Sakura is a beaten down office drone in a dead-end job. But he still has a strong sense of justice, so when a young girl is in trouble, he finds himself transformed into a powerful magical girl!? Now his life finally has purpose, which would be great if he could figure out how to transform…
Well, this is kind of really try-hard, but not in a way that I hate. I think it certainly aims higher than it achieves, but this is one case where I won’t fault the ambition just because it’s being harmlessly silly and still has a good message at its heart. Kind of like an average magical girl show, honestly.
At first this plays very much like a cringe office story, as Sakura’s infuriatingly useless boss attempts to work him to death. The way his perspective changes as he gets used to his alter ego is nice, but the key point is that his circumstances might suck, but Sakura’s a decent guy.
When he isn’t being a girl, of course. It’s a relief to say that there are no easy, phobic jokes fired off once Sakura swaps genders. It’s just… a thing that happens. More to the point, it leads to a weirdly funny porno joke involving his best friend, who’s got not a whiff of gay panic about him, to say the least.
One thing this story does especially well is seed things into it that I genuinely want to know more about, making for some interesting mysteries. A casual mention that Sakura can’t even use magic… yet… just passes right on by, but I sure noticed it. Not that she needs it right at the moment.
And that big old reveal of a classic magical girl trope at the end of the volume made me super happy. It’s so obvious and I should have seen it coming, but it’s still great. I’ve got a sneaking suspicion, based on our small cast thus far, about who’s behind it, which is no bad thing since it’s a great idea. It doesn’t have to be a surprise - it can make narrative sense and still be immensely satisfying.
Regrettably, the art doesn’t do the story many favours. I like Sakura’s magical girl form and the transformation sequence is hilariously appropriate, but this story loves to punctuate its jokes with wild takes and it does not have a strong face game, sad to say, which could have sold the comedy better than it does.
And I like the evil behind it all, mostly, even if it takes the most obvious form. It gets the job done, same as the monster designs, which are somewhat stylish, but could be better. With Sakura’s traditional design, it would have been great to see some truly wild enemies for her to fight, although I think it might have strained the art to the breaking point.
It’s all entirely passable, but the jokes are middling and the art’s okay, and you can see chunks of the plot a mile off. But it’s having fun and it feels fun. It’s kind of like when you try and use all the stuff in your fridge up at once - some things will not incorporate well, but that doesn’t mean the dish can’t be tasty at times.
And it does certainly get better as it goes - the whole second half evil monster is a build-up that, again, is obvious but presented well. This gets a lot of magical girl tropes dead on, I just wish it had been a little more strong about it all.
3 stars - at the end of the day, I know I had fun and I know I’ll have more. There are clear flaws that keep this from being perfect, but as a different take on the magical girl genre it does well as a celebration and parody all at once. Well worth the second volume chance.