Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Bone Valley: A True Story of Injustice and Redemption in the Heart of Florida

Rate this book
From Pulitzer Prize-winner Gilbert King, and based on the international smash hit podcast, comes a shocking expose into an egregious miscarriage of justrice - BONE VALLEY.

Leo Schofield has spent the past 35 years in prison, convicted for the 1987 murder of his young wife, Michelle-a crime he has always denied. He narrowly escaped the death penalty and would have been released by now if he just confessed to the killing, but he refuses to do so because he's innocent.

Few seriously considered Leo's claims of innocence until 2004, when previously unidentified fingerprints from the crime scene were linked to Jeremy Scott, a troubled and violent teenager from the same town in Polk County, Florida. Now, Jeremy has confessed to Michelle's murder-as well as three other murders in the area.

Both Leo and Jeremy insist they are telling the truth, but the State of Florida refuses to believe either man.


Based on the hugely successful Bone Valley podcast, which The Guardian named one of the best podcasts of the year, this brand new investigation sheds light on one of the world's most shocking cases.

384 pages, Hardcover

Published October 7, 2025

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Gilbert King

26 books281 followers
Gilbert Anthony King is an American writer and photographer.

(wikipedia)

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
775 (51%)
4 stars
564 (37%)
3 stars
135 (8%)
2 stars
20 (1%)
1 star
10 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 265 reviews
Profile Image for MarilynW.
2,156 reviews4,882 followers
November 15, 2025
Bone Valley: A True Story of Injustice and Redemption in the Heart of Florida by Gilbert King

Life has so many difficult aspects to it and then I read about the justice (sometimes it seems like "injustice") system I and I start to lose my faith in humanity. At the same time that I wanted to put this book down and walk away because I was disgusted by the things that happened, I also wanted to see how things turned out for the people involved. Murdered people cannot be brought back to life, families who lost their loved ones cannot get them back, those in prison for crimes they didn't do can't get the freedom they lost back.

This book addresses the murder of eighteen year old Michelle Schofield and her husband, Leo, who spent 35 years behind bars for her murder. But it also addresses other murders, too, and it infuriates me that people can murder and then get to walk the streets to murder again. It seems that real, living, breathing people count so much less than winning the freedom or lives of people who have murdered and will do so again if only given the chance.

Jeremy Scott was a teenager who was imprisoned before he was out of his teens but he'd already committed several murders. His youth was extremely troubled, unfair, as far as you can get from a Leave to Beaver family and childhood. All those things are brought up for why we maybe should feel sorry for him and excuse him for the horrific deeds he did but that is where it seems we are minimizing the right for you and I to live and breath from one day to the next.

Read the book, it's very interesting, it's disturbing, I feel for those who are unjustly imprisoned and this book goes into how this can happen, in great detail. It's a shame when checking certain boxes is more important than the truth. A conviction can be much more important than whether the conviction was just. At the same time, often a person is guilty of great misdeeds but not the one for which they are convicted. That's not right but I'm not keen on people getting off on technicalities, either. I don't know how things can be made to work better, there are too many people that benefit from keeping things crooked from what I can tell. Once again, read the book, it's very interesting and disturbing and my heart goes out to all those who have lost loved ones through crime or through false imprisonment.

Pub Oct 7, 2025

Thank you to Flatiron Books for the print edition of this book.
Profile Image for Brendan (History Nerds United).
937 reviews990 followers
August 24, 2025
Leo Schofield is somehow both the unluckiest and luckiest man I have ever heard of. Let's do a quick rundown:

Unlucky:
1. His wife, Michelle, is murdered
2. He is convicted of the murder
3. He is actually innocent
4. The state of Florida doesn't care

Lucky:
1. He isn't executed by Florida (and Florida loves killing people, but not as much as Texas!)
2. He finds himself a new wife while behind bars
3. He finds a bunch of people who want to free him, including a Pulitzer Prize winner who is the author of the book we're talking about
4. The man who actually killed his wife confesses to it (but to add to the unlucky list, Florida still doesn't care)

(Side note: Never change, Florida. Actually, no, you really need to change, Florida.)

This is not an exhaustive list and for the full list, you will need to read Gilbert King's exceptional Bone Valley. King chronicles not only Leo's life, but also the life of the real killer of his wife, Jeremy Scott. King also explains how the podcast the book is based on came into being, and how it ends up dovetailing directly into the effort to free Leo.

I hesitate to reveal much more from the plot, but I will say that this is not necessarily what you expect from a book like this. I expected a narrative that would excoriate Florida's judicial system and read like a thriller. The excoriation does occur, but King writes this book not as a thriller but as a long journey to catharsis. To use a metaphor, he writes a marathon, not a sprint. However, that doesn't mean it's plodding. King didn't win his Pulitzer by mistake. This is one of the easiest to read books of the year. I don't even know how many pages it was, but they flew by. Most importantly, King was able to humanize (but not excuse) a villain I never expected to care about. I guess the author may need to make room for another award on the shelf.

(This book was provided as an advance copy by NetGalley and Flatiron Books.)
Profile Image for Heather~ Nature.books.and.coffee.
1,313 reviews297 followers
August 15, 2025
The first book I've ever read/listened to by Gilbert King, and now I want to read them all. I'm a huge true crime junkie and this one was really fascinating!! I had actually never heard of the Leo Schofield case. The injustice is shocking and mind blowing. In this book, King goes into detail about Leo's case and his life. Leo was convicted of killing his wife in 1987. He has always maintained his innocence, but few people believed him. Then, in 2004, fingerprints that were found at the scene, were finally linked to Jeremy Scott, who was currently serving time for murder. Jeremy even confessed. But they still kept Leo in prison. In this book, King goes into detail about Leo's case and his life, and also gives details about Jeremy's life! There's so much to this story, and I found it so interesting and infuriating! I loved the way King laid out this case, and the research in such a captivating way. If you are into True crime, you will definitely want to read this one.


Thank you to the publisher for the gifted copy. All opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Deanna (she_reads_truth_365).
394 reviews20 followers
October 9, 2025

How far will a legal system and people go to get a conviction?! This question is at the heart of this story. A true story.

This book was fantastic on audio. Filled with snippets of interview clips. I felt like I was listening to a podcast. Indeed, Bone Valley first started off as a podcast and now has been written into a book. The author Gilbert King narrates his own novel. I listened at 1.5x speed.

It is a bit long because there is so much research and information that went into this podcast/book. I was captivated and could not stop listening. You will feel all the emotions with this one.

This true story is for readers who enjoyed Just Mercy and who want a book that is not only about injustice but hope, compassion and forgiveness.

Thank you to Macmillan audio for the gifted audiobook and the opportunity to preview this book. All opinions are my own.

#macaudio2025
Profile Image for Beverly.
675 reviews141 followers
October 27, 2025
✨REVIEW: Bone Valley: A True Story of Injustice and Redemption in the Heart of Florida by Gilbert King✨

Release date: October 7, 2025 (Out now!)

🎧5⭐️

I have always been drawn to stories of wrongful convictions. While they can be infuriating, I am thankful for people who shine light on injustice so that it will (hopefully) occur less often.

❤️When I knew I was reading a five star story:
Around the 65 percent mark, this jumped from a 4 or 4.5⭐️ read to 5⭐️. Why? Hearing Leo (the wrongfully convicted man) talk about how his heart changed towards the man who murdered his wife gave this book a moving and redemptive element.

While this began with many details and facts, it ended as an incredible story of two men who both spent years in prison. The themes of forgiveness and transformation reminded me of Anthony Ray Hinton’s biography- one of my favorites.

🥰If you loved The Sun Does Shine, Just Mercy, or The Sing Sing Files, this book is for you!

⚠️Profanity: 2/5 (infrequent- about ten total)

Sexual: 2/5 (a couple of references to sexual abuse and behavior)

Other: Rejection and abandonment by a parent, murder, physical abuse is referenced)

❓Do you enjoy stories of wrongful convictions? Do you have a favorite book or podcast?

Thank you to for my copy of this audiobook! #macaudio2025
Profile Image for Renée | apuzzledbooklover.
901 reviews69 followers
October 30, 2025
Compelling and unforgettable. Wow, what a book! It’s one I’ll be thinking of for some time. Social justice books always get to me. This is the story of the wrongful conviction of Leo Schofield, who was convicted in the murder of his wife, Michelle, in 1987. 

It’s frustrating for me to read of egregious cases like this, where a person should never have been convicted. Polk County prosecutor John Aguero’s actions in Leo Schofield’s case were despicable. Leo spent over 35 years in prison for this crime.

“I’m not able to get out of my own story.” 

A gripping, unforgettable and emotional story that is so well researched and well written. You will need to listen closely to the audio excerpts included in the book. I think they add to the narrative.

An important part of this story is the aspect of hope and forgiveness. That is something that really resonated with me.

Be sure to put this book on your list for non-fiction November reading. Highly recommend! ✨

CA | Contains some strong profanity.
Profile Image for Renee Roberts.
370 reviews63 followers
April 12, 2026
Really intriguing "corrected narrative" (the author's phrase) of the murder of Michelle Schofield in 1987 and the ensuing conviction of her husband, Leo Schofield. Leo was innocent, and was incarcerated for 37 years in Florida, maintaining his innocence the entire time. Along the way, he and various lawyers and supporters explored every legal avenue for his exoneration and release, but the state continued to deny him at every opportunity for justice. Even after another convicted murderer confessed to killing Michelle. When up for parole on multiple occasions, the state would focus on his "refusal to accept responsibility or show remorse" and flash autopsy photos of his wife's nude body with horrible stab wounds, and he'd be denied. After the Bone Valley podcast reached millions of people, and a sitting judge gave up the bench just to act as Leo's defense attorney, the parole board finally came through and released him in 2024.

Thoughts:

--> The quote mentioned early in the text about how the goal of a prosecutor should be justice, not winning, his case really hit home to me. The Polk County's DA office NEVER thought about justice. In addition, they were slipshod, dishonest, inflammatory, political, self-aggrandizing, dictatorial egotists who should never have been in office.

--> Leo Schofield is one of the unluckiest people ever. His wife is killed, he's unfairly convicted and gives up 37 years of his life in prison, still doesn't have his name cleared officially, and less than a year later is in a horrific motorcycle accident and severely injured. Yet he still feels blessed and grateful, and shows more grace than you'll likely see in another human.

-->Apparently Leo has always been religious/spiritual. His wedding to Michelle was hastened by their involvement with a church, but other than mentioning the congregation pitching in to help with the ceremony, Gilbert King doesn't tell us anything about it. I wonder whether Leo had any support from church members early on? If not, losing them didn't shake his beliefs. But King left that thread hanging.

-->Coverage of the real killer, Jeremy Scott, was thorough, and actually managed to dredge up a little sympathy in my heart for the guy by the end. I don't know if I could forgive him, as Leo has, but I understand how Leo feels thankful for Jeremy's bravery in finally telling the truth.

-->Gilbert King is known for his works on injustice, having earned a Pulitzer for one. I own Devil In The Grove, but haven't gotten around to it. This was good enough to move that one up the list!

Bone Valley may have earned a higher overall rating had I chosen the hard copy. The audio started well with the author narrating, but sprinkled throughout are audio clips of interviews King and his assistant recorded over the years while they researched the case and prepared to begin a podcast. Every one of those clips is muffled and impossible to discern even at full volume. I can see how hearing the original witnesses speaking in their own words would enhance it, but the audio production is subpar.
Profile Image for Ashley.
539 reviews108 followers
October 29, 2025
full RTC but this is actually 949392458259934483/5 stars


tysm to macmillan audio, Flatiron, Leo, Gilbert King & Kelsey for the #gifted audiobook 🥲
Profile Image for Katie Lavoie.
1 review1 follower
February 9, 2026
While I enjoyed some elements of the story in this book, I found a few things extremely problematic. Firstly, while there was a very brief mention in the very last part of the book about Leo reconciling his less than perfect relationship with Michelle, there was little focus on the fact that Leo was an abusive husband. That was factually true, and echoed in many accounts by friends and acquaintances. King makes this a fringe (at best) part of his identity, even criticizing prosecutors for framing him as an abuser. He was an abuser. Full stop. No, that doesn't make him murderer, but it does not absolve him of that. Abuse, such as the documented abuse of Leo toward Michelle, can and sometimes does lead to murder. King barely addresses this as a fact that could point to his guilt, and doesn't even refer to it as "abuse." Name it. Instead, Leo becomes the hero of the story. Did he ever address his own demons and work to be a better man? How so?

Secondly, the book took an unfortunate path in that it became a book about justice for Leo, NOT about justice for Michelle, who had been a victim of violence by two men featured in the book. I would have appreciated her being centered in the story.

Lastly, King went to great lengths to point to various awards, grants, and events he earned or participated in. He talked a lot about his hard work that went into this project. Yes, we get it. You won a Pulitzer Prize previously. I would have preferred a story that centered Michelle, and did not push the narrative of Leo as an equal victim in the story.

I was excited about this book, but mostly disappointed. It was difficult to finish, but I suppose I am glad I did.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Profile Image for Darcia Helle.
Author 31 books751 followers
October 13, 2025
True crime books can sometimes feel exploitative and a bit icky, like we’re being entertained at the victims’ expense. Then there are books like BONE VALLEY, which is careful, compassionate, engaging, and a powerful examination of our flawed justice system.

Leo Schofield’s case goes far beyond a wrongful conviction. This was prosecutorial misconduct on steroids. I can’t help but wonder how many other innocent people that prosecutor is responsible for locking away.

It’s important to note that this was a capital murder case. The prosecutor was seeking the death penalty. If not for a single dissenter during the sentencing phase of the trial, Leo Schofield likely would have been executed long before the truth finally came out.

I can’t imagine spending 36 years locked up for a murder I didn’t commit. Leo has every right to be angry and bitter, and yet he’s not. The way he held himself with kindness and grace in the face of adversity is something we can all learn from.

Gilbert King, the author, narrates the audiobook, which I loved. The audio includes snippets of various interviews done over the years. Some of the sound quality isn’t great, due to the circumstances, so be prepared to adjust the volume at times.

The audiobook ends with an interview/discussion between King and Schofield that was done after the book was completed. Don’t miss this. It’s poignant and beautiful and, yeah, my eyes might have leaked.

*Huge thank you to Macmillan Audio (#MacAudio2025) for the free audiobook download!*
Profile Image for The Reading Raccoon.
1,178 reviews137 followers
November 21, 2025
Bone Valley is a true-crime nonfiction book about what it took to get a man falsely accused of murdering his wife, Michelle, released from prison.

Leo Schofield had served more than thirty years of a prison sentence for his wife’s murder when Pulitzer Prize–winning investigative author Gilbert King became interested in the case. As Gilbert and his research assistant, Kelsey, dig further into the crime, they find a man who was convicted on weak evidence. Even worse, physical evidence found in Michelle’s car points to a completely different man—someone serving life in prison for another murder committed a year after Michelle’s. Gilbert documents the case and builds a popular podcast around the efforts to get Leo released from prison and clear his name.

Gilbert King does an excellent job making crimes that weren’t widely publicized and occurred nearly forty years ago feel compelling, all while keeping the people involved at the center. Even though there’s a lot of detail, the story unfolds at a nice pace, and I never got bored or distracted.

Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Narration notes: This audiobook of Bone Valley was narrated by the author, Gilbert King. He did such a great job that I assumed it was a professional voice actor.

Disclosure: An advanced listening copy of Bone Valley was provided by Macmillan Audio for review purposes. All thoughts and opinions expressed are my own.
Profile Image for Kenzie | kenzienoelle.reads.
899 reviews222 followers
November 22, 2025
IG review: https://www.instagram.com/p/DRXNWIREd...

WOW. That’s it. That’s the whole review.

I’m always drawn to read stories of wrongful incarceration. I thought this book was phenomenal. “Leo Schofield has spent the past 35 years in prison, convicted for the 1987 murder of his young wife, Michelle-a crime he has always denied. He narrowly escaped the death penalty and would have been released by now if he just confessed to the killing, but he refuses to do so because he's innocent.”

This book is an investigation and an expose of a horrific crime, injustice and the justice system and it’s so well done. The hope and forgiveness that this story brings was beautiful. 5 stars for Gilbert King and Kelsey’s investigation and this book and 1 star for the prosecution and Florida justice system.

🎧I highly recommend the audiobook for this one as we hear conversations with Leo Schofield and the author and some recordings from the investigation.
Profile Image for Heather.
1,252 reviews186 followers
November 16, 2025
It has been days since I finished this book and I can't stop thinking and talking about it. I loved it so much. It was profoundly heartbreaking and infuriating. I don't know if I will ever stop being heartbroken over the injustice of it all. This book will stick with me. It was so well done.

Content: talk about murder, rape, domestic abuse and a handful of F words.
Profile Image for Sam Conner.
142 reviews5 followers
October 25, 2025
Five stars for storytelling, writing, making me feel like I was there in the thick of things reporting with him.

ONE F*CKING STAR for the Florida justice system, are you kidding me?! 36 years an innocent man sat in prison. Absolutely wild, and so sad to know there are more cases like this out there too.
Profile Image for Arla Dauscher.
11 reviews1 follower
March 9, 2026
Omg what an indulgent work. I quite enjoyed Devil in the Grove and was expecting something in a similar vein. Instead it’s a book centered on the emotional and work experience of a successful author trying to make a podcast, pretending not to care about making a podcast anymore when it doesn’t seem to be working out, taking a step back from the project for a prestigious fellowship and leaving his assistant, the podcast getting picked up and achieving success, and then deciding to write a book about it to bank further on the actual story— a husband being wrongfully imprisoned for killing his wife for a lifetime. Sure would have been nice if the book focused more on their experiences. At least this author appreciated his assistant 🤣
Profile Image for Jessica.
365 reviews5 followers
January 27, 2026
This was a weird read for me. On the one hand, the actual story at the heart of this book is horrifying. Any wrongfully convicted person in prison is a travesty, and what happened here is very clearly a miscarriage of justice. I’m sorry it took so long for this error to be rectified, but I am happy that Leo was finally freed.

On the other hand, I genuinely disliked this author. He came across as arrogant and suffering from a major savior complex. I really wished he had inserted himself less in the story, or at least in a way that did not constantly feel like he was patting himself on the back.
Profile Image for emmareadsya .
277 reviews2 followers
April 9, 2026
3.5. Really interesting case showing how insane the system can be - even if you don't believe in Leo's innocence, the state didn't have a case to convict him. That said, the story drags at some points because of repeated information - not just the circles of the justice system, of which there are many, but just actual repeated quotes. The audio excerpts were nice but seemed mixed really odd? They were so quiet I would have to turn the volume way up and then the regular narration would blow out my eardrums so eventually I stopped. Maybe that was just my car, idk. Feel like it might be better suited to the podcast format it was originally in.
Profile Image for Lois.
525 reviews4 followers
February 6, 2026
As a professor of criminal justice, I never enjoyed it when my students told me how hard the assignment was while doing it. King wants us to know how hard his assignment was, how diligent his assistant was throughout, and ends up telling a very messy story badly.
Profile Image for Tasha.
254 reviews7 followers
November 3, 2025
This is the first time I've heard of this case and boy was it a doozy. One man accused of murdering his wife and sentenced to life in prison, and potentially the death penalty. And another man who admits to the murder. But yet, the justice system doesn't believe either of them to rectify the unjust sentence. 

The book, and particularly the audiobook, was so well done recounting the whole investigative process. Really digging into what happened at the time of the murder and everything after. All the trials, the interviews with both Leo and Jeremy. It was truly captivating and shows how the justice system can really do harm to people's lives. 
Profile Image for Karla Osorno.
1,093 reviews25 followers
February 11, 2026
Rating 4 stars.

The injustice suffered by an innocent Leo Schofield (36+ years in prison) is infuriating and heartbreaking. This book captures the details discovered by author Gilbert King and his colleague Kelsey Decker over 6 years. Many of the details, written about, I was familiar with from their podcast Bone Valley. This book is well organized and told and includes more behind the scenes than the podcast. King is a great communicator in writing and in the podcast. I’m glad I read it.
Profile Image for Megan.
376 reviews132 followers
November 14, 2026
Am I truly the only one who does not become wide-eyed and vehemently convinced of a man’s innocence simply because a Pulitzer Prize-winning author tells me I should?

Devil in the Grove, King’s Pulitzer-winning account of the Groveland Four, demonstrated King's ability to investigate a miscarriage of justice while producing a riveting narrative. I found it a fascinating read and expected the same rigorous standard of journalism to be applied to this latest work.

Well, that expectation lasted about as long as my patience during an infuriatingly loud scareware virus last week that made me want to chuck my computer out the window. It’s about time for this book to be held accountable, and I have yet to see anyone else doing it.

A compelling, well-crafted narrative creates an emotionally charged story—not a compelling legal case. Although I suspect Gilbert King intended for me to finish this book with righteous indignation for “the hill Leo had to climb,” I instead finished Bone Valley with more questions than answers.

Bone Valley was a remarkably one-sided account of a 35-year-old murder case, interrupted at increasingly unfortunate intervals by the author’s adventures in podcast production, his prestigious writing fellowship, his extraordinary young research assistant, and a gargantuan furry microphone which horrified several interviewees (will revisit this.)

The fundamental problem with this book is that King appears to have adjudicated Schofield innocent long before he finished presenting the evidence—or even started, really. From that point forward, nearly every disputed fact is interpreted through that conclusion. Which is particularly troubling because the complicated evidence is drowned out by emotional resonance. An unreliable conviction is not proof of innocence.

There are three distinct propositions that King frequently seems to treat as interchangeable:
1) The prosecution failed to establish Leo Schofield’s guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
2) Leo Schofield did not murder his wife, Michelle.
3) Jeremy Scott murdered Michelle.

Evidence supporting one proposition does not automatically furnish proof for the others. I am entirely open to the possibility that Schofield was wrongfully convicted. Likewise, I am also open to the possibility that Jeremy Scott was the real perpetrator. What I cannot accept is King’s insistence of presenting these possibilities as foregone conclusions.
Inconvenient evidence is minimized, explained away, or given comparatively little attention, while evidence supporting his preferred narrative is presented with unfounded confidence. I did not appreciate King’s attempt to “tug at my heart strings.” I can form my own opinion.

One of the most disturbing aspects of the book is its treatment of Leo’s documented history of violence towards Michelle. Numerous witnesses testified to his abusive behavior, including people who had lived with the couple and knew them quite well. Their accounts included slapping, trashing the house and living room, and much more serious allegations, such as Leo’s mutterings that “he needed to quit arguing before he killed her.” The fighting was enough to drive out two separate couples who had moved in to help split the rent.

Melissa Phillips reported hearing arguments from their bedroom:
“The source of the bickering always seemed insignificant, and the fight always seemed to have been instigated by Leo. Little things would set him off. Just little stupid things, childish things,” she remembers. Of course, we are reminded of her boyfriend Dean’s own bad behavior, to subtly undermine the couple’s credibility: “After a few months of living with Dean and Melissa, Leo and Michelle arrived home one evening to find the other couple had gone. They’d packed up and left without a word to either of their roommates, and there was an eviction notice taped to the trailer door. In a panic, Leo called the landlord and was surprised to learn that he had been paying rent to Dean, who had apparently been pocketing the cash instead of passing it on to the landlord.”

Another young couple moved in immediately and ran into the same problems as Dean and Melissa. Bobby Leavens became accustomed to finding things broken and out of place during an argument that had occurred while he and his girlfriend Mary were out. “A lot of times I’d come home, and we’d find furniture that belonged in the kitchen upside down in the living room. Or sometimes we’d come home, and the windows were busted out,” he would recall.

It took a mere two months for Leo’s behavior to drive Mary and Bobby out, like Ed Vashon and the couple before them. All five individuals either heard or saw Leo hit Michelle, threaten her, and trash the place in a fit of rage. It’s worth pointing out that these last tenants were troublemakers from the start: “Not long after moving in, the new tenants were protesting the breakdown of costs. The two couples were splitting the rent fifty-fifty, but Bobby felt this was unfair. The front bedroom, shared by Leo and Michelle, was slightly larger. And, he pointed out, they’d claimed the waterbed that had been left when Dean and Melissa were evicted.”

Apparently evicting one couple and stealing a waterbed from another could offer alternate theories for why these couples testified against Leo for the murder of his wife that had nothing to do with his rage.

In the chapter which tells how Leo and Michelle meet, Leo’s destructive behavior observed by witnesses in the preceding paragraphs has already been explained by King. As early as page 18, in fact. Leo’s abusive behavior isn’t just minimized but is repeatedly surrounded by descriptions of the behavior which encourage the reader to sympathize with Leo. It’s a pattern which is easily identifiable.

Consider how he frames Leo’s antics while onstage playing the guitar. Bass player Dave Collins recalls that “the thing about guitarists in bands” is that “most of them are kind of hard to get along with.” That “kind of” is doing a shit ton of work.

“Leo’s ‘fiery reputation’ was cemented during one unforgettable performance…he had invited a girl he’d been casually seeing to watch the performance, but as he rocked out onstage, he glanced over the crowd to see her lifting her shirt, bare chest exposed. Furious that everyone else had seen this, Leo jumped down from the flatbed trailer, tossed his guitar onto the bonfire, and stormed off into the woods...After that night, Leo continued to take the stage with the rescued guitar, now charred by flames and smoky with soot—a lasting testament to his fiery, impulsive nature."

FOR FUCK'S SAKE. If you don't see what that paragraph is doing, then it's a serious problem. If we're talking about Nirvana's love for destroying instruments, that might be a lovely description for an eccentric grunge band whose lead singer once decided to burn his Jaguar instead of smashing it to pieces. It's considerably less charming when that same fiery, impulsive nature is later associated with violence against his nineteen-year-old-wife.

Yes, the guitar incident alone doesn't establish anything of real value concerning Leo's treatment of Michelle. But choice of language MATTERS. King is establishing a sympathetic vocabulary for Leo's temper before the reader encounters the consequences of it. Fiery. Impulsive. Passionate. What about intimidating? Dangerous? Aggressive? It's a literary framing device, and once you recognize it, the subsequent passages become all the more revealing.

Yet the narrative makes this mistake over an over again, encouraging us to understand his behavior as unfortunate conduct of an immature young man with a short temper who subsequently matured after acknowledging his shortcomings. That would be wonderful, if we are to assume his remorse is genuine. Bob Verini would be AGHAST. "Why would we PRESUME to know what this man was thinking?!" We wouldn't, BV. We wouldn't.

Unfortunately, Michelle never had the opportunity to grow older and experience a second chance at life. She was brutally murdered when they were both nineteen. Leo's subsequent personal growth cannot retroactively diminish the significance of his behavior at the time leading up to her death. None of this proves he murdered Michelle. But repeated domestic violence, particularly when accompanied by threats of lethal harm, is not an irrelevant character defect. It is potentially significant evidence which deserves serious examination.

Then there's King's description of Leo's last phone call with Michelle the night she was killed. Before we even get to this conversation, there's already been evidence given for Leo's concern.
Their first roommate, Ed Vashon, overheard an argument and King mentions that Leo and Michelle seem to be fighting more and more. "Arguments would often stem from their shared use of the car. Michelle loved driving. She loved the freedom of having access to a vehicle, and sometimes after work, she'd swing by a friend's house or run an errand. Leo would get worried and wonder where she was and whether something had happened to her. He begged her to pull over somewhere and find a pay phone if she was going to be late. He didn't mind her taking the car, but he wanted to know where she was and what her plans were. He was especially concerned given that Michelle didn't have a driver's license, only a learner's permit."

Michelle loved driving. She loved the feeling of freedom it gave her. Sometimes she visited friends or ran errands. A pretty mundane description of a young woman enjoying the smallest amount of independence. Yet the narrative again shifts almost entirely to Leo's feelings. He worried. He wondered if something had happened. He begged her to call.

He didn't mind?

What an extraordinarily generous husband, allowing his wife to use a vehicle they shared.

Where King sees concern, I see control. What he depicts as benign worry, I understand to be possessive. He wanted to know where she was and what her plans were. Not simply whether she was safe. Where she was. What she intended to do. It's possible Leo did have genuine concerns, given Michelle's driver's permit situation. But King's language repeatedly supplies a charitable explanation for conduct that, considered alongside the abuse testimony, also raises questions about controlling behavior. Depending on where she was driving, needing to find a payphone to check in with Leo might itself have introduced risks. The book doesn't examine that practical consideration.

King's narrative framing assures readers will interpret these statements as Leo's relief rather than a warning. So when she Michelle finally makes that fateful call, we get: "Leo thanked her for calling to let him know the plan and why she'd been late, as he was always badgering her to do. 'Now, was that so hard?' He smiled into the receiver. 'Now we won't have to fight. Everything's good. I know you're okay.'"

The scene is written almost affectionately. But why would failing to call necessarily result in a fight?

Why is she expected to report her every movement, explain her delays, and even to account for her earnings and expenditures? These behaviors may be consistent with coercive control, particularly when considered alongside the testimony about the nature of their relationship. King's narrative framing encourages the reader to see affection where a more skeptical examination might reveal something considerably more troubling.

The inconsistencies between his sympathies for the two men are profound. King asks the reader to sympathize with Leo as an innocent man convicted of murder. Bias is “removed” by asking the reader to sympathize with Jeremy—the real killer—by telling us of his abusive childhood. If Leo can pray for him and ask God to “let Jeremy know love” then readers must do so as well.

Jeremy Scott: The Man Who Confessed to Almost Everything.

The book's treatment of Scott presents another serious problem. He has an extensive history of violence and criminal behavior, as we're told time and time again. He is certainly capable of murder. But capability is not proof he committed this particular murder. His confession history is especially troubling.

Scott repeatedly denied responsibility, made contradictory statements, agreed to confess, retracted admissions, and reportedly wrote "NO" many times across a document he was asked to sign affirming his confession. He's also made sweeping claims about responsibility for other murders—sending letters to officials stating he wanted to return to death row and was now claiming responsibility for every murder in Polk County from 1987 to 1988. Additionally, he asks to be left alone and free all the inmates since "he did the crimes."

When he confesses this way, King tells us the State wants us to disregard this confession as delusional, due to his 80 IQ and mental instability. Yet when it suits his claims of Leo's innocence, we're then asked to believe him. Years after inconsistent accounts, King's investigation is the one to finally produce the true confession that forms the emotional centerpiece of this heartfelt saga.

Scott's relationship with King deserves particular scrutiny. The author describes sending him books, developing a rapport, and encouraging him to speak about his past. Establishing trust with a source is not inherently improper; a relationship with an interviewer doesn't automatically invalidate a confession.

Yet when the source appears highly responsive to attention and emotional encouragement, the circumstances under which a confession emerges become much more important. King also appeals to Scott's conscience, suggesting that acknowledging responsibility could help free an innocent man. This raises obvious questions about suggestibility and the reliability of the resulting statements.

The relevant question isn't whether Scott is a terrible person. It's whether his account of Michelle's murder is independently corroborated. His fingerprints in her abandoned vehicle establish contact with the car, but Scott has already acknowledged stealing its stereo. Prints alone don't account for murder. His account of stabbing Michelle inside the vehicle also raises questions about the apparent absence of corresponding blood in the passenger compartment. There may be explanations for these discrepancies. But explanations require evidence, not a willingness to imagine circumstances under which the preferred theory would be true.

A confession that changes repeatedly deserves scrutiny when its details appear difficult to reconcile with the physical evidence.

I don't know whether Jeremy Scott murdered Michelle Schofield. Repeating his confession with increasing dramatic intensity doesn't make it any more reliable, however.

Skepticism Is A One Way Street:
King is understandably critical of investigators and prosecutors who commit to a theory and interpret every discovery as confirmation of it. Unfortunately, his own investigation becomes vulnerable to precisely the same problem. Consider the arguments concerning the timeline of Michelle's disappearance and murder. The existence of an unexplained interval does not establish what occurred during that interval. Nor does uncertainty about the precise sequence of events automatically render the prosecution's theory impossible.

Similarly, questions surrounding Leo's father's discovery of Michelle's body deserve careful consideration, given the disputed circumstances and testimony. The book raises legitimate concerns about the original investigation, yet these concerns don't eliminate the need to examine the evidence that might implicate Leo.

Judge Scott Cupp's Extraordinary Courage?
Cupp had previously represented Leo as a defense attorney before becoming a judge. Yet King repeatedly makes it seem as though Cupp is an outsider risking his professional career to speak out for Leo. A sitting judge's public statements about a criminal case may raise judicial ethics concerns. But representing a defendant and advocating for his innocence while serving as his attorney? It's not some extraordinary act of heroism! It's literally the man's job!

The Chapter Titles: Innocence By Proclamation

Even the chapter titles seem determined to tell readers which conclusions they must reach.

"KNOW THAT I KNOW."

Leo himself expresses uncertainty re: Scott's guilt. Yet shortly afterward, we're subjected to an elaborate exercise in what can only be described as MUTUAL MIND-READING.

Passing Jeremy's holding cell where Jeremy is lying on the bed, Leo takes a long, hard look at the man said to have confessed to Michelle's murder. Leo knows. Jeremy knows Leo knows. Leo knows Jeremy knows Leo knows. And Jeremy doesn't look him in the eye. This new evidentiary standard makes judicial strict scrutiny look lenient by comparison! We have established that fundamental human rights may be violated by a failure to maintain appropriate eye contact.

I would have preferred the title: "It Seemed to Me He Had Really Done It." At least that would acknowledge the difference between an inference and an established fact.

(It's interesting how this encounter is reported in contrast to the much earlier report about Leo slapping Michelle. Leo can't look Michelle in the eye. He's immediately devastated. When Leo can't look Michelle in the eye after assaulting her, King presents it as evidence of shame and remorse. When Jeremy Scott reportedly doesn't look Leo in the eye, it's presented as evidence of guilt. The same behavior is assigned different meanings depending on which interpretation supports the author's preferred conclusion.)

Then there's "I'VE READ IT ALL,", celebrating Kelsey's epic takedown of a notoriously corrupt prosecutor. Her devastating declaration that she has read the case materials is presented as though she has just delivered the intellectual equivalent of a knockout punch.

Alternative title: "The Research Assistant Who Read the FOOTNOTES."

Scott's bewildering confession history practically demands: "I DID IT. NO, I DIDN'T. ACTUALLY, I DID EVERY MURDER IN POLK COUNTY. JUST LEAVE ME ALONE."

These titles may be amusing, but the underlying criticism is no joke.

The Microphone. Dear God, THE MICROPHONE.

I genuinely cannot believe how often this monstrosity appears. Kelsey uses an enormous furry microphone that becomes a recurring source of discomfort for interviewees. At least three encounters with this beast are memorable enough to warrant mention. Judge Cupp reportedly flinches after being struck in the face with it. Kelsey apologizes while laughing. Another interviewee visibly "recoils" from the microphone—an interaction which is once again treated with amusement.

Even Jeremy Scott is not safe from confrontation by this remarkable piece of equipment.

King oddly describes these incidents as charming anecdotes.

If your interview subjects are visibly uncomfortable about a very disturbing topic, and your microphone has already injured one subject, perhaps the appropriate course of action is not to preserve the incident for literary posterity. Perhaps it is to obtain a smaller microphone. Hold it farther away. Just STOP hitting people with it. This is investigative journalism, not an obstacle course!

The absurdity might have been delightful in a different book. But alongside an investigation into a young woman's brutal murder? Misguided at best. King's apparent fascination with documenting such encounters is emblematic of a larger problem: too much attention is wasted on the investigators' experiences rather than the evidence they're supposed to be investigating.

1/5. Did Leo commit this crime? Maybe. Jeremy? Maybe.
THE MICROPHONE?!
Not outside the realm of possibility.






Profile Image for Teresa.
835 reviews
October 13, 2025
A heartbreaking story of injustice.

Leo Schofield is tried and incarcerated for murdering his wife despite the lack of evidence in this case and despite his desperate attempts to find his wife when she first went missing. I couldn't put this book down. But, the real story is revealed much later. It is the humble humanity of Leo himself. I really cried. How could you not?

Thankful for Gilbert King and his assistant, Kelsey Decker for their dogged analysis of the facts in this case. Their pursuit of the truth is truly admirable.
Profile Image for Jesse.
1,668 reviews12 followers
November 9, 2025
In Bone Valley, Gilbert King takes us deeper into the story of a wrongful conviction in Lakeland, Florida. I haven't listened to the Bone Valley podcast, so I was unfamiliar with this case. Like the author himself, I was a little skeptical going into the story, but King really shows why he is a Pulitzer winner. The case is clearly laid out, and it doesn't take long to get emotionally invested in the story. Definitely a must-read for true crime fans.
Profile Image for Kim.
827 reviews7 followers
October 22, 2025
DNF. I hate it when a book reads like a podcast. Listening to the audiobook and the narrative is exactly like a podcast then it pauses to play live audio clips. This is not a true crime book it's a podcast sold as a book.
Profile Image for Henry.
Author 4 books28 followers
July 16, 2026
This covers a lot of ground from the podcast (and more), but about half of it is also about the making of the podcast. Because, sure, why else would a publisher buy a story that's already been told? Though these sections can be affecting, they can also feel indulgent and congratulatory.
Profile Image for Sharon.
1,178 reviews
December 2, 2025
Thank you @macmillian.audio #MacAudio2025 for the free alc 💖.

Leo Schofield spent 35 years in prison for the 1987 murder of his wife, Michelle—a crime he always said he didn’t commit. He could have been released years earlier if he’d confessed, but he stood firm in his innocence.

In 2004, fingerprints from the crime scene were matched to another man, Jeremy Scott, who later confessed to Michelle’s murder and several others. However, even with that confession, the State of Florida still refused to accept either man’s story. This investigation, based on the hit Bone Valley podcast, digs into one of Florida’s most controversial and baffling murder cases.

This story was truly unbelievable! As soon as I saw the premise, I knew I had to listen to it. As a Florida resident, I was especially curious and I had never heard of this case before. It was shocking to learn that an innocent man could spend decades in prison for a crime someone else confessed to, especially when there was evidence linking that person to the scene. Hard to believe, but that’s exactly what happened. Jeremy Scott was the killer, yet Leo was the one serving the sentence. Thanks to the Bone Valley podcast’s investigation and the spread of the truth, Leo’s story finally came to light, and he was ultimately released.

The audiobook runs for 14 hours and 43 minutes and is narrated by the author. It features audio from the original podcast, along with archival recordings and interviews from the investigation, which made the story feel vivid and real. It was engaging, powerful, and a must listen for true crime fans.

Read if you like:
🍊Wrongful conviction cases
🍊Podcasts
🍊Florida setting
🍊True crime
🍊The pursuit of truth

⚠️CW: Wrongful imprisonment, murder/homicide, violence, domestic violence, graphic crime scene details.
Profile Image for Adanna.
1,023 reviews
November 20, 2025
Author and narrator Gilbert King takes us on a gripping journey through the case of Leo Schofield, a young rock-and-roll guitarist wrongfully convicted of murdering his wife, Michelle, in 1987. Just six months after their wedding, Michelle was brutally stabbed twenty-six times. Despite Leo’s steadfast claims of innocence, he was convicted and sentenced to life in prison. Fast forward decades later, and King uncovers a chilling connection to a nearby serial killer. Can he help exonerate an innocent man?

I hadn’t heard of this wrongful conviction case before diving into the audiobook, but Leo’s story hooked me from the start. King meticulously unpacks each step of the investigation, revealing shocking evidence that supports Schofield’s innocence. It’s infuriating to see how the justice system failed him at every turn. With a solid alibi and no physical evidence linking him to the crime, it’s baffling how he was ever convicted.

What struck me most was King’s passionate belief in Leo's innocence and his relentless pursuit of justice. Despite compelling new evidence, Leo’s appeals were repeatedly denied, showcasing a true miscarriage of justice.

King emphasizes that storytelling can be a powerful tool for justice when all else fails. Thankfully, after years of fighting, Leo finally received the justice he deserved.

The audiobook is enhanced by real audio clips from 911 calls and witness interviews, creating an immersive experience. King’s engaging narration makes for a captivating listen.

Bone Valley offers a profound look at a tragic injustice, making it a great listen for anyone intrigued by true crime and systemic failures in our legal system.

I received a gifted copy of this audiobook.
Profile Image for Anna.
1,225 reviews55 followers
October 30, 2025
I surprised myself by requesting this book from the Macmillan Early Listener program because I’m not a true crime or podcast junkie. The synopsis sounded interesting and I was intrigued by the premise and took a chance trying something different. Stepping outside my normal genres paid off in a big way.

This is the story of Leo Schofield, a man wrongly convicted of killing his young wife in Lakeland, Florida, and the people who worked hard to prove his innocence and obtain his freedom. It is compelling, hard hitting, infuriating, and above all else—hopeful. The book is full of details about the crime, investigation, and legal system and it’s told in a manner that presents those facts while keeping the listener engaged.

Narrated brilliantly by the author; I could not stop listening. I was completely invested in Schofield’s fate and found myself infuriated at the circumstances and misuse of power that combined to work against him.

Through it all, however, I was inspired and moved by Leo Schofield himself. His ability to keep his heart from hardening when all hope seemed lost is remarkable.

This is my first book by Gilbert King and it will not be my last. His investigative and storytelling skills are outstanding. It’s easy to see why he was awarded a Pulitzer Prize.

Thank you to Macmillan Audio and Flatiron Books for the advance copy. All opinions are my own.
Profile Image for Dana K.
2,119 reviews103 followers
November 18, 2025
Thanks to Macmillan Audio for gifted access to this audiobook. All opinions below are my own.

I love a good true crime story. This is the story of a man falsely accused and convicted of killing his wife in Florida. Gilbert King decided to investigate the case and recorded a podcast trying to change the narrative around the accused, Leo's, story. There was clear evidence that someone else had done the crime. If Gilbert could get the alternate suspect to confess, perhaps Leo could go free. The book takes on the journey from the first investigation, through many reinvestigations and the politics of the area that made overturning a conviction a very unlikely prospect.

I enjoyed the journey of this story. And while, I agree, an innocent person should not be incarcerated wrongly, the early narrative of Leo made it hard to root for him. His evolution in prison and ultimate forgiveness for the real perpetrator brought me around on him for sure. It's a great listen if you like true crime and there's a great interview at the end between Gilbert and Leo on the audiobook.
Profile Image for Daniel “Lucky” Barajas.
13 reviews1 follower
September 27, 2026
Finished this book a few weeks back but I have been struggling with what to write as a review. From a casual reader’s perspective, yes, this was an amazingly well paced story & excellently written in order to not lose the reader. There was an incredible amount of facts, theories, testimonials, and positions, which felt overwhelming at times but remained gripping to force reader to feel every single line. Powerful story of innocence lost and the ability to be a light in the darkest of times.

Now as a person who lives in Polk County, Florida where this case took place, I felt knots in my throat, pain in my heart, and horrific gut punches as I read this. Our county sheriff & prosecutor are extremely well known here and not for the greatest reasons. Call it PTSD or whatever, but I hurt reading this story & feeling his pain. One thing that I do know, i could never be as resilient as Leo Scofield.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 265 reviews