Merry Fistmas

by Becca Vale

I finally gave up on relationships after my last girlfriend ended things for the same reason things have gone to shit with every other girl I’ve ever dated.

Everyone says size matters, but that’s only until they realize that too much of a good thing is simply too fucking much. And the baseball bat I’ve got swinging between my legs?

That monster is too much for anyone to take.

Being “blessed” this way means the only happily ever after I’ve got to look forward to is me and my own right hand, but I’ve made my peace with that.

My brother, though?

Corbin doesn’t have the same problem I do, and he deserves better… so when he gets dumped right before Christmas, naturally I grab a six-pack and swing by his place to comfort him.

But then things take an unnatural turn, and comforting him ends up with both of us spilling our secrets.

Then spilling something else.

All over each other.

Suddenly, Christmas is looking like it might end up a whole lot merrier than either one of us expected…

Genres: M M Romance, Novella, Christmas, Romance, Spicy, Gay, Erotica

ebook

Published December 20, 2024

Reviews

[BelleLovesRomance · Rating 5 out of 5]

⭐️ 5/5 🌶 5/5 – Brothers, stretching holes, and feelings? Christmas came early and so did I. 💀

HOLY. FUCKING. FISTMAS. 😳

Brother-on-brother jingle balls?? A goddamn baseball bat cock?? Fistmas cheer and messy-ass feelings all over each other like melted snow and lube?? Uh—YES, PLEASE. 😳🍆❄️

Gage and Corbin are absolute filth in the best fucking way, and Becca Vale really pulled off the impossible—making every unholy, taboo, gloriously fucked-up act feel sweet, emotional, and insanely romantic. Like, yeah, Gage is literally punching that hole, but also growling “you’re mine” with that dominant, caveman energy that made me wanna scream into a pillow. Ugh. I lived for it. 👊🏻🔥

The size kink? Chef’s kiss.
The possessiveness? Had me clenching like Corbin in chapter four.
And don’t even get me started on the dom/sub vibes—had me feral, soft, dripping, and emotionally wrecked all at once. 🧎🏻‍♀️🥹

Merry Fistmas said, “plot? Nah, let’s stretch holes until someone cries about belonging.” And it fucking WORKED. Corbin offering up his freshly-prepped ass like a gift-wrapped Christmas present—with a red ribbon and ginormous plug?? That’s the spirit of giving, bitch. Santa WHO? 🎁🎅

And what made this whole unhinged ride even more addictive? Corbin is the perfect match for Gage—physically and emotionally. That sweet, trusting, easily-blushing submissive boy fits so damn perfectly with Gage's dominant, take-charge, possessive-as-fuck energy. They're two puzzle pieces made to snap together—Corbin is literally the first person who can fully take Gage's monster cock. Like??? Fated mates but make it filthy AF. They're fucking complete. 💞🥰

The desperation, the claiming, the mine mine mine energy that punched me harder than Gage’s damn knuckles ever could. I felt that shit. That emotional layering took this from unhinged smut to unforgettable Christmas romance. And honestly? I’ll never look at Christmas tree or listen to the "I'll Be Home for Christmas" song the same way again. 🎄🎵

Now excuse me while I go reread and moan every filthy possessive line under my breath like a goddamn prayer. 😏🙏🏻

-
Quotes That'll Haunt My Filthy Mind and Hopeless Romantic Heart Forever:

“You think I was making fun? Fuck, Cor. I’m dead serious. You ever wonder why all the girls that throw themselves at me don’t stick around? It’s because no one actually likes getting split in two by a monster like this.”
-
You want me to wear a condom, baby? You're not going to let your brother in here bare? You don't want to feel my cum dripping out of this hot little hole you're offering me, is that it? I don't get to breed you like a bitch in heat?"
-
“Fuck, that’s hot,” he mutters. “I can’t believe this tiny little thing can stretch like this. You’re so fucking tight, Cor. So fucking sexy like this. Look at this greedy little asshole of yours, taking both my fingers like a champ. You meant it, didn’t you? You want this. You want me to make your hole take whatever I give it.”
-
“Damn fucking right you’re seeing someone.”
“Me. You’re mine, Corbin. No one else’s.”
“Not just at Christmas. And not just your hole.”
-
"You're going to be the first hole that can ever take all of me, isn't that right? You're going to learn to take as much as I give you, just like you promised, because you're mine. My brother. My fucking everything."
-
I'm afraid my heart is going to explode, I know for sure even if he never manages to take my cock in his hole, he's it for me.
-

RC and MCs:
🤜🏻 MM, strict top/bottom
🤜🏻 Gage and Corbin are almost 30yo. Gage is 1 year older than Corbin.
🤜🏻 Gage: Dominant top, big brother, 1 inch taller than Corbin, muscular
🤜🏻 Corbin: Submissive bottom, little brother, 1 inch shorter than Gage, freckles, muscular

Genre, tropes, and all things my safety fam needs to know:
🤜🏻 MM contemporary romance
🤜🏻 Incest (brothers)
🤜🏻 Size kink
🤜🏻 Size queen
🤜🏻 Sexual awakening
🤜🏻 Straight to gay
🤜🏻 Gay for you
🤜🏻 First times
🤜🏻 J/P MC
🤜🏻 Mine mine mine
🤜🏻 Pet names: Baby, sweetheart
🤜🏻 Angst: Low
🤜🏻 Vibes: Sweet, romantic, and filthy AF
🤜🏻 OW/OM drama: No
🤜🏻 Cheating/sharing: No
🤜🏻 Third act breakup: No
🤜🏻 Ending: HFN
🤜🏻 Epilogue: No
🤜🏻 Series structure: Standalone

Spice and kinks:
Size kink, frotting, spit as lube, dirty talk, degradation kink, fingerfucking, oil as lube, coming hands-free, breeding kink, handjob, blowjobs, stretching, spanking, pushes cum into, rimming, sex toy (butt plug), intercrural, fisting, cum play, bareback.

[Becca Vale]

Looking for taboo gay smut? Find this yummy m/m holiday brocest novella on itch.io and Smashwords!

[Bettina · Rating 4 out of 5]

4 ⭐️

[Tonya ✨ · Rating 4 out of 5]

I wanted a spicy read for Christmas and this book was exactly that. Not my favorite book from Becca but overall it's still a good spicy novella.

This was also my first book with "fisting" 🤪

[TJ · Rating 4 out of 5]

He won’t break. He was made for me. - Gage

Warnings: Brother-Brother Incest


The Basics

Overall:
1st Person, Dual POV
3rd Act Break Up: No
Slow-burn: No
HEA: Yes
MC sex without other MC(s): No
Spice: 3.75/5
Angst/Stress: 1.5/5
Fluff: 1.5/5
Structure/Format/Flow: 4/5
Overall: 3.75/5 Rounded up to 4

Spicy Moments Include:
Frotting, Handjob, Masterbation, Prostate Orgasms, Hands Free Orgasms, Fingering, Spanking, Blowjobs, Anal Plug, Thigh fucking, Fisting, Anal sex, Bareback, GFY

Main Character Information:
Corbin: Younger brother (1 year younger), Straight Gay?, Bottom, Very submissive and passive
Gage: Slightly taller (1 inch taller), Straight GFY, Top, Very take charge and leads


My Notes:
- Gage has an anaconda, I agree, I don’t think I’d find that to be a good thing. Makes my vagina cringe. Poor guy.
- Gage definitely be following those intrusive thoughts right into Corbin’s lap.
- So much fingering, so much.
- Had a hard time getting into this one. I don’t think fisting and fingering does it for me. I was ready for Gage to tear him a new one by 57%.
- Love the possessiveness from Gage and how Corbin finds himself and gets to enjoy sex for once, both of them actually.
- Corbin and Gage both have insecurities, but are able to find peace in them together.
- Gage’s dirty talk and alpha possessiveness? Fuck yeah

But this is my little brother. With him, I don’t feel anything but perfect. - Gage


Milestone Moments:

Corbin Gets His 2nd Opinion… and More: 16%
Corbin Knows, and Has, the Perfect Xmas Gift: 33%
We All Love Brothers Who Kiss: 57%
Huh?? Move Where??: 68%
Merry Fistmas, Brother: 81%
Gage Really Opens His Present: 90%


Scene That Stuck With Me:

“Don’t stop. I need all of it. You’ve got me so full. I can’t… I need… It’s so…” “Big?” His [Corbin’s] eyes open, dazed but shining, and drill into mine. “Perfect,” he whispers. “Everything I need.”

Going his whole life unable to truly have good sex with anyone without pain or being left unsatisfied, Gage finally has someone that can take all of him, he just happens to be his brother. Gage loves his brother and it was apparent early in the book how much he cares for him and is terrified to hurt him. His cock being massive has always been a place of insecurity and issues. Corbin’s words here were absolutely what Gage needed. Gage asked “Big?” and when I read that I heard it in my head with a slight meekness to it, nothing like the assertive and confident Gage we know, like that was what he expected, more of the same. Corbin settled that voice in his head. There was nothing wrong with Gage or his dick, Gage just simply hadn’t found the right person. Well, realized who the right person was, until he crossed that line with Corbin on the couch. Gage didn’t have a problem being enough for someone, he always had a problem being too much for someone. Not anymore, he’s exactly what Corbin needs.



Quotes That Live Rent Free In My Head:

If Gage ever freeballs, it hangs so far down his thigh I’m surprised it doesn’t dislocate his kneecap. - Corbin

I love making him happy. It’s better than sex. At least, any sex that I’ve ever had. - Corbin

“You’ve got nothing to be sorry about, Cor. You’re being so good for me. Doing exactly what I asked you to.” - Gage

I may not be into men and have never once thought about rubbing off on another guy’s dick, but this is my little brother. Of fucking course I want him to feel good. Of fucking course I want to be the one who makes him to feel good. I just never thought of making it happen quite like this. - Gage

He swallows. “You’re naked.” I kick up a foot. “Nah, I still got my socks on. See?” - Gage

I pop the top on a new beer, hesitant for a second before handing it to him because if the first two got him to drop his pants, I’m almost scared to find out what a third will do. - Gage

“You want me to wear a condom, baby? You’re not going to let your brother in here bare? You don’t want to feel my cum dripping out of this hot little hole you’re offering me, is that it? I don’t get to breed you like a bitch in heat?” - Gage

If “better” means becoming the greedy cockslut we both seem to want me to be, the kind who would offer him my whole for Christmas and shamelessly bend over his couch and beg him to fill it, then not just yes, but hell yes. - Corbin

Small or not, too tight, too tiny… doesn’t matter. The monster wants in that fucking hole. - Gage

Gage: “It’ll hurt, baby. You don’t know what you’re asking for.”
Corbin: “I’m not asking, I’m begging.”

No wonder Corbin didn’t have a great sex life before we started this shit. He was made to be fucked, not to fuck.” - Gage

Then I start to fuck him. My own brother. My perfect fucking match. I fuck him hard, fast, deep. I fuck him until he screams and I fuck him without holding back. I fuck him like I’ve never fucked before, and it’s not good. It’s goddamn amazing. - Gage

He whimpers, little tremors rippling up his spine that make me want to lick it, pin him down and grind deep, dig my fingers into his hips and yank him back, using him like a cocksleeve. One that won’t break. One that I can fuck so much cum out of that his balls run dry, because no matter how much I give him, he’ll always want more. One that I don’t just love, but someone I was born to love… just like his hole was born to take me. - Gage

[Book Binge: Reviews by Melissa DaSilva · Rating 4 out of 5]

There was no possible way I could pass up reading this book with a title like that when I’m a huge fan of fisting in books. This is the first true brothers taboo story I’ve read and I really enjoyed it. I think this author will be my guilty pleasure when I’m feeling like a taboo erotica.

There was a plot to this story but honestly it all revolved around sex anyways so don’t go in expecting some written masterpiece. But I definitely recommend if you’re looking for something fun, taboo and sexy!

[klinta · Rating 4 out of 5]

this gotta be the wildest one i read so far because what do you MEAN the tip was almost as big as his whole fist 😃😃😃

[peoniesandmm · Rating 5 out of 5]

i need mooorreeeee 🙂‍↕️🙂‍↕️

[Rachel Emily · Rating 4 out of 5]

This is shelved under the taboo bookshelf for reasons just FYI!

I think this is the 4th or 5th book from Becca Vale that I have read, and she does have a way to write a fun story that is just entertaining from start to finish. You quickly fall in love with the characters, they are very endearing, and it's fluffy and sweet and very very steamy. I really like she has some longer stories, like some I've bought are 25k+ words so it's more than just one quick erotica scene end story.

If your kink is fisting and overly huge equipment lol, then this one is for you! These two were very sweet, and left me wanting ro read more of them!

[Kim B · Rating 5 out of 5]

This one was so, so good! A beautiful 😉🤣 hot Christmas story of two brothers. One is a hopeless romantic whose girlfriend breaks up with him right before the holidays citing his lack-luster performance in the bedroom. Older brother cheers him up and commiserates with him....because he's actually given up on finding love because of a "not so small" problem he's packing. If you love the size queen trope, you'll love this one!! Super spicy of course! Becca does it again.

[Leigh Gaskill · Rating 5 out of 5]

Damn this was hot. I’ve said it before but I really love when there’s no fighting over right and wrong, just straight to smutty goodness.

I will say…I spent quite a bit of time staring at my hand, maneuvering it into different configurations, making circles with it, to try and figure out how big ‘The Monster’ actually is. Still have no idea.

RIP Corbin’s hole.

[M's ☆~HEA~☆ · Rating 4 out of 5]

And then he’s inside. His whole fist. Inside me. He flexes his fingers, then slowly bunches them together, and a shockwave goes through me that’s beyond pleasure. I start to shake.

I had no idea this book would be so hot. I loved the dynamic of the brothers, both previously straight, fit, regular bros - now taking it to a new level. Intense sex scenes💙

[Rozanna's fantasy romance & smut corner · Rating 3 out of 5]

while this isn't my thing I loved that he wanted to accommodate and got to expand his horizon and learn he's a very needy size queen bottom instead of an straight average /bad lay due to insecurities..

[Brianna · Rating 5 out of 5]

🎶(to the tune of O Holy Night by Bing Cosby) O’ holy night, this was something special🎶

Anyway, yeah this was hot af. 🤙🏻

[Tumyd · Rating 5 out of 5]

Brotherly love! Well Gage certainly 'handed' that to Corbin.
This has been the best story be MsVale so far.
The development of their, already, close relationship was great.

[K · Rating 4 out of 5]

it's exactly what the title says it is... Christmas fisting 😂 if you buy the book, you gotta already know what you are signing up for!

[Reader1218-Jing · Rating 3 out of 5]

Is it too early to celebrate Christmas? Absolutely not. Turns out, when your “gift” needs some serious stretching, the holiday season should run from Thanksgiving all the way to Valentine’s Day.