"His Other Life," by Anna E. Collins, was SUCH a good and addictive book. I listened to this one, and was glad that different readers narrated the parts for male and female characters and that the voices were all different, making it easy to know which character was speaking. That is not always the case. I would have rated this a 5 star read had there been fewer coincidences and had some of the twists been less obvious to me. Still, it was so much fun to read, and very difficult to pace myself. I had to keep going from beginning to end until it was all nicely tied up. This was a 4.5 star rating, but for purposes of Goodreads, I am rounding down to 4. I did figure out a few of the twists, but one big one kept me guessing until a chapter or two before it was revealed, rather than from the get go.
This is the story of a young widow who has spent two years blaming herself for her husband's death in an accident in which the wife, Isla, was driving. She woke up in the hospital, having been, technically, dead herself, for a short while, only to learn her beloved husband, Jonah, had died. Two years later she is still trying to get a grip on her life. She has been staying with her mother, but now her mother wants to sell their home, and Isla's employer, the university where she was an art history professor, wants to know when she will be back. She cannot remember anything about the accident, and wonders why she was driving, rather than Jonah, who normally drove when they were together. She will set out on a quest with a 90 year old man she met through her volunteering for Meals on Wheels, in order to figure out what truly happened two years earlier on that fateful, and tragic, day. In that search, she finds a note in her husband's coat pocket that says, simply, "Call Gemma." Who was Gemma and why had she been calling Jonah at the hotel where Jonah and Isla were celebrating their anniversary and were talking about starting a family? She makes a few other unsettling discoveries along the way. Her team grows when two others join her and the elderly Maverick in their search to solve the mystery of what really happened in that deadly accident.
The author lets us see, from the earliest pages whom Gemma is, and how she is connected to Jonah. She was such a sweet character, with no ill will, but a lot of foolish naïveté. It was impossible to hate her, or really any of the characters, even those who might be considered the villains of the tale.
Maverick's story was secondary story, but somehow connected to everything else that was happening. We learn of letters he wrote to the love of his life during the 1950s when he was recovering from injuries suffered during the Korean War. A young nurse had held his hand and been so kind to him that he never forgot her, so their history was a story within a story that added another layer to this really wonderful novel. It was riveting, for sure. I just wish the author had kept the secrets more tightly hidden, and had not revealed one final, highly unbelievable coincidence in the end.