So, I'll start with a little background. I first came across John Berardi and Precision Nutrition almost a decade ago, and I was immediately impressed with everything I saw. Unlike many voices in the nutrition field, John struck me as someone who had mastered both the art and science of nutrition. His education is solid, especially in a field where many people who are giving advice have little to no real training in the nutritional or biochemical sciences. Yet despite his formal training in the sciences, he exudes an openness to what some might deem the "unscientific." You get the sense that he's not going to write something off simply because we don't have a bunch of studies to support it. In that sense, I sensed he valued the scientific method and has a healthy amount a skepticism, but he is still open-minded.
From everything I read and heard, I could see he was on the cutting edge of the field. And I appreciated his analytical, scientific approach to the process. Based on the info coming out of PN, he did not strike me as someone who jumps on bandwagons. Instead, he was/is the type of person who sees the bandwagon, inspects the bandwagon, and asks questions about where the bandwagon is going, and then after some thought and reflection might take a test drive in the bandwagon. Again, in the nutrition field this is a rare and admirable trait.
Basically, I liked him. I appreciated his intellectual curiosity, his respect for the scientific process, and his ability to distinguish good information from bad information.
And then at a time in my life when I've decided to leave health care after working 25 years as a physical therapist (I also have a degree in nutrition and multiple fitness certifications) to pursue health coaching, I see that he has written a book about becoming a health coach. I didn't even blink. I ordered "Change Maker" Kindle addition right there on the spot.
Anyway, back to the book.
Parts of the book are phenomenal. John has a tremendous amount of insight. And one need only take a glimpse at my goodreads account to see that I share his passion for reading and learning. He is absolutely someone I admire, not because of what he's achieved, but because of who he is.
Unfortunately, I also feel like this book suffers from an identity crisis. It doesn't quite know what it wants to be. At times is feels like a memoir, at others an introduction to the coaching industry, and still at others it resembles a self-help...you can build a billion dollar company too if you just really believe and work hard enough.
There were parts of the book that felt as if they were the book John wanted to write, and there were other parts of the book (like the "what you need to know about hiring and firing") that seemed like they were chapters someone told him he needed to write, so he did.
I mean is this book for someone who is just starting off in the health coaching industry, a relatively young industry, that many people still don't even recognize as being a legitimate thing, or is this a book for an established business (health or otherwise) that is looking to grow or currently experiencing growing pains? The book vacillates between how to get your first client to managing 100 employees. In that sense, I'm not sure this book knows who its audience is.
For me, this book was like a movie that has you bored senseless for periods of time, only to have you on the edge of your seat at others.
Personally, I think the health coaching industry is very similar to what the personal training industry was and still sometimes is. There are a ton of people with a passion for health and fitness who are unhappy with their current job, want out sooner than later and thus get lured into the idea of a fresh start doing something they love. The certifications are appealing because they are a short investment relative to many other career paths (it took me seven years of higher education and ten of thousands of dollars to get licensed as a PT), and most people can do them while still working or meeting other life demands.
The problem is the background and training of those entering both fields are so diverse. You could have a coach/trainer who in addition to becoming a certified coach/trainer also has a nursing or other medical background, or maybe they have a degree in kinesiology or exercise science. Maybe they are a PT with decades of experience like me. And then you have others who have a lot of enthusiasm and passion, but a very superficial understanding of the life and health sciences that provide the basis for the foundational principles of the health and wellness field.
So you have all these newly certified, eternally hopeful health coaches, all dreaming of becoming the next John Berardi, and ironically no shortage of "coaches" for health coaches who are out there selling these new "grads" their proven method, sure-fire-way, how-to packages. But the truth is building a practice in an unestablished, unregulated field like health coaching is hard. For every 1 person that succeeds, another 999 fail. So what do you do with your new certification? You join a facebook page...usually one that has been created by one of those same people trying to sell you their plan for success.
You build a website. You come up with your elevator speech. "I help people blank." You open an Instagram account and post inspiring memes. You trade likes with other wanna-be coaches. And you start your own mini 5-day facebook challenge so you can build that essential and coveted email list...because that's what everyone else in the health coaching group tells you you're supposed to do to be successful. Maybe you read John's book. And then you wait and wonder why you still don't have any clients.
The problem is John Berardi is the exception not the rule. He has a tremendous education. He has incredible instincts. And he has by all accounts won the health coaching lottery. But reading his story, I was reminded of another book I recently read about these freak athletes who literally have won the genetic lottery and have amazing success in their sport. Famous, they then sell their programs, "The Secret to My Success: This is what I did, now you try it." But the thing is these lucky few aren't necessarily successful because of what they did, they were able to do what they did because they are just exceptionally gifted.
I guess the point I'm trying to make is that to be a successful personal trainer or health coach, you have to have a solid education-through experience or formal training, an admirable work ethic, good business instincts, endurance, patience, a lot of support (family, friends, and maybe even financial) and even some good old fashioned luck. Many will try, some will achieve adequate success, and a few will excel. Most will fail and move on.
I think this book could have been better if it would have focused on the average health coach who more than anything needs motivation and a healthy dose of reality that inspires them to continue to pursue their dream in a field where most of us won't survive let alone enjoy the success achieved by the John Berardis of the world. I also wish it would have provided more insight about what we're doing wrong and how to get it right. Honestly, it's when he shares these insights that the narrative shines. It's like he pulls back for fear of narrowing his audience, which is sad, because the health and wellness field is in desperate need of real "Change Makers" and real leadership.
Alas, 3 stars.