Bechdel's return to queer comedy, with which she began her career in her strips, Dykes to Watch Out For. Three masterpiece memoirs follow--Fun House, Are You My Mother? and The Secret to Superhuman Strength--with hardly a smile in them, but I didn't mind. But in fact, as much as I admire these books, I can't recall seeing Bechdel having smiled in these books or elsewhere for decades! Let's just say that she, like her father, is not a paragon of warmth. And oh, she is looking more and more like her grumpy Dad, too! The books are anguished, erudite (Bechdel, always beating herself up, calls them now pretentious in places) self-studies. This book both maintains her political commitments AND at the same time makes fun of her own pretensions.
But in this book we see Bechdel's return to comedy!? Her author photo has her smiling widely; that photo almost seems like a joke in itself, so incongruous is it after all these years. But the premise is that she and her partner Holly raise pygmy goats on a farm in Vermont, near a kind of commune where her former Dykes to Watch Out For crowd live, just to get the old gang back together for a few old people pc jokes. The cover, a Grant Wood American Gothic send-up, shows her and her partner at late middle-age, obviously farmers. This book begins as a sort of auto-fiction about the self-deprecating "Alison" beating herself up for becoming rich and famous in the current milieu of disaster capitalism. In addition to the goats, she is still working on comics, or graphic novels. And dealing with a tv show based on Fun Home, here called Death and Taxidermy, changing her Dad's funeral home work to taxidermy.
Written after having just finished it: And yep, it's pretty much a triumph, one of the best graphic novels of the year, as one of her books always is! It's funny, and insightful, and even sort of ultimately hopeful in the end!? Really amazingly layered, with great drawing, of course. Read every panel closely for little gifts of cleverness and fun. Acknowledging the impending collapse of civilization, seen through the eyes of gloomy Alison, it is nevertheless almost completely light- and warm-hearted!
So what's it about? Life on the farm, life dealing with the present moment, life and comics, and friendship/love/sex, updating the Dykes humor and cast of goofy sweet characters, riffing on current events, vegan life, climate, autocracy, and with a focus on changing contemporary middle age relationships, including polyamory!? Polyamory is both taken seriously and made fun of, ripe for jokes. Bechdel takes contemporary issues both seriously and humorously. So part of this is a kind of hilarious romp that reminded me somehow of that 1969 movie Bob & Carol & Ted & Alice, satire on sexual mores of the times and part of it really is a sociocultural critique.
Part of the book is about Alison planning an unlikely anti-capitalist book project she calls Sum:An Accounting, but in a way, this book brilliantly becomes that book, now called Spent, taking seriously the oligarchic moment as she stresses out about the world, but also at the same time making fun of herself as taking life too seriously. The title is surely about money but is also a play on Joe Matt's book by the same title, about his sex obsession, and this is about sex, too, sweetly and humorously. The chapter titles mirror a book on late capitalism, but they also satirize them as pretentious and boring: "The Process of Production of Capital" (i.e., the leftie anti-capitalist Alison gets pretty rich); "Simple Reproduction" (well, lots of people and also goats are having sex!), and then of course a neighbor couple has a kid as all these goats are have "kids," and it's a wild and joyful time!
One fun thing is that Holly gets to be more popular than Alison through her farm tool videos (re: a chapter titled "The Specialized Worker and His Tools"), and another fun thing is that her sister, who was left out of Fun Home, gets back into Alison's life in an amusing but meaningful way. She's a Trumper, but they find ways to connect, a lesson for our times? In truth, Alison in real life has two brothers and no sisters, but maybe this is about them or one of them. Anyway, this book is wonderful--Funny, insightful and surprisingly warm as Alison reconnects to a community of friends (and her "kid" goats) and partner Holly. Highly recommended.