I have read a few of Edgar Allen Poe’s more famous works coming up through school several years ago, without many strong feelings lingering from the experience. I believed myself to have enjoyed much of it at the time but I was left with only vague remembrances of plots. This past experience did aid in my understanding of such applicable works, while for the others that were new to me I had to put in a little more work to actively understand. As I read more and more works of literature that far precede me (which use a version of english much harder to understand), it becomes clearer to me that the human experience has remained fundamentally unchanged for the most part. When you read a critique of the dangers of an industrialized society from almost 200 years ago, or someone describing physical sensations or mental health issues that only acquired a name a few decades ago, it feels strangely familiar and warm. Despite the sometimes gruesome or dreary subject matter of his short stories, Poe’s masterful ability to describe and evoke human emotion in the characters and the reader respectively reaches out across time in a way not many authors can.
Of course with the book being a collection of short stories and poems, not all of them are winners, and as with Dubliners or Kafka, jumping between stories can be disorienting, especially given the difficulty of the writing and its use of antiquated terms and phrasing. It often took several pages of a story to truly understand the happenings being told, and in a few instances the story ended before that could happen. Specifically with shadow and silence, the second and third short story. However, once over that ‘hump’ there would be a sort of click that would happen where the story would begin to accelerate forward and the build of suspense toward the end aided in this significantly.
Berenice: good.
Shadow: eh
Silence: eh
House of Usher: very good
William Wilson: good and interesting
Man of the crowd: good, interesting, not scary
Rue morgue: very good, Sherlock holmes copied its whole flow, was not as scary as i expected
Maeltrom: good, intense
Monos and una: very slow start, good ending
Never bet the devil your head: good, interesting
Oval portrait: too short
Red death: classic, good
Pit and pendulum: very interesting
Tell tale heart: classic
Black cat: this dude was evil and legitamately hard to read but good ending
Ragged mountains: very interesting
Premature burial: a little too introspective, but good
Purloined letter: not as good as rue morgue but fun sequel
Mummy: bizzare but thought provoking
Imp: too much discussion on the perverse which was discussed in other stories like the black cat, which did it better
Cask of amontillado: classic
With regard to the poetry that consisted of the last 50 or so pages in the book, this was hard to get through. If i was going into it looking to analyze the poetry it would have been better, but I was trying to finish the book and it was even more disjointed reading even shorter unrelated stories with even an harder to understand use of the english language. I am inexperienced in reading poetry as well and so besides some of the poems with a very typical and regular rhyming and rhythmic structure, they just didnt read right. Besides many of them i couldnt even describe what was being discussed, sure the language was vivid but to what end was it being used. I would need to analyze each one one by one and use the internet to help in describing and understanding what is written to appreciate much of it. The few i did enjoy were: Lenore, the Raven, to science, israfel, city in the sea, dream-land, the bells, eldorado, and for annie. These were the ones that either read easily or/and i understood very early on the point of the poem and what it was describing. With some of them being genuinely interesting, but largely these were just the ones that didn’t drain me.
Because of the inconsistency of the experience i give the book a 4, but at times some of these stories and their writing are hard to beat anywhere and going back for particular passages is something i may legitimately consider in the near future.