What do you think?
Rate this book
The Moon is a Door: A Young Adult Dark Academia Fantasy
Dangerous magic. Twisted friendships. A goddess imprisoned.
At Deighton Academy, Astrid's burgeoning powers draw her into a clandestine coven, a world of dark magic and even darker rivalries. Their quest to unleash a forgotten goddess promises ultimate power, but Astrid soon discovers the greatest threat lies within her own coven, where friendships twist into bitter betrayals.
Can she master her magic and stop her former friends before their ambition consumes them all?
Perfect for fans of The Craft and Dead Poets Society, The Moon is a a Door is a thrilling tale of forbidden magic, treacherous bonds, and the dark heart of ambition.
At Deighton Academy, Astrid's burgeoning powers draw her into a clandestine coven, a world of dark magic and even darker rivalries. Their quest to unleash a forgotten goddess promises ultimate power, but Astrid soon discovers the greatest threat lies within her own coven, where friendships twist into bitter betrayals.
Can she master her magic and stop her former friends before their ambition consumes them all?
Perfect for fans of The Craft and Dead Poets Society, The Moon is a a Door is a thrilling tale of forbidden magic, treacherous bonds, and the dark heart of ambition.
410 pages, Kindle Edition
Published September 1, 2025
5 people are currently reading
88 people want to read
About the author
Samantha B. Cummings
2 books8 followersSamantha B. Cummings is a published Young Adult Fantasy author known for her atmospheric, character-driven novels. She specialises in genre-blending, often pulling elements from Dark Academia and mystery to create immersive worlds filled with complex magic systems and unforgettable monsters.
Her works include the well-loved Moons & Magic series, and the newly released Dark Academia novel, The Moon Is a Door, which delves into themes of grief, loyalty, and the secrets buried in old libraries and hidden societies.
When not writing, Samantha hosts a popular podcast discussing what it takes to be an indie author. Find out more on her website, and connect with her via her newsletter, The Coven.
Her works include the well-loved Moons & Magic series, and the newly released Dark Academia novel, The Moon Is a Door, which delves into themes of grief, loyalty, and the secrets buried in old libraries and hidden societies.
When not writing, Samantha hosts a popular podcast discussing what it takes to be an indie author. Find out more on her website, and connect with her via her newsletter, The Coven.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 39 reviews
September 27, 2025
ARC review
The Moon is a Door by Samantha B. Cummings follows Astrid, a young witch with high sensitivity to nature like her deceased mother, who is sent to Deighton Academy where she plans to keep her head down until she can go home to her father. Given her mother's infamy in the community, Astrid hides her identity and unusual power from her classmates. Her plans go awry when she is drawn into a group of witches who will stop at nothing to unleash a power that will make them unstoppable.
I was really interested in Astrid's natural affinity for nature and how they spoke to her. Most of the magic system was generic/what you immediately think of when you hear "witches", so I liked the inidividual strengths and powers. A lot of the side characters lacked this individuality and felt like archetypes with not a lot of substance. The magic academy trope is a classic and I enjoyed this element because it also showed that it was still just a school and Astrid faced the same issues most teenagers do. Astrid is torn between two very different friends/groups and I like that she made the same decisions most people her age would. This book has dark themes but it's still appropriate for a YA audience, compared to some books in this niche that go a little too far for the target age range. If anything, I would say it reads as lower YA.
I can't pinpoint the exact reason but I just didn't feel engaged for at least half of the story. The ending was satisfying though!
The Moon is a Door by Samantha B. Cummings follows Astrid, a young witch with high sensitivity to nature like her deceased mother, who is sent to Deighton Academy where she plans to keep her head down until she can go home to her father. Given her mother's infamy in the community, Astrid hides her identity and unusual power from her classmates. Her plans go awry when she is drawn into a group of witches who will stop at nothing to unleash a power that will make them unstoppable.
I was really interested in Astrid's natural affinity for nature and how they spoke to her. Most of the magic system was generic/what you immediately think of when you hear "witches", so I liked the inidividual strengths and powers. A lot of the side characters lacked this individuality and felt like archetypes with not a lot of substance. The magic academy trope is a classic and I enjoyed this element because it also showed that it was still just a school and Astrid faced the same issues most teenagers do. Astrid is torn between two very different friends/groups and I like that she made the same decisions most people her age would. This book has dark themes but it's still appropriate for a YA audience, compared to some books in this niche that go a little too far for the target age range. If anything, I would say it reads as lower YA.
I can't pinpoint the exact reason but I just didn't feel engaged for at least half of the story. The ending was satisfying though!
August 27, 2025
The Moon Is a Door by Samantha B. Cummings
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ (4/5)
Witchy and weird in the best possible way
This book feels like sneaking through candlelit corridors where the air tastes like smoke and secrets and you’re not entirely sure if the walls are breathing
Astrid is such a vibe. Quiet, a little haunted, stitched together with grief and raw magic. Her loneliness? You feel it in your bones. And the coven: Those brittle, beautiful friendships that glitter like glass right before they shatter.
I was living for the “are they my sisters or are they sharpening the knife?” tension
The setting was Gorgeous and unsettling
Rituals in dark halls, whispers that feel almost sentient and a whole school humming with secrets it really doesn’t want you to know. And that last act - I inhaled it
So why not five stars? The beginning dragged for me. Not fatal, but it felt like the book kept circling itself, waiting to ignite. And the goddess lore? Fascinating, but I wanted more. I wanted mythos that slithered under my skin.
Still, it was enchanting. If you like magical schools, morally gray witches and friendships that feel like stepping into a spell you’re not sure you can break - you need this.
I’ll be in line for book two
[thank you Netgalley for the chance to read this gem early <3]
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ (4/5)
Witchy and weird in the best possible way
This book feels like sneaking through candlelit corridors where the air tastes like smoke and secrets and you’re not entirely sure if the walls are breathing
Astrid is such a vibe. Quiet, a little haunted, stitched together with grief and raw magic. Her loneliness? You feel it in your bones. And the coven: Those brittle, beautiful friendships that glitter like glass right before they shatter.
I was living for the “are they my sisters or are they sharpening the knife?” tension
The setting was Gorgeous and unsettling
Rituals in dark halls, whispers that feel almost sentient and a whole school humming with secrets it really doesn’t want you to know. And that last act - I inhaled it
So why not five stars? The beginning dragged for me. Not fatal, but it felt like the book kept circling itself, waiting to ignite. And the goddess lore? Fascinating, but I wanted more. I wanted mythos that slithered under my skin.
Still, it was enchanting. If you like magical schools, morally gray witches and friendships that feel like stepping into a spell you’re not sure you can break - you need this.
I’ll be in line for book two
[thank you Netgalley for the chance to read this gem early <3]
August 23, 2025
This book kept me hooked from start to finish. It gave me the feelings I had when I read Harry Potter when I was younger and I loved every minute of it! Highly recommend for an easy to follow fantasy read! #NetGalley #TheMoonIsADoor
August 20, 2025
This book gave me major "Sabrina" vibes. In a good way! I liked that there was no clear heros/villains until all was revealed. It ties things together nicely while still leaving the door open for another story to unfold.
The main character Astrid was developed nicely, mixing angsty teenager vibes, with a lonely grieving witchy background. I like that she was a good blend of kind and timid with strong and fierce. You don't often get that in an FMC it's usually one or the other and I found her to be extra relatable because of this. Adding Silas as a love interest has my interest piqued for the next book to see if their story continues or not.
Was overall an enjoyable read.
I received this book as an ARC read from Netgalley
The main character Astrid was developed nicely, mixing angsty teenager vibes, with a lonely grieving witchy background. I like that she was a good blend of kind and timid with strong and fierce. You don't often get that in an FMC it's usually one or the other and I found her to be extra relatable because of this. Adding Silas as a love interest has my interest piqued for the next book to see if their story continues or not.
Was overall an enjoyable read.
I received this book as an ARC read from Netgalley
August 25, 2025
I picked up The Moon is a Door largely because of its striking cover and intriguing description, and as someone who has always enjoyed stories set in supernatural academies—from Harry Potter to Zodiac Academy—I was immediately curious to see where Samantha B. Cummings would take the genre. I’m glad I did, because this book balances familiar themes with fresh storytelling and left me eager for more in the series.
First Impressions
From the very first chapter, the book drops readers into a vividly drawn world. The foundation of the setting is introduced in a way that feels natural, unfolding gradually but with enough clarity that you know exactly what kind of story you’re stepping into. The prose flows easily, making it a smooth and immersive read. Astrid, the protagonist, has an engaging backstory rooted in personal loss and uncertainty, which makes her reluctant arrival at the magical school both relatable and intriguing.
Plot & Pacing
As with many first installments in fantasy series, the pacing starts steadily to establish the rules, history, and atmosphere of this new world. While that groundwork takes time, it pays off when the story picks up momentum in the second half. By the final chapters, the pace is electric—I found myself hooked, racing through the twists and revelations. Importantly, the surprises along the way kept me invested, and the ending struck the perfect balance between resolution and promise of more to come.
Characters
The cast of characters adds richness to Astrid’s journey. Cordelia stands out as fun and quirky, bringing levity and warmth, while Selina provides a compelling “friend or foe” tension that adds spice to the school dynamic. Astrid herself is the heart of the novel; her growth feels authentic, reflecting the challenges of being a teenager navigating not only grief and identity, but also the daunting realities of a new magical world. The friendships in the book feel particularly well-drawn, capturing the shifting dynamics of adolescence where alliances can form and fracture overnight. Dialogue throughout feels natural—not overly stylized, but smooth enough that conversations flow believably.
Writing Style & Atmosphere
Cummings’ writing is both witty and descriptive, often conjuring the sense of watching a film as scenes unfold. The atmosphere of the school and the magical elements are built piece by piece, adding layers of mystery and discovery. I was impressed by how tangible the world felt; it’s the kind of setting that lingers in your imagination even after putting the book down.
Emotional Impact
I found myself connecting with Astrid on an emotional level, particularly in how she processes the loss of a parent and the uncertainty that comes with stepping into the unknown. While the book has its share of humor and lighthearted camaraderie, it also carries deeper emotional threads that ground the fantasy in something real. By the end, the resolution was both satisfying and uplifting, while still leaving plenty of threads for future installments.
Critiques
The book isn’t without its minor flaws. A few word errors caught my eye, which I hope will be smoothed out in editing. Early pacing might feel a little slow for readers eager to jump straight into high drama, but that’s almost to be expected with a first-in-series that takes care to build a detailed world. Otherwise, the narrative felt tight and purposeful, without major plot holes or forced character beats.
Content Considerations
The story delves into dark arts and elements of magical conflict, but it never tips into overly grim or violent territory. Readers sensitive to darker themes may want to be aware of that, but the tone remains accessible and not excessively heavy.
Final Thoughts
The Moon is a Door is a strong start to what promises to be an engaging series. It will appeal to readers who love coming-of-age fantasy, magical schools, and stories that balance mystery with heartfelt character development. While it began as a 3-star read for me due to the slower setup, the finale boosted it solidly into 4-star territory. I closed the book both satisfied with where Astrid’s story had landed and excited to see where it might go next.
Rating: ★★★★☆
Recommended for fans of Harry Potter, Phoenix Academy, and Zodiac Academy.
First Impressions
From the very first chapter, the book drops readers into a vividly drawn world. The foundation of the setting is introduced in a way that feels natural, unfolding gradually but with enough clarity that you know exactly what kind of story you’re stepping into. The prose flows easily, making it a smooth and immersive read. Astrid, the protagonist, has an engaging backstory rooted in personal loss and uncertainty, which makes her reluctant arrival at the magical school both relatable and intriguing.
Plot & Pacing
As with many first installments in fantasy series, the pacing starts steadily to establish the rules, history, and atmosphere of this new world. While that groundwork takes time, it pays off when the story picks up momentum in the second half. By the final chapters, the pace is electric—I found myself hooked, racing through the twists and revelations. Importantly, the surprises along the way kept me invested, and the ending struck the perfect balance between resolution and promise of more to come.
Characters
The cast of characters adds richness to Astrid’s journey. Cordelia stands out as fun and quirky, bringing levity and warmth, while Selina provides a compelling “friend or foe” tension that adds spice to the school dynamic. Astrid herself is the heart of the novel; her growth feels authentic, reflecting the challenges of being a teenager navigating not only grief and identity, but also the daunting realities of a new magical world. The friendships in the book feel particularly well-drawn, capturing the shifting dynamics of adolescence where alliances can form and fracture overnight. Dialogue throughout feels natural—not overly stylized, but smooth enough that conversations flow believably.
Writing Style & Atmosphere
Cummings’ writing is both witty and descriptive, often conjuring the sense of watching a film as scenes unfold. The atmosphere of the school and the magical elements are built piece by piece, adding layers of mystery and discovery. I was impressed by how tangible the world felt; it’s the kind of setting that lingers in your imagination even after putting the book down.
Emotional Impact
I found myself connecting with Astrid on an emotional level, particularly in how she processes the loss of a parent and the uncertainty that comes with stepping into the unknown. While the book has its share of humor and lighthearted camaraderie, it also carries deeper emotional threads that ground the fantasy in something real. By the end, the resolution was both satisfying and uplifting, while still leaving plenty of threads for future installments.
Critiques
The book isn’t without its minor flaws. A few word errors caught my eye, which I hope will be smoothed out in editing. Early pacing might feel a little slow for readers eager to jump straight into high drama, but that’s almost to be expected with a first-in-series that takes care to build a detailed world. Otherwise, the narrative felt tight and purposeful, without major plot holes or forced character beats.
Content Considerations
The story delves into dark arts and elements of magical conflict, but it never tips into overly grim or violent territory. Readers sensitive to darker themes may want to be aware of that, but the tone remains accessible and not excessively heavy.
Final Thoughts
The Moon is a Door is a strong start to what promises to be an engaging series. It will appeal to readers who love coming-of-age fantasy, magical schools, and stories that balance mystery with heartfelt character development. While it began as a 3-star read for me due to the slower setup, the finale boosted it solidly into 4-star territory. I closed the book both satisfied with where Astrid’s story had landed and excited to see where it might go next.
Rating: ★★★★☆
Recommended for fans of Harry Potter, Phoenix Academy, and Zodiac Academy.
September 3, 2025
First and foremost thank you SO much to the author for allowing me to be an ARC reader!
Secondly I do apologize for my late review, but here it is now!
The Moon Is A Door came out September 1st! Available on Kindle Unlimited, or paperback 🧡
Overall: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5
- At no point, did I ever truly see where this book was going. And honestly kudos for keeping me guessing literally the whole time!!
- what i thought was going to be a more cutesy witchy story was VERY different than I anticipated in the absolute best way possible.
- I adore authors who have cool magic systems set up. Not only was while magic in this book well thought out and written, it also has some great visuals of how magic in this world works. I appreciated the nods to *real life* pagan rituals or history, with a mix of Greek myth tossed in there (if you know me you know I love Greek myth!!)
- I cant quite put my finger on it but something about the story felt familiar to me, not like ive read it before, im not saying that, but i dont know maybe the vibe felt familiar? I cant explain it besides it being a fun feeling to have while reading.
- the characters were well written and I appreciate how much visible growth they had throughout the book. It felt well paced if a bit repetitive at times.
- I really enjoyed the world building! It was subtle enough that it didn't even realize it was happening half the time, but i still had this perfectly clear picture of what things looked like or how they functioned.
- I have precisely 2 complaints, the first being something I hope would've been fixed before publishing, but there were spelling errors or phrases that came out kind of clunky, or even a few things that were inconsistent eith other things that had been said, or seemed like something that was meant to be taken out but forgotten. My other complaint is the repetition of things. Particularly a part - ⚠️ spoiler ahead ⚠️ where Astrid is looking for Selena, and she says several times in several different ways "if she'd be anywhere she'd be there!" "If Selena would run to anyplace it would definitely be there" "that seems like the place Selena would be!" Type of thing. It was conveyed once and felt kind of silly how many times it was mentioned. ⚠️ spoiler over ⚠️
- genuinely, I liked that this book took a darker turn, and I love that it left possibilities open for more books in the series. I look forward to keeping up with the series and seeing what other mischief these witches can get into
Overall: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5
Secondly I do apologize for my late review, but here it is now!
The Moon Is A Door came out September 1st! Available on Kindle Unlimited, or paperback 🧡
Overall: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5
- At no point, did I ever truly see where this book was going. And honestly kudos for keeping me guessing literally the whole time!!
- what i thought was going to be a more cutesy witchy story was VERY different than I anticipated in the absolute best way possible.
- I adore authors who have cool magic systems set up. Not only was while magic in this book well thought out and written, it also has some great visuals of how magic in this world works. I appreciated the nods to *real life* pagan rituals or history, with a mix of Greek myth tossed in there (if you know me you know I love Greek myth!!)
- I cant quite put my finger on it but something about the story felt familiar to me, not like ive read it before, im not saying that, but i dont know maybe the vibe felt familiar? I cant explain it besides it being a fun feeling to have while reading.
- the characters were well written and I appreciate how much visible growth they had throughout the book. It felt well paced if a bit repetitive at times.
- I really enjoyed the world building! It was subtle enough that it didn't even realize it was happening half the time, but i still had this perfectly clear picture of what things looked like or how they functioned.
- I have precisely 2 complaints, the first being something I hope would've been fixed before publishing, but there were spelling errors or phrases that came out kind of clunky, or even a few things that were inconsistent eith other things that had been said, or seemed like something that was meant to be taken out but forgotten. My other complaint is the repetition of things. Particularly a part - ⚠️ spoiler ahead ⚠️ where Astrid is looking for Selena, and she says several times in several different ways "if she'd be anywhere she'd be there!" "If Selena would run to anyplace it would definitely be there" "that seems like the place Selena would be!" Type of thing. It was conveyed once and felt kind of silly how many times it was mentioned. ⚠️ spoiler over ⚠️
- genuinely, I liked that this book took a darker turn, and I love that it left possibilities open for more books in the series. I look forward to keeping up with the series and seeing what other mischief these witches can get into
Overall: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️/5
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
September 8, 2025
Thank you to Samantha B. Cummings & her team for a copy of this ARC in exchange for an honest review!
For all my witchy lovers, this is for you. Dark academia meets Mean Girls meets witchcraft. Feared goddesses, a desire for more power, and our sweet Astrid just trying to make it through her first semester of witch academy. It’s giving Sabrina with a darker twist. It’s hard to put down!
Selena gave Regina George a run for her money. Her angst, anger, darkness, and ability to manipulate everything for her own gains was both admirable and also shocking.
While the book felt a smidge drawn out, learning of the depths of Astrid’s power, in part due to her connection to her new friends, was really interesting to learn. All she wanted was to understand her mom’s past, and I feel like she got just the tip of the iceberg so far. If there’s a book two, I can’t wait to read it!
In true witch form, there was collateral damage, and I hope those involved in all of Selena’s plans, witch and human alike, are able to fully recover.
This book was not sweet cutesy Harry Potter magic, it was more school of good and evil magic, and I loved it.
For all my witchy lovers, this is for you. Dark academia meets Mean Girls meets witchcraft. Feared goddesses, a desire for more power, and our sweet Astrid just trying to make it through her first semester of witch academy. It’s giving Sabrina with a darker twist. It’s hard to put down!
Selena gave Regina George a run for her money. Her angst, anger, darkness, and ability to manipulate everything for her own gains was both admirable and also shocking.
While the book felt a smidge drawn out, learning of the depths of Astrid’s power, in part due to her connection to her new friends, was really interesting to learn. All she wanted was to understand her mom’s past, and I feel like she got just the tip of the iceberg so far. If there’s a book two, I can’t wait to read it!
In true witch form, there was collateral damage, and I hope those involved in all of Selena’s plans, witch and human alike, are able to fully recover.
This book was not sweet cutesy Harry Potter magic, it was more school of good and evil magic, and I loved it.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
September 7, 2025
This is such a beautifully written and magical story. I loved Astrid’s unique connection to plants and trees - the way they whispered to her was so enchanting - and the school itself felt alive with magic, from the books to the furniture.
I picked this up because The Craft is one of my all-time favourites, and I was delighted to see the author weave in little nods to it: the hair colour glamour, shoplifting at the local magic store, even a binding spell. It hooked me straight away.
Of course, no witchy school would be complete without coven drama. Enter Selena, Rosemary, and Lilith - three legacy-witch “mean girls” who bring plenty of tension and drama. Astrid, starting out as an outcast with volatile magic, finds herself drawn into their world, and I was rooting for her as she tried to balance belonging with her own power.
Add in an angry goddess, shadow magic, a touch of romance, and some complicated family secrets, and you’ve got a story that kept me turning the pages.
Dark academia vibes, witches, rivalries, and magic at every turn. A YA gem!
I picked this up because The Craft is one of my all-time favourites, and I was delighted to see the author weave in little nods to it: the hair colour glamour, shoplifting at the local magic store, even a binding spell. It hooked me straight away.
Of course, no witchy school would be complete without coven drama. Enter Selena, Rosemary, and Lilith - three legacy-witch “mean girls” who bring plenty of tension and drama. Astrid, starting out as an outcast with volatile magic, finds herself drawn into their world, and I was rooting for her as she tried to balance belonging with her own power.
Add in an angry goddess, shadow magic, a touch of romance, and some complicated family secrets, and you’ve got a story that kept me turning the pages.
Dark academia vibes, witches, rivalries, and magic at every turn. A YA gem!
August 31, 2025
⭐️⭐️⭐️.5
This is a dark academia story, full of mystery, magic and witches 🧙♀️
It's based in a boarding school for witches and we follow the story of Astrid who has been sent to the school following the death of her mother. Astrid is still grieving and now has to fit into a new school and make new friends 🧡 All without her dad by her side and without knowing why she has suddenly been sent here?!
The story has Goddesses, family secrets, betrayal, jealousy, bullying, secret covens, dangerous decisions.
The story was full of suspense which kept me hooked to see if I could get the answers to my questions! 😂 I luved the spooky gothic vibes 🖤
This book would be a fab spooky season read! I really enjoyed this book and look forward to following Astrid in her next adventures 😀 👍
This is a dark academia story, full of mystery, magic and witches 🧙♀️
It's based in a boarding school for witches and we follow the story of Astrid who has been sent to the school following the death of her mother. Astrid is still grieving and now has to fit into a new school and make new friends 🧡 All without her dad by her side and without knowing why she has suddenly been sent here?!
The story has Goddesses, family secrets, betrayal, jealousy, bullying, secret covens, dangerous decisions.
The story was full of suspense which kept me hooked to see if I could get the answers to my questions! 😂 I luved the spooky gothic vibes 🖤
This book would be a fab spooky season read! I really enjoyed this book and look forward to following Astrid in her next adventures 😀 👍
August 31, 2025
Thanks to @netgalley and the publisher for an advanced copy in return for a honest review.
Dangerous magic. Twisted friendships. A goddess imprisoned.
Forbidden magic and treacherous bonds. This book was quite a fun read, even though it did strongly give me Harry Potter vibes, and reminded me of every other witch/wizard school fantasy read, not that that's a bad thing. The story was weaved together so good, and makes way for a great series of Deighton Academy. The Author did a brilliant job of world building and painting such a clear picture in my head of the villages and school. Also the concept of accepting one's self, was a very emotional ride with our main charcter Astrid. A perfect Halloween read.
Dangerous magic. Twisted friendships. A goddess imprisoned.
Forbidden magic and treacherous bonds. This book was quite a fun read, even though it did strongly give me Harry Potter vibes, and reminded me of every other witch/wizard school fantasy read, not that that's a bad thing. The story was weaved together so good, and makes way for a great series of Deighton Academy. The Author did a brilliant job of world building and painting such a clear picture in my head of the villages and school. Also the concept of accepting one's self, was a very emotional ride with our main charcter Astrid. A perfect Halloween read.
August 24, 2025
This was such a fun read. A magic school, witches, and hidden secrets, it doesn’t get any better than that!
One thing that stood out to me was the level of depth in the description. It painted such a clear picture in my mind like I was the one in the story.
The emotions of each character, especially Astrid were so authentic to what was happening. She had the angsty teen vibes at the beginning and slowly had to learn to accept who she is as a witch.
The few twists and turns took me by surprise. The biggest twist of all, I don’t think anyone will be able to guess.😂Overall the story flowed nicely, it gets you hooked early on, and it was perfect with spooky season coming soon.
One thing that stood out to me was the level of depth in the description. It painted such a clear picture in my mind like I was the one in the story.
The emotions of each character, especially Astrid were so authentic to what was happening. She had the angsty teen vibes at the beginning and slowly had to learn to accept who she is as a witch.
The few twists and turns took me by surprise. The biggest twist of all, I don’t think anyone will be able to guess.😂Overall the story flowed nicely, it gets you hooked early on, and it was perfect with spooky season coming soon.
September 1, 2025
We follow Astrid who is just starting magic school for the first time, she doesn’t want to be there and is still dealing with the death of her mum. She ends up befriending a group of girls who want to break the rules, and raise a goddess to gain more power. It had the vibe of Harry Potter meets The Craft, dark academia/ fantasy
Well written and had a good pace. The characters are well developed and are believable. The plot was intriguing. Astrid wants to learn more about her mum’s past at Deighton Academy, so this left enough mystery and secrets to uncover to be developed in future books.
I would definitely read more of this series and see what happens to Astrid next.
Well written and had a good pace. The characters are well developed and are believable. The plot was intriguing. Astrid wants to learn more about her mum’s past at Deighton Academy, so this left enough mystery and secrets to uncover to be developed in future books.
I would definitely read more of this series and see what happens to Astrid next.
September 1, 2025
I kindly received an ARC ebook version of The Moon is a Door from Samantha B Cummings.
There were definitely The Craft vibes to this dark academia witch story. The atmosphere was very vivid and you could almost feel Selena, Lilith & Rosemary walking into the room with all eyes turning to look at them!
Astrid was a great main character full of angst and insecurities.
I loved the witchy magic, with nature and books all speaking to Astrid, I mean who doesn't hear books asking them to buy them 😂 In places it reminded me of The Atlas Six with the plants wanting to please and that you never quite got the whole story of what was going on.
There were definitely The Craft vibes to this dark academia witch story. The atmosphere was very vivid and you could almost feel Selena, Lilith & Rosemary walking into the room with all eyes turning to look at them!
Astrid was a great main character full of angst and insecurities.
I loved the witchy magic, with nature and books all speaking to Astrid, I mean who doesn't hear books asking them to buy them 😂 In places it reminded me of The Atlas Six with the plants wanting to please and that you never quite got the whole story of what was going on.
August 30, 2025
arc review 💜
described as the craft x dead poets society, this ya fantasy is all about dark magic and secret rebel covens. i honestly enjoyed the twists and turns throughout the story and the feeling of never knowing you who you could really trust! it did frustrate me how everyone just blindly accepted selena’s plan and never pushed for more answers. i do struggle to see how this will pan out into a series, but it was an enjoyable read for the upcoming fall season! 🧙🏻♀️
described as the craft x dead poets society, this ya fantasy is all about dark magic and secret rebel covens. i honestly enjoyed the twists and turns throughout the story and the feeling of never knowing you who you could really trust! it did frustrate me how everyone just blindly accepted selena’s plan and never pushed for more answers. i do struggle to see how this will pan out into a series, but it was an enjoyable read for the upcoming fall season! 🧙🏻♀️
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
September 1, 2025
The plot is masterfully constructed, with a narrative that unfolds at an expert pace. It balances moments of calm reflection with pulse-pounding action, ensuring there's never a dull moment. The author weaves together a complex tapestry of events, with each twist and turn feeling both surprising and inevitable...
Why not the five stars?
The beginning it's a little slow but once that starts captivates until the end...
Why not the five stars?
The beginning it's a little slow but once that starts captivates until the end...
August 25, 2025
4.5 rounded up
I was sucked in to this story from the start and I knew I was going to enjoy it, and then that last bit hit and lordy! It was a wild ride!
This book has all the vibes of Sabrina and when you think you have everything figured out - just kidding! No you don't! This story ended before I was ready for it to, but it was a place that made perfect sense.
I can't wait to see what happens next at Deighton Academy!
I was sucked in to this story from the start and I knew I was going to enjoy it, and then that last bit hit and lordy! It was a wild ride!
This book has all the vibes of Sabrina and when you think you have everything figured out - just kidding! No you don't! This story ended before I was ready for it to, but it was a place that made perfect sense.
I can't wait to see what happens next at Deighton Academy!
September 23, 2025
The Moon Is a Door totally pulled me in. I loved the eerie, mysterious vibe of Deighton Academy and the way the story kept me guessing. The characters felt real, and I was hooked until the very last page. If you’re into dark academia with a touch of heart and suspense, this is definitely worth picking up.
August 23, 2025
Thank you to Netgalley and Samantha B. Cummings for The ARC!
I love how the characters are just that wonderful blend of whose good, whose bad. It made me love the characters without any bias. Astrid is such a vibe. Ansty, quiet, reclusive, and yet, she is drawn in to friendship and possibly something much darker than that. The Dark Academic setting was so well done, that gave that right vibe of eeriness and magical whim that compliment each other so well. I really recommend it.
I love how the characters are just that wonderful blend of whose good, whose bad. It made me love the characters without any bias. Astrid is such a vibe. Ansty, quiet, reclusive, and yet, she is drawn in to friendship and possibly something much darker than that. The Dark Academic setting was so well done, that gave that right vibe of eeriness and magical whim that compliment each other so well. I really recommend it.
October 10, 2025
Thank you netgalley for ARC of this book
4 witches, one ancient trapped goddess and a lot of power hunger involved... what could possibly go wrong?
This was advertised as The Craft inspired book. i can see why. The plots and vibes are very similar i felt like Mean Girls meets the Craft. And dont get me wrong when executed well it could work amazingly but imo... it could be more creepy that's what i counted for anyway.
We meet young witch Astrid shipped to school for other witches like her. Astrid is a daugher of Morgana Pearson and is constantly trying to hide it bc her mother was very known among other witches and ... why exactly she is avoiding admitting she is her daughter? besides fear of not living the expectations she has no reason to do so. Her mother just passed away and that's why her father (who we see basically nothing of) is pulling her into this magical school.
In my honest opinion it's weird she got mixed up with our main group of girls. She has bad feelings about them CONSTANTLY and never trusts them even after a teacher who warned her (and did not react to what was happening knowing full well how it could end!!) she chooses this girl group over anything else.
It would be case of toxic friendship despite... well ... it doesn't take much to figure out the girls were always not up to any good. and bc of that i would say the characters who "dont know" (including our FMC) are not that believable at all. the friendship between them was feeling forced as well, i dont think it felt natural or anything like that
what i enjoyed a lot was the flames, trees, books etc. can talk to witches who have talent to hear them and bc that i give it 3* instead of lower rating. The book itself isn't bad just ..... predictable
4 witches, one ancient trapped goddess and a lot of power hunger involved... what could possibly go wrong?
This was advertised as The Craft inspired book. i can see why. The plots and vibes are very similar i felt like Mean Girls meets the Craft. And dont get me wrong when executed well it could work amazingly but imo... it could be more creepy that's what i counted for anyway.
We meet young witch Astrid shipped to school for other witches like her. Astrid is a daugher of Morgana Pearson and is constantly trying to hide it bc her mother was very known among other witches and ... why exactly she is avoiding admitting she is her daughter? besides fear of not living the expectations she has no reason to do so. Her mother just passed away and that's why her father (who we see basically nothing of) is pulling her into this magical school.
In my honest opinion it's weird she got mixed up with our main group of girls. She has bad feelings about them CONSTANTLY and never trusts them even after a teacher who warned her (and did not react to what was happening knowing full well how it could end!!) she chooses this girl group over anything else.
It would be case of toxic friendship despite... well ... it doesn't take much to figure out the girls were always not up to any good. and bc of that i would say the characters who "dont know" (including our FMC) are not that believable at all. the friendship between them was feeling forced as well, i dont think it felt natural or anything like that
what i enjoyed a lot was the flames, trees, books etc. can talk to witches who have talent to hear them and bc that i give it 3* instead of lower rating. The book itself isn't bad just ..... predictable
January 1, 2026
I liked the witchcraft. Cordelia is my favorite character. I want to read the second book.
I received an ARC from the author for an honest review.
I received an ARC from the author for an honest review.
September 2, 2025
I wanted to like this book more then I did, I liked the premise of it and was very excited to have gotten to read it. But I found it predictable, witches for me are hit or miss honestly and I don't want to seem like I didn't appreciate the book, the characters were interesting but I wanted more I guess.
September 16, 2025
I am the author of the book and so yes, obviously I give myself five stars! Sorry not sorry!! 😈
January 2, 2026
Samantha Cummings describes her novel as "a dark academia novel blending Dead Poet's Society's intensity with The Craft's coven spirit" and she's spot on. The Moon Is a Door was a fun and engaging read, full of twists that kept me hooked. Astrid was a relatable main character, and the friendships she built at Deighton Academy felt genuine. What stood out most were the immersive descriptions; I could picture myself in the greenhouse with Astrid and walking beside her through the village beyond the academy. Great YA read! Highly recommend!
Read
August 21, 2025i absolutely loved the vibes of this book. the dark academia setting was perfectly eerie with the storyline of rituals and magic accompanying that so well.
the FMC, Astrid was well balanced. she was at times timid and isolated, others powerful and assured. her development across the whole book was well written, growing into this strong and silently confident witch. this development complimented the storyline so well.
if ur looking for an atmospheric academia novel, with young witches and potentially deadly rituals, this would be the book to grab.
the FMC, Astrid was well balanced. she was at times timid and isolated, others powerful and assured. her development across the whole book was well written, growing into this strong and silently confident witch. this development complimented the storyline so well.
if ur looking for an atmospheric academia novel, with young witches and potentially deadly rituals, this would be the book to grab.
did-not-finish
November 26, 2025DNF @ 20%
One thing I've learned this year is that not finishing books is not disrespectful. It's the other way round. Once I notice that I start thinking about not finishing a book, once I notice that I'm picking up a book to read a certain amount of pages "to get it over with", once I notice that I'm zoning out or trying to speed up, I have to stop. Not because I disrespect the author or the book. But because I respect it.
The concept of this book sounds interesting. A homeschooled Witch losing her mother and now attending the magical academy her mother has attended for the first time. It's clear there is a reason she was homeschooled, it's clear what she has been taught is different from what the students are taught here, it's clear there is a reason her mother and the magical world had a falling out. I'm quite certain the rest of the book will dive deeper into it.
However, I never felt any excitement or connection while reading this book. I had a hard time with the narrative of the heroine. She was constantly saying she was one thing, while doing the opposite thing. There are a lot of descriptions, but there's not much dialogue. And although she is curious, it never feels like she's actively working towards a certain goal. I also missed a certain kind of magic, a certain kind of danger, a certain atmosphere, emotions.
I think the main issue is that the writing style of this book and my reading preferences don't align. I want to feel something while reading, mainly because I simply don't see anything while reading. The moment nothing in a book makes me feel something, I disconnect and start seeing reading the book as a chore. If you're a different kind of reader, you might certainly appreciate this book a lot more than me! I can't say that anything about it was bad. I can just say that what I read so far wasn't for me.
One thing I've learned this year is that not finishing books is not disrespectful. It's the other way round. Once I notice that I start thinking about not finishing a book, once I notice that I'm picking up a book to read a certain amount of pages "to get it over with", once I notice that I'm zoning out or trying to speed up, I have to stop. Not because I disrespect the author or the book. But because I respect it.
The concept of this book sounds interesting. A homeschooled Witch losing her mother and now attending the magical academy her mother has attended for the first time. It's clear there is a reason she was homeschooled, it's clear what she has been taught is different from what the students are taught here, it's clear there is a reason her mother and the magical world had a falling out. I'm quite certain the rest of the book will dive deeper into it.
However, I never felt any excitement or connection while reading this book. I had a hard time with the narrative of the heroine. She was constantly saying she was one thing, while doing the opposite thing. There are a lot of descriptions, but there's not much dialogue. And although she is curious, it never feels like she's actively working towards a certain goal. I also missed a certain kind of magic, a certain kind of danger, a certain atmosphere, emotions.
I think the main issue is that the writing style of this book and my reading preferences don't align. I want to feel something while reading, mainly because I simply don't see anything while reading. The moment nothing in a book makes me feel something, I disconnect and start seeing reading the book as a chore. If you're a different kind of reader, you might certainly appreciate this book a lot more than me! I can't say that anything about it was bad. I can just say that what I read so far wasn't for me.
August 23, 2025
Dark... enchantingly beautiful, magical, and spell-bounding.... step into a world of ritual, of magic like you've never seen before.... into the dark hallowed halls of Deighton Academy... and the world of magic like you may have never known it...
Meet Astrid, our amazing main character... who's always lead the quiet life... secluded away from most others like her ... like other witches.... living with her father away from the Arcane... armed with only the spellwork and knowledge that her mom has taught her...that is until her father decides one day to send her off to the same academy that her mother attended... that her mother left...
It is here where Astrid realizes the true nature of her power... and learns more about what magic truly is .... knowledge that her mother had cut out for being too boring or too uninteresting...
Soon, she is drawn to the darker forces, a trio of witches... and something dark... drawn in by the promises of a friendship.... of friendship in which she thought was true... will she be able to save her new life as she has come to know it? Or will the school, and everything she knows be torn asunder by the goddess that is threatening to awaken...
This novel is absolutely mesmerizing, and will put you until its spell until the very last page.
Thank you to Samantha B. Cummings as well as Netgalley for this copy in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts and opinions are my own, and the rest of my reviews can be found at: https://littlereapling.wixsite.com/fa...
Meet Astrid, our amazing main character... who's always lead the quiet life... secluded away from most others like her ... like other witches.... living with her father away from the Arcane... armed with only the spellwork and knowledge that her mom has taught her...that is until her father decides one day to send her off to the same academy that her mother attended... that her mother left...
It is here where Astrid realizes the true nature of her power... and learns more about what magic truly is .... knowledge that her mother had cut out for being too boring or too uninteresting...
Soon, she is drawn to the darker forces, a trio of witches... and something dark... drawn in by the promises of a friendship.... of friendship in which she thought was true... will she be able to save her new life as she has come to know it? Or will the school, and everything she knows be torn asunder by the goddess that is threatening to awaken...
This novel is absolutely mesmerizing, and will put you until its spell until the very last page.
Thank you to Samantha B. Cummings as well as Netgalley for this copy in exchange for an honest review. All thoughts and opinions are my own, and the rest of my reviews can be found at: https://littlereapling.wixsite.com/fa...
September 5, 2025
Huge thanks to NetGalley and Samantha B. Cummings for providing access to the ARC!
From the very first pages, this book had me hooked. The vivid descriptions of the village, characters, and school drew me in so completely that, despite not usually being someone who “sees” books in my mind, I felt as though I were walking the streets of Deighton and the academy myself.
At its heart, this is more than a YA fantasy adventure—it’s a powerful exploration of grief, the intricacies of female friendship, the search for identity, and the ongoing tug-of-war between what we desire and what might be best for us. It’s a thoughtful meditation on the stories we tell ourselves and the ways they shape our choices.
Though the plot twists are not surprising, they are effective, making the book genuinely hard to put down. Each mystery solved presents another in its place and leaves the reader wanting more.
A true standout is the unique magic system (who doesn’t love a solidly feminist twist?). This decision not only makes the world feel fresh but also opens up fascinating dynamics around gender, legacy, and belonging.
Perhaps most striking of all is the way the novel refuses the simple dichotomy of good versus evil. Instead, it offers a layered examination of the gray spaces in which we all live, refusing to paint characters as wholly innocent or irredeemably corrupt.
In short: this is an enchanting, thought-provoking YA fantasy that blends page-turning suspense with depth and nuance.
From the very first pages, this book had me hooked. The vivid descriptions of the village, characters, and school drew me in so completely that, despite not usually being someone who “sees” books in my mind, I felt as though I were walking the streets of Deighton and the academy myself.
At its heart, this is more than a YA fantasy adventure—it’s a powerful exploration of grief, the intricacies of female friendship, the search for identity, and the ongoing tug-of-war between what we desire and what might be best for us. It’s a thoughtful meditation on the stories we tell ourselves and the ways they shape our choices.
Though the plot twists are not surprising, they are effective, making the book genuinely hard to put down. Each mystery solved presents another in its place and leaves the reader wanting more.
A true standout is the unique magic system (who doesn’t love a solidly feminist twist?). This decision not only makes the world feel fresh but also opens up fascinating dynamics around gender, legacy, and belonging.
Perhaps most striking of all is the way the novel refuses the simple dichotomy of good versus evil. Instead, it offers a layered examination of the gray spaces in which we all live, refusing to paint characters as wholly innocent or irredeemably corrupt.
In short: this is an enchanting, thought-provoking YA fantasy that blends page-turning suspense with depth and nuance.
October 9, 2025
This is The Craft (minus any black characters) taking place in the magic school from the new Sabrina series, so if that’s what you’re in the mood for, then you’re in luck. There’s a great deal of focus on the spells and different types of magic, a great deal of admiration for and desire to fit in with the bad girls, and a fairly straightforward plot with Astrid finding herself swept along in someone else’s story, too indifferent to seek out her own.
Her voice is a flat monotone, expressing mild interest at the best of times, yawn-inducing indifference for the rest. People are angry, people are friendly, disasters happen, she makes friends … and it’s treated with the same interest and energy she has for going to bed. Honestly, I struggled to read this. I kept finding my attention heading to other books, to music, to a movie … even to laundry. I had to make myself sit down and finish it and, when I finally did, I wasn’t surprised in the least at how the book ended. It’s source inspiration is present through every scene and relationship.
This is a solid pass. I don’t see anything in here that I haven’t seen in other books, movies, or TV series, series with stronger character work and more interesting plots. Thank you to Net Galley and the publisher for the ARC.
Her voice is a flat monotone, expressing mild interest at the best of times, yawn-inducing indifference for the rest. People are angry, people are friendly, disasters happen, she makes friends … and it’s treated with the same interest and energy she has for going to bed. Honestly, I struggled to read this. I kept finding my attention heading to other books, to music, to a movie … even to laundry. I had to make myself sit down and finish it and, when I finally did, I wasn’t surprised in the least at how the book ended. It’s source inspiration is present through every scene and relationship.
This is a solid pass. I don’t see anything in here that I haven’t seen in other books, movies, or TV series, series with stronger character work and more interesting plots. Thank you to Net Galley and the publisher for the ARC.
September 7, 2025
I received this as an arc, and this is my honest review:
I missed reading books about witches and covens. I've loved this sub-genre since I was a pre-teen, and read the Circle of Three books, and the Blue is for Nightmares series. I also liked the break from heavy-romance. This was a fun read about friendship, trust, and learning about yourself...also grief.
The magic styles were enjoyable and well-written. I liked that each girl had a "focus" - like nature for example - and that's the type of magic they excelled in. This story also does a really good job at addressing loneliness, even among friends. The coven and it's story was very reminiscent of The Craft, but more enjoyable in my opinion. The climax also had not one but two "gotcha" moments that I did NOT see coming, so in the thrill of it, that was a nice surprise. I enjoy being kept on my toes, and this book did just that!
I don't have much of a critique. The only thing, maybe, is that I'd like to learn more of the teacher's back stories, since we only got very little of that. I'm excited to see how the other characters develop as well.
I am excited to read more of Astrid's story.
I missed reading books about witches and covens. I've loved this sub-genre since I was a pre-teen, and read the Circle of Three books, and the Blue is for Nightmares series. I also liked the break from heavy-romance. This was a fun read about friendship, trust, and learning about yourself...also grief.
The magic styles were enjoyable and well-written. I liked that each girl had a "focus" - like nature for example - and that's the type of magic they excelled in. This story also does a really good job at addressing loneliness, even among friends. The coven and it's story was very reminiscent of The Craft, but more enjoyable in my opinion. The climax also had not one but two "gotcha" moments that I did NOT see coming, so in the thrill of it, that was a nice surprise. I enjoy being kept on my toes, and this book did just that!
I don't have much of a critique. The only thing, maybe, is that I'd like to learn more of the teacher's back stories, since we only got very little of that. I'm excited to see how the other characters develop as well.
I am excited to read more of Astrid's story.
September 8, 2025
I received this book as an ARC.
This was such a fun, witchy read that gave me all the magical school vibes I was hoping for. Astrid really stood out to me, she’s grieving and a little lost, but also stronger than she realizes. I loved that she wasn’t written as just one thing; she could be timid and kind but also fierce when it mattered, which made her easy to connect with.
The atmosphere was great too, candlelit halls, rituals, and a school full of secrets. By the final act I couldn’t stop turning pages. The ending tied things together nicely but still left plenty open for the next book, which I’ll definitely be picking up.
The only reason it’s not five stars for me is that the beginning felt a little slow and I wished the goddess lore had gone a bit deeper. Still, overall this was an enjoyable, immersive read and a really strong start to the series.
This was such a fun, witchy read that gave me all the magical school vibes I was hoping for. Astrid really stood out to me, she’s grieving and a little lost, but also stronger than she realizes. I loved that she wasn’t written as just one thing; she could be timid and kind but also fierce when it mattered, which made her easy to connect with.
The atmosphere was great too, candlelit halls, rituals, and a school full of secrets. By the final act I couldn’t stop turning pages. The ending tied things together nicely but still left plenty open for the next book, which I’ll definitely be picking up.
The only reason it’s not five stars for me is that the beginning felt a little slow and I wished the goddess lore had gone a bit deeper. Still, overall this was an enjoyable, immersive read and a really strong start to the series.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 39 reviews