Welp, this turned out to be quite disappointing. I was excited to read a friends/neighbors-to-lovers fantasy where both MCs are in their early 50s. In fact, I’d still read the hell out of that book. Unfortunately, all I got here was uneven characterization and pacing issues. Twyla has a personality change at 30%, going from badass marshal to someone with massive internalized ageism and fatphobia, in addition to self-esteem issues. She felt invisible in her marriage and as a mom…and yet she never does anything to disabuse her adult children of that notion. She never calls Wade out or demonstrates that she knows how to set boundaries with her family. if she’s so pissed off at her deceased husband for the way he treated her and railing about it to her daughter, why does she let Wade treat her the same way?
Still, I could have overlooked some of this had there been a strong emotional arc and the romance was good. Instead, the author lobbed in a love triangle for no reason. We don’t ever get Frank’s POV, which is a disservice to both him and this story. By the end, I wanted him to want better for himself than Twyla. He gave so much more than he got.
The plot went off the rails at the end. The villain reveal was ridiculous enough to make me contemplate rating this one star instead of two. Despite thoroughly enjoying Hart and Mercy, this turned out to be not my cup of tea at all. The plot became repetitive and the sense of humor was immature. Worst of all, it was pointedly gender essentialist and riddled with gay stereotypes. Duckers was both inappropriate and unprofessional. Such a letdown.
Characters: Twyla is a 53 year old white Marshal and widow. She has three adult children (Wade, DJ, and Hope) and several grandchildren. Frank is a 53 year old white Marshal. He has two adult children Lu and Annie. He also takes care of a baby dragon named Mary Georgina. This is set in Eternity and Tanria.
Content notes: FMC kisses MMC when she’s dating someone else (they only went and on two dates and she doesn’t view this as infidelity), murder, bomb, abduction, physical assault, ageism, internalized and overt fatphobia, diet culture, misogyny (secondary character), past death of FMC’s husband (autoduck accident), past divorce (MMC’s wife left 12 years ago), past death of MMC’s mother, MMC’s father was an alcoholic who didn’t work, family estrangement, gambling debt (secondary character), dragon poop, incontinence, past zombies (drudges), on page sex, sex toy, alcohol, inebriation, hangover, pipe (secondary character), “manhood” as euphemism and equating genitalia with gender, gay stereotypes, gendered pejoratives, gender essentialism, ableist language