Ok, people of the internet - what exactly about this was slow?? Briar sees Noaz. He gives them a compliment. They go on a date - which, might I just stress, happens off-page. They are dating! They are getting married! We're still at page 80 or something. They are SPOILER getting a baby! This wasn't just insta-romance, this was insta-old-married couple.
I talked about the ways Reitan can really hit all the right elements/tropes to make a book really make me enjoy it. I do believe that. But the opposite is true as well - the story, the tropes, the characters (main ones, the rest still has potential) were not to my taste - I didn't click with basically any aspect of the story and while I did "finish it", I skipped so much fluff I am just going with DNF.
Why? Oh, let me count the reasons...
A romance book with no romance - I didn't feel their chemistry and that insta-lust Loren used wasn't working because of Noaz and her/their/his gender spiel. The first date was skipped. They just... suddenly dated. Super seriously.
I've seen Briar described as bland (because I wanted to know why everyone else was praising the book and read some reviews) and honestly, I get what you mean. It feels like Noaz is the star of the show and what happens here is just his wish-fullfilment fantasy. Briar is only the perfect husband, giving him his own personality is not necessary. His icon is boxing gloves and it plays exactly 1% part in the whole book. He has nothing defining while Noaz has nothing but intense, character defining moments. His work, his gender identity, his love for his family... I am actually running out of characteristics, actually.
Noaz is a lot but mostly, he's his gender. Because he just won't stop talking about it. How people are mean and closed-minded. Repeating how he relates to his gender and to gender as a concept and how Briar should react... it's Adak all over again. Noaz has Trauma and so Briar is guilty until proven innocent and he sure makes sure to be overcompensating-ly innocent - he says all the right words, does all the right things that you would normally need mind-reading to accomplish. Because this book is called Noaz because it is very much about him. (I was super happy with Confessions, because both MC's had their own lives and you didn't feel like they stopped living it when they met. This is the opposite.)
Other than feeling preached to, I will say I prefer show than constantly telling. Do you know Murderbot chronicles? I don't know why I keep referencing this series but this is another area it really shines - sexuality and gender in that universe is much more diverse than Noaz is and he sure talks about his differences a lot. In Murderbot (who is also neither gender, FYI) these things are just... there. They exist, no one cares, no one makes a big deal about it... In gay romance, you usually see it with homophobia. Some books focus on that negative aspect (probably because they see it around) while other books just have characters live their life and no one comes in any way on their sexuality because there's nothing to comment on, it's so normal it doesn't bear mentioning/disecting. Well, personally, I really like that - showing how you want the world to behave instead of bashing my head against all the ways humanity is lacking. Okay, rant over.
Van Doren is supposed to be this super-rich, super scary and not entirely legal enterprise. That's the draw of this series. So why not just gloss over it in Noaz? Or wait until the very last part of the book when the reader is falling asleep to spring some unexpected action! When it's too late to save the book!
I was already feeling disinterested with their whirlwind, emotionally kinda flat romance and with how Noaz insisted on testing Briar but than they got - spoiler - a baby and I was really gone. It's nothing against the book, to be fair, but there are stuff I don't experience but can still relate to - getting a baby and by getting a baby I mean talking about it and buying furniture and stuff and talking baby names? NO. I have seen good kid representation (and hey, I count Confessions, Reitan's book, to be one of them so she is capable of it) but this was the worst baby-fever and I am not here for it.
You know what? I think I complained enough. Let's just say Noaz was not my cup of beverage and hope Imry is going to go back to Loren's awesome-sauce-ness.