are, duh!, evil.
Send in the cavalry.
Thank God for the entertaining bits.
63 reviews
July 4, 2025
Roman Industialization

The time-displaced Americans earn their place in Rome with innovations in medicine, agriculture, and weapons. Which is all very fine, until they discover China sent a team to unify China and conquer the world. Well done. And readers who like the knowledge from the future of the 1632 series will enjoy it here.
Profile Image for Dan Edwards.
30 reviews
July 16, 2026
This book was not good. 90% of the plot is in the last 40ish pages. The rest was just people thumping each other on the back and reading off of third century earnings calls.
Profile Image for Larry.
273 reviews4 followers
August 28, 2025
This has the same fascinating presentation of the history of technology--and especially military technology--as the first book of the series, but it's not as much fun. It contains extensive descriptions of "what has gone before" and extensive discourse on not only how the technology introduced in this book made the Romans more prosperous, and more deadly in battle, but recapitulations of the equivalent discourse about innovations *new things* introduced in the first book. Some of this information is repeated--almost word-for-word--in multiple places in this volume.

One major difference between this book and the first volume, is that there is seldom a sense that the characters, or the military enterprises they are engaged in, are seriously threatened. The military tech is too overwhelmingly powerful. There were several fights in the first book where the protagonists just barely squeaked out a victory, or escaped with their lives. Not so here.

Moreover, "Winds of Fate" suffers from a shallow plot arc common in middle books. There is no dramatic conflict. The overall adversary has been identified, but they have not engaged each other in a serious way.

I liked it, but it was focused on world-building and summary of the economic and societal impacts of technology, and not so much by character-driven plot.
Profile Image for Sean.
118 reviews3 followers
March 25, 2025
Who doesn't love a good counterfactual/alternate history/time travel story? I enjoy the world building and technology advancements and how the what ifs branch out in all sorts of ways.
I was a little concerned the author was introducing new protagonists and how that would detract from the story I was enjoying, but I found that overall it embellished the story so I'm okay with it!
I sure hope he can keep up the pace, doing a new book about once a year.
Profile Image for Patrick Gavin.
7 reviews3 followers
October 20, 2026
My first encounters with SM Stirling were as a teen on Usenet groups related to alternate history. He’s one of the grandfathers of the genre. I totally hear his critics from multiple camps, but I for one don’t mind the embedded erudition inherent in his writing style. As much as he frames himself as a modern, relatively progressive descendant of Burroughs, among others, I also detect a didactic bias that draws from the Stratemeyer Syndicate tradition I grew up with.

All of that said, I’m uneasy about the early references to expeditions to the Americas and Australia. The series has a strong public-health ethic, and the Pax Romana may avert the nuclear war in the original timeline, but even brief contact with the Western Hemisphere could expose Indigenous communities to Old World infections—not just smallpox, but influenza, measles, and others.

Is the implicit assumption that these diseases would be less dangerous 1,200 years earlier, or that the Romans have a broader quarantine and disease-control plan in mind? Stopping smallpox wouldn’t by itself prevent epidemics from other pathogens. I’m curious how the series plans to handle that tension, even if contact is limited rather than sustained.

There’s plenty of other elements of this series one could object to, including a less than full throated push for the eradication of slavery, though the author takes pains to, I think accurately, frame the evil practice of old world slavery, at least in the Mediterranean world, as a pernicious but colorblind institution from which manumission across generations was commonplace versus the doctrine of inherent servitude based on perceived characteristics that characterized slavery post 1492. The Americans are invariably portrayed as good guys, even if the supporting characters are flawed. One of the supporting American characters enthusiastically enters into a plural relationship with two enslaved women whom he frees after they become pregnant with his children. Yes, that’s all well and good. And these women stick around with him afterwards, with another character noting, seemingly approvingly, that their children are adopted/ancknowledged and are hence Roman citizens. But the ick factor is still there. Sure, the author goes to pains to make clear that relations with these women were more reciprocal than what Roman men of the time may have felt was typical in terms of relations between the sexes. And there is plenty of clear critique of how Roman men and men of that period in general understood female sexuality. But at the end of the day this character was in a position of unquestionable power over someone else’s human chattel at the inception of these relationships, so that’s not great. It is worth noting, however, that there is at least some disapproval of his behavior from his fellow Americans and subsequent treatments of the character specifically call out his relative lack of empathy when compared to his peers. But Stirling’s world-building frequently involves characters who have some sympathetic traits despite vile ideologies and worldviews.
Profile Image for Sky.
399 reviews
February 3, 2026
This book was much like the first one, except about 1/3 of the text was wasted explaining things that had already been explained. I don't need to be told that when Romans say "the City" they mean Rome even once, much less twice. I don't need to read each individual character reflecting on how great it was to have better harvest equipment, or have Colonia Ferrementa translated three times, or the "Cleopatra was actually Greek" spiel twice, or several pages repeating why rifles are better than bows (one page of Character A thinking about how much better rifles are than bows; one page of Character A explaining to Character B why rifles are better than bows; one page of Character B repeating back to Character A that rifles are indeed better than bows). I am the kind of nerd who likes thinking about historical customs and technologies, I accept and enjoy some explanations and descriptions of how the author thinks these things worked, but please, for the love of god, reread your book and cut out the repetitions! Or hire an editor to do it!

That out of the way, the story is fine. The characters don't really get characterized except that they have lengthy internal monologues explaining how various things work. Their opinions are all the same. I was a little annoyed with the sudden appearance of Evil Chinese Communist time travelers, but I accept that that's what this genre generally does. I think a story about outsiders trying to change the fucked-up internal politics of Rome would've been more interesting than this time traveler arms race situation. Stirling's solution to those problems is "The emperor should just choose a better successor". Marcus Aurelius just... realizes that his eldest son is bad and spends some more time teaching his younger son, who I guess will be good instead.

Artorius's reaction to learning about the existence of other time travelers is pretty hilarious. He learns they exist, somehow magically divines that they're Evil Chinese Communists planing to take over the world, then decides to invade and conquer the neighbors, just in case the communists send guns to them, all while bemoaning the necessity of war that the communists have forced upon him. He has a whole production line of rifles ready spin up to thousands of units a month already waiting but now it's the communists' fault and if it weren't for them he'd be building plows or whatever. The whole thing reads like a satirical indictment of US Cold War foreign policy. But it's hard to tell if the author realizes that.

Anyways, 3/5, can't wait for the next book.
Profile Image for Ahw.
233 reviews3 followers
November 20, 2025
*I* really liked the book. But I don't think it's for everyone.
There is a lot of information dump in here about how the time travelers knowledge has improved the Roman Empire. That's the fun stuff! .....
But as a story? It isn't that good. It needs more story. I would have liked to have seen more of what the Chinese contingent did..... I would like to have seen more about the lives of the main characters....
Actually I'd like fewer main characters. There are 5 of them and they are getting bland.

One style from the author is LONG digressions. In the middle of a thought or a statement from one of the characters there can be PARAGRAPHS of digression description. In this book it seemed excessive.
I had trouble keeping track of who was speaking/thinking when they resume their sentence.
This style isn't unusual for the author and normally isn't distracting and can be good.... but it was excessive here.

Again.... I love this style of book so I will definitely read the next one. But I'm not certain if a normal person would like it.
Profile Image for Nancy.
115 reviews3 followers
December 10, 2025
SM Stirling has delivered his second book about American time travelers in Ancient Rome, and I have to scuttle back to my Latin bookshelf and review nominative declensions.

The American graduate students have been in Rome for awhile trying to change the course of history, a Roman Empire that doesn’t disintegrate and instead solidifies the world order for enlightened white people everywhere. But you can’t sell that book so Steve has to use Americans, who can be all the races and genders.

Enter China. The Han Chinese, in particular, not the Huns and proto-Mongols or whoever was screwing up world domination for the Roman Empire. These are the present-day Han, who develop technology by stealing it, and they have their own time machine. And they brought along political officers to complicate things.

There are so many players, Steve is gonna need another chessboard.

VERDICT: Waiting for the invention of electric guitars and the British Invasion.

https://criticusbookreviews.wordpress...
Profile Image for Frank.
4 reviews
July 12, 2025
Arthur Vandenberg and his team of graduate students barely escaped the end of the world by slipping back in time to 165 CE. Their knowledge of Roman history combined with modern technology will help make Rome strong enough to possibly prevent the end of the world 2,000 years later. That was To Turn The Tide, which I HIGHLY recommend.

Now, in The Winds of Fate, Artorius and company are accelerating the progress of Rome, aided and supported by Marcus Aurelius, the last of the "Good Emperors." But it turns out they weren't alone...

This might even be better than the first book, but it is certainly equal. I think it's some of the best that S.M. Stirling has ever written, and that is saying a lot!

(Oh, ignore the stupid cover. The publisher thinks turning Artorius into a dumb, musclebound cartoon of a soldier will sell more copies. At least Steve was able to make the artist change the tatoo from Marines to Rangers, because that's what Artorius was).
Profile Image for simple_journey.
62 reviews8 followers
September 10, 2025
The second book in S. M. Stirling's time travel/alternate history series. Like the first book, this summary also tells you everything you need to know about this book.

Can the future fate of the world be changed to stop humanity from destroying everything in a fiery nuclear holocaust?

Five reluctant American time travelers transported to ancient Rome have got a chance to try. At least, they do until they discover the hated Chinese government, responsible for the first nuclear launches, has also sent a team back to Imperial China. The arms race begins again. Will the world destroy itself once more?

Unfortunately, we'll have to wait for the rest of the series to release to read as the story unfolds.

Another light read if you are looking simply for entertainment.
Profile Image for Nicole.
2,183 reviews7 followers
September 8, 2025
I hate to give one of my favorite authors a two star review. But this book really contrasts badly with the works he's written before. It's clear he's done a ton of research on the period in question, and it shows, but that's all. The information isn't integrated with the story - it's as if it's a nonfiction book about the Roman Empire with a bit of story thrown in. Not like The Emberverse books or the Nantucket books. I know he can do better.
Profile Image for Quinton.
251 reviews8 followers
October 27, 2025
Wonderful. I was apprehensive about the direction, knowing Sterling’s tendency towards exaggerated evil. But it was such a pleasant surprise. There were some seeming editing failures (mostly some phrases and descriptions that were repeated far too much), but in general the narrative direction was a hit for me. I am just sad knowing I will have to wait for the next book. If this is the direction of the series, then I hope it will be as long as the Emberverse :)
Profile Image for jammaster_mom.
1,073 reviews8 followers
November 7, 2025
I really like the concept of this series and the characters. I am currently studying Latin myself and the Latin words as well as insight into the Roman mind is fascinating to me!
This book is heavier on the technology and lighter on story/characters. This would usually turn me off but getting to see the Chinese group in the mix kept me wondering and reading. I am excited to see where the next book in the series goes from here!
18 reviews
July 17, 2025
interesting sequel to the first novel

The theme is highly interesting, and the author’s descriptions quite detailed and accurate. In fact, my only criticism is that his descriptions of technology are too lengthy, and become quite tedious after a while. Otherwise, it’ll hold your attention.
82 reviews
August 2, 2025
Excellent Sequel

Hard SF, time travel, complex characters, plausible plot.
History lessons galore, "The Roman Empire was an army with a government attached".
I enjoyed it more because I re-read the first book in the series.
And, gosh, I hope that there are more coming.
Stirling never disappoints.
1 review
August 24, 2025
This book was a considerable waste of time. Constantly repeating (sometime verbatim) information and backstory from previous book. Only about 3 chapters that actually advance the narrative.

I'd wait and read the next book in the series. I am sure the author will repeat everything that is in this book.
149 reviews3 followers
August 26, 2025
Hate Lives On

Very much enjoyed the first two books in this series. Great characters and a great story line. Find the thought of making a world safe a very good idea. Looking forward to reading the next great book in this series. Nice to have only one government and believe a Roman would be acceptable.
Profile Image for Nicole Luiken.
Author 20 books170 followers
February 23, 2026
Well researched with fascinating historical detail, but because this covered quite a few years and so it often felt that we were getting recaps of the previous six months while the characters weren't actually doing much in that scene. I wish we'd spent more time with our new Chinese character and less time with Fronto.
Profile Image for Clyde.
1,015 reviews57 followers
October 4, 2026
Good continuation of Stirling's latest 'moderns sent back in time' series. In this one Artorius and his former students redouble their efforts to jumpstart technology in ancient Rome, spurred on by learning that a group of Chinese time travelers is doing the same in the Han dynasty. Is conflict inevitable?
This book suffers middle book syndrome somewhat. The story continues to develop with conspiracy, danger and some battles; but, overall there is less action and adventure than the first in the series. And, it tends to get rather deep into the weeds about how uptime technology could be introduced and used starting on the Roman base. Which I find quite interesting, but then I am a nerd.
Anyway, good read. Looking forward to the next book.

Update:
This book has won the 2026 Dragon award for Best Alternate History Novel! 🙂
Profile Image for Michael Reese.
110 reviews
July 11, 2025
Second Book, good as th3 first

Another great series by S.M. Sterling. Welcome to Ancient Rome. But not our Rome. Not after five Americans arrive by time machine. Enjoy. 1st book is good too, if you haven't read it.
Profile Image for shawn murphy.
492 reviews9 followers
July 20, 2025
Book 2 The Winds of Fate by S.M. Stirling in his Make the Darkness Light trilogy.
4 grad students and and their Professor time travel to escape a Nuclear Fusion war. They hope to change things in the past to avoid this destruction in the future.
953 reviews3 followers
August 29, 2025
This series continues to work nicely. Conflicts arise that will complicate transitioning Rome to the dominant world power. The change process is logical and well-founded, given our limited knowledge of this period.
243 reviews1 follower
September 9, 2025
Excellent Story

Delightful story well written and developed. The characters grow, the progression is logical and it is a fun ride!!
I enjoyed thoroughly and highly recommend this series.
4 reviews2 followers
November 6, 2025
Great book. Please finish the series.

I love it. But having waiting 50 yeats for Larry Niven's Ringworld to finish. Well I don't have much time. And yes this is just as interesting and entertaining as Ringworld.
3 reviews
November 22, 2025
Thought provoking and enjoyable Alt-history

This was a fun book to read. Hope the story continues…will the Romans make it to the New World and if so, what will they find? So many possible branches to this timeline; can’t wait for the next chapter.
292 reviews3 followers
December 31, 2025
Outstanding !

I had been waiting for this book to be published. It was worth the wait. It was even better than the first. Great story, love the premise of it. Finished to quickly.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 52 reviews