Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Why Literature Still Matters

Rate this book
In this wide-ranging and accessible work, Jason M. Baxter puts our contemporary culture in conversation with literature and its “sister arts” to make the compelling—and sometimes chilling—case not just for the relevance but urgency of the humane tradition as we enter our “digital apocalypse.” Baxter draws on his areas of expertise, Dante and C.S. Lewis; his background in teaching the great books, art history, and music history; as well as his own travel literature to give his readers an almost sensuous feeling for what the alternative to our tech-obsessed culture is.

87 pages, Paperback

First published December 16, 2024

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Jason M. Baxter

11 books122 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
322 (60%)
4 stars
156 (29%)
3 stars
45 (8%)
2 stars
3 (<1%)
1 star
3 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 119 reviews
Profile Image for Cindy Rollins.
Author 22 books3,840 followers
December 26, 2024
Excellent little book that roars out of the starting gate with the first essay. So much food for thought and discussion in this volume!
Profile Image for Kay Pelham.
123 reviews64 followers
January 1, 2025
(May, 2025: The review below is for the first printing. Since that time a 2nd edition has been published with formatting changes, including book dimensions and font.)

This beautiful, little book is the first publication from Cassiodorus Press. Let's start with the *little* part: it was the intention of the publisher to provide a 'pocket-size' book that one could slip in his purse, large or small, and have with him wherever he was. The *beautiful* part: I'm going to say one of the things that makes me crazy when people say it of others --- It is 'beautiful inside and out'. Seriously, I usually hate that phrase. It's like I feel guilty for praising your outward appearance, so I've got to get all spiritual. Anyhow, this little book has a beautiful cover, with illustration by young artist Gabriel Chou. The beauty inside is provided by the layout and, of course, Jason Baxter's very poetic way of delivering his ideas.

I had to laugh at some initial criticism by a couple of people about the font size because it actually proved some of Dr. Baxter's points. Here's what I found the font size did for me: I had to slow down. Oh, horrors! Our modern (or post-modern) consumer culture has made us expect things to be smooth and fast. Two things that are illustrated from the start of this beautiful, little book. I could do a whole lot of pointing the finger to other people and our society but could feel that I am complicit also, as I felt compelled to hurry the reading to meet my goal to have it read and reviewed by the end of the weekend in which I received the beautiful, little book in the mail. (I went 3 days past my goal.)

I was particularly struck by how much a high-minded scholar such as Dr. Baxter could be so familiar with contemporary pop culture. When you read his words, it is obvious that these are observations he has made as he goes along with his daily life. He did not go looking for unfamiliar (to him) songs, art, or stories that he could negatively criticize to prove his point --- something that other writers do that comes across laughable and ineffective, like old Senators questioning tech people in hearings about things they haven't a clue about. Because Dr. Baxter lives a life of observation, contemplation, and caring, he comes across as way more authentic than most. His purpose is pure.

Many, many kudos to the staff of Cassiodorus Press for this debut production. I look forward to seeing Angelina Stanford, CP's Founder and Publisher, "among the regal and magnanimous souls on Dante's Jupiter", as Dr. Baxter predicts in his Acknowledgments.

Thank you, Dr. Jason Baxter, for this beautiful, little work, that will be carried about with me in my purse, ready to re-read many, many times. Slowly. Thoughtfully.
Profile Image for Melissa Grice.
247 reviews22 followers
December 30, 2024
I pre-ordered this book to support Dr. Baxter, but I was arrogant enough to believe he’d be preaching to the choir and he wouldn’t have anything new to tell me on this subject. I had forgotten that I’m a modern and Dr. Baxter is a dinosaur—he is to the 21st century what CS Lewis was to the 20th. I was humbled and thankful once again to be able to learn from him. This little book is an invaluable contribution to the conversation that we all need to have on modernity and humanity.
Profile Image for ladydusk.
632 reviews299 followers
January 24, 2025
I'll be thinking about this for a while.
Profile Image for Tori Samar.
625 reviews100 followers
December 30, 2024
“[W]hat I find myself wanting is not just to see beauty, but to be beauty, to make that which I see (or hear or read) become a permanent part of my being. I want to make that thing out there something in here. . . . As one of my teachers says, ‘I don’t want just to see beauty, I want to eat it.’”

I was tempted to binge read this book, but I made myself read it slowly. In many ways, this book is a call to slow down. Dr. Baxter explains so well how we have come to view the world (and ourselves) as a machine. That which is efficient, powerful, fast is the kind of thing we find “beautiful.” So when the natural world presents true beauty to us, we miss it entirely, either because we’re too frantic to stop and truly take it in or too busy quantifying the experience for likes and comments on social media.

What literature does for us then is slow us down. It slows time down. As Dr. Baxter notes, literature offers amplification in the proper sense of the word: “not a hyping up, an acceleration of mass, an increase of momentum, but rather the attempt to render a vision ‘full,’ generous, abundant, charged with density, alive beyond any expectation.” In feasting on great books (and I do mean feasting, not merely consuming), we learn how to feast on beauty, true beauty, once again.

I was already convinced that my reading life in 2025 needs to be about slowing down, about savoring my reading, about picking up longer books again, about taking in my books in whatever manner and at whatever pace they deserve. This book felt like confirmation that I’ve chosen the right path and just need to stay the course.
Profile Image for JoAnn Hallum.
105 reviews65 followers
December 27, 2024
The font is almost unreadable which I hope future printings will remedy because this book is gold for everyone, even the ones with slightly old eyes. Despite the issues with font I still gave it 5 stars because it is so brilliant.
Profile Image for Anne White.
Author 42 books434 followers
July 13, 2025
Four rather than five stars because it felt too short, somewhat incomplete. These days, short and succinct is often laudatory, because people can get through it even in a busy time. However, as Baxter himself points out, the fact that we are reluctant to meander says something worrisome about our changing attitudes towards reading.
Profile Image for Rebecca.
352 reviews6 followers
December 25, 2024
First Reading December 2024:

Four really fine essays.

"An expectation has gotten into our blood and our bones and our brains that we must constantly and actively seek to amp up our lives."

Second Reading:

Read for my CM book group. :)

"We are not readers because we "like" books. Of course we might sometimes simply read for entertainment, as Eliot relaxed by reading detective novels and Lewis relaxed by reading sci-fi, and my high school daughter relaxes by picking up her siblings' middle-grade fantasy novels. But, inspired by the vision I have articulated here, when we read with a sense of urgency, we are not reading primarily for entertainment. Rather, we are engaged in a deep reading, in which we find our hearts quickened, our spirits moved, and our souls enlarged. Those who are haunted by Joy would never describe their pursuit of the eternal -- in prayer, in liturgy, in love, in literature, in music, in painting -- as "entertainment"; rather, we hunger to eat, what Dante called, "the bread of the angels."
Profile Image for Becky Aniol.
45 reviews121 followers
December 3, 2025
Excellent book that isn’t difficult or long but gets you thinking deeply about not only literature but also beauty and culture. I want to go back and read it all again. Highly recommend.
Profile Image for Minte.
105 reviews9 followers
March 8, 2026
Excellent little read on beauty. If you care about literature and beauty, I would recommend this to you, and if you don't care about them, I would recommend it doubly. Baxter had some tough truths in here about the vapidity of social media culture and it was refreshing to read. His phrase "apocalypse of the imagination" is spot-on. I think he could have had another chapter; it did feel like it ended too soon.

I read this at the same time as The Educated Imagination by Northrop Frye, and I wonder if Baxter has read it. Lots of crossover in ideas and encouragement towards what is good in literature as well as why to read it.
Profile Image for Anda P.
148 reviews11 followers
December 27, 2024
Excellent tiny book with tiny font. Great content but some people may need a magnifying glass!
Profile Image for Amy Meyers.
933 reviews28 followers
December 23, 2025
I already agreed with the author about beauty, nature, and literary experiences before reading his book.

This is the second book I’ve “read” by Baxter on audio, and I’m learning he is not an author I can do that with. Certain books, usually nonfiction, need to be seen with the eyes, for me.

So that said, I listened a few times, but I still feel like I didn’t really “get” his point. Either I’m lacking (probable), or he didn’t do a good job at explaining his title. He did a great job at a meandering polemic against modernity and social media, et al, and on the importance of beauty and going out to touch grass. But I feel there are other books that are both more thorough and more insightful on both topics of modern tech/media and what it’s doing to us (not good), and beauty/culture. It’s easy to catch his many anecdotal stories, but I guess to be frank, I’d rather he have been a little more expositional or arranged his points more overtly in a logical order. I feel like I didn’t “catch” his title as clearly as I wanted to, having come into the book all ready to agree with him before he said a word. So I did agree with him, but honestly I felt like he could have argued it more tightly. But like I said, I’m guessing the problem is with me and the audio component.

I’m going to think about how to apply this to my reading next year. I feel tempted by GR’s suggestions and reading challenges to meet goals, regardless of what’s best for my soul, and that means I race through audiobooks without getting the book; but who cares about number of books in a year, if I wasn’t changed or delighted by them?
Profile Image for Danielle Z.
115 reviews4 followers
January 2, 2025
An uplifting, thought-provoking book that forces you to look at how the world has impacted our ability to read literature, but also shows us what we are missing when we give into the tendency to prefer efficiency to beauty, and consumption to savoring.

Ironically have a phone on hand to look up the music and art he references.

I will also say, the type is much too small and I hope this is remedied in future prints.

"... we are losing the ability to be moved by still things because we are moving too fast to be quiet in front of them."
Profile Image for Kerri.
4 reviews
January 8, 2025
“Our response to the whispering voice is the inner core of the literary life” ❤️😭

Dr Baxter took all the unexplained feelings and thoughts about the literary life and laid them out one by one. It really is a book for the reader who wants to know why they feel and think the way they do and the non reader who wants to understand why readers read.
Profile Image for Cynthia Egbert.
2,913 reviews40 followers
October 16, 2026
This was a book with fewer than 100 pages that took me months to read; so much great food for thought. I did not offer everything that I highlighted here, but I did offer what seems like much of the book. I just couldn't help it. It was that powerful for me.

“By his music, Orpheus could calm the hearts of savage beasts and lay a hushing spell on the underworld so that, once, even hell rested from its meaningless toil to listen for a while. According to this tradition, man and the world were made for one another. We belong to it, as much as it belongs to us. The natural world is a great book of ‘symbols,’ that is, natural phenomena that – somehow, someway – resonate and awaken some inner part within us. When we look at the moon over the sea – or a waterfall or cliff or skylark or nightingale – we sense a corresponding quality within. The world is like a tuning fork which, brought near to a second tuning fork – in this case, our hearts – causes the latter to vibrate as well. Inspired by what we see, we reach down into that inner depth, and, if we are able, pull out words or images or chords and scales for what we find, words or pictures or sounds we did not previously know we had. In this way, the natural symbol draws out something that had been ‘deeper down’ and hidden within. And this is why, when you look at a truly great painting, even of some very ordinary landscape, like Constable’s painting of Salisbury, you have an incredible experience: on the one hand, it all seems so plain and quotidian, but, at the same time, it seems saturated with a quality that makes it realer, denser, and slower than anything that could show up in ordinary life.”

“The nineteenth century discovered work, and play became increasingly distrusted. There was now much more work than play: the world resembled a factory rather than a theater.” -Byung-Chul Han

“What would happen, for instance, if my face-to-face relationship with you began to feel like a subset of my virtual interactions with you? In other words, if all day, every day, when you send me a text which amuses me and I ‘like’ it, and then I send something back to you and you ‘love’ it, is it possible that when I am in front of you and you say something I agree with, that how I respond to you could begin to feel like an imperfect attempt to ‘like’ what you’re saying, with slam effect? What I really need you to do is text that to me to be ‘real’ so I can express my ‘like’ properly. Otherwise, my assent does not feel complete.”

“If the restriction of the responses has the effect of narrowing emotional diversity, social media and advertising companies view this tradeoff as the necessary cost of gathering better data on users. The restricted emotional language employed by Facebook is a language a computer can understand and manipulate at scale. The simplified language of a core set of emotional reactions bridges the computational-human gap.” -David Auerbach

“In 2007 the Oxford Junior Dictionary removed close to forty words relating to the natural world in order to make space for words describing our more solitary and digital world. Words like acorn, wren, bramble, dandelion, and willow were removed to make way for words such as blog, broadband, chatroom, and MP3.” -Kristen Page

“But again, if we, like the characters we watch, spend our hours and minutes and seconds uploading our emotions into the system so that we download the energy into our lives and, by means of our devices, become high-octane, animated versions of ourselves, will we also slowly lose access to the emotional subtlety found in the rich treasury of our inherited language?”

“When we encounter beauty, it is almost always accompanied by a strange note of sorrow, a sorrow that arises because beauty feels like something over there, something external to me. And in my gazing upon it, what I find myself wanting is not just to see beauty, but to be beauty, to make that which I see (or hear or read) become a permanent part of my being. I want to make that thing out there something in here. I don’t want to be a tourist. I want to be a local. I don’t want to look at a beautiful country; I want to speak its language, understand the subtlety of its jokes, feel its feelings, hunger for its food, and use its curse words. As one of my teachers says, ‘I don’t want just to see beauty, I want to eat it.’ Or to put it another way: I don’t want to stream, I want to download.”

“God has given us the Morning Star already: you can go and enjoy the gift on many fine mornings if you get up early enough. What more, you may ask, do we want? Ah, but we want so much more – something the books on aesthetics take little notice of. But the poets and the mythologies know all about it. We do not want merely to see beauty, though God knows, even that is bounty enough. We want something else which can hardly be put into words – to be united with the beauty we see, to pass into it, to receive it into ourselves, to bathe in it, to become part of it.” -C.S. Lewis

“Apparently, then, our lifelong nostalgia, our longing to be reunited with something in the universe from which we now feel cut off, to be on the inside of some door which we have always seen from the outside, is not mere neurotic fancy, but the truest index of our real situation. And to be at last summoned inside would be both glory and honour beyond all our merits and also the healing of that old ache.” -C.S. Lewis

“But the good news is that I can, to whatever extent, close the gap between myself and the beauty out there. I can, to whatever extent, get it – a little bit – into the marrow of my bones. I can, to whatever extent, eat beauty.
And how?
Through literature, of course! And painting, and architecture, and music. And liturgy. Indeed, for Lewis, this was even the fundamental drive of ancient myth. We compliment our ancestors, with infinite condescension, believing that they were trying to take their first primitive steps toward science, toward being us, but Lewis thought ancient mythology was instead driven by this spiritual longing to metabolize the beautiful.”

“This, then, is the good news. To some extent, to some measure, we can overcome our time-bound mortality in the effort to draw closer to eternity. Literature – and her sisters arts – is driven by the secret desire to close the gap between myself and that beauty out there, to get that into me, to make beauty not something I simply gaze on, but something I feel palpably, sensuously, tangibly – something that is weighty and heavy and embodied and feels slow and spacious and still and suspended.”

“Walking and talking are two very great pleasures, but it is a mistake to combine them. Our own noise blots out the sounds and silences of the outdoor world; and talking leads almost inevitably to smoking, and then farewell to nature as far as one of our senses is concerned. The only friend to walk with is one (such as I found, during the holidays, in Arthur) who so exactly shares your taste for each mood of the countryside that a glance, a halt, or at most a nudge, is enough to assure us that the pleasure is shared.” -C.S. Lewis

“What is incredible is that, to describe this opulent, spacious, sensuous ‘slowness,’ Spenser would have used the word ‘amplification,’ a word also used to describe the art of modernity. But for our premodern ancestors ‘amplification’ was different: it was an elaborate unfolding within space, as opposed to an increase of the distance between peaks and troughs within time. Amplification was not a hyping up, an acceleration of mass, an increase of momentum, but rather the attempt to render a vision ‘full’, generous, abundant, charged with density, alive beyond any expectation. Amplification wasn’t connected to ‘amps,’ ‘amperes,’ and getting ‘amped up,’ but to ‘ampleness’. It was cornucopia, gracious fullness, generous abundance. It was a special phenomenon, not a temporal one. For us, good writing needs to be stripped down, deliver impact, download huge amounts of kilobytes. For our ancestors, language could luxuriate, grow abundant, by using those very tropes and schemes which we find so cloying. Spenser doesn’t want to rush through or create impact. He wants to slow time, overcome time – spatialize the temporal. He wants this poetic moment to feel dense, holy, and alive. Rather than rushing forward, he wants time to slow down, take its time, reach down into the depths within, while creating a sense of generous and slow spaciousness.”

“Lewis pauses to reflect on how fortunate he was to grow up as a child without access to cars: ‘The deadly power of rushing about wherever I pleased had not been given me. I measured distances by the standard of man, man walking on his two feet, not by the standard of the internal combustion engine. I had not been allowed to deflower the very idea of distance; in return I possessed ‘infinite riches’ what would have been to motorists “a little room”. The truest and most horrible claim made for modern transport is that it “annihilates space”. It does. It annihilates one of the most glorious gifts we have been given. It is a vile inflation which lowers the vibration of distance, so that a modern boy travels a hundred miles with less sense of liberation and pilgrimage and adventure than his grandfather got from traveling ten.’”

“In the lecture C.S. Lewis gave when he assumed his academic chair at Cambridge: De Descriptione Temporum he provocatively claimed that we have less in common with our grandparents’ grandparents, than they had in common with Caesar, Beowulf, Achilles, or the Pharaohs. He arrives at this stupefying assertion by reflecting on a fascinating question: what would happen if we spent more time around our machines than we spent with the natural world? What would happen if machine metaphors got into our imaginations so deeply that we forgot they were there, and, thus, without us even knowing it, we began to think and feel about ourselves and our lives and our goals as if we were machines or work functions too?
In Lewis’s view, this is exactly what happened. As metaphors drawn from classical mechanics slowly began to penetrate the vocabulary of the residents of the modern world, eventually even every-day people began to refer to themselves as ‘consumers’ and ‘producers’ who bring their ‘labor supply’ to ‘human resources departments’ and try, every day, to ‘optimize their productivity.’ What is more, Lewis also reflected on how there were shifts within our individual words, so that, sometimes, what had been words of praise for our ancestors became words of condemnation for us, and vice versa. For instance, Lewis wondered why we use the word ‘stagnation’ (a word that has overtones of malarial swamps) for social conditions our ancestors would have praised because of their ‘permanence.’ Lewis also asked why it is that when we use the word ‘primitive,’ we instantly feel connotations of ‘clumsiness, inefficiency, barbarity,’ whereas our ancestors talked of the ‘primitive church’ or the ‘primitive purity’ of a constitution and meant ‘pure’ and ‘vital’. And then there is my personal favorite: ‘Why does ‘latest’ in advertisement mean ‘best’?’ The answer, according to Lewis, is that now the image of ‘old machines being superseded by new and better ones’ has become for us the controlling archetype in our imagination. Lewis noted that machines and technologies are so important for us as moderns that they began to mark the great milestones of our lives. Along with our marriage and the births of our children, we also remember when we got our first iPhones, just as our grandparents marked out seasons of their lives when the telephone arrived or color television appeared. Indeed, for us, giving our children their first smart phone has become the ritualized initiation into adulthood that has supplanted confirmation, an ordeal of manhood, or bar mitzvah. Lewis was prescient, then: machines are in our brain and our blood and our words and in our air and in our water. Don’t we also tell one another that we don’t have the bandwidth to worry about that right now, but if you just give us a minute, I’ll process what you’ve said? Or we apologize for reverting back to a default mode; well, that’s ok – I guess that’s just how you’re hardwired. We refer to the assets in our department and worry that we might not have the resources we need to sufficiently maximize our outputs.
In other words, what sets us apart, not just from our grandparents’ grandparent’s generation, but from all the rest of human history, is what you might call the ‘psychological internalization’ of the mechanization of the world picture – a pretentious phrase perhaps, but it just means this: an expectation has gotten into our blood and our bones and our brains that we must constantly and actively seek to amp up our lives. We implicitly think of our lives as productivity functions, as if the years allotted to us were leased in return for mechanistic efficiency. And it is this expectation, not just of speed but of acceleration and efficiency and elimination of resistance that ‘separates us most sharply from our ancestors and whose absence would strike us most alien if we could return to their world. Conversely, our assumption that everything is provisional and soon to be superseded, that the attainment of goods we have never yet had, rather than the defense and conservation of those we have already, is the cardinal business of life, would most shock and bewilder them if they could visit ours.’ (Lewis).”

“And this is where it all begins to get a little scary.
If I am right – that next to the high-voltage, amped up paintings of Lichtenstein, the layered and still paintings of the Old Masters (like Rubens) feel slow – then we have an interesting problem. It’s not that paintings by Rubens have lost their beauty; it’s just that our ability to love them, to see them, to feel them, to enter into them has evaporated. We, like Lichtenstein’s machine-users, come at them with so much speed and force that they seem slow to us. Temporal amplification has replaced special amplification.
And if this is happening with our visual arts, could it also be happening with our music and our poetry? Could it be that I don’t have eyes to see beauty, even when it stands in front of me? Indeed, Lewis wondered, is it theoretically possible that we could so perfectly internalize the mechanistic paradigm, and so perfectly immerse ourselves into the world of speed, that we can’t read ancient literature anymore? If I bring speed with me, can I feel space? Can we get moving so fast that the literature of our ancestors just feels…slow?”

“At a beautiful spot while I was drinking in a perfect setting in nature, I watched in disbelief as one woman didn’t even look at the view with her eyes. Glowering, she lumbered up to the site with loose, bored limbs, staring at her phone the whole time, and then stopped, turned around, posed, smiled brilliantly, and took her selfie. As soon as that was over, her downcast look returned, and she moved back toward the car to drive sullenly away, without even having looked at the natural beauty with her own eyes. Her whole ‘experience’ took sixty seconds. I counted.”

“Why do we travel thousands of miles to crop the exotic and fit it into our own dimensions? Why do we domesticate the sites we profess admiration for? We conform them to our own image, and then we upload the experience into feeds and post it, in order to commodify the encounter with the wonderful. In other words, we transform a qualitative experience of beauty into a quantified one, the value of which I then judge in the currency of ‘likes’. Here’s me in front of a lake, me in front of a funny sign, me in front me…me…’100% you’. But this obliterates the possibility of travel…immersion, suspension, confusion, awe, and breakthrough. We are starved for spiritual nutrition, in part, because we consume things which have no calories and no nutritional value. It is for this reason that Byung-Chul Han goes so far as to call the ‘selfie’ phenomenon not only addictive but pathological, a disease in which I have lost interest in everything but my own face. But precisely because I’ve lost the ability to be nourished by anything outside of me, the images leave me hungry, and so I keep consuming, and keep posting and posting.”

“The addictive taking of selfies points toward the inner emptiness of the ego. The contemporary ego is very poor in stable forms of expressions with which it may identify, which would give it a solid identity…And just this insecurity, this anxiousness about oneself, produces the addictive taking of selfies, produces a self that is idling, and never comes to rest. Faced with its inner emptiness, the subject of the selfie tries in vain to produce itself…It is not a narcissistic self-love or vanity which generates the addictive taking of selfies, but an inner emptiness.” -Byung-Chul Han

“If I’m right, then, we are losing the ability to be moved by still things because we are moving too fast to be quiet in front of them…I starve my inner heart, while consuming outer experiences.”

“But does this affect how we read our texts? If, as we said above, literature is akin to being immersed within a landscape, what happens when you lose the landscape? Do you lose the primal analog which operates as the secret paradigm for reading in the first place? Is this the reason we have trouble with the stillness of premodern literature? Lewis seems to have thought so. He once suggested that there is now ‘an invisible wall’ that separates us from our ancestors: ‘The ‘beauties’ which they chiefly regarded in every composition were those which we either dislike or simply do not notice…We must reconcile ourselves to the fact that of the praise and censure which we allot to [premodern] poets only the smallest part would have seemed relevant to those poets themselves.’ (Lewis) In other words, if they could hear the critical judgments that we pass in college classrooms and put in Cambridge Companions, they would be astonished by how much we had missed the point.”

“What we would lose, by losing access to the natural world, is access to the language of the heart.”

“I also wanted to speak openly, so that we have a keen sense of urgency, a sense of urgency founded on the conviction that our world is starving to death even while over-consuming empty cultural calories – that we are undergoing a kind of apocalypse of the imagination. And so, for us, literature is not a pass-time. We are not readers because we ‘like’ books. Of course, we might sometimes simply read for entertainment, as Eliot relaxed by reading detective novels and Lewis relaxed by reading sci-fi, and my high school daughter relaxes by picking up her siblings’ middle-grade fantasy novels. But, inspired by the vision I have articulated here, when we read with a sense of urgency, we are not reading primarily for entertainment. Rather, we are engaged in a deep reading, in which we find our hearts quickened, our spirits moved, and our souls enlarged. Those who are haunted by Joy would never describe their pursuit of the eternal – in prayer, in liturgy, in love, in literature, in music, in painting – as ‘entertainment’; rather, we hunger to eat, what Dante called, ‘the bread of angels.’ And, yes, while we’re at it, we might look a little ‘mad-eyed,’ as Wilbur puts it, if we’re found reading introduction to medieval literature on the beach in California. But so be it: we’re reading to close the gap between the beauty out there and who I am in here. And when we have experiences like this, especially if we have them often, and we start to ‘get good’ at them, then we will, of course, also enjoy our reading.”
Profile Image for Elaine.
219 reviews46 followers
May 20, 2025
As an English teacher, I appreciated this book's call to action. I especially liked the section explaining that students (and the culture in general) used to enjoy recognizing and playing with anaphora, anadiplosis, and other rhetorical devices.

As a calculus teacher, I was incredibly frustrated by his broadsides against math, especially a random jab at Calc 2. It is important to distinguish between our cultures utilitarian obsession with STEM and the beautiful subject of mathematics.
Profile Image for Anna  Zehr.
216 reviews21 followers
January 1, 2026
I was surprised by the length. This author stops when he's done. I appreciate that.

I was also surprised by the scope of the book. It was narrower than I expected, with a primary focus on how literature provides a slow, deep experience in a fast-paced, shallow digital age. This narrow scope was deepened with Baxter's meditations and commentary on classic texts and poetry.

Maybe what I was hoping for can't be achieved by one author. I think I am looking for a book like this with essays by 4-5 authors of Baxter's ilk.

While I hope to get my hands on a physical copy of this book, I did enjoy the author's narration in the audiobook.
Profile Image for Lauren Fee.
445 reviews20 followers
May 6, 2025
This book so beautifully captures why I pursue a literary life.
Profile Image for Lois.
279 reviews45 followers
May 12, 2025
Absolutely amazing! Very readable but still full of depth. I’ll be passing this on to my husband as well.
Profile Image for Kerianne Noel.
124 reviews12 followers
January 1, 2025
A wonderful way to close out a year of reading! I began this book already in agreement with the message that literature, is vitally important, even though we as a culture are losing our ability to appreciate old books. What I wasn’t prepared for is what Dr. Baxter had to say about digital culture (how self-referential we have become, and how digital life flattens our real life experiences) as well as his musings about what is lacking in the messaging of the environmental movement. Mainly, Dr. Baxter underscores the value of (older) living books and the importance of long, leisurely time spent in nature as ways for us to enter into meaningful experiences of Beauty. But for Beauty to move us, we have to first be able to perceive it. That requires slowing down and renewing our own habit of attention. This last one is a convicting point for someone whose life has become increasingly hectic and whose reading life, in particular, has taken a turn toward being one of quantity over quality - or of quality being absorbed (or not) at too quick a pace. Perhaps there’s an invitation there to make 2025 my year of the (slow) re-read…
Profile Image for Mike Smith.
288 reviews7 followers
February 1, 2025
I hate to write this review because I want to rate anything of Jason Baxter’s highly, but I suppose I feel honesty compels me. I don’t think he answers the title question. The truth he lays out is much broader than literature. Even the descriptions of what literature does draw more on other art forms. He seems rather to be showing why contemplation, not literature, matters. And it seems many experiences can provide the same benefit.

However, Baxter still writes beautifully. I love how he relates his travel stories, though I find myself disagreeing with him again when he wants to leave Iceland, nauseous in its otherworldliness - I was exhilarated by the same.
Profile Image for Julia.
351 reviews70 followers
Read
August 14, 2026
"Read more old books!" to paraphrase C.S. Lewis.

I have read several books by different modern authors addressing the decline of culture and literacy. Almost all of them spend more time on the problem than the solution. I listened to the audiobook version of this one. I might need to go back and read it. It is hard to take notes while driving.
Profile Image for Hannah Landis.
254 reviews5 followers
June 24, 2026
Dr Baxter has a lot of good things to say and I would recommend the book.
Profile Image for Chloe.
3 reviews
October 2, 2026
I feel lightened and hopeful rather than downcast and depressed after reading this. I yearn more for beauty than ever before, yet feel excited because I know how much there is in the world even in little things, like a leaf or a poem. I need to read this again, it was so good! Maybe I will understand more next time, and be able to put it into better words. Now I'm off to read some Tolkien!
Profile Image for Erin Ching.
500 reviews
April 16, 2025
This was a very good set of essays on the value of literature in our current time of efficiency / productivity, distraction, and social media scrolling. I especially enjoyed the first and last essays. The font was strangely small.
Profile Image for Kiersten.
32 reviews6 followers
December 31, 2024
An extraordinary and vital little volume. This will merit several rereads in the near future.
Profile Image for JL Torres.
68 reviews5 followers
February 5, 2026
"We are not readers because we "like" books. Of course we might sometimes simply read for entertainment, as Eliot relaxed by reading detective novels and Lewis relaxed by reading sci-fi, and my high school daughter relaxes by picking up her siblings' middle-grade fantasy novels. But, inspired by the vision I have articulated here, when we read with a sense of urgency, we are not reading primarily for entertainment. Rather, we are engaged in a deep reading, in which we find our hearts quickened, our spirits moved, and our souls enlarged. Those who are haunted by Joy would never describe their pursuit of the eternal -- in prayer, in liturgy, in love, in literature, in music, in painting as "entertainment"; rather, we hunger to eat, what Dante called, "the bread of the angels."

"But so be it: we're reading to close the gap between the beauty out there and who I am in here. And when we have experiences like this, especially if we have them often, and we start to "get good" at them, then we will, of course, also enjoy our reading.

And so, yes, we're coming to our studies with a sense of urgency, in part because we are weak and fragile and distractible, and, in part, because so few people value what we know, what we have heard, and what we have felt to be of infinite moment. And we know, at the same time, how almost everything in our "data-culture" - our hyped-up culture of acceleration and force and vertically stretched functions - feels inimical to depth, to stillness, and to the secret longings of the heart."
Profile Image for Ben Nash.
127 reviews7 followers
April 21, 2025
I had high expectations for this, as I loved Baxter's book "The Medieval Mind of C.S. Lewis". This one missed the mark. He didn't set a compelling answer for why literature matters.

The first 2 chapters were fine. The 1st is about the metaphors we live by, and he talks about the chasm there is between us and beauty and the search for it. He talks about how we can close the gap through art, but doesn't explore that much.

It didn't seem much like a book on literature but more on how technological advances and machines affect us.

For a more thorough and biblical/wise outlook on that topic, I highly recommend Tony Reinke's "12 Ways Your Phone is Changing You."

I was hoping he would get to the beauty of God, and how even good and beautiful art is a reflection of God's beauty, and how good literature should teach and delight the reader, but he doesn't explore that deeply.

The book seems too short, a bit thrown together, and it's hard to say what it's mainly about...slowing down? metaphors we live by? man's search for beauty? or the dangers of machines/technology?

The last 2 chapters and epilogue were not needed which is a bummer because that's half the book.

I was really excited for this book, and the topic warrants a great conversation, but the book leaves much to be desired and is lacking.

Don't let this deter you from reading his book on C.S. Lewis which is wonderful.
Profile Image for Sarah Kellogg.
204 reviews50 followers
Read
September 18, 2025
Leaving this unrated for now. I listened to the audiobook, which is read by the author, who speaks with so much passion and has a lovely smooth voice. However, this is the kind of media that I need to have in front of me so I can reread certain paragraphs and let the words fully sink in. Will return to review after reading a physical copy.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 119 reviews