Jake Rogers’ Planet is a fast-paced adventure that takes aspects of Hatchet, The Martian, A Boy and His Dog at the End of the World, and even Minecraft, and creates something refreshing and original. Jake’s story is brimming with danger and discoveries, friendship and faith. It’s the faith content that really serves as the backbone of Jake’s story. He wrestles with God throughout the story and, when God ultimately wins, so does Jake. It’s in surrender that Jake finds his true path to freedom.
This is a great book for young men, especially those between ten and fifteen or so. I, as a thirty-six year old woman, am obviously not the target audience. Which means that the critiques I offer here should be taken with that in mind.
First, let me mention the things that worked for me. My favorite element of this novel is the setting. When Jake falls through a portal to another planet, he finds himself in a world unlike any he’s ever experienced or even imagined. I was captivated by the wholly unique flora and fauna and landscape of this setting. I especially loved all of the wonderful creatures with which Wilder populated this new planet. Which brings me to my favorite character in the story: Jip. Jip is something of a rabbit/flying squirrel with ram’s horns, and he was a delightful animal companion.
There was rarely a dull moment in this story. It was action-packed and fast-paced. I love that there were frequent references to Hatchet, which is one of my favorite books from my childhood. And I especially enjoyed the themes and faith elements. Some big questions are asked in this book. How much do we limit ourselves out of fear of failure, discomfort, or disappointing others? When trying to chart our own course, do we seek to do so at the expense of God’s plan for us? There was a lot of discussion of comparison, of familial disappointments, and of learning to trust God and rely on Him when we would much rather take matters into our own hands. I also really liked a few of Jake’s prayers. They felt sincere and believable.
And now, for some of the things that didn’t really work for me. The most prominent issue I had was with the writing itself. Wilder’s style was a bit stiff and juvenile for my taste. But as the book’s target audience skews younger, this is forgivable. It’s marketed as YA, but I think it would land strongest with older middle grade readers. This is in large part due to my other issue main issue with the story: Jake himself. We’re told that Jake is eighteen, but he reads as being far younger than that in my opinion. He’s initially a very whiny character, one whose motivations or lack thereof I didn’t find very believable. But he grows! By the end of the book, he felt more his age. As this type of growth was a large part of why the story mattered, this is also forgivable. But I have to say that it initially impeded my enjoyment of the book a good deal.
I’m not a video game person, and there were a lot of video game references. Jake coped with his situation by even seeing it as a video game at first. But will this land stronger with the target audience? Absolutely. And finally, I found the themes and faith elements to be a bit heavy-handed in their delivery. There was no subtlety or artistry to them. But again, I think that will work well for the target audience.
While Jake Rogers’ Planet might not be a new favorite for me, I have the utmost respect for it. I backed this book on Kickstarter, and I am so excited to see Wilder find his audience with this story. If I had a young boy in my life into whose hands I could press this book, I would do so in a heartbeat. And Jip will live on in my imagination as one of the most adorable animal companions I’ve ever had the pleasure of encountering!