⭐️ between a 2.75 & 3 / 5 — Sweet, but not quite my flavour 🍬
⚠️ Spoilers ahead! ⚠️
I wanted to like this more than I did. It’s not a bad book — in fact, it has a solid foundation and some genuinely lovely characters — but it just didn’t click for me the way I hoped. The pacing was a little chaotic, the cast was massive, and while there were moments that made me swoon, I never fully fell in love.
📖 Quick recap:
Lexie has spent her life fighting a chronic illness that’s always left her one step away from tragedy. She’s the baby sister in a loud, fiercely loyal family (whose brothers are the definition of overprotective), and she’s spent years preparing for the worst — writing letters to her family, making peace with what she can’t control.
Then there’s Lucky — short for Luciano Beneventi — the family’s lifelong friend and her brothers’ best mate. He’s a football star with a reputation for screwing things up and a deep belief that he’ll only hurt the people he loves. He’s loved Lexie quietly for years but has kept his distance because, well, guilt and self-doubt are kind of his brand.
When the book opens, we’re dropped right into a world that feels lived-in — very lived-in. There are dozens of names and family ties thrown at you in the first few chapters (if you haven’t read Bella Matthews’ other books, it can feel like crashing someone else’s family reunion 🫠). I definitely fall into that category — and genuinely felt like I was missing sooo much backstory and connection between all these characters.
The story kicks off when Lexie finally decides she’s done waiting around for her life to happen — she’s ready to actually live. Lucky, meanwhile, is doing everything he can to resist her, because the stakes are just too high. But of course… resistance is futile.
Lochlan, Lexie’s brother, sees right through him:
“That look right there. That look says you’re lying… It’s the same one you had yesterday whenever you looked at my sister… You might not actually be lying to me, but that’s because you’re definitely dumb enough to be lying to yourself.”
And from there, Lucky’s downfall is immediate 😂. Their connection builds fast — too fast, maybe — but their chemistry is undeniable. Lucky’s the classic tough guy who turns into absolute mush around her:
“Thank you,” she whispers. “You might have a little hero in you after all.”
“Don’t tell anyone, okay?”
“Promise.”
Sir… please. The way he’s a total marshmallow for her had me clutching my chest 🥹.
Then there’s this moment — one of my favourites — when it becomes clear Lucky’s always seen Lexie. He knows her in a way no one else does, all quiet observation and deep understanding:
“Yeah, asshole, you passed. Now go get my sister and treat her like the princess she deserves to be. I'll see you guys back at the house later.”
“That's where he's wrong. Lexie's not a princess. She's the fucking warrior.”
That line hit me right in the feels. It’s not just a declaration — it’s proof that Lucky’s been paying attention all along, admiring her strength even before she saw it in herself.
The second half amps up the pace (somehow even more) — health scares, near-death moments, grand gestures — and before you know it, we’ve gone from “just tonight” to full-on marriage territory by page 274 😅. It’s fast, it’s emotional, it’s… a lot.
💭 My take:
The heart of this story — Lexie finally choosing life, and Lucky learning he’s worthy of love — is beautiful. But the pacing is uneven, the character count overwhelming, and at times it felt like I missed whole chapters of their emotional build-up.
What to expect:
• Childhood-friends-to-lovers 💞
• Chronic-illness rep handled with care
• Big chaotic family energy (prepare to take notes)
• A hero who’s soft for her and a heroine who’s tougher than she looks 🫶
• Some truly heart-melting quotes and tender moments
• Pacing that might make you feel a little dizzy
Final thoughts:
Sweet Temptation has plenty of heart, and I did smile more than once — Lucky and Lexie’s tenderness is hard not to love. But between the rush, the crowd, and the insta-romance vibes, it just didn’t fully land for me. Still, it’s warm, emotional, and exactly what it says on the tin: a sweet temptation. 💖