What do you think?
Rate this book
Broke my heart for the plot
Ever meet someone who just gets you? Like, out of nowhere, they show up, and suddenly everything clicks? That’s what happened when Ilaria met Shiloh.
She's a third culture kid who’s never quite fit anywhere, at least not until Creekhaven. And Shiloh? He’s the carefree, alwayshasherback kind of friend that people spend a lifetime searching for. Together, they’ve built something rare—a friendship that’s all deep conversations, fun adventures, and the sense of belonging Ilaria’s always wanted.
But as life moves them forward, Ilaria begins feeling the weight of things unsaid. Can she risk it all to find out if there’s something even deeper, or is friendship the real magic she’s been searching for all along?
A story for anyone who knows that home isn’t always a place—and that sometimes, the best connections are the ones that sneak up on you.
She's a third culture kid who’s never quite fit anywhere, at least not until Creekhaven. And Shiloh? He’s the carefree, alwayshasherback kind of friend that people spend a lifetime searching for. Together, they’ve built something rare—a friendship that’s all deep conversations, fun adventures, and the sense of belonging Ilaria’s always wanted.
But as life moves them forward, Ilaria begins feeling the weight of things unsaid. Can she risk it all to find out if there’s something even deeper, or is friendship the real magic she’s been searching for all along?
A story for anyone who knows that home isn’t always a place—and that sometimes, the best connections are the ones that sneak up on you.
380 pages, Paperback
Published December 17, 2024
2 people are currently reading
6 people want to read
About the author
Sherin Carol
1 bookSherin Carol is a brand designer, storyteller, and an all-around creative whirlwind who thrives on bringing ideas to life. Her love for storytelling began in childhood, scribbling in diaries and writing poems, which evolved through her teenage years into blogging and, eventually, writing her debut novel, broke my heart for the plot. The novel explores the deep, often unspoken bonds of friendship and the complexities of emotions that shape our connections, resonating with readers who appreciate heartfelt narratives about identity and belonging.
When she’s not writing, Sherin is busy crafting brand identities that make you stop and say, "Wow!" (she hopes) or sketching quirky cartoons or puns that might end up in her journal—or on the nearest napkin. A self-proclaimed design nerd with a soft spot for classic playlists and polaroid-worthy moments, Sherin believes creativity should always be fun and meaningful.
Whether it’s through her designs or her stories, Sherin’s mission is simple: to make you feel something. Because at the end of the day, life’s too short for uninspired designs or empty words.
When she’s not writing, Sherin is busy crafting brand identities that make you stop and say, "Wow!" (she hopes) or sketching quirky cartoons or puns that might end up in her journal—or on the nearest napkin. A self-proclaimed design nerd with a soft spot for classic playlists and polaroid-worthy moments, Sherin believes creativity should always be fun and meaningful.
Whether it’s through her designs or her stories, Sherin’s mission is simple: to make you feel something. Because at the end of the day, life’s too short for uninspired designs or empty words.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 29 of 29 reviews
February 16, 2025
Book Review: "Broke My Heart for the Plot"
Broke My Heart for the Plot is a heartfelt exploration of friendship, identity, and the longing for connection. The story introduces Ilaria, a third-culture kid who’s used to feeling out of place—until she arrives at Creekhaven and meets Shiloh. Their bond feels effortless and natural, filled with deep conversations, spontaneous adventures, and the comfort Ilaria has always craved.
Shiloh is the kind of friend everyone hopes to find—loyal, supportive, and always in Ilaria’s corner. Together, they create a world that feels safe and special. However, life has a way of complicating even the best of friendships, and as unspoken feelings and questions bubble to the surface, Ilaria is faced with a choice: does she risk their connection for the possibility of something more, or hold onto the friendship that has given her so much?
The novel beautifully captures the nuances of friendship—its joy, complexity, and bittersweet moments. It also delves into themes of self-discovery and finding "home" in people rather than places. The pacing is steady, and the writing is infused with emotion and relatability.
Overall, Broke My Heart for the Plot is a poignant read for anyone who has ever experienced the blurred lines between friendship and love, or found a sense of belonging in an unexpected place. It’s a story that will tug at your heartstrings and leave you reflecting on the connections that shape us.
Broke My Heart for the Plot is a heartfelt exploration of friendship, identity, and the longing for connection. The story introduces Ilaria, a third-culture kid who’s used to feeling out of place—until she arrives at Creekhaven and meets Shiloh. Their bond feels effortless and natural, filled with deep conversations, spontaneous adventures, and the comfort Ilaria has always craved.
Shiloh is the kind of friend everyone hopes to find—loyal, supportive, and always in Ilaria’s corner. Together, they create a world that feels safe and special. However, life has a way of complicating even the best of friendships, and as unspoken feelings and questions bubble to the surface, Ilaria is faced with a choice: does she risk their connection for the possibility of something more, or hold onto the friendship that has given her so much?
The novel beautifully captures the nuances of friendship—its joy, complexity, and bittersweet moments. It also delves into themes of self-discovery and finding "home" in people rather than places. The pacing is steady, and the writing is infused with emotion and relatability.
Overall, Broke My Heart for the Plot is a poignant read for anyone who has ever experienced the blurred lines between friendship and love, or found a sense of belonging in an unexpected place. It’s a story that will tug at your heartstrings and leave you reflecting on the connections that shape us.
February 14, 2025
Guess what?
I read a book of 380 pages in one go literally after ages.
Do we all sometimes not wonder where home is ? I think even the protagonist is wondering about the same. For some people, art is everything and they always like to think out of box and they would love a place that’s got a place for art. This book got to be my comfort place. It’s been ages I read a book like this one.
Ilaria Meeting with Shiloh is fascinating and i like the idea of two artists meeting and sharing their love for art. Their bond grows as days pass and what they share is something magnificent. My favourite part is when Ilaria and Shiloh start going out more often and start having fun together. I wish I had someone that creative in my life. The steady presence in friendship is so important in the long run and for a bond to bloom and that’s reflected in their bond. The way author describes Dough Re Mi, I literally have imagined a whole place in my head. But no matter what Shiloh disappearing like that was so overwhelming for me . This keeps happening with everyone out there. However , the whole week trip that they’re on is just spine chilling and it is something from my bucket list. And as days pass, their journeys get fascinating. And it fills my heart to see characters happy . Even though sometimes two people who love each other may not end up together, it makes me happy to see them happy with their own lives.
This book is so so refreshing!!
Definitely, a page turner .
I read a book of 380 pages in one go literally after ages.
Do we all sometimes not wonder where home is ? I think even the protagonist is wondering about the same. For some people, art is everything and they always like to think out of box and they would love a place that’s got a place for art. This book got to be my comfort place. It’s been ages I read a book like this one.
Ilaria Meeting with Shiloh is fascinating and i like the idea of two artists meeting and sharing their love for art. Their bond grows as days pass and what they share is something magnificent. My favourite part is when Ilaria and Shiloh start going out more often and start having fun together. I wish I had someone that creative in my life. The steady presence in friendship is so important in the long run and for a bond to bloom and that’s reflected in their bond. The way author describes Dough Re Mi, I literally have imagined a whole place in my head. But no matter what Shiloh disappearing like that was so overwhelming for me . This keeps happening with everyone out there. However , the whole week trip that they’re on is just spine chilling and it is something from my bucket list. And as days pass, their journeys get fascinating. And it fills my heart to see characters happy . Even though sometimes two people who love each other may not end up together, it makes me happy to see them happy with their own lives.
This book is so so refreshing!!
Definitely, a page turner .
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
March 6, 2025
Ah yes, another book that promised a cozy friendship and instead emotionally drop-kicked me into next week. I signed up for soft, heartfelt moments, and Sherin Carol said, “Oh, you wanted feelings? Here, have ALL OF THEM.”
Ilaria and Shiloh’s friendship is the kind that makes you want to text your bestie at 2 AM just to say, “Thanks for existing.” It’s raw, messy, and filled with the kind of unsaid things that could either make or break them. Sherin captures their dynamic flawlessly—it's sharp, authentic, and too relatable.
And just when you think you’ve figured it out—BOOM! Emotional wreckage ahead. Sherin masterfully plays with the what-ifs and maybes of love and friendship, making you question every “platonic” bond in your own life.
💭 Closing Thoughts:
This book didn’t just break my heart—it shattered it, gift-wrapped the pieces, and mailed them back with a note saying “You’re welcome.” If you love slow-burn friendships, heart-wrenching choices, and books that make you feel too much, this one’s for you. It was hard to stop myself from falling in love with the book's hard cover & cute bookmarks 🤍
🔖 QOTD: Have you ever had a friendship so deep it made you wonder if there was something more? 👀
Ilaria and Shiloh’s friendship is the kind that makes you want to text your bestie at 2 AM just to say, “Thanks for existing.” It’s raw, messy, and filled with the kind of unsaid things that could either make or break them. Sherin captures their dynamic flawlessly—it's sharp, authentic, and too relatable.
And just when you think you’ve figured it out—BOOM! Emotional wreckage ahead. Sherin masterfully plays with the what-ifs and maybes of love and friendship, making you question every “platonic” bond in your own life.
💭 Closing Thoughts:
This book didn’t just break my heart—it shattered it, gift-wrapped the pieces, and mailed them back with a note saying “You’re welcome.” If you love slow-burn friendships, heart-wrenching choices, and books that make you feel too much, this one’s for you. It was hard to stop myself from falling in love with the book's hard cover & cute bookmarks 🤍
🔖 QOTD: Have you ever had a friendship so deep it made you wonder if there was something more? 👀
February 11, 2025
I really wanted to love Broke My Heart for the Plot because the premise sounded so good. The setting of Creekhaven is beautifully described—it feels like the kind of small town you’d want to escape to, and that really added to the book’s charm. The plot itself is solid, and I liked the themes of self-discovery and friendship.
That said, the writing felt a bit too fast-paced for me. I found myself wanting to slow down and sit with the emotions, but the story moved so quickly that I didn’t get the chance to fully connect with what was happening. Ilaria and Shiloh’s friendship is supposed to be the heart of the story, but something about their connection didn’t feel entirely real to me. Their interactions felt a little rushed, and I struggled to get emotionally invested in them.
Overall, this book has some great elements, but it just didn’t fully click for me. If you enjoy fast-moving stories with a strong sense of place, you might still enjoy it!
That said, the writing felt a bit too fast-paced for me. I found myself wanting to slow down and sit with the emotions, but the story moved so quickly that I didn’t get the chance to fully connect with what was happening. Ilaria and Shiloh’s friendship is supposed to be the heart of the story, but something about their connection didn’t feel entirely real to me. Their interactions felt a little rushed, and I struggled to get emotionally invested in them.
Overall, this book has some great elements, but it just didn’t fully click for me. If you enjoy fast-moving stories with a strong sense of place, you might still enjoy it!
February 11, 2025
This book had a deep impact on me. It tells a touching story about strong friendships, the comfort of love, and the need to find a place where you truly belong. The emotions felt so real that I couldn’t help but connect with the characters on a personal level. Each one had their own struggles and flaws, but that only made them more lovable.
The writing was easy to follow, yet every scene carried so much meaning. Right from the first page, the story grabbed my attention with its clever dialogue and unpredictable twists. It had moments that made me smile, others that made me emotional, and plenty that kept me curious.
It was a short but powerful read, and even after finishing it, I kept thinking about the story and its characters.
The writing was easy to follow, yet every scene carried so much meaning. Right from the first page, the story grabbed my attention with its clever dialogue and unpredictable twists. It had moments that made me smile, others that made me emotional, and plenty that kept me curious.
It was a short but powerful read, and even after finishing it, I kept thinking about the story and its characters.
February 21, 2025
Broke My Heart for the Plot by Sherin Carol is a contemporary romance that talks about love, curiosity for art, music and others culture, friendship, and self-discovery. Ilaria, a third-culture kid, never wholly belonged anywhere but found solace in Creekhaven and an unexpected connection with Shiloh. Shiloh became her constant companion, with whom everything felt right and they clicked really well. Their kind of friendship was rare because of it being built on real conversations over hot chocolate, a series of adventures, and unwavering support. But as life keeps moving forward, Ilaria begins to wonder whether there's something more between them or if it's actually the friendship that has been her search for magic.
The way author builds up the characters, makes you feel relatable with it. I really loved the witty banter between Iliara and Shiloh. This lightens up the storyline from several seriousness. Then, the emotional depth of the narrative that blends humor and wit keeps the reader glued to the book.
Although 1/3rd part of the book might feel really slow paced because that is where the whole story, characters and everything is building up. Overall, the book provides a really engaging mix of heartbreak and drama, though sometimes it takes that familiar step into romance clichés.
Broke My Heart for the Plot is a heartwarming, fun read, reminding us that home is not always a place but the people around us.
The way author builds up the characters, makes you feel relatable with it. I really loved the witty banter between Iliara and Shiloh. This lightens up the storyline from several seriousness. Then, the emotional depth of the narrative that blends humor and wit keeps the reader glued to the book.
Although 1/3rd part of the book might feel really slow paced because that is where the whole story, characters and everything is building up. Overall, the book provides a really engaging mix of heartbreak and drama, though sometimes it takes that familiar step into romance clichés.
Broke My Heart for the Plot is a heartwarming, fun read, reminding us that home is not always a place but the people around us.
February 3, 2025
Alright, this book? It gives off that warm reminder of coffee on a rainy day. It follows Ilaria, a girl who goes to a new city to study art and has no idea on where she belongs until she meets Shiloh. He’s that magical friend that gets you. Their friendship consists of meaningful conversations, amusing escapades, and the feeling of being at home in an unfamiliar place.
The way this book describes the painting of their story? So deep. There is a flying sensation in the sketchbooks, the city streets, and the cozy coffee shop around Ilaria. It’s not only about her pursuing her dreams, it’s about evolving, finding oneself, and figuring out that home isn't always a certain spot. Sometimes, it’s people.
If you enjoy books that evoke real feelings, this one’s for you. It's unadorned yet emotional, and the kind of story that overhangs over you even after you’ve finished reading it.
The way this book describes the painting of their story? So deep. There is a flying sensation in the sketchbooks, the city streets, and the cozy coffee shop around Ilaria. It’s not only about her pursuing her dreams, it’s about evolving, finding oneself, and figuring out that home isn't always a certain spot. Sometimes, it’s people.
If you enjoy books that evoke real feelings, this one’s for you. It's unadorned yet emotional, and the kind of story that overhangs over you even after you’ve finished reading it.
February 4, 2025
This was a sweet story, that I devoured in a couple of days. Don't look at the length of the book, it's quite easy to read. The language is simple to understand and the dialogue delivery is to the point.
I loved how the story progressed. The time that Ilaria spent with everyone, be it with Shiloh or even a stranger was beautifully explained and exciting to read. Shiloh has a golden retriever vibes.
My favourite chapters were the ones at the end, which were so reflective from Ilaria's point of view. It made me realise how mature she was.
Mrs. Langley and Madame DuBois are my favourite characters. They are very humble and their life experiences speak volumes in the book.
Additionally, I loved the playlist that the author curated so carefully. I could find my favourite songs in there.
To conclude, I would suggest you read this book with patience. Every chapter holds a meaning. For a debut novel, this was indeed impressive.
I loved how the story progressed. The time that Ilaria spent with everyone, be it with Shiloh or even a stranger was beautifully explained and exciting to read. Shiloh has a golden retriever vibes.
My favourite chapters were the ones at the end, which were so reflective from Ilaria's point of view. It made me realise how mature she was.
Mrs. Langley and Madame DuBois are my favourite characters. They are very humble and their life experiences speak volumes in the book.
Additionally, I loved the playlist that the author curated so carefully. I could find my favourite songs in there.
To conclude, I would suggest you read this book with patience. Every chapter holds a meaning. For a debut novel, this was indeed impressive.
February 19, 2025
📚 Book Review: *Broke My Heart for the Plot* by Sherin Carol
---
#Part 1: Book Details & Summary
1️⃣ Book Details:
- Title: *Broke My Heart for the Plot*
- Author: Sherin Carol
- Genre: Contemporary Romance / Literary Fiction
- Published Year: December 2024
- Page Count: 380
- Target Audience: Young Adults & Adults
- Publisher: Notion Press
2️⃣ Setting:
The story unfolds in Creekhaven, a fictional town brimming with artistic energy and cobblestone charm. The setting shifts between bustling cityscapes and intimate spaces like a cozy coffee shop, which serves as a sanctuary for the protagonist. These contrasts mirror Ilaria’s journey from displacement to belonging, with the author’s lush descriptions making the town feel like a character itself—alive with music, art, and whispered secrets.
3️⃣ Main Characters:
- Ilaria: A rootless art student grappling with cultural identity, whose introspective nature and quiet resilience make her achingly relatable.
- Shiloh: A free-spirited musician who becomes Ilaria’s anchor, radiating warmth and loyalty while masking his own vulnerabilities.
Their dynamic evolves from tentative camaraderie to a bond that defies labels, with Ilaria’s artistic lens and Shiloh’s spontaneity creating a harmony that drives the narrative. Secondary characters, like coffee shop regulars, add texture without overshadowing the central duo.
4️⃣ Plot and Problem Area:
Ilaria’s move to Creekhaven sparks a quest for self-discovery, where her friendship with Shiloh blurs into a tender exploration of "what if." Challenges arise as they navigate artistic ambitions, unspoken feelings, and a pivotal discovery in Ilaria’s diary. The pacing simmers slowly, mirroring real-life emotional growth, before crescendoing into a climax that questions whether love and friendship are mutually exclusive. The resolution—subtle yet satisfying—leans into the idea that home is crafted through shared moments, not geography.
---
#Part 2: Reader’s Opinion
1️⃣ Strengths/Things I Liked Most:
- Atmospheric Depth: Carol’s prose is a sensory feast—readers can *taste* the bitter coffee, *hear* the strum of Shiloh’s guitar, and *feel* the weight of unsaid words.
- Nuanced Relationships: The platonic-romantic tension is masterfully handled, avoiding clichés for a raw, authentic portrayal of human connection.
- Themes of Belonging: Ilaria’s struggle as a third-culture kid resonates universally, particularly in scenes where she sketches her surroundings to “anchor” herself.
2️⃣ Weaknesses/Things I Didn't Like:
- Pacing Hiccups: The first third lingers on setup, which, while rich in detail, may test impatient readers.
- Underdeveloped Subplots: Certain threads, like Ilaria’s art school challenges, fade into the background, leaving missed opportunities for deeper stakes.
3️⃣ Message/Theme:
The novel’s heart lies in its exploration of **identity** and **belonging**, arguing that “home” is a mosaic of people and moments rather than a physical space. It also deftly questions societal expectations of romance, suggesting that deep friendships can be just as transformative.
4️⃣ Author's Writing Style:
Carol’s style is lyrical yet accessible, blending introspective monologues with crisp dialogue. Her use of metaphors—like comparing relationships to unfinished sketches—adds layers without pretension. The diary entries interspersed throughout provide intimacy, though their abrupt inclusion occasionally disrupts the flow.
---
#Part 3: Conclusion
1️⃣ My Opinion with Reasons:
This book lingered in my mind like a half-remembered melody. While the slow start tested my patience, the emotional payoff was worth it. Carol’s refusal to force romance into neat boxes felt revolutionary, though I craved more closure for secondary characters. I’d eagerly read her future works for their emotional authenticity alone.
2️⃣ Final Verdict:
A must-read for fans of *Normal People* or *The Midnight Library*, this novel is perfect for introspective readers who cherish character-driven stories. Its exploration of platonic love makes it a standout in the romance genre.
3️⃣ Rating of the Book:
4/5 Stars
- Plot: 3.5/5 (Pacing issues, but impactful climax)
- Characters: 5/5 (Ilaria and Shiloh are unforgettable)
- Writing Style: 4.5/5 (Lyrical yet grounded)
- Themes: 5/5 (Timely and poignant)
---
#Bonus Elements
📖 Memorable Quotes:
- “We don’t find home—we build it from the people who stay.”*
- “His laughter was a song I never knew I needed to hear.”
🎨 Cover Analysis:
The soft watercolor cover, with its muted tones and sketched coffee cup, echoes the novel’s blend of artistry and quiet emotion—a perfect visual metaphor.
📈 Emotional Impact:
This book doesn’t just tug heartstrings; it plucks them like a guitar, leaving a bittersweet hum long after the final page.
💬 Comparison:
Think *Eleanor Oliphant Is Completely Fine* meets *Call Me By Your Name*, but with a uniquely millennial voice.
📚 Recommendation:
Ideal for book clubs or solo reads on rainy afternoons—pair with a latte and a box of tissues.
---
Final Thoughts:
*Broke My Heart for the Plot* is a tender ode to the friendships that shape us, proving that sometimes the most profound love stories don’t need a label. Sherin Carol has crafted a narrative that feels like a conversation with an old friend—messy, beautiful, and utterly unforgettable.
---
#Part 1: Book Details & Summary
1️⃣ Book Details:
- Title: *Broke My Heart for the Plot*
- Author: Sherin Carol
- Genre: Contemporary Romance / Literary Fiction
- Published Year: December 2024
- Page Count: 380
- Target Audience: Young Adults & Adults
- Publisher: Notion Press
2️⃣ Setting:
The story unfolds in Creekhaven, a fictional town brimming with artistic energy and cobblestone charm. The setting shifts between bustling cityscapes and intimate spaces like a cozy coffee shop, which serves as a sanctuary for the protagonist. These contrasts mirror Ilaria’s journey from displacement to belonging, with the author’s lush descriptions making the town feel like a character itself—alive with music, art, and whispered secrets.
3️⃣ Main Characters:
- Ilaria: A rootless art student grappling with cultural identity, whose introspective nature and quiet resilience make her achingly relatable.
- Shiloh: A free-spirited musician who becomes Ilaria’s anchor, radiating warmth and loyalty while masking his own vulnerabilities.
Their dynamic evolves from tentative camaraderie to a bond that defies labels, with Ilaria’s artistic lens and Shiloh’s spontaneity creating a harmony that drives the narrative. Secondary characters, like coffee shop regulars, add texture without overshadowing the central duo.
4️⃣ Plot and Problem Area:
Ilaria’s move to Creekhaven sparks a quest for self-discovery, where her friendship with Shiloh blurs into a tender exploration of "what if." Challenges arise as they navigate artistic ambitions, unspoken feelings, and a pivotal discovery in Ilaria’s diary. The pacing simmers slowly, mirroring real-life emotional growth, before crescendoing into a climax that questions whether love and friendship are mutually exclusive. The resolution—subtle yet satisfying—leans into the idea that home is crafted through shared moments, not geography.
---
#Part 2: Reader’s Opinion
1️⃣ Strengths/Things I Liked Most:
- Atmospheric Depth: Carol’s prose is a sensory feast—readers can *taste* the bitter coffee, *hear* the strum of Shiloh’s guitar, and *feel* the weight of unsaid words.
- Nuanced Relationships: The platonic-romantic tension is masterfully handled, avoiding clichés for a raw, authentic portrayal of human connection.
- Themes of Belonging: Ilaria’s struggle as a third-culture kid resonates universally, particularly in scenes where she sketches her surroundings to “anchor” herself.
2️⃣ Weaknesses/Things I Didn't Like:
- Pacing Hiccups: The first third lingers on setup, which, while rich in detail, may test impatient readers.
- Underdeveloped Subplots: Certain threads, like Ilaria’s art school challenges, fade into the background, leaving missed opportunities for deeper stakes.
3️⃣ Message/Theme:
The novel’s heart lies in its exploration of **identity** and **belonging**, arguing that “home” is a mosaic of people and moments rather than a physical space. It also deftly questions societal expectations of romance, suggesting that deep friendships can be just as transformative.
4️⃣ Author's Writing Style:
Carol’s style is lyrical yet accessible, blending introspective monologues with crisp dialogue. Her use of metaphors—like comparing relationships to unfinished sketches—adds layers without pretension. The diary entries interspersed throughout provide intimacy, though their abrupt inclusion occasionally disrupts the flow.
---
#Part 3: Conclusion
1️⃣ My Opinion with Reasons:
This book lingered in my mind like a half-remembered melody. While the slow start tested my patience, the emotional payoff was worth it. Carol’s refusal to force romance into neat boxes felt revolutionary, though I craved more closure for secondary characters. I’d eagerly read her future works for their emotional authenticity alone.
2️⃣ Final Verdict:
A must-read for fans of *Normal People* or *The Midnight Library*, this novel is perfect for introspective readers who cherish character-driven stories. Its exploration of platonic love makes it a standout in the romance genre.
3️⃣ Rating of the Book:
4/5 Stars
- Plot: 3.5/5 (Pacing issues, but impactful climax)
- Characters: 5/5 (Ilaria and Shiloh are unforgettable)
- Writing Style: 4.5/5 (Lyrical yet grounded)
- Themes: 5/5 (Timely and poignant)
---
#Bonus Elements
📖 Memorable Quotes:
- “We don’t find home—we build it from the people who stay.”*
- “His laughter was a song I never knew I needed to hear.”
🎨 Cover Analysis:
The soft watercolor cover, with its muted tones and sketched coffee cup, echoes the novel’s blend of artistry and quiet emotion—a perfect visual metaphor.
📈 Emotional Impact:
This book doesn’t just tug heartstrings; it plucks them like a guitar, leaving a bittersweet hum long after the final page.
💬 Comparison:
Think *Eleanor Oliphant Is Completely Fine* meets *Call Me By Your Name*, but with a uniquely millennial voice.
📚 Recommendation:
Ideal for book clubs or solo reads on rainy afternoons—pair with a latte and a box of tissues.
---
Final Thoughts:
*Broke My Heart for the Plot* is a tender ode to the friendships that shape us, proving that sometimes the most profound love stories don’t need a label. Sherin Carol has crafted a narrative that feels like a conversation with an old friend—messy, beautiful, and utterly unforgettable.
March 5, 2025
I've just finished reading 'Broke My Heart for the Plot', and I'm still experiencing the emotional journey. This book defies conventional romance genres, instead offering a uniquely strong exploration of identity, belonging, and the complexities of human emotions.
As a third-culture kid, Ilaria's struggles to find her place in the world resonated deeply with me. Her destiny leading her to Creekhaven was a turning point, and I adored how the author wove together her encounters with strangers-turned-family, particularly the endearing Mrs. Langley and Madame DuBois. Their warmth and kindness radiated through the pages, making me feel like I was part of the community.
Then, of course, there's Shiloh - the boy with the golden heart. His interactions with Ilaria were pure magic, leaving me giggling and awestruck. Their shared passions and vulnerability made their connection feel authentic and relatable.
This book masterfully delves into the intricacies of human behavior, attraction, and emotions. It exposes the vulnerabilities that accompany love's happiness, making for a thought-provoking read. The diary entries in the second half added an extra layer of depth, showcasing Ilaria's complex emotions and introspective nature.
What struck me most was the author's skillful storytelling. And considering this is their debut novel, The writing is effortless, making it impossible not to devour the pages. Don't let the page count fool you-this book will consume you, and you'll be flipping the pages like a maniac to uncover the next revelation.
A truly remarkable read that will linger in your thoughts long after you finish reading.
✨Highly recommended✨
Perfect for fans of:
• Emotional and uplifting stories
•Relatable and well-developed characters
•Thought-provoking themes and discussions
•Beautifully written prose and flawless storytelling
As a third-culture kid, Ilaria's struggles to find her place in the world resonated deeply with me. Her destiny leading her to Creekhaven was a turning point, and I adored how the author wove together her encounters with strangers-turned-family, particularly the endearing Mrs. Langley and Madame DuBois. Their warmth and kindness radiated through the pages, making me feel like I was part of the community.
Then, of course, there's Shiloh - the boy with the golden heart. His interactions with Ilaria were pure magic, leaving me giggling and awestruck. Their shared passions and vulnerability made their connection feel authentic and relatable.
This book masterfully delves into the intricacies of human behavior, attraction, and emotions. It exposes the vulnerabilities that accompany love's happiness, making for a thought-provoking read. The diary entries in the second half added an extra layer of depth, showcasing Ilaria's complex emotions and introspective nature.
What struck me most was the author's skillful storytelling. And considering this is their debut novel, The writing is effortless, making it impossible not to devour the pages. Don't let the page count fool you-this book will consume you, and you'll be flipping the pages like a maniac to uncover the next revelation.
A truly remarkable read that will linger in your thoughts long after you finish reading.
✨Highly recommended✨
Perfect for fans of:
• Emotional and uplifting stories
•Relatable and well-developed characters
•Thought-provoking themes and discussions
•Beautifully written prose and flawless storytelling
February 1, 2025
Broke my heart for the Plot is a beautiful introspective novel that follows a young woman, Ilaria, as she leaves her hometown to study art and design, carving out a new life in an unfamiliar city. More than just a story of ambition, it’s a delicate exploration of cultural differences, personal growth, and the quiet yet profound relationships that shape us.
The protagonist’s journey is painted with vivid imagery—sketchbooks filled with fleeting moments, bustling city streets that feel both exhilarating and isolating, and a coffee shop that becomes her second home. Her job as a barista adds a comforting rhythm to the story, grounding her in a space where she slowly finds her place among strangers who become something more. She even adds a new touch to the shop with her talent.
One of the most compelling aspects of the novel is her platonic relationship with Shiloh. Their bond is filled with subtle gestures—happy moments, shared silences, and the unspoken understanding that doesn’t need words. In a world where romantic narratives often take center stage, this quiet companionship feels refreshingly real and deeply moving. But things change when the tables turn.
The writing is atmospheric and evocative, balancing introspection with everyday moments that feel like tiny, significant brushstrokes on a larger canvas. By the end, it’s clear that home is not just a place, but a feeling—a collection of people, moments, and spaces that make us feel seen.
For readers who love stories of self-discovery, quiet friendships, and the transformative power, this book is a must-read.
The protagonist’s journey is painted with vivid imagery—sketchbooks filled with fleeting moments, bustling city streets that feel both exhilarating and isolating, and a coffee shop that becomes her second home. Her job as a barista adds a comforting rhythm to the story, grounding her in a space where she slowly finds her place among strangers who become something more. She even adds a new touch to the shop with her talent.
One of the most compelling aspects of the novel is her platonic relationship with Shiloh. Their bond is filled with subtle gestures—happy moments, shared silences, and the unspoken understanding that doesn’t need words. In a world where romantic narratives often take center stage, this quiet companionship feels refreshingly real and deeply moving. But things change when the tables turn.
The writing is atmospheric and evocative, balancing introspection with everyday moments that feel like tiny, significant brushstrokes on a larger canvas. By the end, it’s clear that home is not just a place, but a feeling—a collection of people, moments, and spaces that make us feel seen.
For readers who love stories of self-discovery, quiet friendships, and the transformative power, this book is a must-read.
February 11, 2025
📚 Book- Broke My heart for the plot
✍️ Author - Sherin Carol
Rating: ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ✨ (4.5/5)
📄"Broke My Heart" by Sherin Carol is a poignant and thought-provoking novel that explores the complexities of love, loss, and identity. The story follows Ilaria, a young woman who relocates to Creekhaven for university, as she navigates the ups and downs of life, love, and friendship.
⭐The author masterfully weaves together themes of self-discovery, creativity, and the power of human connection. Ilaria's journey is deeply relatable, as she grapples with feelings of displacement and uncertainty, only to find solace in her art, music, and newfound friendships.
🖇️The supporting characters are equally well-crafted, particularly Shiloh, who brings a warmth and authenticity to the story. The romance that blossoms between Ilaria and Shiloh is sweet and tender, but also nuanced and realistic.
📌 What struck me most about this book was its thoughtful exploration of the human experience. Sherin Carol tackles tough topics like heartbreak, anxiety, and self-doubt with sensitivity and compassion, offering a message of hope and resilience that will resonate with readers long after they finish the book.
📍Recommendation:
If you enjoy character-driven fiction, romance, and stories about self-discovery, "Broke My Heart" is a must-read. Be prepared for a emotional rollercoaster, but also be assured that the journey will be worth it.
Thankyou! Happy reading📚
✍️ Author - Sherin Carol
Rating: ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ✨ (4.5/5)
📄"Broke My Heart" by Sherin Carol is a poignant and thought-provoking novel that explores the complexities of love, loss, and identity. The story follows Ilaria, a young woman who relocates to Creekhaven for university, as she navigates the ups and downs of life, love, and friendship.
⭐The author masterfully weaves together themes of self-discovery, creativity, and the power of human connection. Ilaria's journey is deeply relatable, as she grapples with feelings of displacement and uncertainty, only to find solace in her art, music, and newfound friendships.
🖇️The supporting characters are equally well-crafted, particularly Shiloh, who brings a warmth and authenticity to the story. The romance that blossoms between Ilaria and Shiloh is sweet and tender, but also nuanced and realistic.
📌 What struck me most about this book was its thoughtful exploration of the human experience. Sherin Carol tackles tough topics like heartbreak, anxiety, and self-doubt with sensitivity and compassion, offering a message of hope and resilience that will resonate with readers long after they finish the book.
📍Recommendation:
If you enjoy character-driven fiction, romance, and stories about self-discovery, "Broke My Heart" is a must-read. Be prepared for a emotional rollercoaster, but also be assured that the journey will be worth it.
Thankyou! Happy reading📚
February 6, 2025
Broken my heart for the plot by Sherin Carol is a bright romance read.
It starts with Shiloh, a third culture kid who begins her story by telling the various places that could be called home. The story then moves on to her past life and how she has reached in the quaint little musical town of Creekhaven. Then comes Ilaria, a bright boy who dreams and lives on music.
As soon as they meet, Shiloh knows that her heart has taken the leap. They start as friends who then move on to be best friends ,sharing important parts of their lives with eachother. The story then blossoms into a cute little romance as they go on and face various challenges together, like setting up stand , music rehearsal etc. Then comes the intersting part where Ilaria gets hold of something which makes him get a closer viewpoint of Shiloh's life.
The diary entry part of Shiloh made my interest really spike. Also, the part where they talk about boundaries in relationship, how they are there for eachother everytime,made me swoon over the couple.
Sometimes I found the story too detailed like an essay format but it also helped me in really getting to know the viewpoint and mentality of the lead characters.
The cover is really pretty and the title is apt. The word building is really constructive and good.
A really fun and heartfelt romance read.
It starts with Shiloh, a third culture kid who begins her story by telling the various places that could be called home. The story then moves on to her past life and how she has reached in the quaint little musical town of Creekhaven. Then comes Ilaria, a bright boy who dreams and lives on music.
As soon as they meet, Shiloh knows that her heart has taken the leap. They start as friends who then move on to be best friends ,sharing important parts of their lives with eachother. The story then blossoms into a cute little romance as they go on and face various challenges together, like setting up stand , music rehearsal etc. Then comes the intersting part where Ilaria gets hold of something which makes him get a closer viewpoint of Shiloh's life.
The diary entry part of Shiloh made my interest really spike. Also, the part where they talk about boundaries in relationship, how they are there for eachother everytime,made me swoon over the couple.
Sometimes I found the story too detailed like an essay format but it also helped me in really getting to know the viewpoint and mentality of the lead characters.
The cover is really pretty and the title is apt. The word building is really constructive and good.
A really fun and heartfelt romance read.
May 26, 2025
"Broke My Heart For The Plot" is a YA emotional yet a healing romance.
This is the story of Ilaria, a girl who starts a new journey in a new small town with nervous anticipation finds her best friend, a person who understands her, becomes her own person. They started to have the best life full of dreams and mischief and find their own identity at the same time. But when this friendship becomes something more Ilaria finds herself in the worst position of her life. And in this journey we witness how she overcomes it all.
The first thing that will catch your attention is how beautifully the author portrays the beautiful background with small town warm vibes, along with the chaotic life of college. It is so vivid you can transfer yourself there. Then the depth of Ilaria's character, the thoughts and desires are done so well all through the book. And not just Ilaria, Shiloh is interesting too as well as the minor characters.
As for the overall plot is good, keep you engage all these rollarcoster journey. But my best part of the story is when Shiloh starts reading the dairy entries. I keep thinking about that part, it somehow adds more intensity to the story. I enjoyed the whole story so much.
This is the story of Ilaria, a girl who starts a new journey in a new small town with nervous anticipation finds her best friend, a person who understands her, becomes her own person. They started to have the best life full of dreams and mischief and find their own identity at the same time. But when this friendship becomes something more Ilaria finds herself in the worst position of her life. And in this journey we witness how she overcomes it all.
The first thing that will catch your attention is how beautifully the author portrays the beautiful background with small town warm vibes, along with the chaotic life of college. It is so vivid you can transfer yourself there. Then the depth of Ilaria's character, the thoughts and desires are done so well all through the book. And not just Ilaria, Shiloh is interesting too as well as the minor characters.
As for the overall plot is good, keep you engage all these rollarcoster journey. But my best part of the story is when Shiloh starts reading the dairy entries. I keep thinking about that part, it somehow adds more intensity to the story. I enjoyed the whole story so much.
May 26, 2025
"Broke My Heart For The Plot" by Sherin Carol is a Young Adult fiction that is going to touch your heart with its "finding identity and root" tropes.
In the story we follow Ilaria, who moves to a fictional, picture perfect small town for her further studies. While she is dreading how she's going to adjust there, she meets a free spirited boy Shiloh and it starts a beautiful relationship and a journey for Ilaria.
The story mainly celebrates friendship and its different forms, and also the meaning of home, your people, your place. I love how the author shows the beautiful different sides of Ilaria and Shiloh's friendship, how it becomes so much more for both of them. And how it also becomes a reason for Ilaria's heartbreak and a self-discovery journey.
I like reading the book, it's enjoyable. So many places Ilaria's feelings are very relatable. But I also have to admit the story at times feels stretched a bit. But the way the book ends with an open ending. I cannot stop thinking about it.
So overall the book is a good one and I definitely recommend it.
In the story we follow Ilaria, who moves to a fictional, picture perfect small town for her further studies. While she is dreading how she's going to adjust there, she meets a free spirited boy Shiloh and it starts a beautiful relationship and a journey for Ilaria.
The story mainly celebrates friendship and its different forms, and also the meaning of home, your people, your place. I love how the author shows the beautiful different sides of Ilaria and Shiloh's friendship, how it becomes so much more for both of them. And how it also becomes a reason for Ilaria's heartbreak and a self-discovery journey.
I like reading the book, it's enjoyable. So many places Ilaria's feelings are very relatable. But I also have to admit the story at times feels stretched a bit. But the way the book ends with an open ending. I cannot stop thinking about it.
So overall the book is a good one and I definitely recommend it.
February 9, 2025
"Broke My Heart for the Plot" is a heartfelt story that captures the beauty of unexpected friendships and the longing for belonging. Ilaria, who has never quite found a place to call home, arrives in Creekhaven and finds an anchor in Shiloh—a friend who makes her feel understood in a way she never has before. Their bond is effortless, filled with late-night talks, shared laughter, and an unspoken connection that feels almost magical.
As life moves forward, the lines between friendship and something more blur, leaving Ilaria with a question she isn’t sure how to answer. The book beautifully portrays the complexities of relationships, the weight of unspoken emotions, and the courage it takes to face them.
With intimate and deeply personal writing, this novel is an emotional journey of self-discovery and connection. It’s a story that lingers, reminding us that home isn’t always a place—it’s the people who make us feel seen.
As life moves forward, the lines between friendship and something more blur, leaving Ilaria with a question she isn’t sure how to answer. The book beautifully portrays the complexities of relationships, the weight of unspoken emotions, and the courage it takes to face them.
With intimate and deeply personal writing, this novel is an emotional journey of self-discovery and connection. It’s a story that lingers, reminding us that home isn’t always a place—it’s the people who make us feel seen.
February 1, 2025
Ilaria was a art student who came to Purpville St for studies. She want to be in a place with people who loves arts like her and doesn't fear to share their interests. She is such a kind soul who always looking forward for good things and never hesitate to help others. And she meet a guy,Shiloh her neighbor who slowly becoming more than that.
I really love the bond between Shiloh and Ilaria. They are so good with eachother and always be there for each other. I love how Shiloh is so caring and such a gentleman with Illaria. Their chemistry between them is so adorable and Interesting 😭🤌🤩🥰🎀
Damm if you tell me I will be liking the book more than I am already, yes you are right. The last chapter hold more emotions and the way it was written do well? My god I really want to meet the author and hug her to tell that you are such a great written. 🤌😩🤩💗🔥
February 5, 2025
It was masterfully done to convey the tug of emotion and the dread of destroying something wonderful by desiring more. This steady flame isn't romantic; rather, it's about figuring out what for want of a better word feels such as the location and to someone. I found the book particularly noteworthy because of the way it examines identity, cultural displacement, and romance not just affection for one another, but relationships at its purest and most purest form.Her friendship with Shiloh is among the novel's most captivating elements. Subtle gestures, joyful moments, shared silences, and an unspoken comprehension that transcends words are all part of what makes up their bond. This modest friendship is profoundly touching and feels surprisingly genuine. But when the roles are reversed, things are different.
May 26, 2025
Oh. My. God. This book was everything! Broke
My Heart for the Plot took me on an emotional rollercoaster, and I loved every second of it. Ilaria and Shiloh's friendship was just so real-the kind of connection we all wish we had. The way the story explored belonging, not just in a place but in a person, was sO beautifully done. The best part? The tension. That unspoken "What if?" between them had me hooked. The writing made me laugh, tear up, and think about my own friendships in a whole new way. This book really made me think about my own friendships and all the things we sometimes Leave unsaid. It perfectly captures that bittersweet feeling of growing up, how relationships change, and the scary but exciting moment when you start wondering if there's something more. Honestly, it's one of the best books I've ever read-so full of heart, depth, and a kind of magic that stays with you.
My Heart for the Plot took me on an emotional rollercoaster, and I loved every second of it. Ilaria and Shiloh's friendship was just so real-the kind of connection we all wish we had. The way the story explored belonging, not just in a place but in a person, was sO beautifully done. The best part? The tension. That unspoken "What if?" between them had me hooked. The writing made me laugh, tear up, and think about my own friendships in a whole new way. This book really made me think about my own friendships and all the things we sometimes Leave unsaid. It perfectly captures that bittersweet feeling of growing up, how relationships change, and the scary but exciting moment when you start wondering if there's something more. Honestly, it's one of the best books I've ever read-so full of heart, depth, and a kind of magic that stays with you.
May 27, 2025
Alright, this book? It gives off that warm reminder of coffee on a rainy day. It follows Ilaria, a girl who goes to a new city to study art and has no idea on where she belongs until she meets Shiloh. He's that magical friend that gets you. Their friendship consists of meaningful conversations, amusing escapades, and the feeling of being at home in an unfamiliar place.
The way this book describes the painting of their story? So deep. There is a flying sensation in the sketchbooks, the city streets, and the cozy coffee shop around Ilaria. It's not only about her pursuing her dreams, it's about evolving, finding oneself, and figuring out that home isn't always a certain spot. Sometimes, it's people.
If you enjoy books that evoke real feelings, this one's for you. It's unadorned yet emotional, and the kind of story that overhangs over you even after you've finished reading it
The way this book describes the painting of their story? So deep. There is a flying sensation in the sketchbooks, the city streets, and the cozy coffee shop around Ilaria. It's not only about her pursuing her dreams, it's about evolving, finding oneself, and figuring out that home isn't always a certain spot. Sometimes, it's people.
If you enjoy books that evoke real feelings, this one's for you. It's unadorned yet emotional, and the kind of story that overhangs over you even after you've finished reading it
May 26, 2025
"Broke My Heart for the Plot" by Sherin Carol is a contemporary novel that delves into the profound connection between llaria and Shiloh. Ilaria, a third culture kid who has struggled to find her place, finally feels a sense of belonging in Creekhaven, largely due to her friendship with Shiloh-a carefree and supportive companion.
Their band is characterized by deep conversations and shared adventures, offering Ilaria the acceptance she's always yearned for. As their relationship evolves, Ilaria grapples with unspoken feelings and faces the dilemma of risking their friendship to explore a deeper connection. The narrative explores themes of belonging, the complexities of unspoken emotions, and the magic inherent in true friendship.
Their band is characterized by deep conversations and shared adventures, offering Ilaria the acceptance she's always yearned for. As their relationship evolves, Ilaria grapples with unspoken feelings and faces the dilemma of risking their friendship to explore a deeper connection. The narrative explores themes of belonging, the complexities of unspoken emotions, and the magic inherent in true friendship.
May 26, 2025
This book was such a beautiful and emotional read. It follows Ilaria, an art student who moves to a new city to follow her dreams. Along the way, she forms a deep friendship with Shiloh, a connection that slowly turns into something more. Their bond was one of my favorite parts of the book—it felt so real, full of warmth, understanding, and unspoken feelings.
What I loved most about this book was how it captured the feeling of finding "home" in people rather than places. The cozy coffee shop, the art, the city streets, it all felt so vivid and comforting. The writing was simple yet powerful, making it easy to connect with the characters and their emotions. If you enjoy heartfelt stories about love, friendship, and self-discovery, this book is definitely worth reading.
What I loved most about this book was how it captured the feeling of finding "home" in people rather than places. The cozy coffee shop, the art, the city streets, it all felt so vivid and comforting. The writing was simple yet powerful, making it easy to connect with the characters and their emotions. If you enjoy heartfelt stories about love, friendship, and self-discovery, this book is definitely worth reading.
May 26, 2025
Broke my heart for the plot by Sherin Carol! A captivating story of Romance, that takes you in a world of Ecstasy, Culture, Emotions, and a profound tale of relationship.
Shiloh's story is totally captivating, the sweet friendship with Ilaria, and the cute, lovely romance, the very nostalgia, with such details, that steals the heart completely.
Author Sherin Carol's superb narration, and the very fine plot, keeps you totally hooked, the more pages you turn. . . the more the story becomes intresting.
This is indeed a memorable read, and a beautiful combination of culture , music, love, nature. . . That the readers shouldn't miss.
Needle to say, it's worthy enough to take your time, to give you a mesmerising experience...
Recommended!!
Shiloh's story is totally captivating, the sweet friendship with Ilaria, and the cute, lovely romance, the very nostalgia, with such details, that steals the heart completely.
Author Sherin Carol's superb narration, and the very fine plot, keeps you totally hooked, the more pages you turn. . . the more the story becomes intresting.
This is indeed a memorable read, and a beautiful combination of culture , music, love, nature. . . That the readers shouldn't miss.
Needle to say, it's worthy enough to take your time, to give you a mesmerising experience...
Recommended!!
February 6, 2025
Reading this book felt like a warm hug in the form of words. Ilaria’s journey of self-discovery, the new city, the art, and—of course—Shiloh, made me feel like I was right there with them.
Their friendship is the kind you dream of—the kind that sees you, understands you, and makes the world feel a little less lonely.
The way the book paints their story is absolutely beautiful. Every moment—the sketchbooks, the city streets, the coffee shop—feels alive, like a piece of art in itself.
More than anything, it’s a reminder that home isn’t just a place; sometimes, it’s a person. And that realization? It stays with you.
Their friendship is the kind you dream of—the kind that sees you, understands you, and makes the world feel a little less lonely.
The way the book paints their story is absolutely beautiful. Every moment—the sketchbooks, the city streets, the coffee shop—feels alive, like a piece of art in itself.
More than anything, it’s a reminder that home isn’t just a place; sometimes, it’s a person. And that realization? It stays with you.
February 9, 2025
Broke My Heart for the Plot by Sherin Carol is a poignant exploration of friendship, belonging, and the delicate line between platonic and romantic love.
Ilaria, a third culture kid, finds solace in Creekhaven and an unbreakable bond with Shiloh, her steadfast, adventurous best friend. But as life propels them forward, unspoken emotions begin to surface, forcing Ilaria to confront what their connection truly means.
Author Sherin Carol masterfully captures the beauty and heartbreak of deep friendships, making this novel a heartfelt read for anyone who has ever questioned whether love or friendship is the greater force.
A tender, introspective, and deeply resonant story.
Ilaria, a third culture kid, finds solace in Creekhaven and an unbreakable bond with Shiloh, her steadfast, adventurous best friend. But as life propels them forward, unspoken emotions begin to surface, forcing Ilaria to confront what their connection truly means.
Author Sherin Carol masterfully captures the beauty and heartbreak of deep friendships, making this novel a heartfelt read for anyone who has ever questioned whether love or friendship is the greater force.
A tender, introspective, and deeply resonant story.
May 26, 2025
Broke My Heart for the Plot by Sherin Carol is a poignant exploration of friendship, belonging, and the delicate line between platonic and romantic love.
Ilaria, a third culture kid, finds solace in Creekhaven and an unbreakable bond with Shiloh, her steadfast, adventurous best friend. But as life propels them forward, unspoken emotions begin to surface, forcing Ilaria to confront what their connection truly means.
Author Sherin Carol masterfully captures the beauty and heartbreak of deep friendships, making this novel a heartfelt read for anyone who has ever questioned whether love or friendship is the greater force.
A tender, introspective, and deeply resonant story.
Ilaria, a third culture kid, finds solace in Creekhaven and an unbreakable bond with Shiloh, her steadfast, adventurous best friend. But as life propels them forward, unspoken emotions begin to surface, forcing Ilaria to confront what their connection truly means.
Author Sherin Carol masterfully captures the beauty and heartbreak of deep friendships, making this novel a heartfelt read for anyone who has ever questioned whether love or friendship is the greater force.
A tender, introspective, and deeply resonant story.
May 26, 2025
The story is about Ilaria, as she moves to a different town to pursue her dream. She has mixed feelings about staying, if she'll make friends or if she'll be able to adjust in the new environment.
This book isn't like the usual ones that you read.
From the first line, I was sucked into the beautiful world. The book is like a comforting hug to everyone who stays away from their home, for any reason, be it studies or job or anything else. The book provides reassurance that even if you are away from your home, that maybe the place where you are will turn into your second home, that you will find great people their who will start to seem like family.
This book isn't like the usual ones that you read.
From the first line, I was sucked into the beautiful world. The book is like a comforting hug to everyone who stays away from their home, for any reason, be it studies or job or anything else. The book provides reassurance that even if you are away from your home, that maybe the place where you are will turn into your second home, that you will find great people their who will start to seem like family.
February 1, 2025
Someone whose about to move out from her home , ilaria was the character with whom I connected the most.
I was hooked into Ilaria's voice—her longing for belonging, the quiet ache of feeling like an outsider no matter where she is something I deeply related to.
However, the real star of this novel is the relationship between Ilaria and Shiloh. The friendship feels so real—not only in the way they talk, but in those unspoken moments between them, where a glance or a pause carries more weight than words. The push and pull of emotions, the fear of ruining something good by wanting *more*, was beautifully done. It is a slow-burn not of the romantic kind but of finding out what, for lack of a better term, and to whom, feels like home. The way the book explores identity, cultural displacement, and love—not just romantic, but platonic love at its most raw and unconditional—made it a standout for me.
I was hooked and loved the story so much , it's the bittersweet emotions that made me fall in love with the story more .
I was hooked into Ilaria's voice—her longing for belonging, the quiet ache of feeling like an outsider no matter where she is something I deeply related to.
However, the real star of this novel is the relationship between Ilaria and Shiloh. The friendship feels so real—not only in the way they talk, but in those unspoken moments between them, where a glance or a pause carries more weight than words. The push and pull of emotions, the fear of ruining something good by wanting *more*, was beautifully done. It is a slow-burn not of the romantic kind but of finding out what, for lack of a better term, and to whom, feels like home. The way the book explores identity, cultural displacement, and love—not just romantic, but platonic love at its most raw and unconditional—made it a standout for me.
I was hooked and loved the story so much , it's the bittersweet emotions that made me fall in love with the story more .
June 11, 2025
It is one of those books that quietly makes its way to your heart.
Reading this book was a wholesome experience. I loved Ilaria's character so much, her strength, her confidence to build her life, her friendship bond with Shiloh, the cozy environment – coffee shop, her art, paintings, their world filled with self growth and development. If you're looking for an enjoyable yet inspiring read, this one's for you.
Displaying 1 - 29 of 29 reviews