A fun volume of Medalist that humanizes Hikaru, Inori’s rival, as swiftly as it demonizes her. Implying, accurately, that people are often a lot more complicated than we initially think them to be.
The focus on Hikaru turns out to be an interesting take on things, plus it glosses over some of Inori’s story to get the two of them back to throwing down on the ice pretty swiftly. It’s a narrative shakeup that really works.
If there’s one thing that I don’t think makes much of a dent, it’s Rioh’s sudden love for Hikaru, which is as open here as it was not really mentioned previously. Technically, it’s because she’s moving to a new club, but it felt a bit forced and awkward (I’m also at the ‘jaded at eternal love when you’re not even 14’ stage of my life).
Hikaru’s mask slips all over the place this time out. She’s mouthy, overconfident, more than a little full of herself, and beyond driven to beat Inori, who Hikaru sees as the real heir to the legacy of her coach, Jun. The way to prove herself better than Jun goes right through Inori.
I’ve said before - I love this idea that Inori could be taking the road that the grim Jun took and Hikaru’s feeling far more akin to Tsubasa. It’s not quite there in their skating yet, but she’s clearly convinced herself of this at the very least.
The next competition is not only crazy important, but full of surprises. There are some big moments from characters you might not have expected and some real shocks. You’re only perfect at something until you’re not, and given what was on the line, is it possible that nerves finally played a part?
Part of me thinks that having a rival that remains an impossible machine of perfection is a great hook, but there’s a lot more to be mined from where things sit at the end of this volume. It’s also a reminder that this is a sport that can be brutally unforgiving in myriad ways.
The drama of Medalist remains spot on. There have been some moments where I think these kids are a little more mature than their ages suggest, to the point of incredulity, but mostly it’s been a heck of a ride.
This volume really drills down on Hikaru’s journey and totally changes things up. It was a great way to move things forward and I can genuinely say that I’m not sure exactly where it’s going, but I can’t wait to find out.
Oh, there’s also an extended omake section that doesn’t amount to much.
4.5 stars - love confession and omake aside, this was another fantastic instalment. It’s one of my favourite competition manga and almost certainly my favourite sporting one.
This was the rare volume where it mainly focused on Hikaru and I missed following the story of the heroine, Inori and her coach Tsukasa. I'd rather not have Hikaru be the second heroine.
One thing I find unfitting is how the author chooses to portray 11 year old Hikaru. She acts like she is 16-18 years old from the get-go, is presented as way too mature to be 11 and I don't agree with how her age is portrayed.
Yes, she's an amazing skater and athlete, however no 11 year olds act like that! So far she's been condescending, fake, rude, self-centered, has a "pick me" attitude and is not likeable. Even though there is a lot of backstory for her character, I'm not feeling the rival storyline or her relationships.
Also I find Jun Yodaka to be a fictional version of Yuzuru Hanyu, only for Jun to be 200% the intensity of Yuzu. It's WAY too dramatic and uncalled for on how the author portrays Jun as a coach and past competitor to Tsukasa. Why is he SO mean and critical to literal children who are trying their best? Each chapter he's acting like the arrogant evil villain who criticizes others and is overly proud of his own achievements. He's an insufferable character.
Inori, on the other hand, is a GREAT heroine and her characterization is the reason why this series has been so successful and popular! She definitely acts her age. She's determined, never gives up, hard-working, happy-go-lucky, lovable and adorable! I'd rather the series focus on her primarily instead of her rivals. Her respect and love for her coach Tsukasa is honorable and the highlight of the series.
On a concluding note to this review, another unrealistic theme is just how much these young athletes strive to be number 1 and want to win each competition. In figure skating, you really don't need to win in order to achieve your goals. Each skater is on their own artistic and athletic journey, this means that not necessarily winning means everything. The series is SO focused on winning that I don't want it to become a toxic/unrealistic example to real life figure skaters who are reading this manga and pursuing this sport.
4.5 stars Wieder ein richtig spannender Band. Fand es erfrischend, dass dieser Band sich sehr auf Hikaru fokussiert hat, da wir sie bisher noch nicht gut kennenlernen konnten. Dadurch haben wir zwar Inoris zweiten Auftritt bei der JGP-Reihe verpasst, jedoch treffen die beiden nun endlich bei einem Wettkampf direkt aufeinander. Es scheint, dass Hikaru auch nicht immer ganz mit Jun Odaka übereinstimmt - zB was Inori angeht - trotzdem frage ich mich, was theoretisch passieren würde, wenn Hikaru nicht gewinnt und somit ihre Vereinbarung nicht hält. Gleichzeitig empfinde ich den Druck, den Odaka auf Hikaru mit sowas ausübt alles andere als pädagogisch wertvoll, weshalb ich erst recht froh bin, dass sie die Sonidoris hat. Inori scheint sich auch weiterentwickelt zu haben und ich bin sehr auf ihren Auftritt gespannt, erst recht weil diese Meisterschaft ja bereits zwei große Überraschungen der unschönen Art mit sich gebracht hat. Einfach eine tolle Reihe!!
4⭐️ Cry! My queen has fallen in her important competition.
……
The thought of Hikaru changed. But she still chase his back. Who is the most similar to him? — If I’d stayed in Nagoya, I would have gone on thinking all I was good for was hurting people. I’ve only learned how precious my time was now that I’ve lost it. That coach talks about sacrifice like it’s always a bad thing, but I want to learn why Jun Yodaka is so obsessed with it. — Like my last name suggests, I will become a nightly “wolf”, one who won’t lose to a predetermined fate. But I won’t be a light that casts dark shadows around it. No, I will become the light of hope. — A girl who can only live on the ice. One who utters the exact same words as Jun Uodaka - words I could never come up with. I don’t want to prove I am at the top. What I want is to take the gold from this mini Jun Yodaka.
This volume of Medalist focuses on Hikaru and her move to Starfox FSC, taking a short break away from Inori. I think this has been long time coming, and it's interesting to see more of Hikaru's home life, motivations, and struggles.
I loved this volume for how it fleshes out Hikaru's character, especially because she chose to move clubs, when Inori chose not to. It also builds up the very stressful All-Japan Junior Championships, and I can't wait to see how it fully plays out!
We get a heavy focus on Hikaru in this one and it is a nice change of pace and provides some more insight into her life and thoughts. Then poor Iruka. I really like the bonds she is forming with Inori. I have a feeling that things are going to get gloomy for a bit but I am still fully on board.