Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Trading Fate: How a Little-known Company Stopped British Columbia from Becoming an American State

Rate this book
This uniquely west-coast take on Canada's origin story focuses on a long-forgotten event that nearly led to British Columbia becoming part of the United States.

Long before a certain American president took to social media to express his desire to make Canada the fifty-first state, the west coast of what is today called British Columbia found itself in the crosshairs of two imperial powers, faced with the very real possibility of being ceded to the United States.

In the summer of 1789, a political and trade dispute between the Nuu-chah-nulth Nation, imperial Spain, Great Britain, and the USA converged in Nootka Sound, off Vancouver Island. If not for the intervention the King George’s Sound Trading Company, Vancouver Island and British Columbia’s fate could have turned out very differently, and the concept of a Canada that extended from Atlantic to Pacific would have been finished before it even began.

With clear, engaging prose, author Graeme Menzies lays out the setting, intrigue, and dynamic cast of characters that ultimately determined Canada’s geographical fate. Released at a time when imperialism, sovereignty, and national identity are more relevant than ever, this book asks us to ponder the events that shaped a nation and established a relationship between neighbouring countries that has once again become precarious.

288 pages, Paperback

Published September 16, 2025

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Graeme Menzies

9 books4 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
6 (24%)
4 stars
11 (44%)
3 stars
7 (28%)
2 stars
1 (4%)
1 star
0 (0%)
Displaying 1 - 8 of 8 reviews
Profile Image for Ian Beardsell.
297 reviews38 followers
June 17, 2026
I grabbed this book from my library wondering if the author, Graeme Menzies, was actually related to the botanist who was on Vancouver's voyage to Nootka in 1792. If so, there was no mention....

In any case, the modern Menzies has crafted a book that nicely summarizes BC's political history under the thesis that the Nootka Crisis of the late 1780s essentially set the stage for how BC became destined to join Canadian Confederation.

The book was an excellent supplement to my recent readings of the voyage of George Vancouver, who was sent out to Nootka Sound on the western shores of the island that now bears his name, to settle a dispute over trading rights in that area. In brief, although the Spanish had briefly explored the Pacific Northwest coast in the early 1770s, they were taken by surprise when Captain Cook's crew made a fortune in trading the otter pelts they had collected in their extended 1778 visit at Nootka Sound, also known as King George Sound. This resulted in a bit of a "fur rush" to the area in the 1780s, culminating in the Nootka Crisis when the King George Sound Company was turned away from trading by the Spanish Admiral Martinez, who was sent by the authorities to impose more of a presence on the northern coastline. Eventually England reached an amicable agreement with the Spanish, who backed away from their reliance on the centuries old papal bull of the Inter Caetera, which they believed had given them rights to all territories west of a certain point in the Caribbean. The consensus had now become that territorial expansion needed to be backed up by actual settlement as claimed by the British fur traders.

From the Nootka Crisis, Menzies takes us through the indigenous peoples' reaction to the fur trade, which, at least under the British, was going reasonably well until more and more Americans got involved in the 1800s. There has always been an axis of North-South trade in the Pacific Northwest due to the geographical fact of the Rocky Mountains cutting off the coast from the rest of the continent. The British saw the writing on the wall as they saw so many American settlers pouring into the Oregon Territory after the explorations of Lewis and Clark that they decided they needed to pull the fur trade north to a fort at the tip of Vancouver Island, which became our provincial capital, Victoria, BC. From President Polk's "54-40 or fight", manifest destiny, and sheer numbers, Americans threatened to swamp this British bastion until Canada proposed building a continental railroad all the way to the west coast to incorporate the region into the newly formed country that had gained political independence from London.

The book covers a lot of territory, somewhat quickly and lightly, but one can really see how Menzies is quite accurate on his take that the early squabble over fur trading at Nootka set the stage for British Columbia ultimately becoming a Canadian province rather than an American state.
25 reviews1 follower
October 17, 2025
Trading Fate is extremely well researched and written. It presents a history of British Columbia origins in a readable and engaging way. Well done.
3 reviews
August 4, 2026
West Coast - Best Coast since 1778.

Super interesting read , who knew that Spanish and British both were chilling with the Indigenous People in the land that would become B.C. way back 250 years ago. Menzies brings us right into the history of a time that is hard to imagine now (sail around the entire continent to get some paper signed). Well researched with plenty of personal stories of the explorers and sailors and merchants and First Nations, kept the pages turning. Brings it all home with a compelling argument and a couple of ‘sliding door’ moments that would have changed the shape of BC and Canada. Menzies is the Erik Larson of BC History research and personalized history.
Profile Image for Dave Betts.
63 reviews1 follower
August 6, 2026
Easy to read, and easy to understand history of Spanish, British and American conquest of the western part of the North America and how British Columbia became a part of Canada.
Profile Image for Dalton Hurren.
12 reviews
December 18, 2025
Always interesting to read about uncommon events that leave large ripples in history
Profile Image for Dan Trefethen.
1,366 reviews94 followers
October 10, 2025
200 years ago, the state of the North American west coast was very unsettled. Spain held most of the Southwest, including California. Russia had claim to Alaska. But from the Oregon border (roughly) up to the Alaskan panhandle, it was open country without a strong claim.

And then they found sea otters.

The fur trade galvanized interest in the west coast. The trade centered on Nookta Sound on Vancouver Island and a few other nearby locations. England, Spain and the United States took interest.

The author's thesis is but for an English trading company and a ham-handed encounter by a Spanish captain to capture English ships, the west coast may have been claimed by Spain as part of its coastal territory, and then handed to the Americans at the end of the Mexican War along with their other North American possessions. That would have been 1848. When America bought Alaska from Russia about 20 years later, that would have given the United States the entire west coast. At the end of the Mexican War that 49th parallel border only extended to the Rocky Mountains, and the Dominion of Canada was 20 years away. Canada would have stopped at the Rockies. Until Dominion, British Columbia was an English colony, and they voted on whether to maintain that or join the Dominion.

The book describes many voyages and encounters with the Native Americans, pointing out that Enlightenment attitudes by the British were more advanced than the later American attitudes (much less the Spanish one of conquest and conversion to Catholicism). This meant the British had some good, balanced relations based on trade with the tribes, and acknowledged tribal ownership of land; it could be bought, but not seized.

It's good to remember how fluid borders were, once upon a time. They are human constructs, and the determination of them can be messy, time-consuming, and turn on seemingly small actions by a few people.
Profile Image for Andrew.
445 reviews3 followers
May 22, 2026
This book is a history of British Columbia, specifically how it relates to how it became a province of Canada. The books starts with the first European discovery by the British and Spanish sailors. The book continues through the fur trading years and increasing American presence in the Oregon Territories with pressure to become a British colony. Finally there was the debate about joining Canada.

The author postulates that a British fur company the "King George’s Sound Trading Company" starting in 1789 played a decisive part in creating the foundation for Britain's claims to what would become British Columbia. There is a final chapter about what could have happened if the trading company had not founded when it did. The author speculates that there would have been a real possibility the British Columbia would have been part the the United States. This was all written during a time when the US president is taunting Canada by calling it the 51st state.
Displaying 1 - 8 of 8 reviews