What do you think?
Rate this book
Une enfant prodigieuse
A MOTHER KNOWS HER CHILD BEST. DOESN'T SHE?
'Brilliant and creepy, I wolfed it down! One of my favourite reads of 2025' LISA JEWELL
Charlotte's daughter, Stella, is sensitive and brilliant - perhaps even a genius - but after the sudden death of her babysitter, Blanka, the once disruptive and anti-social child has become docile and agreeable. And what's more unsettling is that she has begun to mirror Blanka's personality, from her accent and repetitive phrases to fierce cravings for Armenian meat stew after being raised a vegetarian.
Charlotte is pregnant with her second child, depleted and sick, and convinced that Blanka herself is somehow responsible for Stella's transformation. But how could Blanka still be entwined in their lives?
As Charlotte becomes increasingly obsessed, it's clear her husband believes this is all in her head and soon, Charlotte is convinced she is the only one who can save her daughter.
Told through a singular, chilling voice, Clever Little Thing holds light to the blurred lines of diagnosis in children and to the vital power of maternal instinct. Kaleidoscopic and tense, pulse-pounding and genuinely creepy, this is an ode to motherhood and a story that will haunt listeners long after its epic finale.
'Compelling and creepy' ASHLEY ELSTON
'An eerie, twisty story of a mother trying to protect her daughter' TRACY SIERRA
'Perfectly unnerving' ASHLEY AUDRAIN
'Unsettling in the best way' MARY KUBICA
'Incredibly moving, tense, and deliciously creepy' ASHLEY TATE
'Brilliant and creepy, I wolfed it down! One of my favourite reads of 2025' LISA JEWELL
Charlotte's daughter, Stella, is sensitive and brilliant - perhaps even a genius - but after the sudden death of her babysitter, Blanka, the once disruptive and anti-social child has become docile and agreeable. And what's more unsettling is that she has begun to mirror Blanka's personality, from her accent and repetitive phrases to fierce cravings for Armenian meat stew after being raised a vegetarian.
Charlotte is pregnant with her second child, depleted and sick, and convinced that Blanka herself is somehow responsible for Stella's transformation. But how could Blanka still be entwined in their lives?
As Charlotte becomes increasingly obsessed, it's clear her husband believes this is all in her head and soon, Charlotte is convinced she is the only one who can save her daughter.
Told through a singular, chilling voice, Clever Little Thing holds light to the blurred lines of diagnosis in children and to the vital power of maternal instinct. Kaleidoscopic and tense, pulse-pounding and genuinely creepy, this is an ode to motherhood and a story that will haunt listeners long after its epic finale.
'Compelling and creepy' ASHLEY ELSTON
'An eerie, twisty story of a mother trying to protect her daughter' TRACY SIERRA
'Perfectly unnerving' ASHLEY AUDRAIN
'Unsettling in the best way' MARY KUBICA
'Incredibly moving, tense, and deliciously creepy' ASHLEY TATE
352 pages, Paperback
First published January 14, 2025
201 people are currently reading
23866 people want to read
About the author
Helena Echlin
7 books143 followersHello! Clever Little Thing, coming in January 2025, is my first psychological thriller. I’ve written for various publications, including the Guardian and the Times, and the steadiest job I ever had was writing an etiquette advice column, for which I had zero qualifications. I lived in northern California for many years, and am now back in my native UK with my American husband and two children. I teach creative writing for Oxford University’s Department of Continuing Education.
.
.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 813 reviews
September 14, 2025
I can't wait for 2025, as I’ve been reading one mind-blowing book after another! Helena Echlin's latest work gives you chills and goosebumps. It can be summed up in a few words: eerie, creepy, yet engaging, emotional, and surprisingly thought-provoking, with its realistic approach to motherhood, mental health, and autism awareness. This twisty, jaw-dropping psychological thriller has so many layers, appealing to a wide range of readers. It explores dysfunctional family dynamics, the heavy psychological and physical burdens of motherhood, grief, cultural identity, child psychology, all wrapped in a mysterious narrative with hints of supernatural horror and fantasy.
The protagonist, Charlotte, is captivating despite her many flaws and mental struggles, having been raised by a chronically depressed, emotionally distant mother who left invisible scars on her soul. Determined to do better for her daughter Stella, who shows signs of autism and high intelligence at 8, Charlotte creates a protective cocoon around her. But Stella's emotional outbursts, rigid eating habits, and difficulties with social interaction test Charlotte's patience, especially while she's pregnant and her husband is largely absent due to work.
When their socially awkward nanny Blanka, who unexpectedly connects with Stella, quits her job and is later found dead, Charlotte becomes alarmed. She forms a bond with Blanka's mother, Irina, who had been living with Blanka until her final days.
As Charlotte grows closer to Irina, she notices startling changes in Stella—she becomes more social, changes her handwriting, takes up new habits like crocheting, and begins eating new foods. These red flags leave Charlotte questioning everything. Why is Stella no longer the brilliant, emotionally volatile child she once knew? Is Charlotte in denial about her daughter’s transformation because of their special bond? Or is something far more sinister at play, as Stella begins acting disturbingly like her late nanny? Could possession be real, or is Charlotte losing her mind under the stress of pregnancy and recent family tragedies?
I absolutely loved this unique story and its clever conclusion. The book starts slow, but it leaves enough breadcrumbs to keep you hooked, and the final third pulls the rug out from under you with shocking twists. It's a blend of twisty paranormal psychological thriller and emotional women’s fiction about motherhood, and the author nails both genres. I highly recommend adding this phenomenal read to your list!
Many thanks to NetGalley and Penguin Group Viking/Pamela Dorman Books for providing this fantastic thriller's digital review copy in exchange for my honest thoughts.
Follow me on medium.com to read my articles about books, movies, streaming series, astrology:
medium blog
instagram
facebook
twitter
The protagonist, Charlotte, is captivating despite her many flaws and mental struggles, having been raised by a chronically depressed, emotionally distant mother who left invisible scars on her soul. Determined to do better for her daughter Stella, who shows signs of autism and high intelligence at 8, Charlotte creates a protective cocoon around her. But Stella's emotional outbursts, rigid eating habits, and difficulties with social interaction test Charlotte's patience, especially while she's pregnant and her husband is largely absent due to work.
When their socially awkward nanny Blanka, who unexpectedly connects with Stella, quits her job and is later found dead, Charlotte becomes alarmed. She forms a bond with Blanka's mother, Irina, who had been living with Blanka until her final days.
As Charlotte grows closer to Irina, she notices startling changes in Stella—she becomes more social, changes her handwriting, takes up new habits like crocheting, and begins eating new foods. These red flags leave Charlotte questioning everything. Why is Stella no longer the brilliant, emotionally volatile child she once knew? Is Charlotte in denial about her daughter’s transformation because of their special bond? Or is something far more sinister at play, as Stella begins acting disturbingly like her late nanny? Could possession be real, or is Charlotte losing her mind under the stress of pregnancy and recent family tragedies?
I absolutely loved this unique story and its clever conclusion. The book starts slow, but it leaves enough breadcrumbs to keep you hooked, and the final third pulls the rug out from under you with shocking twists. It's a blend of twisty paranormal psychological thriller and emotional women’s fiction about motherhood, and the author nails both genres. I highly recommend adding this phenomenal read to your list!
Many thanks to NetGalley and Penguin Group Viking/Pamela Dorman Books for providing this fantastic thriller's digital review copy in exchange for my honest thoughts.
Follow me on medium.com to read my articles about books, movies, streaming series, astrology:
medium blog
January 14, 2025
Possession?
Charlotte’s daughter Stella cannot stand the sound of the waves at the beach, or the sound of water running in the bathtub. She has an aversion to snuggling. And, she also throws tantrums that her mom calls “freak out mode”. Her screams were once so loud and piercing that she rushed her to the ER.
But, she can also read at an ADULT level, although she has only just completed grade three.
Other moms suggest that the anti social child be tested because of her behavior-but Charlotte doesn’t want Stella to be labeled. She would never want Stella to feel the way her own mom made her feel-“not good enough”.
But then suddenly, after the death of her babysitter, Blanka, just days after she had resigned, the once disruptive child has become almost TOO agreeable.
“OH YES!” became her answer to everything-just like Blanka.
She begins mirroring Blanka-not only in personality but also by taking on some of her physical traits.
Her father is thrilled that Stella seems to be outgrowing her strange early tendencies, but Charlotte is convinced that Blanka has taken over Stella’s body, and with an unlikely accomplice-Blanka’s mother, Irina-Charlotte is determined to save her daughter.
But, is it Stella who needs the saving? The book opens with Charlotte talking to a Dr. Beaufort (Now) and these chapters alternate with chapters from THEN.
Although this takes place in modern times, the writing is very formal (example: “I proffered the blanket, tied with a gray silk ribbon-it’s luxe minimalism was out of place here-instead looking drab and utilitarian) Perhaps that is what made it such a SLOW BURN. And, despite the premise it DID NOT have the CREEPY factor that I expected.
It took me much longer than usual to finish.
I liked the story-but I didn’t love it.
NOW AVAILABLE!
Thank You to Pamela Dorman Books for the invitation to read this one. I received a gifted ARC and as always-these are my candid thoughts.
Charlotte’s daughter Stella cannot stand the sound of the waves at the beach, or the sound of water running in the bathtub. She has an aversion to snuggling. And, she also throws tantrums that her mom calls “freak out mode”. Her screams were once so loud and piercing that she rushed her to the ER.
But, she can also read at an ADULT level, although she has only just completed grade three.
Other moms suggest that the anti social child be tested because of her behavior-but Charlotte doesn’t want Stella to be labeled. She would never want Stella to feel the way her own mom made her feel-“not good enough”.
But then suddenly, after the death of her babysitter, Blanka, just days after she had resigned, the once disruptive child has become almost TOO agreeable.
“OH YES!” became her answer to everything-just like Blanka.
She begins mirroring Blanka-not only in personality but also by taking on some of her physical traits.
Her father is thrilled that Stella seems to be outgrowing her strange early tendencies, but Charlotte is convinced that Blanka has taken over Stella’s body, and with an unlikely accomplice-Blanka’s mother, Irina-Charlotte is determined to save her daughter.
But, is it Stella who needs the saving? The book opens with Charlotte talking to a Dr. Beaufort (Now) and these chapters alternate with chapters from THEN.
Although this takes place in modern times, the writing is very formal (example: “I proffered the blanket, tied with a gray silk ribbon-it’s luxe minimalism was out of place here-instead looking drab and utilitarian) Perhaps that is what made it such a SLOW BURN. And, despite the premise it DID NOT have the CREEPY factor that I expected.
It took me much longer than usual to finish.
I liked the story-but I didn’t love it.
NOW AVAILABLE!
Thank You to Pamela Dorman Books for the invitation to read this one. I received a gifted ARC and as always-these are my candid thoughts.
December 31, 2024
Chilling, bizarre, intriguing, and creepy. Clever Little Thing is Helena Echlin's clever book which had me guessing what was real, what was true, is this a possession, is what is happening due to a mental health diagnosis, etc. I enjoyed that I was never quite sure what was happening for most of the book.
Charlotte is a pregnant married woman with an intelligent, quirky, antisocial, and quick to tantrum, daughter, Stella. When Stella's babysitter, Blanka dies suddenly, Charlotte notices changes in her daughter. Stella begins talking like Blanka, craves Armenian food, and wants meat even though she was raised vegetarian. Charlotte's husband does not see anything wrong with Stella's changes, but Charlotte can't help but be unnerved and become obsessed by them.
This book was a bit of a slow burn, and I struggle with slow burns. What I did enjoy was not knowing if Stella was possessed, was Charlotte imagining things, was Stella just mourning her deceased babysitter by trying to be like her? I thought this was very well done.
I also wrestled with who was more troubled, Charlotte or Stella? Both had times where I questioned their actions and behaviors.
I enjoyed the unsettling feel of this book with its creepy undertones. There were a few twists and revelations in this book which I did not see coming. This book touches on motherhood, marriage, loss, relationships, and mental health.
This book is well written, well thought out, and kept me guessing. While I enjoyed this book and found it to be clever, it was missing that little bit of something that would push my rating higher.
Thank you to Pamela Dorman Books and NetGalley who provided me with a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. All the thoughts and opinions are my own.
Read more of my reviews at www.openbookposts.com 📖
Charlotte is a pregnant married woman with an intelligent, quirky, antisocial, and quick to tantrum, daughter, Stella. When Stella's babysitter, Blanka dies suddenly, Charlotte notices changes in her daughter. Stella begins talking like Blanka, craves Armenian food, and wants meat even though she was raised vegetarian. Charlotte's husband does not see anything wrong with Stella's changes, but Charlotte can't help but be unnerved and become obsessed by them.
This book was a bit of a slow burn, and I struggle with slow burns. What I did enjoy was not knowing if Stella was possessed, was Charlotte imagining things, was Stella just mourning her deceased babysitter by trying to be like her? I thought this was very well done.
I also wrestled with who was more troubled, Charlotte or Stella? Both had times where I questioned their actions and behaviors.
I enjoyed the unsettling feel of this book with its creepy undertones. There were a few twists and revelations in this book which I did not see coming. This book touches on motherhood, marriage, loss, relationships, and mental health.
This book is well written, well thought out, and kept me guessing. While I enjoyed this book and found it to be clever, it was missing that little bit of something that would push my rating higher.
Thank you to Pamela Dorman Books and NetGalley who provided me with a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. All the thoughts and opinions are my own.
Read more of my reviews at www.openbookposts.com 📖
January 14, 2025
HAPPY PUBLICATION DAY!
A Clever Little Thing is a super clever debut!
This book can best be described as a combination of The Push, Baby Teeth, and Behind Her Eyes.
I really don’t want to give away any details from this plot. It is best to go in blind and experience it for yourself. I know this isn’t that helpful of a review, but I fear my last sentence has already given away too much.
I can’t believe this is a debut! The writing is intoxicating and I couldn’t put it down for a minute. Echlin is a master storyteller and expertly leads the reader in so many directions.
I absolutely loved Clever Little Thing and am recommending it as one of my favorite psychological thrillers of the year! I can’t wait to read more from this talented writer! All of the stars!
5/5 stars
Expected publication date: 1/14/25
Thank you to NetGalley and Penguin Group - Viking for the ARC of Clever Little Thing in exchange for an honest review.
A Clever Little Thing is a super clever debut!
This book can best be described as a combination of The Push, Baby Teeth, and Behind Her Eyes.
I really don’t want to give away any details from this plot. It is best to go in blind and experience it for yourself. I know this isn’t that helpful of a review, but I fear my last sentence has already given away too much.
I can’t believe this is a debut! The writing is intoxicating and I couldn’t put it down for a minute. Echlin is a master storyteller and expertly leads the reader in so many directions.
I absolutely loved Clever Little Thing and am recommending it as one of my favorite psychological thrillers of the year! I can’t wait to read more from this talented writer! All of the stars!
5/5 stars
Expected publication date: 1/14/25
Thank you to NetGalley and Penguin Group - Viking for the ARC of Clever Little Thing in exchange for an honest review.
November 9, 2024
Clever Little Thing is bingeable, entertaining, and keeps you guessing until the end. The book has a slower start as it introduces you to the characters but it picks up in the second half.
The book was well written and easy to read. I enjoyed the paranormal/supernatural elements and the unique premise. Readers of psychological and mom thrillers will enjoy this one.
This book is being compared to The Push and aside from the book being about a mother, Clever Little Thing is completely different (in a good way).
Clever Little Thing by Helena Echlin will be available on January 14. Many thanks to Pamela Dorman Books and NetGalley for the gifted copy!
The book was well written and easy to read. I enjoyed the paranormal/supernatural elements and the unique premise. Readers of psychological and mom thrillers will enjoy this one.
This book is being compared to The Push and aside from the book being about a mother, Clever Little Thing is completely different (in a good way).
Clever Little Thing by Helena Echlin will be available on January 14. Many thanks to Pamela Dorman Books and NetGalley for the gifted copy!
December 11, 2024
Charlotte and Pete have a happy marriage, an 8 year old daughter, Stella, and another little one on the way. Charlotte sometimes struggles with Stella's behavior. She's practically a genius who reads well beyond her years but socially she's awkward. She often displays "freak-out mode" when something doesn't go her way. She's sensitive to touch and sound.
When their nanny, Blanka, suddenly dies Charlotte finds herself worried even more for her daughter. It's as if her behavior has changed over night. She no longer reads, she's putting on weight, and her temperament is as calm as can be. Charlotte can't help but to wonder if Blanka has somehow possessed their daughter.
I'm not going to say too much more because I don't want to spoil future readers. What I will say is that this was an absolute page turner for me. I had no idea what was going. Is she possessed? Is Charlotte experiencing some kind of psychosis? I had so many questions and theories. Echlin took me completely by surprise when she started spilling the devious little secrets. Throughout most of the book I believed one thing until the rug got pulled out beneath me and I realized that not everything is what I assumed. I love when that happens. Echlin's debut psychological thriller is a worthy entry in the genre. 4 stars!
Thank you to NetGalley and Penguin Group - Viking for my complimentary copy.
When their nanny, Blanka, suddenly dies Charlotte finds herself worried even more for her daughter. It's as if her behavior has changed over night. She no longer reads, she's putting on weight, and her temperament is as calm as can be. Charlotte can't help but to wonder if Blanka has somehow possessed their daughter.
I'm not going to say too much more because I don't want to spoil future readers. What I will say is that this was an absolute page turner for me. I had no idea what was going. Is she possessed? Is Charlotte experiencing some kind of psychosis? I had so many questions and theories. Echlin took me completely by surprise when she started spilling the devious little secrets. Throughout most of the book I believed one thing until the rug got pulled out beneath me and I realized that not everything is what I assumed. I love when that happens. Echlin's debut psychological thriller is a worthy entry in the genre. 4 stars!
Thank you to NetGalley and Penguin Group - Viking for my complimentary copy.
Read
April 23, 2025DNF at 63%- if I finish this I’ll end up rating it 1 star and I just don’t care enough to hate-finish it 😂
I went into this completely blind thinking it was like The Push, Dearest, The Unprotected, Nightbitch etc (I love books about the struggles of new motherhood) and it was just a complete flop imo.
Apparently this is a possession/horror book, but it was so slow moving, and honestly just so poorly done, that I wasn’t picking up any of what I think the author was trying to put down. I was 2/3rds of the way into the book before I realized, this is annoying, nothing has happened, and where is this going?!? 😅
Onto the next!!!
I went into this completely blind thinking it was like The Push, Dearest, The Unprotected, Nightbitch etc (I love books about the struggles of new motherhood) and it was just a complete flop imo.
Apparently this is a possession/horror book, but it was so slow moving, and honestly just so poorly done, that I wasn’t picking up any of what I think the author was trying to put down. I was 2/3rds of the way into the book before I realized, this is annoying, nothing has happened, and where is this going?!? 😅
Onto the next!!!
May 29, 2025
This book was what it was hyped to be - creepy, weird, mysterious, frustrating (on Charlotte's behalf because I couldn't decide how I felt about her for most of the time), annoyed (by Irina for the same reason), and turned off by Blanka who had way too much presence for a dead person. Yet, I'm so glad to have stuck through all that. Getting to read how the mystery unfolded was a treat. The epilogue took it to another level after I thought it was all resolved.
I didn't love the tropes, but given how the story unfolded, I could look past them. They were mostly a bit too convenient and hackneyed for my taste: a mom who thinks her kid is way smarter than her age, a perfect though overly dense husband, a weird immigrant lady that's a little scary (yeah, let's lean into that xenophobia!), and school moms who are mean to the hero mom. As I write this review, I realize I really did not like any of the characters - not one. But because the truth is more incensing than most of the characters, I was able to stay engaged and curious.
Not really sure if I would classify this as horror, but there is an unanswered question of the paranormal. Mostly, I would call it suspense. I guess it should be called a paranormal suspense novel. Easy and fast to read. I enjoyed it and recommend it.
I didn't love the tropes, but given how the story unfolded, I could look past them. They were mostly a bit too convenient and hackneyed for my taste: a mom who thinks her kid is way smarter than her age, a perfect though overly dense husband, a weird immigrant lady that's a little scary (yeah, let's lean into that xenophobia!), and school moms who are mean to the hero mom. As I write this review, I realize I really did not like any of the characters - not one. But because the truth is more incensing than most of the characters, I was able to stay engaged and curious.
Not really sure if I would classify this as horror, but there is an unanswered question of the paranormal. Mostly, I would call it suspense. I guess it should be called a paranormal suspense novel. Easy and fast to read. I enjoyed it and recommend it.
January 26, 2025
Title/Author: Clever Little Thing by Helena Echlin
Page Count: 352
Publisher: Pamela Dorman Books
Format: I read a digital arc from NetGalley
Other Books I Enjoyed by This Author: First time reading
Affiliate Link: https://bookshop.org/a/7576/978059365...
Release Date: January 14th, 2025
General Genre: Psychological Suspense Thriller/Supernatural
Sub-Genre/Themes: Domestic drama, neurodivergent children (diagnosis not known), parenting, Armenian people, motherhood, Pre and postnatal depression, mood disorders, paranoia, Postpartum psychosis, nannies, self-harm, suicide, SA, pregnancy
Writing Style: Short chapters, alternating timelines (Then & Now), intricately plotted
What You Need to Know: "A taut, powerful psychological thriller following a mother who must confront a sudden and terrifying change in her daughter after the abrupt death of their babysitter."
My Reading Experience: I love psychological thrillers centered around new mothers and/or pregnancy.
Especially if there's something paranormal or supernatural going on too. I love intimate exposure behind closed doors of marriages and I also love an unreliable, unlikable narrator--you get all of this with, Clever Little Thing.
The most entertaining and compelling aspect of this book was that even though I had a sense of where the story was headed, I never once expected *exactly* how it would get there. One development took me completely by surprise, so props to the author for a solid blindside. Are there some unrealistic elements to the story? Yes.
Did I have to suspend disbelief a few times, also yes. But hear this: We live in a world that proves beyond the shadow of a doubt, that truth is stranger than fiction. I read headlines of real-life situations that make my jaw drop every day. Nothing surprises me anymore. I do not show up to my fictional book expecting reality because nobody could make that up anyway.
So yes, things go off the rails.
The main character is exhausting in the way she leaps to wild conclusions for no reason.
This was fun. I had a good time putting this one together and the author was great at keeping all the important cards close to her chest while allowing a few clues to reveal just enough to keep me hooked.
Final Recommendation: If you enjoy creepy kids, paranoid first-time parents, juicy drama, and unexpected twists and turns, this is for you. Please note my content warnings in the "themes/sub-genre" section
Comps: The Push & The Whispers by Ashley Audrain (elements of both books), Baby Teeth by Zoje Stage, The Changeling by Victor LaValle, Jennifer Hillier thrillers
Page Count: 352
Publisher: Pamela Dorman Books
Format: I read a digital arc from NetGalley
Other Books I Enjoyed by This Author: First time reading
Affiliate Link: https://bookshop.org/a/7576/978059365...
Release Date: January 14th, 2025
General Genre: Psychological Suspense Thriller/Supernatural
Sub-Genre/Themes: Domestic drama, neurodivergent children (diagnosis not known), parenting, Armenian people, motherhood, Pre and postnatal depression, mood disorders, paranoia, Postpartum psychosis, nannies, self-harm, suicide, SA, pregnancy
Writing Style: Short chapters, alternating timelines (Then & Now), intricately plotted
What You Need to Know: "A taut, powerful psychological thriller following a mother who must confront a sudden and terrifying change in her daughter after the abrupt death of their babysitter."
My Reading Experience: I love psychological thrillers centered around new mothers and/or pregnancy.
Especially if there's something paranormal or supernatural going on too. I love intimate exposure behind closed doors of marriages and I also love an unreliable, unlikable narrator--you get all of this with, Clever Little Thing.
The most entertaining and compelling aspect of this book was that even though I had a sense of where the story was headed, I never once expected *exactly* how it would get there. One development took me completely by surprise, so props to the author for a solid blindside. Are there some unrealistic elements to the story? Yes.
Did I have to suspend disbelief a few times, also yes. But hear this: We live in a world that proves beyond the shadow of a doubt, that truth is stranger than fiction. I read headlines of real-life situations that make my jaw drop every day. Nothing surprises me anymore. I do not show up to my fictional book expecting reality because nobody could make that up anyway.
So yes, things go off the rails.
The main character is exhausting in the way she leaps to wild conclusions for no reason.
This was fun. I had a good time putting this one together and the author was great at keeping all the important cards close to her chest while allowing a few clues to reveal just enough to keep me hooked.
Final Recommendation: If you enjoy creepy kids, paranoid first-time parents, juicy drama, and unexpected twists and turns, this is for you. Please note my content warnings in the "themes/sub-genre" section
Comps: The Push & The Whispers by Ashley Audrain (elements of both books), Baby Teeth by Zoje Stage, The Changeling by Victor LaValle, Jennifer Hillier thrillers
December 20, 2024
!!! Spoiler Alert !!!
3 Stars! ✨ Huge thanks to Penguin Group Viking, Pamela Dorman Books, and NetGalley for the ARC! Clever Little Thing by Helena Echlin is dropping on January 14, 2025, with 352 pages of crazy maternal instincts, creepy vibes, and some twists that'll leave you questioning everything 🤯
✨ Tropes & Themes ✨
✧ Maternal Fear 💔
✧ Paranormal Suspense 👻
✧ Family Secrets 🕵️♀️
✧ Creepy Kid 👧
✧ Gaslighting 🚩
✧ Psychological Obsession 🧠
Okay, let’s talk Charlotte. Pregnant with her second kid, Luna, but all her attention is on her first daughter, Stella, who’s definitely acting a little too weird after their babysitter dies suddenly. We're talking full-on possession vibes—mimicking Blanka (the babysitter) with her accent and food cravings. At first, I’m hooked, right? Is Stella really possessed?! I’m all in, but then... things got... uh... out there.
Charlotte's decisions were a mess, y’all. She seriously thinks about giving up Luna to her husband Pete (who, side note, she knows is a rapist) just to keep Stella safe. What? I’m like, “Charlotte, honey, what are you even doing?!” This moment had me shook, because her desperate obsession with Stella clouds her judgment completely. Seriously, her moral compass was lost at sea.
And then there’s the twist with Pete, Blanka’s abuse, and Stella's possession. Blanka’s ghost wants Charlotte to take Stella away from Pete to break the possession, but even then, Charlotte’s willing to make such drastic, messed-up choices. It was hard to follow her emotional journey when her decisions were so... well... unsettling. The emotional depth I was craving just wasn’t there, and it was tough to look past her seriously questionable actions.
Now, the concept? So good. A mom’s instincts mixed with supernatural horror? YES, PLEASE. But the execution? Not so much. Some twists that should’ve been freaky came across as... well, kinda comical. 🤷♀️ I found myself laughing at parts that were definitely meant to be serious, and the ending left me with more confusion than closure.
But hey, if you’re into unreliable narrators and creepy kid stories, you might still enjoy this one. Just be ready for some wild twists, uncomfortable maternal themes, and a lot of head-scratching moments.
📌 Content Warnings (CW):
- Child neglect
- Pregnancy complications
- Gaslighting
- Death of a caretaker
- Parental obsession
TL;DR: Creepy kids, ghostly vibes, and a mom making some seriously questionable choices. It’s a wild ride, but the twists lean more campy than clever. Worth a read if you love maternal suspense, but not one I’ll revisit.
3 Stars! ✨ Huge thanks to Penguin Group Viking, Pamela Dorman Books, and NetGalley for the ARC! Clever Little Thing by Helena Echlin is dropping on January 14, 2025, with 352 pages of crazy maternal instincts, creepy vibes, and some twists that'll leave you questioning everything 🤯
✨ Tropes & Themes ✨
✧ Maternal Fear 💔
✧ Paranormal Suspense 👻
✧ Family Secrets 🕵️♀️
✧ Creepy Kid 👧
✧ Gaslighting 🚩
✧ Psychological Obsession 🧠
Okay, let’s talk Charlotte. Pregnant with her second kid, Luna, but all her attention is on her first daughter, Stella, who’s definitely acting a little too weird after their babysitter dies suddenly. We're talking full-on possession vibes—mimicking Blanka (the babysitter) with her accent and food cravings. At first, I’m hooked, right? Is Stella really possessed?! I’m all in, but then... things got... uh... out there.
Charlotte's decisions were a mess, y’all. She seriously thinks about giving up Luna to her husband Pete (who, side note, she knows is a rapist) just to keep Stella safe. What? I’m like, “Charlotte, honey, what are you even doing?!” This moment had me shook, because her desperate obsession with Stella clouds her judgment completely. Seriously, her moral compass was lost at sea.
And then there’s the twist with Pete, Blanka’s abuse, and Stella's possession. Blanka’s ghost wants Charlotte to take Stella away from Pete to break the possession, but even then, Charlotte’s willing to make such drastic, messed-up choices. It was hard to follow her emotional journey when her decisions were so... well... unsettling. The emotional depth I was craving just wasn’t there, and it was tough to look past her seriously questionable actions.
Now, the concept? So good. A mom’s instincts mixed with supernatural horror? YES, PLEASE. But the execution? Not so much. Some twists that should’ve been freaky came across as... well, kinda comical. 🤷♀️ I found myself laughing at parts that were definitely meant to be serious, and the ending left me with more confusion than closure.
But hey, if you’re into unreliable narrators and creepy kid stories, you might still enjoy this one. Just be ready for some wild twists, uncomfortable maternal themes, and a lot of head-scratching moments.
📌 Content Warnings (CW):
- Child neglect
- Pregnancy complications
- Gaslighting
- Death of a caretaker
- Parental obsession
TL;DR: Creepy kids, ghostly vibes, and a mom making some seriously questionable choices. It’s a wild ride, but the twists lean more campy than clever. Worth a read if you love maternal suspense, but not one I’ll revisit.
Read
April 1, 2025DNF @64%
November 5, 2024
If you enjoy bingeable psychological thrillers, pick this one up and go into it BLIND!
As an avid thriller reader, I find it more and more difficult to find a 5-star one to really impress me. This one had a different type of twist to it, and although I could see a lot of the reveals coming it was still done so well. Echlin’s writing is the true star of the book though, I wasn’t expecting this to pack such an emotional punch - one reveal in particular around the halfway mark really hit home for me and provided some really fantastic quotes.
This should be a buzzy thriller for early ‘25 and it deserves all the praise!
As an avid thriller reader, I find it more and more difficult to find a 5-star one to really impress me. This one had a different type of twist to it, and although I could see a lot of the reveals coming it was still done so well. Echlin’s writing is the true star of the book though, I wasn’t expecting this to pack such an emotional punch - one reveal in particular around the halfway mark really hit home for me and provided some really fantastic quotes.
This should be a buzzy thriller for early ‘25 and it deserves all the praise!
December 10, 2024
ARC for review. To be published January 14, 2025.
3.4 rounded down to 3 stars. But it’s 3.4 stars.
Charlotte’s daughter Stella is a little odd, maybe brilliant. But following the death of her babysitter, Blanca, something has changed….she had begun to mirror Blanca’s personality and mannerisms.
Instead of just dropping her off at the nearest fire station with a blanket and a note (I guess it’s best that I don’t have children, yes?) Charlotte tries to solve the problem. Meanwhile she’s in her second pregnancy and deathly ill. Can she figure out what is going on, with the help of Blanca’s mother?
I’m not sure what took these ladies so long, because, again, I don’t have children, but I do know people and I was pretty darn sure what was happening right at the outset (and that was it.) The book kept me turning pages, though.
3.4 rounded down to 3 stars. But it’s 3.4 stars.
Charlotte’s daughter Stella is a little odd, maybe brilliant. But following the death of her babysitter, Blanca, something has changed….she had begun to mirror Blanca’s personality and mannerisms.
Instead of just dropping her off at the nearest fire station with a blanket and a note (I guess it’s best that I don’t have children, yes?) Charlotte tries to solve the problem. Meanwhile she’s in her second pregnancy and deathly ill. Can she figure out what is going on, with the help of Blanca’s mother?
I’m not sure what took these ladies so long, because, again, I don’t have children, but I do know people and I was pretty darn sure what was happening right at the outset (and that was it.) The book kept me turning pages, though.
August 22, 2024
“Clever Little Thing” by Helena Echlin was a thrilling and imaginative mystery that I could not put down! The story revolves around an eight year old girl who is somewhere on the spectrum in an unusual way. Her babysitter dies suddenly and the child suddenly takes on all the characteristics of the babysitter’s personality to the extreme degree. The Mom knows something is not right, but because the child was so difficult before taking on the babysitter’s characteristics no one else sees it! The twists and turns are propulsive and I truly had no idea where this story was going. It’s a mystery, a thriller and ventures into the paranormal. Clear your calendar because it’s unputdownable! Loved it!!
Thank you NetGalley and PENGUIN GROUP Viking for the ARC of this book in exchange for my honest review.
June 19, 2024
I absolutely loved this novel! I'm picky about my psychological thrillers, but this one 100% delivers. It has layers and depth, intriguing characters, smart writing, intense suspense, and genuinely surprising twists. Echlin perfectly captures the complicated emotions and nuances of motherhood. Comparisons to The Push, which I also loved, are spot-on. I couldn't put it down!
January 13, 2025
A mother must confront a sudden change in her daughter's behavior after the abrupt death of their babysitter. Charlotte is convinced that the babysitter's spirit has possessed her daughter, and she becomes obsessed with saving her. This chilling psychological thriller explores the blurred lines of diagnosis in children and the power of maternal instinct.
This book is absolutely phenomenal! I love so many aspects of it. Firstly, it was completely unexpected, so I recommend not reading the blurb before diving in. The characters were captivating, and the subtle paranormal occurrences added an intriguing element.
The book was clever, fast-paced, and full of unpredictable twists. I appreciated the cultural references, as I also come from a different country, and the author did an excellent job incorporating them. I was immediately drawn into the story, and while you may predict a few twists, the true outcome will surprise you.
There are a few triggers to be aware of, so I recommend checking before reading. The author's depiction of the children's behavior was so vivid that I couldn't help but wonder if it was based on personal experience or thorough research. The dynamics between the mother and daughter and their compromises to avoid conflicts were fascinating to read about.
I don't want to give too much away, but I truly adored this book! If you enjoy a touch of the paranormal and a well-written story that will keep you hooked, this is the perfect read. It's so engaging that you won't be able to put it down, so clear your schedule before starting because you'll be binge-reading this book in no time.
Thank you, PENGUIN GROUP Viking | Pamela Dorman Books for digital ARC. I am leaving this review voluntarily.
This book is absolutely phenomenal! I love so many aspects of it. Firstly, it was completely unexpected, so I recommend not reading the blurb before diving in. The characters were captivating, and the subtle paranormal occurrences added an intriguing element.
The book was clever, fast-paced, and full of unpredictable twists. I appreciated the cultural references, as I also come from a different country, and the author did an excellent job incorporating them. I was immediately drawn into the story, and while you may predict a few twists, the true outcome will surprise you.
There are a few triggers to be aware of, so I recommend checking before reading. The author's depiction of the children's behavior was so vivid that I couldn't help but wonder if it was based on personal experience or thorough research. The dynamics between the mother and daughter and their compromises to avoid conflicts were fascinating to read about.
I don't want to give too much away, but I truly adored this book! If you enjoy a touch of the paranormal and a well-written story that will keep you hooked, this is the perfect read. It's so engaging that you won't be able to put it down, so clear your schedule before starting because you'll be binge-reading this book in no time.
Thank you, PENGUIN GROUP Viking | Pamela Dorman Books for digital ARC. I am leaving this review voluntarily.
October 26, 2024
I really enjoyed this book- it was creepy and kept me guessing! The story centers on Charlotte, whose daughter Stella is seen as a difficult child to others, though Charlotte can see no problem. When their babysitter, Blanca, dies, Stella’s personality changes and Charlotte is convinced she is being possessed by Blanka in some way.
I love a story with an unreliable narrator and you get that here, as everyone around Charlotte thinks she is crazy. I went back and forth throughout the book on what was really happening. It was easy to root for her either way due to her fierce loyalty and drive to fight for Stella. There were some great twists in the 2nd half of the book, the biggest which I didn’t see coming at all. There were a couple things that were a bit unrealistic but still fit well with the story and didn’t bother me much. The very end of the book introduces some questions that kept me thinking about it even after I finished reading. I liked the ending overall.
Overall, I really enjoyed this book and thought it was creepy and unique. There were some great surprises and it kept me guessing the whole way through. Would definitely recommend to those who like psychological thrillers. Thanks to Netgalley for providing me with a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
I love a story with an unreliable narrator and you get that here, as everyone around Charlotte thinks she is crazy. I went back and forth throughout the book on what was really happening. It was easy to root for her either way due to her fierce loyalty and drive to fight for Stella. There were some great twists in the 2nd half of the book, the biggest which I didn’t see coming at all. There were a couple things that were a bit unrealistic but still fit well with the story and didn’t bother me much. The very end of the book introduces some questions that kept me thinking about it even after I finished reading. I liked the ending overall.
Overall, I really enjoyed this book and thought it was creepy and unique. There were some great surprises and it kept me guessing the whole way through. Would definitely recommend to those who like psychological thrillers. Thanks to Netgalley for providing me with a copy of this book in exchange for an honest review.
September 7, 2024
✨CLEAR YOUR CALENDARS for January. You will be doing nothing but devouring this absolutely breathtaking page-turner of a book.
✨It’s a heart wrenching look at motherhood in the trenches with a hint of supernatural and is an absolute roller coaster of a thrill ride. Think THE PUSH – on steroids.
✨The author has masterfully written a layered and intriguing story that will keep you guessing and second guessing throughout. I could not put this one down
🌿Read if you like:
✨Mom noir
✨Psychological thrillers
✨Hints of supernatural
✨Stories of neurodivergent children
✨It’s a heart wrenching look at motherhood in the trenches with a hint of supernatural and is an absolute roller coaster of a thrill ride. Think THE PUSH – on steroids.
✨The author has masterfully written a layered and intriguing story that will keep you guessing and second guessing throughout. I could not put this one down
🌿Read if you like:
✨Mom noir
✨Psychological thrillers
✨Hints of supernatural
✨Stories of neurodivergent children
January 29, 2025
Suspenseful novel about a mother's love and family secrets that can destroy. Stella is a very intelligent 8 year old who reads adult books, is interested in science but also has sensory issues and difficulty making friends. Charlotte is Stella's mother and is reluctant to have her labeled but also having difficulties in getting her daughter to fit in at school and the neighborhood. Charlotte's husband Pete feels she is babying Stella and he wants her to do all the things other kids do. Things come to a head when Charlotte becomes pregnant with her second child and Stella's babysitter Blanka abruptly leaves. Stella's personality changes overnight and she begins to act and talk just like Blanka. Is she possessed? What in the world is going on?
Charlotte is a difficult character to like as she makes a lot of mistakes in dealing with Stella's situation and she keeps putting herself and her unborn baby in jeopardy. But something is not right in her household and I really liked the creepy set-up and Blanka's mother Irina who added some common sense and an air of mystery to the story. This also featured one of my biggest fears; getting put in a psych ward against my will. Will Charlotte and Irina help Stella? I enjoyed this novel and found the twists engaging and creepy. Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for a copy of this ARC for review.
Charlotte is a difficult character to like as she makes a lot of mistakes in dealing with Stella's situation and she keeps putting herself and her unborn baby in jeopardy. But something is not right in her household and I really liked the creepy set-up and Blanka's mother Irina who added some common sense and an air of mystery to the story. This also featured one of my biggest fears; getting put in a psych ward against my will. Will Charlotte and Irina help Stella? I enjoyed this novel and found the twists engaging and creepy. Thank you to NetGalley and the publisher for a copy of this ARC for review.
November 11, 2024
This.. this is what a true psychological thriller is 👏🏻
Charlotte’s daughter Stella has a particular way of liking things: she doesn’t eat meat, she doesn’t like the sound of water, she often has melt downs.
After the sudden death of Stella’s babysitter, Blanka, Charlotte notices abrupt changes in Stella’s behavior. All of a sudden, she devours meat stew, she doesn’t mind the sound of water, she seems to be behaving without meltdowns. Charlotte is desperate to find out why her daughter has changed so much, amidst her husband and friends saying she has just grown out of it and also easier to get along with/manage.
This book was so well written! Hats off to the author. There are dual timelines, psych evals, and immense character depth. It reminded me of an Alice Feeney book which is HIGH praise.
Definitely put this one on your radar - pub date 01.14.25
4.5⭐️
Thanks so much to Pamela Dorman Books, NetGalley, and GOODREADS (giveaway) for my e-arc and physical copy!
Charlotte’s daughter Stella has a particular way of liking things: she doesn’t eat meat, she doesn’t like the sound of water, she often has melt downs.
After the sudden death of Stella’s babysitter, Blanka, Charlotte notices abrupt changes in Stella’s behavior. All of a sudden, she devours meat stew, she doesn’t mind the sound of water, she seems to be behaving without meltdowns. Charlotte is desperate to find out why her daughter has changed so much, amidst her husband and friends saying she has just grown out of it and also easier to get along with/manage.
This book was so well written! Hats off to the author. There are dual timelines, psych evals, and immense character depth. It reminded me of an Alice Feeney book which is HIGH praise.
Definitely put this one on your radar - pub date 01.14.25
4.5⭐️
Thanks so much to Pamela Dorman Books, NetGalley, and GOODREADS (giveaway) for my e-arc and physical copy!
January 7, 2025
What did I just read?! It started off feeling reminiscent of The Push by Ashely Audrain, but by 2/3 of the way through it became increasingly unbelievable, and not in a good way. This was weird, disturbing, and kind of ridiculous. Plus, LOTS of content warnings. (A good portion of the last 1/2 made me very uncomfortable, and that doesn't often happen to me with books.)
October 3, 2024
When a book is compared to THE PUSH I truly can’t stay away. As a fan of mommy-noir/psychological suspense I had high expectations going into CLEVER LITTLE THING.
After the death of the family nanny a mother has growing concerns that her neurodivergent daughter has unexpected behavioral changes. What started off as a fantastic premise morphed into an unsettling story that went into a direction that I hoped it wouldn’t go.. I can certainly read dark books, and I also appreciate “weird” books, but it appears that the combination of dark + weird within the same story is too much for me.
Additionally, as a parent of a neurodivergent child the way that the daughter was represented hit me the wrong way. Admittedly, I may be sensitive to characters that present with Autism and how they are portrayed in fiction, but it didn’t work for me here.
I appreciate the opportunity to be an early reader and I hope this story will resonate with others!
RATING: 3/5
PUB DATE: January 14, 2015
Many thanks to Viking and NetGalley for an electronic ARC in exchange for an honest review.
After the death of the family nanny a mother has growing concerns that her neurodivergent daughter has unexpected behavioral changes. What started off as a fantastic premise morphed into an unsettling story that went into a direction that I hoped it wouldn’t go.. I can certainly read dark books, and I also appreciate “weird” books, but it appears that the combination of dark + weird within the same story is too much for me.
Additionally, as a parent of a neurodivergent child the way that the daughter was represented hit me the wrong way. Admittedly, I may be sensitive to characters that present with Autism and how they are portrayed in fiction, but it didn’t work for me here.
I appreciate the opportunity to be an early reader and I hope this story will resonate with others!
RATING: 3/5
PUB DATE: January 14, 2015
Many thanks to Viking and NetGalley for an electronic ARC in exchange for an honest review.
January 23, 2025
ARC provided in exchange for an honest review.
This book definitely had parts that took me by surprise! I love not knowing what’s about to happen, or even better, catching me completely unaware! The book, although fiction, felt very real and relevant to what many people are going through today. Raising children on the spectrum where no two rules apply for the same person makes it difficult for parents. This book explores that and so much more with some sci-fi elements too. I would recommend to anyone who likes domestic thrillers and fiction!
This book definitely had parts that took me by surprise! I love not knowing what’s about to happen, or even better, catching me completely unaware! The book, although fiction, felt very real and relevant to what many people are going through today. Raising children on the spectrum where no two rules apply for the same person makes it difficult for parents. This book explores that and so much more with some sci-fi elements too. I would recommend to anyone who likes domestic thrillers and fiction!
January 10, 2025
4⭐️
Thank you @netgalley and the publisher @vikingbooks for providing the arc in exchange for an honest review.
My thoughts: This psychological thriller is a stunning debut that truly hooked me from the start. I went in blind, knowing very little about the plot, and I had an incredible time experiencing it. The story left a deep emotional impact on me, lingering in my thoughts long after I finished reading. It's a medium-paced read, taking you through the characters’ everyday lives, but with an undercurrent of tension and intrigue that keeps it exciting.
What stood out the most for me was the book's exploration of the complexities of motherhood. It delves into the various stages of becoming a mother, the physical and emotional changes that come with it, and the lengths a parent is willing to go to inorder to protect their child.
More than the plot itself, I found myself deeply connected to the characters. There was one character in particular, who I can't reveal, that I absolutely despised. Towards the end, I felt a surge of anger, and I found myself wishing they would suffer more for their actions. It's not often that I feel so strongly about characters in a thriller, but this one really drew out my emotions.
I highly recommend you don't miss this one.
Thank you @netgalley and the publisher @vikingbooks for providing the arc in exchange for an honest review.
My thoughts: This psychological thriller is a stunning debut that truly hooked me from the start. I went in blind, knowing very little about the plot, and I had an incredible time experiencing it. The story left a deep emotional impact on me, lingering in my thoughts long after I finished reading. It's a medium-paced read, taking you through the characters’ everyday lives, but with an undercurrent of tension and intrigue that keeps it exciting.
What stood out the most for me was the book's exploration of the complexities of motherhood. It delves into the various stages of becoming a mother, the physical and emotional changes that come with it, and the lengths a parent is willing to go to inorder to protect their child.
More than the plot itself, I found myself deeply connected to the characters. There was one character in particular, who I can't reveal, that I absolutely despised. Towards the end, I felt a surge of anger, and I found myself wishing they would suffer more for their actions. It's not often that I feel so strongly about characters in a thriller, but this one really drew out my emotions.
I highly recommend you don't miss this one.
January 23, 2025
4.5 stars
A tense, slow burn psychological thriller that keeps you guessing. Is the mother experiencing postpartum psychosis or is there something supernatural at work. Or, is the little girl more a clever thing than even her mother believes?
I loved the twists and turns in this one, and even at the end I still wasn't 100% clear about all the answers.
A tense, slow burn psychological thriller that keeps you guessing. Is the mother experiencing postpartum psychosis or is there something supernatural at work. Or, is the little girl more a clever thing than even her mother believes?
I loved the twists and turns in this one, and even at the end I still wasn't 100% clear about all the answers.
October 30, 2024
I loved the beautiful things Helena Echlin did with Clever Little Thing, even though I didn’t love everything about the story itself. It was the character growth that really impressed me. From start to finish, Charlotte undergoes a massive transformation in her emotional awareness. Her narration quickly reveals her privileged voice, as well as her stifled emotions. She relies on her self-imposed rules of etiquette, which sound wise in theory, but lead to poor boundaries in practice. She cares very little for those who aren’t part of her tax bracket, and she views her child’s babysitter mechanically, rather than seeing her as a person. She loves her daughter dearly, and appreciates all of the qualities that make her unique as a child, but she refuses to acknowledge vital truths regarding her child’s behavior. She looks back on her own childhood with sadness, continually questioning and judging her mother’s behavior. And she possesses an overwhelmingly evident bias toward foreign customs, despite a somewhat performative drive at comprehension. The author managed to take all of these characteristics and work through them as the story unfolds, allowing Charlotte to become a better version of herself by the end of the novel.
Clever Little Thing embraces the popular evil child trope, although Stella isn’t quite Damian, despite the possibility of possession. Her changing behavior after her babysitter’s death is cause for concern, although no one but Charlotte seems to be taking this seriously. This was another aspect Echlin did well. Even though we know, as readers, that Charlotte might not be a completely reliable narrator, we also recognize that she isn’t losing her mind. The way other characters cast doubt upon her observations, and explain away Stella’s behavior, is extremely frustrating. It mirrors real life so well that it succeeds in causing distress.
While Clever Little Thing had its unique components, I wouldn’t say its path was decidedly different from other stories using this trope. The narrative was always interesting to me, though. The more Stella’s behavior looked like that of Bianca, her deceased babysitter, the more my curiosity grew.
The twist certainly helped eradicate an implication that had made me uncomfortable throughout the book. I’m glad I leaned into trusting the author with it. Although it wasn’t something I automatically assumed, I felt like the story crumbled a bit after it was revealed. I also need to warn that it could be extremely triggering for some readers. I cannot say how without spoiling things. Even though my basic rule of thumb when picking up a thriller or a horror novel is to expect potentially triggering content, this reveal still caught me off guard, and while other aspects of the book’s content might also prove difficult for some readers, this particular piece may be even more jarring because of how it is illustrated.
I was, overall, satisfied with the final resolve, although what was suggested within the last few sentences irritated me. I think all that Echlin accomplished before that worked well enough, and there was no good reason for this highly implausible addition.
3.5 stars
I am immensely grateful to Pamela Dorman Books and NetGalley for my copy. All opinions are my own.
Clever Little Thing embraces the popular evil child trope, although Stella isn’t quite Damian, despite the possibility of possession. Her changing behavior after her babysitter’s death is cause for concern, although no one but Charlotte seems to be taking this seriously. This was another aspect Echlin did well. Even though we know, as readers, that Charlotte might not be a completely reliable narrator, we also recognize that she isn’t losing her mind. The way other characters cast doubt upon her observations, and explain away Stella’s behavior, is extremely frustrating. It mirrors real life so well that it succeeds in causing distress.
While Clever Little Thing had its unique components, I wouldn’t say its path was decidedly different from other stories using this trope. The narrative was always interesting to me, though. The more Stella’s behavior looked like that of Bianca, her deceased babysitter, the more my curiosity grew.
The twist certainly helped eradicate an implication that had made me uncomfortable throughout the book. I’m glad I leaned into trusting the author with it. Although it wasn’t something I automatically assumed, I felt like the story crumbled a bit after it was revealed. I also need to warn that it could be extremely triggering for some readers. I cannot say how without spoiling things. Even though my basic rule of thumb when picking up a thriller or a horror novel is to expect potentially triggering content, this reveal still caught me off guard, and while other aspects of the book’s content might also prove difficult for some readers, this particular piece may be even more jarring because of how it is illustrated.
I was, overall, satisfied with the final resolve, although what was suggested within the last few sentences irritated me. I think all that Echlin accomplished before that worked well enough, and there was no good reason for this highly implausible addition.
3.5 stars
I am immensely grateful to Pamela Dorman Books and NetGalley for my copy. All opinions are my own.
December 27, 2024
This is a “creepy kid” book that definitely sounded so intriguing. It was a slow burn for me but I still was able to enjoy the suspense of the plot. Charlotte is the mother of 8 year old Stella and is expecting her next child. Stella has behavioral issues but yet seems so smart. Charlotte has a hard time dealing with these problems. After the death of Stella's nanny, Blanka, she begins to act in control and more well behaved, almost taking on the familiar traits of Blanka. Charlotte is baffled at what is going on with her daughter. This one started out strong for me but then fell flat throughout the rest of it. I would still check out this author in the future.
Thank you to the publisher and netgalley for the gifted copy in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.
Thank you to the publisher and netgalley for the gifted copy in exchange for an honest review. All opinions are my own.
September 18, 2024
If you love books like “The Push” and “Baby teeth” this one’s for you!! When Charlottes daughter changes drastically overnight after her longtime babysitter quits, Charlotte cannot accept that all these changes are for the good of her daughter. What has happened to Stella and is Charlotte going crazy?
This book was definitely a page turner for me. You never quite know what’s going on but it’s so intriguing that you keep relentlessly turning the pages. This book will make you question everything until the very last page!
This book was definitely a page turner for me. You never quite know what’s going on but it’s so intriguing that you keep relentlessly turning the pages. This book will make you question everything until the very last page!
October 27, 2024
This was just weird and not in a fun enough way for me to be able to suspend disbelief for its entirety. I think I’m just tired of mommy thrillers that use pregnancy-related depression as a plot device.
December 27, 2024
Helena Echlin’s debut psychological thriller Clever Little Thing is a total mind-trip of a book. It’s reminiscent of Baby Teeth and The Push in some of its general plot points, but it kept me unsettled the entire time because I never knew what was going to happen next.
I don’t want to summarize too much of the plot – and I beg you to avoid the blurb from the publisher! – because it’s best to go into this one blind, but here are a few basics: Charlotte and Pete are happily married with a precocious daughter named Stella and a baby on the way. Stella is a brilliant but challenging child, prone to bouts of aggression and violence when she gets upset. But when Stella’s babysitter Blanka suddenly dies, Stella’s personality begins to change…
And that’s all I’ll say about the plot, but trust me when I tell you that Clever Little Thing surprised me at every turn. It’s so refreshing to read a psychological thriller that really lives up to both words in the genre: This book is written with the frenetic, propulsive pace of a thriller, but it also really wormed its way into some dark recess of my brain that made me feel so uneasy and so genuinely concerned for the characters. The use of first-person POV works so well for this story, immersing readers in Charlotte’s state of mind: her spiraling thoughts and fears and desperation. Third trimester pregnancy and early motherhood are such fraught, stressful, overwhelming times for women already, so placing the events of this story around that period of Charlotte’s life added another level of emotional complexity.
There’s also thoughtful commentary about neurodivergence and the importance of parental advocacy, the immigrant experience, gaslighting, and complicated family dynamics, all integrated into an original, suspenseful examination of motherhood and relationships. Clever Little Thing is such an impressive debut, and I can’t wait to see what’s next for Helen Echlin. Thank you to Pamela Dorman Books for the early reading opportunity.
I don’t want to summarize too much of the plot – and I beg you to avoid the blurb from the publisher! – because it’s best to go into this one blind, but here are a few basics: Charlotte and Pete are happily married with a precocious daughter named Stella and a baby on the way. Stella is a brilliant but challenging child, prone to bouts of aggression and violence when she gets upset. But when Stella’s babysitter Blanka suddenly dies, Stella’s personality begins to change…
And that’s all I’ll say about the plot, but trust me when I tell you that Clever Little Thing surprised me at every turn. It’s so refreshing to read a psychological thriller that really lives up to both words in the genre: This book is written with the frenetic, propulsive pace of a thriller, but it also really wormed its way into some dark recess of my brain that made me feel so uneasy and so genuinely concerned for the characters. The use of first-person POV works so well for this story, immersing readers in Charlotte’s state of mind: her spiraling thoughts and fears and desperation. Third trimester pregnancy and early motherhood are such fraught, stressful, overwhelming times for women already, so placing the events of this story around that period of Charlotte’s life added another level of emotional complexity.
There’s also thoughtful commentary about neurodivergence and the importance of parental advocacy, the immigrant experience, gaslighting, and complicated family dynamics, all integrated into an original, suspenseful examination of motherhood and relationships. Clever Little Thing is such an impressive debut, and I can’t wait to see what’s next for Helen Echlin. Thank you to Pamela Dorman Books for the early reading opportunity.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 813 reviews