What do you think?
Rate this book
A Hudson Valley Murder Mystery
Second Chance
Almost a year after the murder that shook Lobell College to its core, the start of a new academic year brings familiar faces back to the scene of the crime. Daniel Rosenbaum starts his first year as dean of the English department and takes a hands-on role in advising students. Lily Peterson and Gianna d’Angelo return to continue their undergrad studies after the death of the professor they were both in love with.
Meanwhile, on the other side of the Hudson, Tony d’Angelo is working hard. With his sister back in college, it’s all hands on deck to keep his dad’s auto shop running and take care of his infant niece. He still finds time to spend most nights with his boyfriend, Daniel, although he can’t seem to find the words to talk to his family about his relationship. Tony’s life is exactly what he’s always wanted it to be—so why does he feel like he’s struggling to be himself?
When a Lobell professor is once again found murdered, the idyll of the last months is turned on its head. Can Tony and Daniel stay out of harm’s way this time? Or will the fragile new peace they’ve found together be shattered?
Meanwhile, on the other side of the Hudson, Tony d’Angelo is working hard. With his sister back in college, it’s all hands on deck to keep his dad’s auto shop running and take care of his infant niece. He still finds time to spend most nights with his boyfriend, Daniel, although he can’t seem to find the words to talk to his family about his relationship. Tony’s life is exactly what he’s always wanted it to be—so why does he feel like he’s struggling to be himself?
When a Lobell professor is once again found murdered, the idyll of the last months is turned on its head. Can Tony and Daniel stay out of harm’s way this time? Or will the fragile new peace they’ve found together be shattered?
ebook
Published February 4, 2025
7 people are currently reading
38 people want to read
About the author
S.B. Barnes
3 books37 followersS. B. Barnes attended college in the Hudson Valley, studying English Language and Literature and Anthropology (although unlike her characters, her time there was not interrupted by crime-solving). She grew up split between the USA and Germany, attending university in both countries before eventually settling in Germany. Today, she works as a teacher and lives with her husband, son, and two cats. Fiction has always been one of her greatest loves, as a reader, as a teacher, and as a writer, and she hopes you enjoy reading her work as much as she enjoys creating it.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 44 reviews
December 27, 2024
4.5 ⭐️
How I admire authors who dare irritate us.
I really enjoyed this author's debut novel, and thus approached this installment with no small degree of trepidation (sophomore slump is real, y'all!). But if anything, I liked this better. Being in Tony's head is something of a relief after spending book one in Daniel's overthinking, catastrophizing brain; and while Tony has a heaping pile of trauma to work through -- something that he acknowledges to himself over the course of the book, and that he realizes stems partly from, but also precedes, the events of book 1 -- he is fundamentally a pragmatic, grounded character who is self-aware enough to know when he's fooling himself. The mystery is very much secondary, and there is never really any question as to the perpetrators. But this is less a whodunit than an exploration of how violence, loss, and trauma spin out over time --there is a direct link to the crime in the first book -- and how this affects people in both obvious and indirect ways.
So what's with the irritation? Readers of book one (and really, you must read book one first; otherwise you'll be reading blind) will remember that the two academics, Daniel and Colette, had a healthy liberal skepticism of the police and copaganda, made exponentially worse by the way the investigation went down. This mutual dislike and, in Daniel's case, distrust informs his actions throughout this story, in a way that many readers -- myself included -- will find headshakingly naive, if not actively dangerous for several of the main characters. Being in Daniel's head in this book would have been fatal: he's so riven with guilt over what he perceives as his failings over the events of book one, so sure of his rightness and rectitude, and so unwilling to see the pain, fear, and even harm his actions cause others -- not least, but not only, the husband of the poor murder victim -- that it would be unbearable to be absorbed in this interior monologue of self-righteous, self-centering justification. Happily, Tony is just as skeptical as we are: he understands why Daniel acts as he does, and he goes along with it to a point, but he doesn't necessarily agree with it and makes this clear to Daniel both during and after the fact. If the reader is shaking their head at Daniel's actions, so is Tony; and while a couple of times I wished Tony would make more of a stand in the moment, he didn't mince words or feelings after the fact. This all makes Daniel seem unsympathetic, which is somewhat unfair; he's being a dumbass, but at least he's a sincere dumbass. But what saves the story is Tony's willingness, despite being down bad for Daniel, to hold Daniel accountable for how his actions affected him and their relationship. Had Tony hand-waved away his disagreements with Daniel, it would have been a much less satisfying read.
While crime series featuring non-LEO MCs can be a cautionary tale of diminishing returns -- at a certain point, the implausability of having civilians solving crimes left and right becomes too glaring to ignore -- I sincerely hope we get a return to this world. We leave Tony and Daniel in a good, solid place, but still very much in the beginning of their story; while there are tantalizing threads dangling involving multiple side characters that I hope get further fleshed out. Delighted as I was to see in the end material that Barnes's next book is a hockey romance (!!!!!!), I'm looking forward to another round with Tony and Daniel soon.
I got an ARC from GRR in exchange for an honest review.
How I admire authors who dare irritate us.
I really enjoyed this author's debut novel, and thus approached this installment with no small degree of trepidation (sophomore slump is real, y'all!). But if anything, I liked this better. Being in Tony's head is something of a relief after spending book one in Daniel's overthinking, catastrophizing brain; and while Tony has a heaping pile of trauma to work through -- something that he acknowledges to himself over the course of the book, and that he realizes stems partly from, but also precedes, the events of book 1 -- he is fundamentally a pragmatic, grounded character who is self-aware enough to know when he's fooling himself. The mystery is very much secondary, and there is never really any question as to the perpetrators. But this is less a whodunit than an exploration of how violence, loss, and trauma spin out over time --there is a direct link to the crime in the first book -- and how this affects people in both obvious and indirect ways.
So what's with the irritation? Readers of book one (and really, you must read book one first; otherwise you'll be reading blind) will remember that the two academics, Daniel and Colette, had a healthy liberal skepticism of the police and copaganda, made exponentially worse by the way the investigation went down. This mutual dislike and, in Daniel's case, distrust informs his actions throughout this story, in a way that many readers -- myself included -- will find headshakingly naive, if not actively dangerous for several of the main characters. Being in Daniel's head in this book would have been fatal: he's so riven with guilt over what he perceives as his failings over the events of book one, so sure of his rightness and rectitude, and so unwilling to see the pain, fear, and even harm his actions cause others -- not least, but not only, the husband of the poor murder victim -- that it would be unbearable to be absorbed in this interior monologue of self-righteous, self-centering justification. Happily, Tony is just as skeptical as we are: he understands why Daniel acts as he does, and he goes along with it to a point, but he doesn't necessarily agree with it and makes this clear to Daniel both during and after the fact. If the reader is shaking their head at Daniel's actions, so is Tony; and while a couple of times I wished Tony would make more of a stand in the moment, he didn't mince words or feelings after the fact. This all makes Daniel seem unsympathetic, which is somewhat unfair; he's being a dumbass, but at least he's a sincere dumbass. But what saves the story is Tony's willingness, despite being down bad for Daniel, to hold Daniel accountable for how his actions affected him and their relationship. Had Tony hand-waved away his disagreements with Daniel, it would have been a much less satisfying read.
While crime series featuring non-LEO MCs can be a cautionary tale of diminishing returns -- at a certain point, the implausability of having civilians solving crimes left and right becomes too glaring to ignore -- I sincerely hope we get a return to this world. We leave Tony and Daniel in a good, solid place, but still very much in the beginning of their story; while there are tantalizing threads dangling involving multiple side characters that I hope get further fleshed out. Delighted as I was to see in the end material that Barnes's next book is a hockey romance (!!!!!!), I'm looking forward to another round with Tony and Daniel soon.
I got an ARC from GRR in exchange for an honest review.
February 4, 2025
A Joyfully Jay review.
4.25 stars
I was quick to pick up this second book in the Hudson Valley Murder Mysteries series, having liked the first. Tony and Daniel are great characters, and this book is told from Tony’s POV, which worked great for the storytelling. While most of the information you need is here, I would suggest that the books be read in order, since many of the same characters come into play.
This book is well balanced between the romantic storyline and the mystery storyline. It’s also a little more straightforward than the first book when it comes to the latter.
Overall, this was another solid book in the series, particularly where the relationship was concerned. I really enjoy the cast of characters, especially Tony and Daniel, and I’m looking forward to what comes next.
Read Kris’ review in its entirety here.
4.25 stars
I was quick to pick up this second book in the Hudson Valley Murder Mysteries series, having liked the first. Tony and Daniel are great characters, and this book is told from Tony’s POV, which worked great for the storytelling. While most of the information you need is here, I would suggest that the books be read in order, since many of the same characters come into play.
This book is well balanced between the romantic storyline and the mystery storyline. It’s also a little more straightforward than the first book when it comes to the latter.
Overall, this was another solid book in the series, particularly where the relationship was concerned. I really enjoy the cast of characters, especially Tony and Daniel, and I’m looking forward to what comes next.
Read Kris’ review in its entirety here.
December 31, 2024
********** Contains Spoilers**********
I’m new to SB Barnes’s work and I’m looking forward to reading more. I really enjoyed reading the continuation of Daniel and Tony’s story. During the events that unfolded in the first book of the Hudson Valley Murder Mystery Series Daniel and Tony have definitely grown closer. Tony is basically living at Daniel’s. I still think that they’re great together and that their chemistry is off the charts. I liked how everything unfolded, even though it was pretty easy to work out who killed professor Amelia Lawrence. I didn’t really like some of Daniel’s thought processes and actions during this book. Yes, I can kind of understand his reasoning but he took on guilt that wasn’t his, just the same as Colette. They didn’t want another student to not get the help they desperately need but they both need to realise that they’re professors/student advisors and not trained to help anyone with their mental health.
I enjoyed seeing everyone come together when Tony called telling them that Daniel was missing. They definitely have an amazing friend group and family support. I loved that Tony finally came out to his family, even though they knew he was with Daniel it just wasn’t discussed. Tony knew that they love and support him but he’s worried that they’d lose people they care about when they hear about his sexual orientation. I’m glad that Tony and his sister Gianna cleared the air and actually opened up to each other about everything that they’ve been through as I believe it’s going to help them both going forward. All I can say is that Mario is a lot worse a person than I already thought he was when we actually get to hear how he treated Gianna. Daniel’s cat Worf is absolutely adorable, especially how he keeps on stealing Tony’s hair ties to play with them as he doesn’t want Tony to leave since he only ties his hair up when he’s leaving the apartment. I’m looking forward to reading more of SB Barnes books in the future. I’d recommend this book, series and author to others.
******I received a complimentary copy of this book through GRR. I would still happily review this book even if I purchased it myself. My thoughts and feelings about this book are completely unbiased******
I’m new to SB Barnes’s work and I’m looking forward to reading more. I really enjoyed reading the continuation of Daniel and Tony’s story. During the events that unfolded in the first book of the Hudson Valley Murder Mystery Series Daniel and Tony have definitely grown closer. Tony is basically living at Daniel’s. I still think that they’re great together and that their chemistry is off the charts. I liked how everything unfolded, even though it was pretty easy to work out who killed professor Amelia Lawrence. I didn’t really like some of Daniel’s thought processes and actions during this book. Yes, I can kind of understand his reasoning but he took on guilt that wasn’t his, just the same as Colette. They didn’t want another student to not get the help they desperately need but they both need to realise that they’re professors/student advisors and not trained to help anyone with their mental health.
I enjoyed seeing everyone come together when Tony called telling them that Daniel was missing. They definitely have an amazing friend group and family support. I loved that Tony finally came out to his family, even though they knew he was with Daniel it just wasn’t discussed. Tony knew that they love and support him but he’s worried that they’d lose people they care about when they hear about his sexual orientation. I’m glad that Tony and his sister Gianna cleared the air and actually opened up to each other about everything that they’ve been through as I believe it’s going to help them both going forward. All I can say is that Mario is a lot worse a person than I already thought he was when we actually get to hear how he treated Gianna. Daniel’s cat Worf is absolutely adorable, especially how he keeps on stealing Tony’s hair ties to play with them as he doesn’t want Tony to leave since he only ties his hair up when he’s leaving the apartment. I’m looking forward to reading more of SB Barnes books in the future. I’d recommend this book, series and author to others.
******I received a complimentary copy of this book through GRR. I would still happily review this book even if I purchased it myself. My thoughts and feelings about this book are completely unbiased******
January 14, 2025
4/5 stars! This is the second book in this series (so far). I enjoyed the first book, but found parts of the storyline kind of drawn out. I found that to be slightly improved in this book. The author has strong writing skills. I just wish I couldn't keep guessing the ending of the mysteries so early on in the books. But this book improved by expanding the effort put into secondary and side characters. Looking forward to what is next in this series.
February 4, 2025
4.5 stars - I enjoyed this second book even more than the first (though it is a narrow thing; both were wonderful.) While it shows I read this over a couple of days, I should mention, I read the second half in one sitting and stayed up until 2:00 AM to finish it.
While the first book follows Daniel, this one focuses on Tony, and I thought it was a wonderful choice to give us insights to his experience of their relationship. I don't think I've read an experience with 'coming out' (quotations for various reasons) quite like Tony's, but it felt entirely natural. He's never made any declarative statements, but his friends have known for a while, and his family has recently figured it out. He's not trying to hide it, staying over at Daniel's most nights, but feeling like he's still sneaking around a bit.
The mysteries aren't the strongest part of this series; however, this one was still compelling (my bloodshot eyes can attest), and that aspect felt a little bit more assured than the first book. (Again, this is not meant as shade; I gave the first book the same rating, this one just felt slightly enhanced.)
I am mainly here for the feels, and Tony . . . TONY. You wonderfully semi-stoic softie, thinking your feelings and experiences aren't worth talking about or sharing. I think the character development in this book was also a cut above book 1, which makes sense. Daniel is older and more established; he does have realizations, but his life wasn't as upended as Tony's is.
Also, I must give five stars for the aspect of managing a sprawling cast of characters in a way that felt deft and not pure chaos. The chaos of particular moments is well described, but it never felt like I was lost in a sea of names that I had no reference for.
I don't know if the author plans to continue in this series, but I wouldn't mind a book about Colette . . . or Gianna . . . honestly, I'd take a book about any of the side characters. However, I will add any future books by S.B. Barnes to my priority TBR.
Thanks to GRR for the advanced reader copy! It got me to read the first book that I purchased last year, and I found some new favorites.
While the first book follows Daniel, this one focuses on Tony, and I thought it was a wonderful choice to give us insights to his experience of their relationship. I don't think I've read an experience with 'coming out' (quotations for various reasons) quite like Tony's, but it felt entirely natural. He's never made any declarative statements, but his friends have known for a while, and his family has recently figured it out. He's not trying to hide it, staying over at Daniel's most nights, but feeling like he's still sneaking around a bit.
The mysteries aren't the strongest part of this series; however, this one was still compelling (my bloodshot eyes can attest), and that aspect felt a little bit more assured than the first book. (Again, this is not meant as shade; I gave the first book the same rating, this one just felt slightly enhanced.)
I am mainly here for the feels, and Tony . . . TONY. You wonderfully semi-stoic softie, thinking your feelings and experiences aren't worth talking about or sharing. I think the character development in this book was also a cut above book 1, which makes sense. Daniel is older and more established; he does have realizations, but his life wasn't as upended as Tony's is.
Also, I must give five stars for the aspect of managing a sprawling cast of characters in a way that felt deft and not pure chaos. The chaos of particular moments is well described, but it never felt like I was lost in a sea of names that I had no reference for.
I don't know if the author plans to continue in this series, but I wouldn't mind a book about Colette . . . or Gianna . . . honestly, I'd take a book about any of the side characters. However, I will add any future books by S.B. Barnes to my priority TBR.
Thanks to GRR for the advanced reader copy! It got me to read the first book that I purchased last year, and I found some new favorites.
February 17, 2025
3.5/5 - Not quite as good as book 1, unfortunately. I loved Tony’s POV and the exploration of his identity and his complicated feelings about coming out and his family. But the author used a lot of this book to explore Tony’s reaction to various events in book 1, which made it sometimes feel like a retread instead of a new book and which killed a lot of the momentum in the beginning. I wish the author had found a way to use the events of this book to explore those issues instead. Tony also often felt like a third wheel to this book’s events because Daniel was still the driving force behind the mystery investigation and Tony was absent for several key developments. And there were way too many side characters; I found Tony’s friend group uninteresting because they mostly felt like the “accepting/wacky queer friend group” trope instead of real people who were adding something to the story.
Overall, though, I love the author’s character work, which is far above average for the romance genre and which feels motivated by a genuine desire to explore different perspectives rather than just a way to check off popular trope boxes.
Overall, though, I love the author’s character work, which is far above average for the romance genre and which feels motivated by a genuine desire to explore different perspectives rather than just a way to check off popular trope boxes.
February 7, 2025
So it seems I’ll be buying all the books this author writes in the future.
4.5 stars. Rated up cause Tony. How I love him.
This book is this time from Tony’s point of view and it’s such a different perspective and incredibly well done. Tony has had problems with his sexuality/lack of interest about it for a long time and being in his POV while he is figuring out who he is and how to communicate it. My poor heart. Loved it so much.
I guessed the murderer but that didn’t make me enjoy it any less. I normally don’t like when characters do stupid shit, but this time when they did questionable things it was either from the right place (mistrust of the police for example), or the MCs knew full well it was stupid.
I think the highlight of this series for me so far are the two MCs. They are both so multi dimensional, defy stereotypes and are very human. Very recommended.
A couple of quotes below, mild spoilers so you are warned.
4.5 stars. Rated up cause Tony. How I love him.
This book is this time from Tony’s point of view and it’s such a different perspective and incredibly well done. Tony has had problems with his sexuality/lack of interest about it for a long time and being in his POV while he is figuring out who he is and how to communicate it. My poor heart. Loved it so much.
I guessed the murderer but that didn’t make me enjoy it any less. I normally don’t like when characters do stupid shit, but this time when they did questionable things it was either from the right place (mistrust of the police for example), or the MCs knew full well it was stupid.
I think the highlight of this series for me so far are the two MCs. They are both so multi dimensional, defy stereotypes and are very human. Very recommended.
A couple of quotes below, mild spoilers so you are warned.
Tony really, really doesn’t want to try explaining to anyone why he put a murderer and her kidnapping victim in his car with his sister. The only explanation is that it would have made his boyfriend sad to do anything else.
At least, Tony thinks Daniel is tenured. He’s tenure-track, whatever that means. The way he said it when he told Tony made it sound as if the college gifted him a baby unicorn.
Sex, sure, he was interested in sex on a conceptual level, but not with anyone in particular and definitely not with anyone he tried dating.
February 5, 2025
This is the second book in the Hudson Valley Murder Mysteries series. Reading the books in order is necessary.
****
In Second Chance, we are reunited with Daniel and Tony, almost a year after the murder of Daniel's colleague - an event that almost ended their relationship before it began, and altered the lives of so many people. This is the aftermath, and we see it from Tony's POV this time. It is a story about healing and moving on, and how not dealing with trauma can be just as damaging as the cause.
The return to Lobell College brings another murder, along with tension, heartbreak, and the fear that danger is always just around the corner. The murder mystery is central to the story but what truly makes this book shine is its emotional depth, especially through Tony's perspective.
Tony's internal struggle with his self-imposed pressure to come out and his confusion over how to label himself - or not - was incredibly well done. His journey feels raw and real, reflecting his emotional turmoil and the complexity of sexuality and acceptance. Anyone who has ever been in a relationship and has found themselves overwhelmed by their feelings will relate to Tony's internal monologue as he tries to wrap his head around being consumed by his desires, fears and devotion. Daniel and Tony's relationship is beautifully written, filled with tenderness, passion, a little bit of spice, and a vulnerability that makes every moment between them feel weighty and significant. Their connection feels genuine, layered with tension and the quiet heartbreak of unspoken words.
But what really resonated with me was how the story doesn't shy away from the hard stuff. Tony's struggle with his mental health as he tries to be a rock for everyone around him is raw and authentic. He knows he isn't handling his trauma well (read: at all) and his reluctant acceptance that he might need help is so real. His journey is incredibly relatable for anyone who has ever found themselves drowning in their own emotions.
The mystery isn't the central point of this story, though it helps keep it moving. But it's really about love and identity and family, and finding the courage to be honest with yourself.
[I received an advanced copy of this book. All reviews and ratings are my own.]
****
In Second Chance, we are reunited with Daniel and Tony, almost a year after the murder of Daniel's colleague - an event that almost ended their relationship before it began, and altered the lives of so many people. This is the aftermath, and we see it from Tony's POV this time. It is a story about healing and moving on, and how not dealing with trauma can be just as damaging as the cause.
The return to Lobell College brings another murder, along with tension, heartbreak, and the fear that danger is always just around the corner. The murder mystery is central to the story but what truly makes this book shine is its emotional depth, especially through Tony's perspective.
Tony's internal struggle with his self-imposed pressure to come out and his confusion over how to label himself - or not - was incredibly well done. His journey feels raw and real, reflecting his emotional turmoil and the complexity of sexuality and acceptance. Anyone who has ever been in a relationship and has found themselves overwhelmed by their feelings will relate to Tony's internal monologue as he tries to wrap his head around being consumed by his desires, fears and devotion. Daniel and Tony's relationship is beautifully written, filled with tenderness, passion, a little bit of spice, and a vulnerability that makes every moment between them feel weighty and significant. Their connection feels genuine, layered with tension and the quiet heartbreak of unspoken words.
But what really resonated with me was how the story doesn't shy away from the hard stuff. Tony's struggle with his mental health as he tries to be a rock for everyone around him is raw and authentic. He knows he isn't handling his trauma well (read: at all) and his reluctant acceptance that he might need help is so real. His journey is incredibly relatable for anyone who has ever found themselves drowning in their own emotions.
The mystery isn't the central point of this story, though it helps keep it moving. But it's really about love and identity and family, and finding the courage to be honest with yourself.
[I received an advanced copy of this book. All reviews and ratings are my own.]
February 8, 2025
A new academic year is beginning at Lobell College, just about a year after the death of a professor. Professor Daniel Rosenbaum steps in as dean and is taking an active part in counselling students. Students Gianna d’Angelo and Lily Peterson return to complete their studies after the death of the professor they both loved. Tony d’Angelo continues to work at the family garage, picking up extra work so his sister can complete her degree. Tony and Daniel are happy together but Tony feels as if he is struggling to be himself. He cannot find the words to discuss his relationship with Daniel with his family. Then the unthinkable happens. Another professor is murdered and it seems as if Tony and Daniel are pulled in again. Who knows if their relationship will survive all the stresses being put on it.
So much going on for Tony. He should be delighted with his relationship with Daniel and he is, but he is struggling with telling his parents he is gay, struggling to work extra hours to accommodate Gianna’s schedule and struggling to balance his time between home, work and Daniel. Daniel has extra duties now as a dean and he wants to do everything he can for the students he advises. Both men want to feel successful but think they are falling short. To work through everything, they need to communicate and have an open mind. This is a fantastic book and a great series. The story builds in intensity until you cannot put it down. Pick it up and be prepared to be captured.
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book. All opinions are my own.
So much going on for Tony. He should be delighted with his relationship with Daniel and he is, but he is struggling with telling his parents he is gay, struggling to work extra hours to accommodate Gianna’s schedule and struggling to balance his time between home, work and Daniel. Daniel has extra duties now as a dean and he wants to do everything he can for the students he advises. Both men want to feel successful but think they are falling short. To work through everything, they need to communicate and have an open mind. This is a fantastic book and a great series. The story builds in intensity until you cannot put it down. Pick it up and be prepared to be captured.
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book. All opinions are my own.
January 30, 2025
Murder has struck the university again, and this time, Daniel finds himself under the scrutiny of detectives. With yet another professor killed on campus, the mystery pulls you in, keeping you on edge as the pieces slowly come together. Who did it? And why?
Thankfully, Daniel isn’t alone in this. Tony and Colette are by his side, and together, they work to uncover the truth—while still dealing with the emotional aftermath of Mario’s murder months earlier. Their shared trauma lingers, adding depth to their characters as they navigate grief, suspicion, and the complexities of life after loss.
But Second Chance isn’t just about mystery and murder—it’s also a story of love, friendship, and found family. The relationships between Daniel, Tony, and Colette bring warmth to the narrative, reminding us that even in the darkest times, connection and support can make all the difference. The book is also filled with quirky, unusual characters that add layers of intrigue and entertainment to the unfolding drama.
If you enjoy academic mysteries, strong character dynamics, and a plot that keeps you guessing, this book delivers. The blend of suspense and heart makes Second Chance an engaging and satisfying read.
Thankfully, Daniel isn’t alone in this. Tony and Colette are by his side, and together, they work to uncover the truth—while still dealing with the emotional aftermath of Mario’s murder months earlier. Their shared trauma lingers, adding depth to their characters as they navigate grief, suspicion, and the complexities of life after loss.
But Second Chance isn’t just about mystery and murder—it’s also a story of love, friendship, and found family. The relationships between Daniel, Tony, and Colette bring warmth to the narrative, reminding us that even in the darkest times, connection and support can make all the difference. The book is also filled with quirky, unusual characters that add layers of intrigue and entertainment to the unfolding drama.
If you enjoy academic mysteries, strong character dynamics, and a plot that keeps you guessing, this book delivers. The blend of suspense and heart makes Second Chance an engaging and satisfying read.
January 21, 2025
Ren Faire knife, '07 Toyota Camry, hair ties & Worf, lamb saag, ripped chinos, jumper cables, IV drip, Jamie Oliver pan
You must've read Book 1 prior to reading 'Hudson Valley Murder Mysteries', Book 2. Book 2's storyline relies heavily on Book 1's storyline.
The majority of the characters are from Book 1, and are well-described and well-developed there. It's a completely different mystery and a few new characters are used. The MCs are still Professor Daniel Rosenbaum and auto mechanic Tony D'Angelo. Their relationship has morphed into familiarity and comfortableness.They still generate a lot of steam. There's much angst amongst the various characters.
This well-written book's imagery is richly descriptive and easily envisioned. There's not as much action and tension as Book 1. Intrigue and drama are the key elements. "Second Chance" is compelling and easy-to-read. The pages flew by and was over before I knew it. I greatly enjoyed this book and found the end satisfying. I hope there are more books for the series and in the pipeline. An easy and fervent recommend!
You must've read Book 1 prior to reading 'Hudson Valley Murder Mysteries', Book 2. Book 2's storyline relies heavily on Book 1's storyline.
The majority of the characters are from Book 1, and are well-described and well-developed there. It's a completely different mystery and a few new characters are used. The MCs are still Professor Daniel Rosenbaum and auto mechanic Tony D'Angelo. Their relationship has morphed into familiarity and comfortableness.They still generate a lot of steam. There's much angst amongst the various characters.
This well-written book's imagery is richly descriptive and easily envisioned. There's not as much action and tension as Book 1. Intrigue and drama are the key elements. "Second Chance" is compelling and easy-to-read. The pages flew by and was over before I knew it. I greatly enjoyed this book and found the end satisfying. I hope there are more books for the series and in the pipeline. An easy and fervent recommend!
February 6, 2025
In the follow-up novel, "Second Chance" by S.B. Barnes, we get to catch up with Daniel and Tony once again after the difficulties in the last book. This time, we see things from Tony's point of view, which gives us a deeper peek into his personal battles.
In this book, Tony deals with his own mental health problems while trying to help the people around him, and it's really easy to relate to him as he struggles to deal with his emotions.
The romance between Daniel and Tony is a central focus, and it's all about tenderness, passion and, yes, vulnerability. The story delves into the complexities of their relationship, including Tony's internal conflict with his sexuality and his journey of self-discovery.
There's a murder mystery plotline, too, but at the heart of "Second Chance" is the beautiful exploration of love, identity, and the courage to be honest with oneself. It's a poignant and emotionally resonant story that will resonate with readers who have faced their own personal struggles.
In this book, Tony deals with his own mental health problems while trying to help the people around him, and it's really easy to relate to him as he struggles to deal with his emotions.
The romance between Daniel and Tony is a central focus, and it's all about tenderness, passion and, yes, vulnerability. The story delves into the complexities of their relationship, including Tony's internal conflict with his sexuality and his journey of self-discovery.
There's a murder mystery plotline, too, but at the heart of "Second Chance" is the beautiful exploration of love, identity, and the courage to be honest with oneself. It's a poignant and emotionally resonant story that will resonate with readers who have faced their own personal struggles.
February 6, 2025
Can probably be read as a standalone, but best read after book 1 due to connecting events and all the familiar characters that were introduced there. We do get reminded of who some characters are (which I'm grateful for, because I already forgot), but some aren't re-introduced with their roles/relationships to the main characters, so best to read book 1.
The last villain seemed like they needed help from the beginning and I got so frustrated at some of the MCs for keeping information to themselves. I get that they distrust the police after what happened in book 1, but how they all went about trying to solve the murder and keeping evidence from the police had me so frustrated.
One thing I loved in this second book is that Daniel and Tony's lives are starting to get mixed together well, like their friends, and then their families. All the scenes of everyone gather or coming together in times of crises were so wholesome and heartwarming (even though some were due to bad news) but it was so nice to see their relationship surpass another level and how everyone got along really well.
There is a small typo around 61% when This does not affect my review and I still thoroughly enjoyed the mystery and romance of this book. I cannot wait for what this author puts out next!
The last villain seemed like they needed help from the beginning and I got so frustrated at some of the MCs for keeping information to themselves. I get that they distrust the police after what happened in book 1, but how they all went about trying to solve the murder and keeping evidence from the police had me so frustrated.
One thing I loved in this second book is that Daniel and Tony's lives are starting to get mixed together well, like their friends, and then their families. All the scenes of everyone gather or coming together in times of crises were so wholesome and heartwarming (even though some were due to bad news) but it was so nice to see their relationship surpass another level and how everyone got along really well.
There is a small typo around 61% when This does not affect my review and I still thoroughly enjoyed the mystery and romance of this book. I cannot wait for what this author puts out next!
February 7, 2025
3.5⭐️
I like the first book and this one is good as well. I don’t think I enjoyed it quite as much, but I do think the characters are well done. I appreciate dimensional characters and Daniel and Tony are definitely that, layered, flawed, and even sometimes quite lovely. I like them together, and loved how much they progressed as a couple. The mystery side of the plot wasn’t my favorite. It had too much amateur sleuthing for my taste and was kind of a mess by the resolution. Daniel’s also has some shockingly bad decision making throughout the book which was pretty aggravating. Even considering his guilt from the events in first book, his actions didn’t make sense. But, the relationship is authentic and the characters are engaging, so I really enjoyed that part of the book. Hopefully there’s more in store for these two, they are a strong couple with lots of potential.
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book
I like the first book and this one is good as well. I don’t think I enjoyed it quite as much, but I do think the characters are well done. I appreciate dimensional characters and Daniel and Tony are definitely that, layered, flawed, and even sometimes quite lovely. I like them together, and loved how much they progressed as a couple. The mystery side of the plot wasn’t my favorite. It had too much amateur sleuthing for my taste and was kind of a mess by the resolution. Daniel’s also has some shockingly bad decision making throughout the book which was pretty aggravating. Even considering his guilt from the events in first book, his actions didn’t make sense. But, the relationship is authentic and the characters are engaging, so I really enjoyed that part of the book. Hopefully there’s more in store for these two, they are a strong couple with lots of potential.
I voluntarily reviewed a complimentary copy of this book
December 17, 2024
I liked book one of this... series? Duology so far, I suppose. And I was glad to have an opportunity to read book two. I'd probably have enjoyed it more if I'd read book one more recently (though the author did a good job providing enough background to make things make sense without info-dumping the whole thing).
I thought the characters (MCs and supporting cast) were very well written, and the plot moved along well. I did (uncharacteristically for me) figure out who the murderer was early on, which made some of the plot frustrating, but I still enjoyed watching the reveal play out. I'll look forward to reading more from this author.
My thanks to Gay Romance Reviews for an advance copy of this book.
I thought the characters (MCs and supporting cast) were very well written, and the plot moved along well. I did (uncharacteristically for me) figure out who the murderer was early on, which made some of the plot frustrating, but I still enjoyed watching the reveal play out. I'll look forward to reading more from this author.
My thanks to Gay Romance Reviews for an advance copy of this book.
December 23, 2024
The book is closer to a 4 than a 3.
I received the book from Gay Romance Reviews for the promise of an objective review. I had not read this author previously so obviously had not read the first book in the series which I did not feel to be a disadvantage. The plot can stand on its own and enough of the year-ago events are brought up that one is not left with confusion.
The characters of both Tony and Daniel are well-developed. Whether Tony's insecurities arise from events the prior year is doubtful in my mind as I have a feeling they stem from before.
As for the plot, it develops smoothly but I figured out the murderer well before events unfolded.
I will look forward to further books by this author - it gave me a nice combination of mystery and MM romance.
I received the book from Gay Romance Reviews for the promise of an objective review. I had not read this author previously so obviously had not read the first book in the series which I did not feel to be a disadvantage. The plot can stand on its own and enough of the year-ago events are brought up that one is not left with confusion.
The characters of both Tony and Daniel are well-developed. Whether Tony's insecurities arise from events the prior year is doubtful in my mind as I have a feeling they stem from before.
As for the plot, it develops smoothly but I figured out the murderer well before events unfolded.
I will look forward to further books by this author - it gave me a nice combination of mystery and MM romance.
February 5, 2025
I would like to thank GRR for the opportunity to read and review this ARC.
Yeahhhhhh maybe it's because I'm Canadian and I'm feeling really bristly rn, but this was just too much "obstruction of justice" for me. This was all kinds of unstable and I'm still feeling very uncool about Daniel's version of "helping". His inane reasoning went hard. And I truly felt for Tony...but then when DOING the right thing did not happen WILLINGLY AND BY CHOICE, i came back into my body.
These college kids are 20+ yrs old and have parents. If Gianna was MY sister i would have dragged her by the ponytail. I'm honestly tired of feeling like this. Discernment and diplomacy should not be rare examples of right action...even in my MM Romances.
So yeah, no. This was just not for me.
Yeahhhhhh maybe it's because I'm Canadian and I'm feeling really bristly rn, but this was just too much "obstruction of justice" for me. This was all kinds of unstable and I'm still feeling very uncool about Daniel's version of "helping". His inane reasoning went hard. And I truly felt for Tony...but then when DOING the right thing did not happen WILLINGLY AND BY CHOICE, i came back into my body.
These college kids are 20+ yrs old and have parents. If Gianna was MY sister i would have dragged her by the ponytail. I'm honestly tired of feeling like this. Discernment and diplomacy should not be rare examples of right action...even in my MM Romances.
So yeah, no. This was just not for me.
February 6, 2025
What a great follow up book to book one. I love that we are reunited with Tony and Daniel but this time we get Tony's perspective. Like the first book a murder happens on campus where Daniel works but murder is not what moves the story. What moves the story is the continued relationship between these two, the tension Tony feels by not be out, and the lingering trauma and aftermath from the first murder in book one. A great realistic portrayal of mental health and suffering from trauma (especially Tony) while trying to maintain a relationship. Lots of trigger points so be aware but at its core it is about hope, recovery, accepting oneself and love. I did receive an ARC and leave this honest review.
February 6, 2025
The first book was mostly about Daniel's ill advised crime solving exploits and this one is about Tony's. That just means they are clearly perfect for each other. Tony also gave such a sincere insight into his mind and heart. He's clearly so gone on Daniel that its adorable but we also get to see him healing from the trauma of last year and coming out.
The murder mystery, somewhat like the first one, is sad. The murderer are broken people making bad choices. Although this murder's consequences were much further reaching than the first.
Long story short, this series takes place in the worst college in America that is a hot bed of incredibly depressing murders. And a hot crime solving professor.
The murder mystery, somewhat like the first one, is sad. The murderer are broken people making bad choices. Although this murder's consequences were much further reaching than the first.
Long story short, this series takes place in the worst college in America that is a hot bed of incredibly depressing murders. And a hot crime solving professor.
February 6, 2025
The love story between Tony and Daniel proceeds very well, despiteTony having to face a lot of struggles, since he’s working a lot to help his sister, and he’s having problems in coming out to his parents.
Daniel is working at the university as a professor, and they both are trying to recover from the past events, but a new mistery comes to unsettle their lives, and they will have to solve it, like they previously did months before with the other one.
I loved this second book so much as I loved the first one. The plot, and the mistery, is well constructed, and I loved the way the relationship between the two main characters takes a step forward, leading them to the place they deserve.
Recommended if you like love stories and misteries.
Daniel is working at the university as a professor, and they both are trying to recover from the past events, but a new mistery comes to unsettle their lives, and they will have to solve it, like they previously did months before with the other one.
I loved this second book so much as I loved the first one. The plot, and the mistery, is well constructed, and I loved the way the relationship between the two main characters takes a step forward, leading them to the place they deserve.
Recommended if you like love stories and misteries.
February 13, 2025
I enjoyed this academic mystery as much as, if not more than the first one, primarily because of Tony. I love that he finally finds the words to come out to his family and most of all, I love the way he is with Daniel. Daniel is very much still analyzing his actions from the first book and when crime strikes again he can't seem to get out of his own head and pay any true attention to the emotional tone of situations and how things including his statements and actions are affecting others. Tony supports and understanding him, but he also doesn't excuse him or finally hold him accountable and make him see reality. These two are very good together and for each other and that shows admirably in this story.
January 23, 2025
Prepare to find yourself reading well into the night!
You absolutely must read book 1, Heart First, in this series before Second Chance.
Lobell College is an institution of learning...and also danger.
Daniel, dean of the English Department, gets more than he bargains for when he begins advising students.
Especially following the actions in the previous book!
Tony, a mechanic in a neighboring town, becomes embroiled in the college, and even more so with Daniel.
Their relationship grows as do the bodies and clues.
I received an ARC from GRR.
I recommend this series and eagerly await the future installments, as well as the rest of the books SB will hopefully write.
You absolutely must read book 1, Heart First, in this series before Second Chance.
Lobell College is an institution of learning...and also danger.
Daniel, dean of the English Department, gets more than he bargains for when he begins advising students.
Especially following the actions in the previous book!
Tony, a mechanic in a neighboring town, becomes embroiled in the college, and even more so with Daniel.
Their relationship grows as do the bodies and clues.
I received an ARC from GRR.
I recommend this series and eagerly await the future installments, as well as the rest of the books SB will hopefully write.
February 6, 2025
Book 2 of the Hudson Valley Murder Mysteries, I did not get the chance to read book1. However, minus the mentions of the incidents in the previous volume, I didn't feel lost and learned just enough to know that the characters experienced enough to have to adapt and support each other. Tony is very relatable as a person and I feel for his concerns regarding his relationship with Daniel. The balance of telling a story with a sizable cast is wonderful. And, while there is a mystery about, you follow the progress with family, love and personal growth. A great read anyone could enjoy who's looking for this kind of blend.
June 1, 2025
Everything I said in my review for the first book holds true for this book. My hope for more action and less talk remains unfulfilled. The characters (main and secondaries) are better defined so I have not lost interest in them at least. Not all murder mystery series based in/around educational institutions can maintain interesting plots for long ... some do (e.g. Ashe's First Quarto books, Zubro's Tom Mason & Scott Carpenter books just barely!) with others - not so much (the Creighton Manor Mysteries and Lev Raphael's Nick Hoffmann series); I not convinced this series will last the distance for me.
February 4, 2025
Tony and Daniel are back in this second book of the series. As Tony and Daniel are settling in together, mostly living together, Daniel has a colleague stabbed at work. Once again, Tony and Daniel try to solve the crime with the help of their friends and Tony's sister, Gianni, It's a convoluted trail with them trying to protect students and family. I love Tony and Daniel together, Tony's protectiveness and Daniel being so empathetic. I hope there is another book with them. I received a copy of this book through Gay Romance Reviews and this is my voluntary opinion.
February 8, 2025
Exciting, didn't see this coming. Tony and Daniel are still working on recovering from the events of the last school year. Tony is still existing not being open and honest about his true self with family and friends. They both have a few communication issues, but they mean well. There is another new mystery that challenges them and facilitates their growth. This story is about trust, self discovery, friendship, love and accepting one's truth. Nicely done! I received an ARC and am voluntarily leaving a review.
January 30, 2025
Yet another professor is murdered on campus, and Daniel has caught the eye of the detectives. This mystery adventure keeps you wondering and guessing who did it. Also we can’t forget Tony or Colette helping Daniel figure it out. All three are still working through the trauma of Mario’s murder several month previous. Along with the mystery is love, friendship, found family and plenty of unusual characters.
February 4, 2025
This was another good book by author SB Barnes. The mystery isn't as important as the characters in this book and I enjoyed seeing more than Daniels perspective, especially with some of Daniels feeling and actions. Tony is more focused on in this book. The growing relationship between Daniel and Tony is great. They feel "real" together.
This is a series that would best be read in order.
I received a copy of this book and this is my honest opinion.
This is a series that would best be read in order.
I received a copy of this book and this is my honest opinion.
February 6, 2025
I enjoyed this second installment a lot. We really get into the realistic struggles for Tony and Daniel as they build a life together. This is Tony's POV, and I was all in for him. We experience his insecurities and his worries about what others would think about his being gay, especially his family. He is trying to keep things normal at the mechanic shop and with his niece. We also get a side mystery and a surprising amount of nice intimate times with our established couple!
February 8, 2025
This is the second book in the Hudson Valley Murder Mysteries series by S.B.Barnes. I would recommend reading the books in order.
Tony and Daniel are great characters, and this book is told from Tony’s POV.
This book is well balanced between the romantic storyline and the mystery storyline.
The mystery isn't the central point of this story, though it helps keep it moving. But it's really about love and identity and family, and finding the courage to be honest with yourself.
Tony and Daniel are great characters, and this book is told from Tony’s POV.
This book is well balanced between the romantic storyline and the mystery storyline.
The mystery isn't the central point of this story, though it helps keep it moving. But it's really about love and identity and family, and finding the courage to be honest with yourself.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 44 reviews