Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

Murder in Old Forge, Pennsylvania: The Tragic Death of the Ziemba Children

Rate this book

208 pages, Paperback

Published July 8, 2025

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Brian W. Kincaid

3 books1 follower

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
6 (22%)
4 stars
6 (22%)
3 stars
9 (33%)
2 stars
5 (18%)
1 star
1 (3%)
Displaying 1 - 4 of 4 reviews
5 reviews
July 2, 2026
There is a moment near the end of the book when the District Attorney, fresh from a 2019 resentencing hearing at which Brian Kincaid has just testified for the Commonwealth, shakes the author’s hand and tells him: “You should finish working on that book you were writing.”

Kincaid does not appear to notice he’s recorded the work’s armature: that the single most important goal of the book is to fulfill Brian Kincaid’s wish to write a thriller or procedural drama. Everything and everyone involved in the case become instruments in his symphony. Conductor and magician, Kincaid conjures victims’ never-reported thoughts from thin air, transforms physical appearances to represent the moment's moral judgment, and speaks the language of journalism with a blockbuster accent.

But my critique isn’t about the man. It's about the method, and the work that method produced. My beef is this: reading this book feels like being forced to watch a movie through glasses you’d much rather remove.

I will spoiler the rest because I am not sure what the rules are for nonfiction.


The children at its center deserved an account. Instead, they are disrespected—instrumentalized to serve the goals of a man who, on the evidence of his own pages (which feature a grinning headshot?) feels he has directed his own Cape Fear, in reverse.

Good for him.
Profile Image for Leona McAlarney.
3 reviews
March 1, 2026
When I read the introduction I almost didn’t read it. I was 10 years old when this happened. I lived a few blocks away. So many memories came back when I heard someone write a book about this. My aunt lived 45 minutes away and my parents thought about sending my younger brother and I to stay with her until the murderer was found. I remember hearing so many different things about what happened. After reading the book I do have a better understanding of what happened with the search and in the courtroom.
Profile Image for Roxanne.
156 reviews4 followers
August 23, 2025
Kincaid gets away with the magic trick of revealing the killer from the get go, since his recount of the cursed community’s back story is a riveting page turner. I’m not even a fan of true crime and yet I found myself wanting to scream at the unaware townspeople that the murderer was one of the leaders in the search committee.

Kincaid gives the court case equal flair with lawyers harboring grudges, small town animosities, and a sociopath on trial. Finally, the post script of Kincaid’s tangential brush with the case is downright bone chilling.
Murder in Old Forge Pennsylvania’s suspense is so palpable that I only read it during the daylight.
Profile Image for Donna.
65 reviews1 follower
March 21, 2026
This was the first high-profile case I remember from my childhood. The book was interesting; however, the author repeated himself quite often. He definitely needed a better editor.
Displaying 1 - 4 of 4 reviews