'A Crystalline Glimpse of Hope'
I am using this often-abused term "hope" in starting this review, even though I know that Thomas Moore himself regards "hope" as so confusing that he warned me against using it when writing about his new book. I interviewed him for an upcoming magazine story I am writing about the publication of The Eloquence of Silence, which is approximately Moore's 30th book and is distinctively different than many of his other books.
"The word hope can be a problem," he told me in our interview. "People will think I'm talking about hoping for something, something they might want or some specific outcome. But when I talk about hope, I'm not interested in those things. I don't know what the future holds. I don't think that hope refers to a specific set of doctrines. But generally I would say that hope is an essential way of approaching life, as in the call to value 'faith, hope and charity.' If we are concerned about how to live in a community, today, I can't think of a better trio to follow than faith, hope and charity. But don't let people think that I'm talking about hope for an object of desire."
So I have added Moore's qualifier from his own lips.
And, now, I can write clearly in this review: This is a remarkably hope-filled book. Despite many of the somber spiritual challenges posed in this book, it's overall a remarkably joyful collection of readings.
If you have been a fan of Moore's work, perhaps since his 1992 best-seller Care of the Soul, then you know that his books cover a cosmic range of themes. Among the favorites by Moore in my home library are 2004's Dark Nights of the Soul and 2017's Ageless Soul. But, along the way, Moore even wrote a book abut golf. No kidding. I don't own a copy, but for the record it's called The Guru of Golf.
In his vast literary output, then, it's saying something to call this book "unique."
So, why is this one so unusual? Let's start with the fact that he encourages readers to dive in anywhere, almost on any page. You could read the chapters in this book in reverse order, if you want, or select chapters at random. Each one is a crystalline artwork, and I use that word intentionally because Moore himself says he thinks of this book as an "artwork."
Each chapter opens with a brief excerpt of a classic spiritual tale or essay or poem. Then, he tells us a little true story that casts light through the lens of that opening passage. The result is chapters that are just a few pages long and that light up like a Dale Chihuly glass creation, sometimes delighting readers and sometimes troubling us.
The opening passages in each chapter are drawn from a wide range of faith traditions. Many of these very brief passages amount to stories you'll be eager to read to a friend as soon as you have discovered them. I know that was my experience reading this book. People got a little tired of my saying, "Oh! Oh! I've got to read this one to you, too."
The central theme of the book is described as "silence" in the main title, but in my interview with Moore he admitted that the word that really captures the main theme is: "emptiness."
"But who would buy a book that says it's about emptiness? That sounds like a blank book," he joked, explaining why he agreed to The Eloquence of Silence as the main title and hid the word "emptiness" in the book's subtitle.
What else makes this book special? It's so easy to read! While many of Moore's books are written for specific audiences—sometimes aimed more at religious leaders, therapists and academics than ordinary readers—this book is for all of us. There's something here for everyone to discover, day by day, and there's no excuse that you don't have the time. These chapters take just a few minutes.
And for all of that hopeful, joyous light Moore has given us—I'm as happy with this new Moore book as I've been since I first discovered Care of the Soul more than 30 years ago.