Sugar Ray Robinson was if not the most, than certainly one of the most recognizable celebrities of the 1940s and 1950s. In an era where sports represented one of the few avenues where black men were allowed to succeed on anything like an equal level with their white counterparts, Robinson with his natural boxing talent, flamboyant charm, and gift for cultivating attention stood out.
Unfortunately, this book never really digs particularly deeply into Robinson the man.
There are brief synopses of major fights, some character sketches, and some allusions to issues with women and poor business dealings but on the whole we don’t learn much about Robinson or his era.
This is partly due to the author perhaps stretching himself too thin into attempting to chronicle Robinson’s life in the context of celebrity culture in America. It’s an ambitious and fascinating idea but the length of the book never really allows for any in depth treatment of either.
There are interspersed with Robinson’s life, diversions into the lives of Tiger Woods, Michael Jordan, Allen Iverson, Kobe Bryant, O.J. Simpson, Jack Johnson and other minor and major celebrities. All interesting people to be sure but one wonders who or what this book really wants to say.
As a side note, the author does spend a good amount of time comparing Robinson and Jack Johnson. Johnson of course was the first true black American sports celebrity that for good or bad, paved the way for Robinson and others after him.
Perhaps my admiration of Johnson colored my impression of how the author depicts Johnson here but it seems that he views him in a negative light. There are frequent references to Johnson’s brashness and unwillingness to compromise himself for the sake of black or white fans.
The author seems to view this a negative in that he often cites how Robinson was successful with white fans (despite being like Johnson in his flamboyance) because he learned to not be as in your face as Johnson was.
In the next breath however he mentions how Robinson was also uncompromising and not at all like Joe Louis who was deferential to whites throughout most of his career.
Which was he? Compromising? Uncompromising? Perhaps the answer is more complex than this simple binary choice but I was admittedly irked by his using Johnson as an example of how a black athlete should not act.
There are some interesting things here about Robinson and while the book clearly needs some editing and more coherence, it is still a worthwhile read about someone who seemed to be a very interesting man.