What do you think?
Rate this book
The Audacious Sisterhood of Smoke & Fire #1
The Mysteries of Pendowar Hall
She vowed to solve a murder.
Now she’s in danger of losing her heart … and her very life.
Diana Taylor, a bright and spirited governess who has sworn off love, is sent to Pendowar Hall in Cornwall to honor a pledge. She vows to teach her godmother’s niece and to find out who was behind the suspicious death of the former baronet. But her new charge is also a mystery, as is the man who inherited the ancient coastal estate—the charismatic but brooding Royal Navy Captain William Fallbrook, who is home on leave to recover from an injury.
As Diana investigates, her feelings for the enigmatic Captain Fallbrook blossom, and her guard goes up. Pendowar Hall is brimming with secrets as well as a frightening legend about a Mermaid’s Curse. What is behind the mysterious footsteps in the night? Is there more to the story of the tragic deaths of the former baronet’s wife and son? What secrets is Captain Fallbrook hiding? Can she trust the man who has stolen her heart?
He looks to be entranced by Diana, even though her determination to dig up the past seems to get on his last nerve. Soon, Diana’s bold quest to unmask his uncle’s killer leads her into terrifying danger, for someone is determined to end her life before she can discover the truth.
Read in Kindle Unlimited!
The Audacious Sisterhood of Smoke & Fire
Book 1 - The Mysteries of Pendowar Hall
Book 2 - The Secrets of Thorndale Manor
Book 3 - Danger at Darkmoor Park
Now she’s in danger of losing her heart … and her very life.
Diana Taylor, a bright and spirited governess who has sworn off love, is sent to Pendowar Hall in Cornwall to honor a pledge. She vows to teach her godmother’s niece and to find out who was behind the suspicious death of the former baronet. But her new charge is also a mystery, as is the man who inherited the ancient coastal estate—the charismatic but brooding Royal Navy Captain William Fallbrook, who is home on leave to recover from an injury.
As Diana investigates, her feelings for the enigmatic Captain Fallbrook blossom, and her guard goes up. Pendowar Hall is brimming with secrets as well as a frightening legend about a Mermaid’s Curse. What is behind the mysterious footsteps in the night? Is there more to the story of the tragic deaths of the former baronet’s wife and son? What secrets is Captain Fallbrook hiding? Can she trust the man who has stolen her heart?
He looks to be entranced by Diana, even though her determination to dig up the past seems to get on his last nerve. Soon, Diana’s bold quest to unmask his uncle’s killer leads her into terrifying danger, for someone is determined to end her life before she can discover the truth.
Read in Kindle Unlimited!
The Audacious Sisterhood of Smoke & Fire
Book 1 - The Mysteries of Pendowar Hall
Book 2 - The Secrets of Thorndale Manor
Book 3 - Danger at Darkmoor Park
330 pages, Kindle Edition
First published February 22, 2025
About the author
Syrie James
23 books997 followersSyrie James writes about bold, smart women who defy the odds and overcome daunting obstacles to achieve a cherished creative dream, find truth and justice, or help people in need, often finding love along the way. She is the international, USA TODAY, and Amazon bestselling author of many novels of historical fiction, mystery, romance, and YA which have been published in 21 languages.
Syrie's Historical Murder Mystery series, The Audacious Sisterhood of Smoke & Fire, is set in Victorian England and features sister sleuths who will stop at nothing to uncover the truth. The series includes the Amazon bestseller "The Mysteries of Pendowar Hall," "The Secrets of Thorndale Manor" and the upcoming "Danger at Darkmoor Park."
Los Angeles Magazine dubbed Syrie the “queen of nineteenth century re-imaginings.” Her novel “The Lost Memoirs of Jane Austen” sold at auction to HarperCollins and became an international bestseller, and was named Best New Fiction by Regency World Magazine. Her passion for love stories and the paranormal led to her critically acclaimed “Dracula, My Love,” “Nocturne,” and the YA series “Forbidden.” Her enduring love of all things English and 19th century led to her Amazon bestselling Dare to Defy Historical Romance series.
Syrie’s books have received starred reviews from Publisher’s Weekly, hit many Best of the Year lists, been designated as Library Journal Editor’s Picks of the Year, and won numerous awards including the national Audiobook Audie Award for Romance and the Women’s National Book Association Great Group Read (“The Secret Diaries of Charlotte Bronte”), and Barnes and Noble’s Romantic Read of the Week and Bookbub’s Best Snowbound Romance (“Nocturne”).
Syrie is also a WGA member with numerous scripts sold to film and television, and a published playwright, actress, and stage director.
Find Syrie at:
syriejames.com,
Facebook,
Instagram
Syrie's Historical Murder Mystery series, The Audacious Sisterhood of Smoke & Fire, is set in Victorian England and features sister sleuths who will stop at nothing to uncover the truth. The series includes the Amazon bestseller "The Mysteries of Pendowar Hall," "The Secrets of Thorndale Manor" and the upcoming "Danger at Darkmoor Park."
Los Angeles Magazine dubbed Syrie the “queen of nineteenth century re-imaginings.” Her novel “The Lost Memoirs of Jane Austen” sold at auction to HarperCollins and became an international bestseller, and was named Best New Fiction by Regency World Magazine. Her passion for love stories and the paranormal led to her critically acclaimed “Dracula, My Love,” “Nocturne,” and the YA series “Forbidden.” Her enduring love of all things English and 19th century led to her Amazon bestselling Dare to Defy Historical Romance series.
Syrie’s books have received starred reviews from Publisher’s Weekly, hit many Best of the Year lists, been designated as Library Journal Editor’s Picks of the Year, and won numerous awards including the national Audiobook Audie Award for Romance and the Women’s National Book Association Great Group Read (“The Secret Diaries of Charlotte Bronte”), and Barnes and Noble’s Romantic Read of the Week and Bookbub’s Best Snowbound Romance (“Nocturne”).
Syrie is also a WGA member with numerous scripts sold to film and television, and a published playwright, actress, and stage director.
Find Syrie at:
syriejames.com,
Facebook,
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 79 reviews
January 26, 2025
Syrie James is an author whose books I read and loved way before bookstagram. I was enthralled with this gothic tale from the very beginning and it had me on the edge of my seat until the end. The book is filled with clever nods to Jane Eyre, but is entirely a unique tale of gothic suspense all its own. This was such a satisfying reading experience! Great reveals and an intriguing mystery! I’m eager to read the next book in this promising series.
Good to Know:
A couple of instances of mild profanity, reference to infidelity, kisses only romance
Thank you, Dragonblade Publishing for a complimentary copy of the book via NetGalley. All opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.
Good to Know:
A couple of instances of mild profanity, reference to infidelity, kisses only romance
Thank you, Dragonblade Publishing for a complimentary copy of the book via NetGalley. All opinions expressed in this review are entirely my own.
February 19, 2025
A brooding manor on the Cornwall coast, dark family secrets, a wild young girl, a sea captain who may have murdered to inherit, and a governess sent to discover truths that someone would kill to keep unknown fill the latest tale from the talented pen of Syrie James. I’ve long been familiar with Syrie James’ work and saw the announcements of her latest series project that would give tribute to some of the best of romantic suspense from the past. There was no way I was going to miss this.
Mysteries of Pendowar Hall is the first of a series featuring the oldest sister in a trio of amateur sleuths by night and clever governesses by day. Diana goes on behalf of her dying godmother to discover the truth of her brother’s death. The report that it was suicide isn’t just abhorrent to her, but she knows that he’d never do such a thing.
So, taking advantage of the new heir, Captain Falbrook’s need to find a governess for his wayward young cousin, Diana arrives to discover what she can. Her charge has the reputation of being a dunce at school matters and recalcitrant and wild enough that no governess ever stayed long. Diana is no green girl and has quite a bit of experience. She grows to suspect the girl’s issues with schooling stem from something other than a rebellious, spoiled character. The estate is a brooding old place right on a coast notorious for its smuggling history and there are plenty who tell of the lore and legends of the area including a curse on the family for anyone who falls in love. Diana can’t disdain the legends too much because she herself has heard mysterious footsteps in the night and the lights that shine in the tower.
Even as she attempts to solve the current mysteries of the place and encounters people who give her hints toward the right trail, she finds herself slowly thawing into a friendship with both Captain Falbrook and his cousin. In fact, she realizes after a time that she might be getting tender feelings and that wouldn’t do since she’s the governess- and he may still be a murderer. The longer she is at Pendowar Hall; the more she thinks her godmother’s hunch about her late brother is right. If only she can find his journals… and keep surviving the accidents that befall her.
The Mysteries of Pendowar Hall was all I was anticipating. It is a wonderful tribute to Jane Eyre with several clearly familiar moments, but also hearkens to my favorite childhood romantic suspenses by Victoria Holt, Mary Stewart, Daphne du Maurier, and Phyllis Whitney. Diana is observant and clever. She’s got a couple allies counting the butler and the village vicar, but they can’t know exactly what she’s poking into. She’s working on her own so I was practically biting my nails a few times with then danger was palpable and the atmosphere of unknown menace was thick. I had my finger on a few people, but I was well and far off.
Loved seeing Diana start to heal from her guilt over her mother's death and the captain open up about his own guilt. And, that was heartwarming seeing Diana make friends with her charge and figure out the girl had a disability (modern day dyslexia) and figured out how to help her strategize for it.
All in all, I thought it abso-fab and can’t wait to get the next installment with her sisters at their mysterious ghostly estate where they are starting a school. If you love sweet historical romance combined with classical-style suspense, put this one on your reading list.
I rec'd an eARC via NetGalley to read in exchange for an honest review.
My full review will post at Caffeinated Reviewer 4.23.25.
Mysteries of Pendowar Hall is the first of a series featuring the oldest sister in a trio of amateur sleuths by night and clever governesses by day. Diana goes on behalf of her dying godmother to discover the truth of her brother’s death. The report that it was suicide isn’t just abhorrent to her, but she knows that he’d never do such a thing.
So, taking advantage of the new heir, Captain Falbrook’s need to find a governess for his wayward young cousin, Diana arrives to discover what she can. Her charge has the reputation of being a dunce at school matters and recalcitrant and wild enough that no governess ever stayed long. Diana is no green girl and has quite a bit of experience. She grows to suspect the girl’s issues with schooling stem from something other than a rebellious, spoiled character. The estate is a brooding old place right on a coast notorious for its smuggling history and there are plenty who tell of the lore and legends of the area including a curse on the family for anyone who falls in love. Diana can’t disdain the legends too much because she herself has heard mysterious footsteps in the night and the lights that shine in the tower.
Even as she attempts to solve the current mysteries of the place and encounters people who give her hints toward the right trail, she finds herself slowly thawing into a friendship with both Captain Falbrook and his cousin. In fact, she realizes after a time that she might be getting tender feelings and that wouldn’t do since she’s the governess- and he may still be a murderer. The longer she is at Pendowar Hall; the more she thinks her godmother’s hunch about her late brother is right. If only she can find his journals… and keep surviving the accidents that befall her.
The Mysteries of Pendowar Hall was all I was anticipating. It is a wonderful tribute to Jane Eyre with several clearly familiar moments, but also hearkens to my favorite childhood romantic suspenses by Victoria Holt, Mary Stewart, Daphne du Maurier, and Phyllis Whitney. Diana is observant and clever. She’s got a couple allies counting the butler and the village vicar, but they can’t know exactly what she’s poking into. She’s working on her own so I was practically biting my nails a few times with then danger was palpable and the atmosphere of unknown menace was thick. I had my finger on a few people, but I was well and far off.
Loved seeing Diana start to heal from her guilt over her mother's death and the captain open up about his own guilt. And, that was heartwarming seeing Diana make friends with her charge and figure out the girl had a disability (modern day dyslexia) and figured out how to help her strategize for it.
All in all, I thought it abso-fab and can’t wait to get the next installment with her sisters at their mysterious ghostly estate where they are starting a school. If you love sweet historical romance combined with classical-style suspense, put this one on your reading list.
I rec'd an eARC via NetGalley to read in exchange for an honest review.
My full review will post at Caffeinated Reviewer 4.23.25.
March 24, 2025
TITLE: The Mysteries of Pendowar Hall: A Victorian Historical Mystery (The Audacious Sisterhood of Smoke & Fire Book 1)
AUTHOR: Syrie James
PUB DATE: 02.22.2025
She vowed to solve a murder.
Now she’s in danger of losing her heart … and her very life.
If there was a book I have more copies and editions of, it would be Jane Eyre. Reading The Mysteries of Pendowar Hall by new to me
Author Syrie James, wrote a great gothic mystery that I just enjoyed. The story is clever, and I enjoyed the different characters,
while following along the unsuspecting twists and turns.
I love reading the first book in the series, and this book hooked me right away.
AUTHOR: Syrie James
PUB DATE: 02.22.2025
She vowed to solve a murder.
Now she’s in danger of losing her heart … and her very life.
If there was a book I have more copies and editions of, it would be Jane Eyre. Reading The Mysteries of Pendowar Hall by new to me
Author Syrie James, wrote a great gothic mystery that I just enjoyed. The story is clever, and I enjoyed the different characters,
while following along the unsuspecting twists and turns.
I love reading the first book in the series, and this book hooked me right away.
May 7, 2025
I just really like Cornwall as a setting. Also, the dyslexia representation was unexpected, but so good! The dramatic pacing was a bit uneven towards the end of the book, but overall enjoyable read.
March 22, 2025
Jane Eyre is one of my all time favorites & I absolutely loved this romantic historical fiction loosely based on the classic story. Filled with mystery, secret rooms, a challenging pupil, a mermaid’s curse, & a handsome but wounded captain, this gothic adventure had me quickly turning the pages. The Mysteries of Pendowar Hall is my first book by Syrie James & can’t wait to read more!
Diana Taylor’s on a mission to solve a mystery. Her godmother believes her nephew was murdered & has sent Diana to Pendowar Hall as a governess to her niece to discover the truth. But, the new baronet Captain William Fallbrook proves an enticing enigma who’s on leave from the navy recovering from an injury. Her fifteen year old pupil also proves a challenge as she tries to find ways to help her learn. As Diana, investigates the death of the previous baronet, she finds a household surrounded by secrecy & a curse that could be her undoing.
I loved this book! Diana’s an intelligent, driven heroine who loves reading especially the newly published Jane Eyre. I loved how dedicated she was to Emma to find ways to help her with dyslexia. William is the brooding, taciturn hero who’s a fitting likeness of Mr. Rochester. I loved how mysterious he was & I honestly wasn’t sure if he was the villain or hero at first.
The mystery was amazing with a gothic, atmospheric setting complete with footsteps in the night, hidden rooms, & plenty of red herrings. I was on the edge of my seat as Diana searches for clues. The villain ended up being somewhat of a surprise with many twists and turns along the way. I loved all the clever nods to Jane Eyre.
Highly recommend this amazing start to a new series! Can’t wait to read the next book! This is a kisses only historical gothic romance. I received an advanced complimentary copy from the publisher & author but also purchased through Kindle Unlimited. All opinions are my own & voluntarily provided.
Diana Taylor’s on a mission to solve a mystery. Her godmother believes her nephew was murdered & has sent Diana to Pendowar Hall as a governess to her niece to discover the truth. But, the new baronet Captain William Fallbrook proves an enticing enigma who’s on leave from the navy recovering from an injury. Her fifteen year old pupil also proves a challenge as she tries to find ways to help her learn. As Diana, investigates the death of the previous baronet, she finds a household surrounded by secrecy & a curse that could be her undoing.
I loved this book! Diana’s an intelligent, driven heroine who loves reading especially the newly published Jane Eyre. I loved how dedicated she was to Emma to find ways to help her with dyslexia. William is the brooding, taciturn hero who’s a fitting likeness of Mr. Rochester. I loved how mysterious he was & I honestly wasn’t sure if he was the villain or hero at first.
The mystery was amazing with a gothic, atmospheric setting complete with footsteps in the night, hidden rooms, & plenty of red herrings. I was on the edge of my seat as Diana searches for clues. The villain ended up being somewhat of a surprise with many twists and turns along the way. I loved all the clever nods to Jane Eyre.
Highly recommend this amazing start to a new series! Can’t wait to read the next book! This is a kisses only historical gothic romance. I received an advanced complimentary copy from the publisher & author but also purchased through Kindle Unlimited. All opinions are my own & voluntarily provided.
January 28, 2025
This was definitely more mystery and slice of life than Romance, I would actually say it was quite light on the Romance but I enjoyed this book a lot. This reminds me of one my favorite books I read as a child (I never read Jane Erye so I cannot make the comparisons there). It was defiantly a little spooky with the legend and I think the final chapter set up the remainder of the series as we didn't really see her sisters till then. But the mystery was interesting, the spooky things happening around the castle had me nervous. I liked seeing how much Diana really loved teaching and how much thought she put in to finding the right way to get through to her charge, it was endearing. Our Captain was in the book but really very much a secondary character and this was single POV so we never really saw his side except when it was told to Diana. I liked this book a lot and I hope the next comes out soon.
March 24, 2025
This book was so good! With its great cast of characters, suspenseful Gothic mystery, and nods to Jane Eyre, I couldn’t put down!
The setting was wonderfully atmospheric with an ancient estate by the sea. There are secret rooms and passageways, mysterious footsteps heard late at night, and a legendary curse involving a mermaid. The mystery kept me guessing to the very end, and even though I thought I had it figured out, the end totally threw me.
I loved the relationship between Diana and her student, Emma, and the romance between William and Diana was lovely, but it’s secondary to the mystery.
Diana Taylor, a spirited governess, is sent to Pendowar Hall to teach her godmother’s niece and uncover the truth behind the former baronet’s suspicious death. There, she meets Captain William Fallbrook, a charismatic but brooding Royal Navy officer.
As Diana investigates Pendowar Hall, she uncovers secrets, including a Mermaid’s Curse, and develops feelings for Captain Fallbrook, but can she trust him?
Diana’s quest to uncover the truth about his uncle’s killer puts her in danger, and he seems torn between fascination and frustration with her determination.
This is the first book in the author’s ‘Audacious Sisterhood of Smoke & Fire’ series, and I can’t wait for the next book!
Thanks to the publisher and Austenprose PR for a copy. All opinions expressed her completely my own.
The setting was wonderfully atmospheric with an ancient estate by the sea. There are secret rooms and passageways, mysterious footsteps heard late at night, and a legendary curse involving a mermaid. The mystery kept me guessing to the very end, and even though I thought I had it figured out, the end totally threw me.
I loved the relationship between Diana and her student, Emma, and the romance between William and Diana was lovely, but it’s secondary to the mystery.
Diana Taylor, a spirited governess, is sent to Pendowar Hall to teach her godmother’s niece and uncover the truth behind the former baronet’s suspicious death. There, she meets Captain William Fallbrook, a charismatic but brooding Royal Navy officer.
As Diana investigates Pendowar Hall, she uncovers secrets, including a Mermaid’s Curse, and develops feelings for Captain Fallbrook, but can she trust him?
Diana’s quest to uncover the truth about his uncle’s killer puts her in danger, and he seems torn between fascination and frustration with her determination.
This is the first book in the author’s ‘Audacious Sisterhood of Smoke & Fire’ series, and I can’t wait for the next book!
Thanks to the publisher and Austenprose PR for a copy. All opinions expressed her completely my own.
February 21, 2025
Syrie James has done it again with her imaginative, clever, and wonderfully written new novel. She has created an independent, resourceful heroine who has a delicate mission thrust upon her by her elderly godmother. Her mission to discover the true cause of death of the owner of Pendowar Hall places her in an awkward, possibly dangerous, position. The author subtly interweaves reminiscences of the Brontë sisters' novels just as we are developing the sensation of "Jane Eyre" déjà vu. The characters come alive with their distinctive voices and personalities while we begin to suspect one after another and, eventually, begin to think that no one or everyone was a party to the crime. The suspense heightens as several mysterious "coincidences" occur, putting our heroine's life in possible danger. Is she imagining that someone is trying to harm her? Are we imagining things? I cannot tell you what happens in the end, but I can tell you that I was surprised!
March 11, 2025
What genre is your comfort read? One of my favorite types of comfort reads is Gothic romantic suspense.
Governess Diana Taylor has been sent by her Godmother to Pendowar Hall in Cornwall to teach her Godmother’s niece, Emma Fallbrook, and to investigate the mystery of her Godmother’s brother’s (the former Baronet’s) death. The new owner of the estate is the former baronet’s nephew, Captain William Fallbrook. The Captain is home recovering from a wound. He is handsome and charismatic, but it’s rumored he has a woman in every port. Is he all that he seems? What is the mermaid’s curse, and did it cause the previous baronet’s death?
My thoughts on this novel:
• I liked how Diana was a caring governess and helped her ward Emma build her confidence by trying to figure out the facts behind the death of her father as well as help her with her learning disability. Diana was a strong woman and kept on working on solving the mystery, while helping others and finding romance for herself. I always enjoy stories that involve governesses.
• The Captain was an intriguing and mysterious romantic figure.
• I loved all the references to Jane Eyre. The entire novel had a Jane Eyre vibe to it, but I especially loved the meeting of Diana and the Captain. It reminded me so much of the meeting between Jane Eyre and Mr. Rochester.
• The cover of this novel is beautiful. Blue is my favorite color.
• This is the first novel in the new series – The Audacious Sisterhood of the Smoke and Fire. I like the series title. I can’t wait for the next book. I also hope that Diana and her sisters will be able to start their own school as they planned.
• I loved the mysteries and the gothic romance. It was a great escapism read and reminded me of some of my favorite authors in this genre including Daphne Du Maurier, Victoria, Holt, and Mary Stewart.
• This was a clean read. The book had a good romance, but mostly focused on the mystery.
• This novel had a great setting. I always love mysterious manors on the coast of Cornwall.
Overall, The Mysteries of Pendowar Hall by Syrie James was a riveting start to a great new series with a captivating Gothic romantic suspense mystery.
Book Source: Review copy from Dragonblade Publishing as part of the Austenprose PR Book Tour. Thank-you! Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
This review was first posted on my blog at: https://lauragerold.blogspot.com/2025...
Governess Diana Taylor has been sent by her Godmother to Pendowar Hall in Cornwall to teach her Godmother’s niece, Emma Fallbrook, and to investigate the mystery of her Godmother’s brother’s (the former Baronet’s) death. The new owner of the estate is the former baronet’s nephew, Captain William Fallbrook. The Captain is home recovering from a wound. He is handsome and charismatic, but it’s rumored he has a woman in every port. Is he all that he seems? What is the mermaid’s curse, and did it cause the previous baronet’s death?
My thoughts on this novel:
• I liked how Diana was a caring governess and helped her ward Emma build her confidence by trying to figure out the facts behind the death of her father as well as help her with her learning disability. Diana was a strong woman and kept on working on solving the mystery, while helping others and finding romance for herself. I always enjoy stories that involve governesses.
• The Captain was an intriguing and mysterious romantic figure.
• I loved all the references to Jane Eyre. The entire novel had a Jane Eyre vibe to it, but I especially loved the meeting of Diana and the Captain. It reminded me so much of the meeting between Jane Eyre and Mr. Rochester.
• The cover of this novel is beautiful. Blue is my favorite color.
• This is the first novel in the new series – The Audacious Sisterhood of the Smoke and Fire. I like the series title. I can’t wait for the next book. I also hope that Diana and her sisters will be able to start their own school as they planned.
• I loved the mysteries and the gothic romance. It was a great escapism read and reminded me of some of my favorite authors in this genre including Daphne Du Maurier, Victoria, Holt, and Mary Stewart.
• This was a clean read. The book had a good romance, but mostly focused on the mystery.
• This novel had a great setting. I always love mysterious manors on the coast of Cornwall.
Overall, The Mysteries of Pendowar Hall by Syrie James was a riveting start to a great new series with a captivating Gothic romantic suspense mystery.
Book Source: Review copy from Dragonblade Publishing as part of the Austenprose PR Book Tour. Thank-you! Opinions expressed in this review are completely my own.
This review was first posted on my blog at: https://lauragerold.blogspot.com/2025...
April 9, 2025
GR 2-stars = It was okay.
I really struggled to connect with this story. Although it is well written and well edited, I was bored to tears. I started skipping chapters, and the fact that I never felt lost in the story tells you something about the pacing and style.
Read through KU.
I really struggled to connect with this story. Although it is well written and well edited, I was bored to tears. I started skipping chapters, and the fact that I never felt lost in the story tells you something about the pacing and style.
Read through KU.
August 16, 2025
Y'all. This book was a lot of fun. I sought out more books by this author after loving The Lost Memoirs of Jane Austen. It's book #1 of a clean, Victorian Gothic fiction series.
I tiptoed into this one, not being a fan of the murder-y types of mysteries. Since this one was about our main character going to snoop out if anything is amiss where someone passed away weeks ago, it seemed safe.
I'd say it's Jane Eyre-ish meets a bit of Beauty & The Beast. Yes, please!
Our young woman goes to a dark, stone castle of the Cornwall Coast, overlooking the stormy sea as a governess where the new owner is a brooding, injured, grumpy Naval officer.
Oh yeah, and there's a big Mermaid Curse that supposdly is to blame for the death of the old baronet of the castle! 🧜♀️
There is a learning disability that is handled very well.
While it is not a historical wonder of a Julie Klassen mystery, and at times it was redundant on a few words (I'm a nerd 🤓 ), it was a lot fun, and I couldn't quit reading.
Oh, and I was completely fooled with the mystery. I wasn't able to guess the true villain and I LOVE that.
Triggers: Suicide (in a big way), learning disabilities
I tiptoed into this one, not being a fan of the murder-y types of mysteries. Since this one was about our main character going to snoop out if anything is amiss where someone passed away weeks ago, it seemed safe.
I'd say it's Jane Eyre-ish meets a bit of Beauty & The Beast. Yes, please!
Our young woman goes to a dark, stone castle of the Cornwall Coast, overlooking the stormy sea as a governess where the new owner is a brooding, injured, grumpy Naval officer.
Oh yeah, and there's a big Mermaid Curse that supposdly is to blame for the death of the old baronet of the castle! 🧜♀️
There is a learning disability that is handled very well.
While it is not a historical wonder of a Julie Klassen mystery, and at times it was redundant on a few words (I'm a nerd 🤓 ), it was a lot fun, and I couldn't quit reading.
Oh, and I was completely fooled with the mystery. I wasn't able to guess the true villain and I LOVE that.
Triggers: Suicide (in a big way), learning disabilities
September 27, 2025
FREE today (September 27, 2025) on Amazon.
February 19, 2025
In USA Today’s bestselling author Syrie James’s soon-to-be released “The Mysteries of Pendowar Hall,” Miss Diana Taylor travels to Cornwall at the request of her ailing godmother to investigate the supposed suicide of her godmother’s brother, the baronet Thomas Fallbrook. Diana's tasks also include managing the baronet’s 15-year-old daughter, who cannot read, and interacting with the handsome, mysterious new baronet, Captain William Fallbrook.
“She was pleased to see beneath his prickly exterior. Captain Fallbrook was a thoughtful man.
‘Pray, avoid the north wing, however, and don’t go near the north tower. It has been unoccupied for decades and is in disrepair.’
Diana nodded. It was her second warning to avoid the north wing.”—Chapter 5.
Mysterious lights, ancient curses, and a questionable solicitor alert Diana that all is not as it should be. Lots of “Jane Eyre” vibes, eh? I was hooked.
As Diana uncovers the truth behind Sir Thomas’s death and his daughter’s condition, she faces a series of accidents—perhaps not accidents but attempts to stop her.
“The captain thought Diana’s worries were groundless. The parish constable had closed Sir Thomas’s case and would clearly never look into it again. But Diana had a gut feeling that her godmother was right. Someone had murdered the baronet and gotten away with it.” —Chapter 10.
Titillating suspense layered with a little romance, this first book in the “Audacious Sisterhood of Smoke & Fire” series is a must-read for fans of historical mysteries. Syrie James never disappoints, and “The Mysteries of Pendowar Hall” is no exception.
“She was pleased to see beneath his prickly exterior. Captain Fallbrook was a thoughtful man.
‘Pray, avoid the north wing, however, and don’t go near the north tower. It has been unoccupied for decades and is in disrepair.’
Diana nodded. It was her second warning to avoid the north wing.”—Chapter 5.
Mysterious lights, ancient curses, and a questionable solicitor alert Diana that all is not as it should be. Lots of “Jane Eyre” vibes, eh? I was hooked.
As Diana uncovers the truth behind Sir Thomas’s death and his daughter’s condition, she faces a series of accidents—perhaps not accidents but attempts to stop her.
“The captain thought Diana’s worries were groundless. The parish constable had closed Sir Thomas’s case and would clearly never look into it again. But Diana had a gut feeling that her godmother was right. Someone had murdered the baronet and gotten away with it.” —Chapter 10.
Titillating suspense layered with a little romance, this first book in the “Audacious Sisterhood of Smoke & Fire” series is a must-read for fans of historical mysteries. Syrie James never disappoints, and “The Mysteries of Pendowar Hall” is no exception.
March 19, 2025
Secrets and legend are at the heart of this romance that has a gothic feel. Set in an estate along the Cornwall coastline the atmosphere is dark and brooding. Diana, the FMC, is a governess sent to the castle by her godmother to figure out what happened to her brother the former baronet. What she finds is the attractive heir to the estate, Captain William Fallbrook, her student, Miss Fallbrook who is described as wild and unteachable, and a staff that is keeping secrets. The more Diana learns about the estate and its inhabitants the more she wonders who can be trusted. Can she figure it out before someone else dies?
One of my favorite parts is the legend of the mermaid, how can I not love a legend complete with a chamber dedicated to it?!?! Especially when it is said to have been built out of love. Diana is an enjoyable character. She is determined, thoughtful, resourceful, and wants to figure out how to help Miss Fallbrook. As with any good MMC there are hidden emotions beneath Captain William Fallbrook’s gruff exterior. The romance was closed door with just kisses and meaningful looks. The mystery kept me guessing and reading to figure it out. This was an enjoyable read and I am looking forward to the next book in the series. I recommend this book to readers that enjoy gothic mysteries and romances.
Thanks to Austenprose and the author for the gifted copy. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
One of my favorite parts is the legend of the mermaid, how can I not love a legend complete with a chamber dedicated to it?!?! Especially when it is said to have been built out of love. Diana is an enjoyable character. She is determined, thoughtful, resourceful, and wants to figure out how to help Miss Fallbrook. As with any good MMC there are hidden emotions beneath Captain William Fallbrook’s gruff exterior. The romance was closed door with just kisses and meaningful looks. The mystery kept me guessing and reading to figure it out. This was an enjoyable read and I am looking forward to the next book in the series. I recommend this book to readers that enjoy gothic mysteries and romances.
Thanks to Austenprose and the author for the gifted copy. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
February 25, 2025
I have really been enjoying historical mysteries with some romance weaved in. The Mysteries of Pendowar Hall had this fabulous gothic vibe to it. Set overlooking the sea, in a manor with a forbidden wing, and a mermaid's curse cast upon it.
I found I really enjoyed the authours writing style. The descriptions of the landscape, the grounds around the manor, and the manor itself added this real sense of foreboding to the story.
The mystery in this story was excellent. I had absolutely no inkling who the perpetrator was. It was a true surprise. One of those ones where I thought back, wondering what signs I missed, and I don't think there were any.
Underlying the mystery is the strong bond forming between our main character, who has come to Pendowar as a governess, and the young lady of the house. This was such an uplifting storyline.
And then there was the romance. I prefer my romance subtle. That's my preference, and I'd never criticize anyway who likes it any other way. But, you can't tell me this isn't incredibly seductive.
"His lips were a hair's breadth away. The sensation of wanting to feel those lips on hers was so strong that Diana's insides began to tremble. "
Overall, this was such a delightful story with an intriguing mystery, and by the end, I was unable to put it down until I had finished.
I received an advanced copy of this book. My opinions are my own.
I found I really enjoyed the authours writing style. The descriptions of the landscape, the grounds around the manor, and the manor itself added this real sense of foreboding to the story.
The mystery in this story was excellent. I had absolutely no inkling who the perpetrator was. It was a true surprise. One of those ones where I thought back, wondering what signs I missed, and I don't think there were any.
Underlying the mystery is the strong bond forming between our main character, who has come to Pendowar as a governess, and the young lady of the house. This was such an uplifting storyline.
And then there was the romance. I prefer my romance subtle. That's my preference, and I'd never criticize anyway who likes it any other way. But, you can't tell me this isn't incredibly seductive.
"His lips were a hair's breadth away. The sensation of wanting to feel those lips on hers was so strong that Diana's insides began to tremble. "
Overall, this was such a delightful story with an intriguing mystery, and by the end, I was unable to put it down until I had finished.
I received an advanced copy of this book. My opinions are my own.
March 9, 2025
syrie james delivered a captivating blend of mystery with a hint of romance in the mysteries of pendowar hall. the atmospheric seaside setting and the gothic undertones immediately drew me, and created a sense of intrigue and suspense that was woven throughout the story. the lore surrounding pendowar hall was rich and compelling and kept me turning the pages.
diana’s relationships with the fallbrooks was my favorite part of the story. her bond with emma was especially heartwarming, and her dynamic with william added a touching emotional element. their interactions were tender and believable. i couldn’t help but root for their connection as the mystery deepened and even threatened their lives.
the mystery itself was masterfully crafted, and kept me guessing until the very end. just when you think you have it figured out, james throws in unexpected twists that keep the tension high. the mysteries of pendowar hall is a beautifully written and thoroughly engaging read. it’s perfect for fans of abigail wilson who enjoy historical mystery with a touch of romance and a gothic edge.
content: kisses
thank you to the author, dragonblade publishing, and austenprose for the gifted copy. my thoughts are my own.
diana’s relationships with the fallbrooks was my favorite part of the story. her bond with emma was especially heartwarming, and her dynamic with william added a touching emotional element. their interactions were tender and believable. i couldn’t help but root for their connection as the mystery deepened and even threatened their lives.
the mystery itself was masterfully crafted, and kept me guessing until the very end. just when you think you have it figured out, james throws in unexpected twists that keep the tension high. the mysteries of pendowar hall is a beautifully written and thoroughly engaging read. it’s perfect for fans of abigail wilson who enjoy historical mystery with a touch of romance and a gothic edge.
content: kisses
thank you to the author, dragonblade publishing, and austenprose for the gifted copy. my thoughts are my own.
February 21, 2025
Historical romance is in a strange place right now and it’s one of my favourite genres so I want to support it as much as I can. Dragonblade is an indie publisher that specialises in historical romance so I wanted to try their catalogue.
The Mysteries of Pendowar Hall is reminiscent of Jane Eyre - Diana accepts a position as governess at an estate run by a Captain of the Royal Navy. He has little time or care for civilian life even though - Diana learns soon enough - his 15-year-old charge cannot read or write. The servants all warn Diana about the otherworldly happenings at the estate - a mermaid tale, and the suicide of the previous owner which might have been a murder.
I read Syrie James’s Lost Memoirs of Jane Austen decades ago when it was released and I remember enjoying it. Pendowar Hall was fine - not hugely surprising so I found the plot a rather boring, but the writing was good and it made me want to try more books by Dragonblade but definitely something more fun and light.
My endless thanks to NetGalley and Dragonblade for this ARC!
The Mysteries of Pendowar Hall is reminiscent of Jane Eyre - Diana accepts a position as governess at an estate run by a Captain of the Royal Navy. He has little time or care for civilian life even though - Diana learns soon enough - his 15-year-old charge cannot read or write. The servants all warn Diana about the otherworldly happenings at the estate - a mermaid tale, and the suicide of the previous owner which might have been a murder.
I read Syrie James’s Lost Memoirs of Jane Austen decades ago when it was released and I remember enjoying it. Pendowar Hall was fine - not hugely surprising so I found the plot a rather boring, but the writing was good and it made me want to try more books by Dragonblade but definitely something more fun and light.
My endless thanks to NetGalley and Dragonblade for this ARC!
February 21, 2025
⭐️⭐️⭐️💫
This was a sweet, mysterious gothic romance. Though I wasn’t utterly blown away by this book, I enjoyed the mystery and the strong FMC who was ahead of her time.
THOUGHTS 💭
⛵️ I loved the air of mystery and dread throughout the whole book. It was a rather lighthearted read for a murder mystery.
⛵️ The old manor and a grumpy baronet gave me Beauty & the Beast vibes that I was here for.
⛵️ Our FMC Diana doesn’t hold any punches; she says what she means and means what she says. She is so smart and curious and adventurous… I was a bit disappointed that the Captain didn’t seem to appreciate that about her when he found out she was investigating.
⛵️ The mystery WAS very mysterious! The author did an amazing job making you question everyone around our MC. I thought FOR CERTAIN I knew who the murderer was on multiple occasions, only to have my mind changed alongside Diana’s.
Thanks so much to the author, Dragonblade Publishing, and Austenprose for the ARC of this book!
This was a sweet, mysterious gothic romance. Though I wasn’t utterly blown away by this book, I enjoyed the mystery and the strong FMC who was ahead of her time.
THOUGHTS 💭
⛵️ I loved the air of mystery and dread throughout the whole book. It was a rather lighthearted read for a murder mystery.
⛵️ The old manor and a grumpy baronet gave me Beauty & the Beast vibes that I was here for.
⛵️ Our FMC Diana doesn’t hold any punches; she says what she means and means what she says. She is so smart and curious and adventurous… I was a bit disappointed that the Captain didn’t seem to appreciate that about her when he found out she was investigating.
⛵️ The mystery WAS very mysterious! The author did an amazing job making you question everyone around our MC. I thought FOR CERTAIN I knew who the murderer was on multiple occasions, only to have my mind changed alongside Diana’s.
Thanks so much to the author, Dragonblade Publishing, and Austenprose for the ARC of this book!
January 31, 2025
This was a Gothic romantic suspense and mystery novel. It was a good read. Our heroine is sent by her godmother to look into her brother’s death - supposed a suicide but she doesn’t agree. As our heroine investigates, she gets close to her charge, who has dyslexia, as she is her governess. She also gets close to her employer who is an injured Navy captain. Legends have swirled around the manor for generations about a mermaid ghost who causes injury and death when the master falls in love with the governess. Our characters are taken on a winding path through mystery and suspense. This is a single point of view, no spice romance.
I received an eARC of this book through Austenprose Tours and am voluntarily leaving an honest review.
I received an eARC of this book through Austenprose Tours and am voluntarily leaving an honest review.
March 5, 2025
If you are a historical fiction or mystery lover, you will love this book. It kept me intrigued and wondering, "Who did it" the entire time. Several times, I thought I knew the killer, but alas, I was wrong in the end. This was a great read, and I can't wait for book 2 to come out.
October 5, 2026
Book 112:
Book: The Mysteries of Pendowar Hall
Author: Syrie James
Format: Kindle
Genre: Historical Romance/Historical Fiction/Mystery
Pages: 330
Stars: 4.5 rounded up.
Started on: 9/30/26
Finished on: 10/4/26
Favorite characters: I LOVED Diana. Her tenacity. Her spirit. Her energy. Her determination. She pushed the envelope where it needed to be pushed. She felt all the emotions- guilt. fear. passion. compassion. love. faith. curiosity. I appreciated her drive to ensure the women in her life were educated- knew how to read/write.
I LOVED Diana's relationship with Miss Fallbrook- she refused to let her fall by the wayside like other governesses.
The Captain - I was indifferent at first, but I came to adore his character and what he brought to the story.
Best part: I would say the mystery! You go through the entire book trying to figure out certain things.. and my mind was blown because I sure thought I had it figured out about 85% of the way through! Someone comes in the room to speak to Diana and I was like, yep, this is it! They're going to tell her the truth right here. And NOPE!!!!
Favorite quotes:
------
"Sir Thomas must have been fond of reading- a man after her own heart." I love books that reference the love of reading.. and books.
"They are not at their peak now, of course, but Autumn has a beauty of it's own." Since this is part of the October bingo board, I was so happy to hear the Fall reference!
"Reading is one of my favorite pastimes." And in another passage, the author writes, "Reading is one of life's greatest pleasures." Diana gestured to the books on the schoolroom shelves. "A world of knowledge awaits you inside every one of those books. Curling up in a quiet corner with a novel is like diving into an imaginary world."
"Choose a job you love......." The captain began and she finished with him, "And you will never have to work a day in your life."
"It was a bright morning with just a hint of breeze and the trees flaunted their autumn colors...." <3 Another Fall reference! Obsessed.
"When life's circumstances are not what we wish them to be, we have no alternative but to make the best of what is. We might be obliged to change our thinking and move in a new direction- and that is all right, for if we stand still in one place too long, we might find ourselves stuck at that point forever."
"It's Christmas , Miss Taylor. Gifts must be accepted in the spirit in which they were given. It is a rule." He glanced at his ward. "Is that not so?"
"How do I do that?" Diana whispered. "How do I forgive myself?"
"By believing in your heart that you are deserving of it."
"God has a way of bringing us to the people we are meant to meet."
----
Seriously, I couldn't pick just one quote! They were all incredible!!!
Thoughts:
MAGNIFICENT BOOK. I am so thankful Olde American Spirit recommended it.
Syrie James does a fantastic job creating a mysterious energy to Pendowar Hall. I love the addition of "folklore" so to speak. I love wondering whether the curse is real or not. Diana was a fantastic character- there were moments I felt I could just sit down and have a cup of tea with her. Her drive and passion to ensure women were educated made me want to wrap my arms around the books I read and say "Thank you."
Thankful I was able to learn to read.
Thankful I have access to books.
Thankful I get to talk about them with people I love.
Reading this book really stirred up that thankful spirit in me.
Also, the gothic element to the book- almost this eeriness surrounding Pendowar Hall, but not really understanding it fully. It kept me turning each page.
Book: The Mysteries of Pendowar Hall
Author: Syrie James
Format: Kindle
Genre: Historical Romance/Historical Fiction/Mystery
Pages: 330
Stars: 4.5 rounded up.
Started on: 9/30/26
Finished on: 10/4/26
Favorite characters: I LOVED Diana. Her tenacity. Her spirit. Her energy. Her determination. She pushed the envelope where it needed to be pushed. She felt all the emotions- guilt. fear. passion. compassion. love. faith. curiosity. I appreciated her drive to ensure the women in her life were educated- knew how to read/write.
I LOVED Diana's relationship with Miss Fallbrook- she refused to let her fall by the wayside like other governesses.
The Captain - I was indifferent at first, but I came to adore his character and what he brought to the story.
Best part: I would say the mystery! You go through the entire book trying to figure out certain things.. and my mind was blown because I sure thought I had it figured out about 85% of the way through! Someone comes in the room to speak to Diana and I was like, yep, this is it! They're going to tell her the truth right here. And NOPE!!!!
Favorite quotes:
------
"Sir Thomas must have been fond of reading- a man after her own heart." I love books that reference the love of reading.. and books.
"They are not at their peak now, of course, but Autumn has a beauty of it's own." Since this is part of the October bingo board, I was so happy to hear the Fall reference!
"Reading is one of my favorite pastimes." And in another passage, the author writes, "Reading is one of life's greatest pleasures." Diana gestured to the books on the schoolroom shelves. "A world of knowledge awaits you inside every one of those books. Curling up in a quiet corner with a novel is like diving into an imaginary world."
"Choose a job you love......." The captain began and she finished with him, "And you will never have to work a day in your life."
"It was a bright morning with just a hint of breeze and the trees flaunted their autumn colors...." <3 Another Fall reference! Obsessed.
"When life's circumstances are not what we wish them to be, we have no alternative but to make the best of what is. We might be obliged to change our thinking and move in a new direction- and that is all right, for if we stand still in one place too long, we might find ourselves stuck at that point forever."
"It's Christmas , Miss Taylor. Gifts must be accepted in the spirit in which they were given. It is a rule." He glanced at his ward. "Is that not so?"
"How do I do that?" Diana whispered. "How do I forgive myself?"
"By believing in your heart that you are deserving of it."
"God has a way of bringing us to the people we are meant to meet."
----
Seriously, I couldn't pick just one quote! They were all incredible!!!
Thoughts:
MAGNIFICENT BOOK. I am so thankful Olde American Spirit recommended it.
Syrie James does a fantastic job creating a mysterious energy to Pendowar Hall. I love the addition of "folklore" so to speak. I love wondering whether the curse is real or not. Diana was a fantastic character- there were moments I felt I could just sit down and have a cup of tea with her. Her drive and passion to ensure women were educated made me want to wrap my arms around the books I read and say "Thank you."
Thankful I was able to learn to read.
Thankful I have access to books.
Thankful I get to talk about them with people I love.
Reading this book really stirred up that thankful spirit in me.
Also, the gothic element to the book- almost this eeriness surrounding Pendowar Hall, but not really understanding it fully. It kept me turning each page.
March 29, 2026
A gothic tale of myths and mysteries on the Cornish coast. How many lives will the water take before an answer to the mysterious deaths arises?
April 16, 2026
It was okay, but it could have been better.
April 24, 2025
If you love brooding romantic men and gothic romances in the style of Daphne Du Maurier and Charlotte Brontë as much as I do, then The Mysteries of Pendowar Hall should be on your radar. The book pays homage to Jane Eyre and features an intriguing curse and legend about mermaids.
Overall, James has penned an atmospheric gothic suspense novel with a clever mystery, a likable heroine, a believable romance, and beautiful visual imagery of Cornwall. The Mystery of Pendowar Hall is the first book in The Audacious Sisterhood of Smoke & Fire series, and I look forward to reading book two.
Adaptation Recommendation: It could work as a standalone film, part one in a series of movies, or a limited series.
Content Note: Closed-door romance.
Overall: 4
Romance: 4
Disclosure: I received a free copy from the publisher via Netgalley and Austenprose PR. This book review is my honest opinion.
Overall, James has penned an atmospheric gothic suspense novel with a clever mystery, a likable heroine, a believable romance, and beautiful visual imagery of Cornwall. The Mystery of Pendowar Hall is the first book in The Audacious Sisterhood of Smoke & Fire series, and I look forward to reading book two.
Adaptation Recommendation: It could work as a standalone film, part one in a series of movies, or a limited series.
Content Note: Closed-door romance.
Overall: 4
Romance: 4
Disclosure: I received a free copy from the publisher via Netgalley and Austenprose PR. This book review is my honest opinion.
February 22, 2025
A page-turning historical mystery and an intriguing Gothic romance—and a powerful love letter to books and reading.
Perfect for fans of deliciously spooky ghost stories, engrossing mysteries, sweet romances, enchanting mermaids, dashing naval captains, and spirited independent heroines, this sparkling novel also speaks directly to the hearts of readers who treasure books and believe passionately in the value of literacy and education for everyone, even—especially—those for whom the priceless gift and essential skill of learning to read seems forever out of reach.
In The Mysteries of Pendowar Hall, Syrie James invites us to keep pace with the quick-witted Diana Taylor as she attempts to accomplish seemingly impossible tasks in a very short space of time. For one thing, she’s promised to find out whether her godmother’s beloved brother, Sir Thomas Fallbrook, died by suicide, as the parish constable insists, or was murdered—and since her godmother’s health is failing, Diana knows she must learn as much as she can as fast as possible. When she takes up a position as governess to the late Sir Thomas’s daughter Emma, a talented but obstinate and headstrong girl with a reputation for driving governesses away, Diana discovers Miss Fallbrook has never been able to learn how to read, and she vows she’ll find a way to help. Meanwhile, she is increasingly drawn to her pupil’s cousin, Captain William Fallbrook, who has just inherited the magnificent Pendowar Hall….
Diana knows very well that it can be dangerous to trust people too quickly. Having been hurt before, she’s determined to be a discerning judge of character—indeed, her beloved sister warns her not to be as naive and trusting as the governess heroine of a novel they’ve both read recently, Charlotte Brontë’s Jane Eyre. It’s fascinating to watch as Diana tries to sort out whom to trust.
The Mysteries of Pendowar Hall combines the pleasures of following the twists and turns of mystery and romance with the challenges of confronting pressing issues of trust, grief, loss, and learning how to adapt to change. “Why,” Diana wonders early on, “was everything and everyone she held dear always taken from her?” After she reflects on disappointments large and small, her godmother advises her that “When life’s circumstances are not what we wish them to be, we have no alternative but to make the best of what is.”
Like the novels of Jane Austen and Charlotte Brontë, The Mysteries of Pendowar Hall addresses substantial, enduring themes in a memorable way. This is a fun, thought-provoking, and satisfying story, with engaging, believable characters. I’m a longtime admirer of Syrie James’s fabulous novels and plays, and it was truly a delight to read the first book in this new and exciting series—I’m already keen to find out what “The Secrets of Thorndale Manor” are and to follow the adventures of the “Audacious Sisterhood of Smoke & Fire.”
Thank you to Dragonblade Publishing for an advance copy of the novel; opinions expressed in my review are entirely my own.
Perfect for fans of deliciously spooky ghost stories, engrossing mysteries, sweet romances, enchanting mermaids, dashing naval captains, and spirited independent heroines, this sparkling novel also speaks directly to the hearts of readers who treasure books and believe passionately in the value of literacy and education for everyone, even—especially—those for whom the priceless gift and essential skill of learning to read seems forever out of reach.
In The Mysteries of Pendowar Hall, Syrie James invites us to keep pace with the quick-witted Diana Taylor as she attempts to accomplish seemingly impossible tasks in a very short space of time. For one thing, she’s promised to find out whether her godmother’s beloved brother, Sir Thomas Fallbrook, died by suicide, as the parish constable insists, or was murdered—and since her godmother’s health is failing, Diana knows she must learn as much as she can as fast as possible. When she takes up a position as governess to the late Sir Thomas’s daughter Emma, a talented but obstinate and headstrong girl with a reputation for driving governesses away, Diana discovers Miss Fallbrook has never been able to learn how to read, and she vows she’ll find a way to help. Meanwhile, she is increasingly drawn to her pupil’s cousin, Captain William Fallbrook, who has just inherited the magnificent Pendowar Hall….
Diana knows very well that it can be dangerous to trust people too quickly. Having been hurt before, she’s determined to be a discerning judge of character—indeed, her beloved sister warns her not to be as naive and trusting as the governess heroine of a novel they’ve both read recently, Charlotte Brontë’s Jane Eyre. It’s fascinating to watch as Diana tries to sort out whom to trust.
The Mysteries of Pendowar Hall combines the pleasures of following the twists and turns of mystery and romance with the challenges of confronting pressing issues of trust, grief, loss, and learning how to adapt to change. “Why,” Diana wonders early on, “was everything and everyone she held dear always taken from her?” After she reflects on disappointments large and small, her godmother advises her that “When life’s circumstances are not what we wish them to be, we have no alternative but to make the best of what is.”
Like the novels of Jane Austen and Charlotte Brontë, The Mysteries of Pendowar Hall addresses substantial, enduring themes in a memorable way. This is a fun, thought-provoking, and satisfying story, with engaging, believable characters. I’m a longtime admirer of Syrie James’s fabulous novels and plays, and it was truly a delight to read the first book in this new and exciting series—I’m already keen to find out what “The Secrets of Thorndale Manor” are and to follow the adventures of the “Audacious Sisterhood of Smoke & Fire.”
Thank you to Dragonblade Publishing for an advance copy of the novel; opinions expressed in my review are entirely my own.
February 27, 2025
Last weekend, Syrie James released her new Gothic novel, The Mysteries of Pendowar Hall. This is the first in her series, The Audacious Sisterhood of Smoke & Fire. Blending suspense with a love story, this novel follows Diana Taylor as she begins working as governess for fifteen-year-old Emma… and investigates the circumstances around Emma’s father’s recent death. Could the handsome new master of Pendowar Hall, Captain Fallbrook, have played a part? Or did the late Sir Thomas have other enemies?
Why I Chose This Book:
Gothic suspense and romance with inspiration from Jane Eyre? Yes, please! The Mysteries of Pendowar Hall offers many of my favorite themes and genre tropes, all wrapped up in one shiny bow. As soon as I heard about this book from Laurel Ann Nattress, I was I excited to read it (and the rest of the series).
What I Liked:
- Numerous allusions to Jane Eyre. From the way Diana Taylor meets Captain Fallbrook to their fireside chat, from her being a governess to him being a broody and well-traveled man, there are several scenic and thematic nods to Charlotte Brontë’s novel. Moreover, the characters themselves frequently talk about their love of Jane Eyre (then published under the name Currer Bell). I loved all of this!
- Curses, mermaids, and mysterious nighttime activities
- Creepy dreams
- Attempts on Diana’s life – oh no!
- Emma Fallbrook’s learning disability (which I correctly diagnosed right away, even if such a term didn’t yet exist in 1849)
- Surprising secrets and twists!
- Forbidden romance
Final Thoughts
The Mysteries of Pendowar Hall is an enthralling novel that matches the tone of mid-nineteenth century Gothic fiction perfectly. The murder mystery takes up the bulk of the narrative, with a confounding mix of clues leading to different suspects. (I was shocked at who the villain turned out to be!) However, I also enjoyed the scenes about unraveling Emma’s learning disability and the romance between Diana and Captain Fallbrook that later starts to emerge. I thoroughly enjoyed this novel and can’t wait for the next books in the series. The Secrets of Thorndale Manor will arrive this June, while Danger at Darkmoor Park is due in September.
Special thanks to Syrie James, Dragonblade Publishing, Austenprose PR, and NetGalley for providing me with an ARC of this book!
* Please read my full review on my blog, Amanda's Book Corner! *
Why I Chose This Book:
Gothic suspense and romance with inspiration from Jane Eyre? Yes, please! The Mysteries of Pendowar Hall offers many of my favorite themes and genre tropes, all wrapped up in one shiny bow. As soon as I heard about this book from Laurel Ann Nattress, I was I excited to read it (and the rest of the series).
What I Liked:
- Numerous allusions to Jane Eyre. From the way Diana Taylor meets Captain Fallbrook to their fireside chat, from her being a governess to him being a broody and well-traveled man, there are several scenic and thematic nods to Charlotte Brontë’s novel. Moreover, the characters themselves frequently talk about their love of Jane Eyre (then published under the name Currer Bell). I loved all of this!
- Curses, mermaids, and mysterious nighttime activities
- Creepy dreams
- Attempts on Diana’s life – oh no!
- Emma Fallbrook’s learning disability (which I correctly diagnosed right away, even if such a term didn’t yet exist in 1849)
- Surprising secrets and twists!
- Forbidden romance
Final Thoughts
The Mysteries of Pendowar Hall is an enthralling novel that matches the tone of mid-nineteenth century Gothic fiction perfectly. The murder mystery takes up the bulk of the narrative, with a confounding mix of clues leading to different suspects. (I was shocked at who the villain turned out to be!) However, I also enjoyed the scenes about unraveling Emma’s learning disability and the romance between Diana and Captain Fallbrook that later starts to emerge. I thoroughly enjoyed this novel and can’t wait for the next books in the series. The Secrets of Thorndale Manor will arrive this June, while Danger at Darkmoor Park is due in September.
Special thanks to Syrie James, Dragonblade Publishing, Austenprose PR, and NetGalley for providing me with an ARC of this book!
* Please read my full review on my blog, Amanda's Book Corner! *
March 6, 2025
3 1/2 stars. This was an enjoyable historical mystery set in Victorian times with a strong gothic vibe. Diana, a strong female protagonist, has gone to Pendowar Hall at the request of her elderly godmother to be a governess to her niece who has a reputation for being a difficult student and to look the mysterious death of her brother, the girl's father. Diana, and her two sisters, had a reputation growing for solving mysteries and hopes to use that talent at Pendowar Hall that has a supposed Mermaid's Curse that results in death if the governess fell in love with the master. The new owner of the Hall, Captain Fallbrook, was somewhat taciturn but a growing attraction between the two left Diana in a precarious position. Should she trust her heart, which had betrayed her before, and risk death? Or would she finally find love and solve the Mysteries of Pendowar Hall?
I liked Diana. She has a stronger character than many stars of gothic stories. Some of her behavior may be a bit ahead of her time but not so glaring that I can't believe it. I really liked how she struggled with her charge, Emma, who believed that she was not smart because she couldn't read and didn't even see the point in trying. In modern terms we would call it dyslexia but that was not recognized in any form at that time. Diana tried a variety of approaches to help Emma and through trial and error came up with some methods. But it wasn't an immediate fix. Very realistic.
The romance was a minor storyline but nicely portrayed. The mystery was the star of the show. There were a number of facets to the mystery and it kept me guessing until near the end and had an exciting finale. I look forward to reading more of this series.
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for an ARC in exchange for an honest opinion.
I liked Diana. She has a stronger character than many stars of gothic stories. Some of her behavior may be a bit ahead of her time but not so glaring that I can't believe it. I really liked how she struggled with her charge, Emma, who believed that she was not smart because she couldn't read and didn't even see the point in trying. In modern terms we would call it dyslexia but that was not recognized in any form at that time. Diana tried a variety of approaches to help Emma and through trial and error came up with some methods. But it wasn't an immediate fix. Very realistic.
The romance was a minor storyline but nicely portrayed. The mystery was the star of the show. There were a number of facets to the mystery and it kept me guessing until near the end and had an exciting finale. I look forward to reading more of this series.
Thanks to Netgalley and the publisher for an ARC in exchange for an honest opinion.
July 29, 2025
📚✨ BOOK REVIEW ✨📚
Title: The Mysteries of Pendowar Hall
Series: The Audacious Sisterhood of Smoke & Fire, Book 1
Author: Syrie James
Genre: Historical Romance / Gothic Mystery
Rating: ⭐⭐⭐ (3 stars)
📝 My Thoughts:
Aye aye, Captain! The opening had Sound of Music vibes with a governess arriving at a grand estate full of secrets and a brooding, wounded naval officer who may or may not be a murderer. Intriguing, right?
But while the premise pulled me in and the Gothic elements whispered of Jane Eyre, this story leaned far more into mystery than romance and the romance is where I felt most let down. The heroine and hero barely spent time together before he declared her “amazing,” and I simply didn’t buy that anything slow-burning or believable had developed between them. The emotional potential was there, but the connection never fully sparked.
The writing is gentle, thoughtful, and atmospheric. The heroine is intelligent and capable, and the Cornish setting with its secrets, cliffs, and wild beauty gives everything a broody elegance. But the pacing is slow, and the plot beats often feel familiar rather than fresh.
🔖 Favorite Quote:
“Love could at times be a force too strong to be reckoned with. It could blot out common sense.”
📌 Series Info:
Book 1 in a series following three sisters. This can be read as a standalone, but future books will likely focus on her siblings.
❗️Triggers to note:
Mentions of suicide, child loss, drowning, grief. No graphic content, it’s a clean read.
📖 Recommend to:
Readers who prefer their historical fiction light on heat, heavy on atmosphere, and love a heroine with purpose. Think of Jane Eyre with less fire and more fog.
📌 Final Verdict:
A beautiful setting and promising mystery, but I wish the romance had been given more room to bloom. Still, I’m curious to see where the Sisterhood of Smoke & Fire goes next.
#HistoricalRomance #GothicMystery #CleanRomance #BookReview #TheMysteriesOfPendowarHall #SyrieJames #SoundOfMusicVibes #JaneEyreLite #SlowBurnFail #HistoricalFiction #DragonbladePublishing
Title: The Mysteries of Pendowar Hall
Series: The Audacious Sisterhood of Smoke & Fire, Book 1
Author: Syrie James
Genre: Historical Romance / Gothic Mystery
Rating: ⭐⭐⭐ (3 stars)
📝 My Thoughts:
Aye aye, Captain! The opening had Sound of Music vibes with a governess arriving at a grand estate full of secrets and a brooding, wounded naval officer who may or may not be a murderer. Intriguing, right?
But while the premise pulled me in and the Gothic elements whispered of Jane Eyre, this story leaned far more into mystery than romance and the romance is where I felt most let down. The heroine and hero barely spent time together before he declared her “amazing,” and I simply didn’t buy that anything slow-burning or believable had developed between them. The emotional potential was there, but the connection never fully sparked.
The writing is gentle, thoughtful, and atmospheric. The heroine is intelligent and capable, and the Cornish setting with its secrets, cliffs, and wild beauty gives everything a broody elegance. But the pacing is slow, and the plot beats often feel familiar rather than fresh.
🔖 Favorite Quote:
“Love could at times be a force too strong to be reckoned with. It could blot out common sense.”
📌 Series Info:
Book 1 in a series following three sisters. This can be read as a standalone, but future books will likely focus on her siblings.
❗️Triggers to note:
Mentions of suicide, child loss, drowning, grief. No graphic content, it’s a clean read.
📖 Recommend to:
Readers who prefer their historical fiction light on heat, heavy on atmosphere, and love a heroine with purpose. Think of Jane Eyre with less fire and more fog.
📌 Final Verdict:
A beautiful setting and promising mystery, but I wish the romance had been given more room to bloom. Still, I’m curious to see where the Sisterhood of Smoke & Fire goes next.
#HistoricalRomance #GothicMystery #CleanRomance #BookReview #TheMysteriesOfPendowarHall #SyrieJames #SoundOfMusicVibes #JaneEyreLite #SlowBurnFail #HistoricalFiction #DragonbladePublishing
January 29, 2025
Gothic mystery from the “queen of nineteenth century re-imaginings.”
A massive manor house. An isolated location. A smart, persistent, and plucky governess. A handsome, wounded hero. Suspicious death. Mysterious doings in the night. An age-old legend of supernatural revenge. Surprising discoveries. Danger. Denial. Romance.
With her new book, The Mysteries of Pendowar Hall: A Victorian Historical Mystery, Syrie James deftly channels Daphne Du Maurier and Victoria Holt to deliver a delicious take on the classic gothic mystery. I’ve long admired James’s work with historical fiction, especially her delightful books exploring the lives and loves of Jane Austen and Charlotte Bronte, so I was thrilled to learn she was adding “mystery” to her tool box. In the same way she reimagines the lives of those beloved authors, James adds her own touch to this heroine’s story, giving her the very real challenge of teaching a talented charge who nonetheless still cannot read—all while simultaneously trying to determine if an “accidental” death was really an accident, and dodging frightening threats to her own life. Oh, and trying very hard not to fall in love with her employer!
I thoroughly enjoyed the book and was gripped from the first page: the characters are interesting and believable, the mystery compelling, and the romance adds a nice soupcon of spice to the story. Somewhere, Victoria Holt is smiling!
A massive manor house. An isolated location. A smart, persistent, and plucky governess. A handsome, wounded hero. Suspicious death. Mysterious doings in the night. An age-old legend of supernatural revenge. Surprising discoveries. Danger. Denial. Romance.
With her new book, The Mysteries of Pendowar Hall: A Victorian Historical Mystery, Syrie James deftly channels Daphne Du Maurier and Victoria Holt to deliver a delicious take on the classic gothic mystery. I’ve long admired James’s work with historical fiction, especially her delightful books exploring the lives and loves of Jane Austen and Charlotte Bronte, so I was thrilled to learn she was adding “mystery” to her tool box. In the same way she reimagines the lives of those beloved authors, James adds her own touch to this heroine’s story, giving her the very real challenge of teaching a talented charge who nonetheless still cannot read—all while simultaneously trying to determine if an “accidental” death was really an accident, and dodging frightening threats to her own life. Oh, and trying very hard not to fall in love with her employer!
I thoroughly enjoyed the book and was gripped from the first page: the characters are interesting and believable, the mystery compelling, and the romance adds a nice soupcon of spice to the story. Somewhere, Victoria Holt is smiling!
January 22, 2025
*I received a free ARC from the publisher through NetGalley in exchange for my honest review*
I thought this was a great start to the series. It introduces the recurring characters and their background but leaves a lot of room for more development of the two sisters who are not the focus of this book. The ending also leaves a little hint at what might be ahead for Athena and Selena in the next book. There is a lot going on in book 1 and I never felt like the author was trying to do too much. Each aspect of the story gets just the right amount of attention and development. I enjoyed how Diana was able to grow and learn to be more flexible in how she worked with Emma and in helping Emma and William forge their own bond. It was also really interesting to see how dyslexia may have been considered in the 19th century. I thought the mystery part was really well done - there were plenty of twists and turns and red herrings to keep me guessing. I was so sure I knew who the murderer was right up until the truth about that person came out. I did not see the actual murderer coming until they were revealed to Diana. The character of William was also more than just a secondary character/love interest for the heroine and since the entire book is told from Diana's point of view, we as the reader get to learn about him at the same time as Diana - which keeps you guessing as to what his motives are in some situations. I'm curious to see if Diana will appear in the future books and in what capacity since her sisters only make a short appearance through letters and then at the end.
I thought this was a great start to the series. It introduces the recurring characters and their background but leaves a lot of room for more development of the two sisters who are not the focus of this book. The ending also leaves a little hint at what might be ahead for Athena and Selena in the next book. There is a lot going on in book 1 and I never felt like the author was trying to do too much. Each aspect of the story gets just the right amount of attention and development. I enjoyed how Diana was able to grow and learn to be more flexible in how she worked with Emma and in helping Emma and William forge their own bond. It was also really interesting to see how dyslexia may have been considered in the 19th century. I thought the mystery part was really well done - there were plenty of twists and turns and red herrings to keep me guessing. I was so sure I knew who the murderer was right up until the truth about that person came out. I did not see the actual murderer coming until they were revealed to Diana. The character of William was also more than just a secondary character/love interest for the heroine and since the entire book is told from Diana's point of view, we as the reader get to learn about him at the same time as Diana - which keeps you guessing as to what his motives are in some situations. I'm curious to see if Diana will appear in the future books and in what capacity since her sisters only make a short appearance through letters and then at the end.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 79 reviews