There may be some dispute about what the purpose of philosophy should be, but one strong contender is that it should be about seeking the good life and finding happiness. In this selection of stories, Voltaire, the philosopher’s anti-philosopher, shows many characters seeking happiness in different ways, and we get to see just how elusive that happiness is.
This volume comprises six stories. Candide is of course the most famous one, and tells the tale of a young man dismissed as a servant and forced to fend for himself in the world. He is accompanied by an optimistic philosopher called Pangloss who believes that we live in the best of all possible worlds, but this is constantly belied by the series of terrible disasters and atrocities that are experienced or witnessed by Candide and his companions.
Micromegas is a shorter story about giants from outer space who commune with the philosophers of Earth. The story ends in a discussion about the soul, in which the giants laugh at the more arrogant pretentions to human superiority that are expressed.
Zadig is the tale of a philosopher who keeps hoping that the pursuit of virtue will bring him happiness, but he passes from one misfortune to another. He finally reconciles himself to the notion that everything is intended for the best (a conclusion strangely at odds with Candide), but the tale ends ambiguously with a happy ending, followed by a few more events that tail off.
In the only poem of the collection, What Pleases the Ladies, a knight is helped to glory by an old crone, but she insists on his marrying her and consummating the marriage. Though repelled by the old woman, he agrees to do so, and is rewarded when she turns out to be a beautiful fairy.
For The Ingenu, we have the tale of a Huron with European blood who is utterly unfamiliar with European customs. Attempts are made to educate him into French habits and Catholicism, but the Huron is free from the prejudices of a conditioned upbringing, and is soon able to think more freely than this. In a second half to the story that is never successfully integrated, we see Saint-Yves have sex with an official to secure the release of her lover (the Ingenu), and watch her die from guilt and shame.
Finally, the book ends with The White Bull. Drawing on a traditional tale of a princess seeking to remove a curse on her lover who has been turned into a bull, the story also finds time to include (and mock) a large number of Biblical stories and characters.
Voltaire offers us no final answer about what it is to be happy, but he spends some time exploring the idea, and he certainly has many ideas about what makes us unhappy. Happiness in Voltaire’s stories generally comes from within, and it is no surprise that the conclusion of Candide shows our hero learning to tend to his own garden. Zadig and the Ingenu find greater peace of mind by cultivating their mind through learning and philosophy.
However, we must not mistake this for any specific system of philosophy. Voltaire is somewhat down on philosophical systems. The absurd optimism of Pangloss is constantly belied by the horrors of a tale that includes murder, slavery, robbery, rape and dismemberment.
Curiously the only thing that makes the appalling events of Candide palatable is Voltaire’s seeming callousness towards his characters. The tale is told in a matter of fact way, and we are encouraged to laugh at the catalogue of atrocities, and to ridicule the foolishness of our heroes.
Zadig’s optimism about virtue is also seen to be misplaced, and a large part of his story is spent seeking to find a golden mean between two forms of virtuous behaviour that both seem to get him into trouble. In Micromegas too, philosophers are reduced to absurdity. They are figures so small that the giants do not even realise the planet is inhabited at first, but they still have inflated ideas about the importance of humanity.
It may seem strange that a philosophical writer such as Voltaire should seem to have such a low opinion of many fields of philosophy but actually this is quite characteristic. Many academics and intellectuals devote a large part of their writings to debunking the work of their colleagues.
The ultimate limit of philosophy however is that happiness is frequently unobtainable for Voltaire’s characters because they are at the mercy of external forces. At best, they can find a way of becoming resigned to their fate, and avoid making their misfortunes worse by their own actions.
It is in this field that Voltaire’s satirical bent is given full sway. As is typical of satirists however, his eagerness to reduce everything to absurdity risks losing sight of all principles, even the ones that he believes in.
For example, Voltaire believed in the need for strong government, but his portrayal of rulers in his stories is not a favourable one. Many of the appalling happenings portrayed in Candide were true historical events, and needed only a little exaggeration. In The White Bull, the tyranny and insecurity of monarchy is stressed so much that it is hard not to feel that it unconsciously presages the French Revolution, which was soon to happen.
In his portrayal of religion, Voltaire also goes perhaps further than he intended. Voltaire does not appear to have been an atheist, but he inadvertently makes a good case for it. His works are fiercely anti-clerical, and a number of corrupt or inept clergymen are dotted throughout the stories. They are seen giving poor education, or seeking to seduce women.
The White Bull ridicules Old Testament stories and reduces them to the level of absurd myths similar to those of Greek legends. The constant misfortunes of the characters in Candide, Zadig and other tales also fail to suggest an orderly universe controlled by a benevolent being. In The Ingenu, Voltaire writes:
“It is an absurdity, an outrage against the human race, an attack on the Infinite and Supreme Being, to say: ‘There is one truth essential to man, and God has hidden it’.”
Voltaire here comes closest to acknowledging the absurdity of believing in a god that commands a single truth open to all, but somehow fails to make this known to us. However, he cannot quite follow through this obvious conclusion, and soon shies away from it.
While Voltaire’s views were certainly advanced in many ways, they are still somewhat behind our own thinking – at least what we now consider advanced. He is occasionally anti-Semitic. His portrayal of women is often dubious too. When the riddle of ‘What Pleases the Ladies’ is revealed, it turns out that it is love of power. There are also plenty of fickle and faithless women in Voltaire’s stories, with only a few virtuous ones.
Not that Voltaire’s morality is too narrow-minded. When Saint-Yves agrees to have sex with Saint-Pouange in order to obtain the release of the Ingenu, and then dies from the shame, Voltaire clearly feels that she is more wrong to give way to guilt than she was to perform the sexual deed. There is no sense here of a woman corrupted forever by sex, and if she had confessed her action to Hercules (the Ingenu), it is clear that he would not have condemned her.
Voltaire’s works are not for those who are seeking good characterisation, and stories in which you care for the people in them. However, they are fascinating intellectual studies that offer amusing subversions of popular genres. He is certainly never dull, and the stories brim with erudition and interesting ideas.