E ARC provided by Edelweiss Plus
8th grader Harper has a job serving cocoa at the Sweet Shack in the local ice skating rink, the Skatium. She used to be on the girls' hockey team, since her grandmother and mother were obsessed with hockey and her older brothers all played, but after an incident in a game, she won't even go on the ice. This poses a problem when the owner of the rink asks her to participate in a mentorship program. Jason D'Andre, a prominent tween pairs skater, has moved to town and will be helping out, but Harper is still reluctant. It takes the insistence of eight year old friend Bronte to get Harper to acquiese, and even then, she refuses to actually get out on the ice. Jason is not only at the rink, but also enrolls in Summit Middle School. When Harper finds out that the two live in the same neighborhood, they walk home together. Jason has his own issues with skating, and is not fond of the attention that his skating has brought him. Harper's best friend was Bea, but she was involved in the incident that took Harper off the ice. Bea's brother, Brian, has been very mean to Harper ever since. When Bea insists that Harper come to her birthday party, there's a snafu with the cocoa, but the two have a heart to heart talk and make up. Harper is enjoying the mentorship program, but is anxious when she thinks she has caused Bronte to injure herself. Eventually, Harper and Jason talk about their issues with the ice, and decide to try to help each other out. They are good friends, but as they spend more and more time together, they become fonder and fonder of each other. Will they be able to return to the skating that they love, and will they be more than friends?
Strengths: I'm trying not to spoil some of the plot twists here, but yes, the two start dating... after Harper asks Jason out! Loved that part! I also appreciated that they really did start out as friends, had a lot in common, and talked to each other for support. It's also fun that Harper is a hockey player with deep ties to the sport, and Jason is a figure skater, since it's often the other way around. Bronte is an interesting character to have, and Harper trying to be a positive role model is great. I'd love to see more tweens mentoring slightly younger kids. Both Harper and Jason seemed like they were high schoolers (especially since Harper has a job), and the illustration style on the cover is similar to some of the Young Adult titles I have seen, which will encourage even 8th graders to pick this up. This was a generally positive story with no dead relatives, a new kid in town who is fairly well adjusted, and a supportive sports environment. The budding romance is super sweet and involves a kiss. I would love to see SO MANY more stories like this.
Weaknesses: Kids today. They whine a lot. While this is completely on trend for whatever this younger generation is called, it makes an old person like me want to slap them a tiny bit. Blitt's titles are solid middle grade stories, but often seem to get stuck in some kind of publishing purgatory. This came out as Cocoa Crushes about 2020, but maybe only through Scholastic book orders. I also couldn't seem to get a hold of a copy of Carols and Crushes. Scholastic's WISH books are so popular with my students; I don't understand why they are so hard to get for my library.
What I really think: If I can find a prebound copy of this, I'll definitely purchase it. I've bought some paperback titles because I couldn't get them any other way, but for whatever weird reason, my students are reluctant to check out paperbacks! Fans of Suzanne Nelson's and Taylor Garland's WISH titles will drink this one up like a cup of hot chocolate with marshmallows!