Everyone in Charleston is gathered for the annual Isle of Palms yacht race. They sip tea from Theodosia Browning's Indigo Tea Shop at the "tea by the sea" event waiting for the yachts to come into harbor. Just as the winner is about to be announced, 61-year-old Oliver Dixon picks up an antique pistol and poises to fire to signal the end of the race. As he does, the pistol explodes and Oliver is dead. While everyone thinks it was a tragic accident, Theodosia is not so sure. What if someone rigged the pistol to explode on purpose? Detective Tidwell seems to think it was an accident but won't rule out murder. He sets his sights on Ford Cantrell, a drunken party crasher who had words with Oliver just before Oliver's death. Ford's sister, Lizbeth Cantrell, calls on old ties to Theodosia's family and asks Theodosia to prove her brother innocent. Theodosia feels compelled to help but she wants to see justice done and to do that and possibly clear Ford's name, she has to catch the real killer. At Drayton's mystery tea event, Lizbeth wants to know who killed Oliver Dixon but before the fortune teller can answer, the power goes out and the tea cup is shattered. It's up to Theodosia to keep ferreting out clues, sending them to Detective Tidwell and hoping he'll catch the killer.
I liked this mystery better than the first one. I had an inkling of who it might be at first when that person was introduced but then I quickly changed my mind. I never guessed who the murderer was. There really aren't any solid clues. I loved the themed teas concept and this book introduced me to some new teas I haven't heard of before. I may even order some South Carolina tea to try. The head jumping is less than in the first book but still jarring and weird. Also very unnecessary. The plot of this one is very dated. It's the early 00s when PDAs were becoming all the rage and the world is going wireless. These people act like they've never heard of the internet before, let alone wifi. Invest in Apple, not Grapevine, or perhaps Grapevine is a fictional Apple? What did we do without our Smart Phones? It's weird to read landlines ringing and answering machines picking up!
The characters still don't wow me though. I kept hearing some of them speak in BBC period drama accents because they came across as stuffy and old-fashioned. I don't like the third person narration. Theodosia is nice enough. She's kind and hospitable. She's a little too nice and a bit of a pushover. She's also very nosy. She really has no reason to investigate this potential murder but she feels compelled to because Lizbeth Cantell helped take care of Theo's mother and played with young Theo while her mother was dying. Sure that's nice but it sounds like it was Lizbeth's job, maybe she's a hospice nurse and that was a long time ago. Theodosia shouldn't feel beholden to anyone just because they were kind and helpful when it was the right thing to do. She's an ex-marketing manager turned tea shop owner, not the police. Her potential romance seems to have fizzled out. They're both too busy for a relationship right now it sounds like. Theodosia is not the most effective sleuth but she does share her findings with the police, even if it leads to the wrong person being accused.
Drayton is the master tea blender and basically the mastermind behind the whole operation. He blends the teas, chooses the packaging and has come up with themes for events. He has some great ideas and if they didn't serve food, I'd absolutely attend an event. He comes across as super old-fashioned and stuffy, a relic from another era. I love history and I'm all about historic preservation but I also love modern technology and it's very necessary to our lives, sadly. He won't be able to do anything without a computer, the internet and soon, an iPhone yet he resists. Come to the dark side! Haley, the young employee, is more with it. She has a Palm Pilot and is eager to try any new technology. She's cheeky and a lot of fun though she complains about doing her job when she's given extra work to do. That's not the way it works!
Another series regular is Delaine, a clothing boutique owner and the neighborhood gossip. She's horrible! She's nosy and needs to know literally everything about a person and then promptly shares that information with everyone else without a thought. She doesn't understand there may be consequences. She also doesn't understand that some people are on a budget and can't afford her shop. She keeps pushing Theo to make a purchase Theo can't afford! Delaine talks the ears of people until they buy something just to get away from her. Yikes! I do not like her one bit. I also don't like Timothy Neville much. He's the president of the Heritage Society and very strange. He's rude, mysterious and odd. He improves by the end of the story but he is not someone I want to know either. Miss Dimple, Theodosia's bookkeeper, is a kind, elderly woman who seems to have a sense of fun and playfulness. She is happy to be asked to help investigate. A Miss Marple fan perhaps? Or Jessica Fletcher wannabe? Detective Tidwell is a blustery sort of man. He talks the talk and tries to flummox Theodosia. He's paid to find the most likely suspect, not prove their innocence or guilt. He's not very pleasant but I think he and Theo are coming to an understanding. I think he respects her intelligence and knows she has the gossip hotline operating next door. A big shout out to Early Grey, the bestest good boy ever! He's a therapy dog who visits the elderly at their assisted living/nursing home. They love to spoil him and treat him to a special liver brownie cake. Lucky dog to have found Theodosia who is willing to take him to places where he will get extra attention and treats.
New characters include the victim, Oliver Dixon, a 60-something year old newlywed. He's a beloved member of the community and involved in a tech start up company manufacturing add-ons for PDAs. (I'm channeling my inner fortune teller and telling him to invest in Apple! ;-) ) Oliver seems smart and rich. He's active in one of the local yacht clubs, hence the honor of closing the race. Oliver also seems devoted to his new and much younger wife. Doe Belvedere is 25 if she's a day and a former beauty queen, sorority girl and most likely, a gold digger. She's the type who has everything handed to her and coasts through life based on looks alone. Looks don't last honey. Take your hubby's money and invest it in Apple! Theodosia has an iMac (more dated than a Palm Pilot), she sees what's what! Doe does not act like the grieving widow at all. She's young and maybe it hasn't hit her or maybe she's acting a role for the public or maybe she was a gold digger and doesn't care her husband is dead. I'm leaning towards gold digger because she's selling off her late husband's possessions ALREADY, before the funeral! She's selling with the help of Oliver's second cousin, Giovanni Loard, an eccentric, pretentious antiques dealer. He seems charming, knowledable about antiques but not tea and very charming. Theodosia likes him a lot. He seems distressed at first that his cousin has been killed and is the first to jump into action. That doesn't make him seem like a murderer but then he's helping Doe sell things which could be kind of him or calculating. How does she know she can trust him?
Ford Cantrell shows up at the yacht race drunk to argue with Oliver. Their families are long standing rivals like the Hatfields and the McCoys. What was the argument about? Ford has a hunting and nature preserve out in the country. Aunt Libby is skeptical because she's never seen any of the more normal creatures he advertises, let alone wild boar! The man sure likes his guns and is a little creepy. Is he merely eccentric or warning Theodosia off her investigation? Either way, he's creepy and not someone I would like to cross. Billy Manolo is a handyman who works for the yacht club. He was at the race setting up. He even borrowed a tablecloth from Theodosia. The man is cranky and has a short temper. He even threatens Theodosia. I really think some of the clues point to him as the murderer. He has the opportunity and has the temper to do it. Did he have the knowledge? I hope the murderer was Booth Crowly, another prominent member of Charleston society. He's a wealthy businessman and likes to throw his weight around and threaten people. He's seen arguing with Billy and is a yacht club big wig. UGH This guy is just awful. Toss him in jail for being an all around horrible person. I don't think he's bluffing when he threatens Theodosia so what is he hiding he doesn't want her to know about? Did he load the pistol that killed Oliver?