In the first half of the last century, feeble-mindedness was widely accepted as a scourge to society and civilization. And though hereditary diseases or disorders of the mind and body were often factors in its diagnosis, morality and sexuality were believed equally as important and just as inheritable by birth. For this reason, hundreds of girls and young women from broken homes, orphanages, jails, hospitals, convents, and shelters across Rhode Island were accused of being a danger to themselves and society and legally committed to an institution for the feeble-minded. Exeter Girls is a collection of notes and letters following the true stories of three women — Evelyn, Cora, and Dorothy — whose harrowing journeys through this gauntlet of institutionalization will astonish you with confessions of injustice, tragedy, and despair.
Jason R. Carpenter is a Rhode Island writer and researcher who has spent over twenty-five years studying the history of the state's institutions. His books include Exeter Girls: Letters From a Feeble-Minded School, Vox Humana: The Story of the State Hospital Pipe Organ, and, newest, House Dogs in the Turnips.
I saw this at my library and knew immediately i had to read it. The title was a reminder of my earliest nightmares, the haunted Ladd school in Exeter RI. The book tells the stories of three young women who were confined to the school through letters mostly between the girls and their families and Dr Ladd, the head of the school.
The author gives a little context of the science at the time and how the schools were managed. I wish the author had included more about the history of the Exeter school and how he did his research. But the stories are horrifying and really paint a picture of what life was like at the time for poor families who were unlucky enough to come to Dr. Ladd’s attention.
Note: DO NOT read this book if you are expecting happy endings.
As one would expect given the subject of the book and the time frame of the letters, there is archaic medical terminology used that would be considered derogatory today, along with heavy themes of misogyny, ableism, and support of eugenics (among other things).
Overall I found this quite good, though the structure was quite bare and at times things were difficult to follow.
The book is separated into three parts, each involving a young woman and her related correspondence between her, family members, clinicians, judges, social workers, and the like.
Perhaps it's my ADHD getting in the way here, but this is where I felt some structure would have really helped; apart from the quick blurb beforehand, the book really was just three stacks of letters. Perhaps a quick intro as to who everyone in these letters were would have helped? That way, at least the reader could flip back to the start of the letters for a quick refresher as to who is who. Also, while I've been living in Rhode Island since 2012 (under extreme duress), not everyone is familiar with the state; even some quick maps of where things are in the state or in Providence and Cranston would have been nice. Some photos of the infirmary and the school would have been wonderful. But... nothing but these letters. Hmm.
Again, I did enjoy this, but I felt I had to meet things halfway.
2/6 While the premise is very interesting, I thought the execution was lacking. All this was was a series of letters between Ladd and three different families/"cases". Before each "case" there would be about a one paragraph blurb about the school/ Dr Ladd himself. this book could've gone into more detail about the school, the patients and the people involved in the school as a whole. I'm not exactly sure if this book wanted us to "take a side" as it were between Ladd and the families. But everything Ladd cautioned the families of, came true according to the end-of-chapter "what happened to so-and-so". Ladd cautioned that if the girls were let go back to their families, they'd get taken advantage of, get pregnant, and then need state welfare to provide for them and their babies. Surprise, each girl got pregnant (one three times) and each ended up on the state welfare. One thing that could be held in contention was if these girls were truly "feeble-minded" or if they were just trapped in a cycle of poverty.
TBH, I got bored of the back and forth letters that, while the dates were different, were highly repetitive, so I ended up skimming (the second set of letters especially) and read the "what happened to them" at the end of each "chapter". There were only three chapters. Will not read again
Using letters from the archives of the Ladd School- called the RI School for the Feebleminded at the time the stories take place- Carpenter tells of three female patients at the school and their experience. Other than introductory paragraphs, Carpenter allows the letters to tell their stories in an engaging and poignant way. Excellent insight into the structure of our welfare system and reliance on eugenics at the time.
A non-fiction account consisting of correspondence regarding inmates of the Exeter School. (Called the Ladd School when I was growing up). Citizens including children were confined simply for having a low IQ or being promiscuous, seeming them a risk to society as it was believed they would reproduce. Chilling.
Was hoping that it would have more information than letters. Also, nothing about the author which lends some credibility behind the use of proper research and if he was authorized to publish?
This left me absolutely speechless. This is a book that will stay with me always. Ready to have a deep and long conversation about this book. Someone HMU
I was expecting more details but only Dr. Ladd's letters appear to be uncensored. The letters from patients and family are limited. I wanted to know about life within the "school" but the letters do not provide that information. They do, however, provide an insight into the "eugenically" slanted view of the times and the terrible labeling of women who had sex outside of marriage as morons or imbeciles. It was appalling.
Just wish there were more details about how life inside the school was for these young women. Women, who appear, to have only committed the crime of having a child out of wedlock or sex outside of marriage.
This book to me into the minds of the Dr.'s and those at the location. As well as the family. I wanted so much more out of the book but was thrilled with the personal letters. At times I did question which was off the 'norm' the girls or the Dr. Very good read for anyone into Asylum life.