I rather enjoyed reading through this book. Aging is certainly not the topic that I think most people want to even think about, much less read a bunch of commentary on studies, theories, and what-not about, yet I'm certainly curious about it myself. It likely comes back to idea that we fear what we don't understand, and while I would not say I understand aging after reading this book, I do feel like I have a little more understanding of what we do and don't know about it. The way in which the author takes us through studies that have been done, and analyzed them from a scientific perspective... where they were not able to be duplicated, where they were, which ones suffer from which deficiencies in terms of structure, mechanisms, an analysis of the actual difficulties in constructing good studies, which ones were able to add to the collective knowledge, even if it wasn't necessarily a lot. It definitely felt like a critical text, and I certainly appreciate that.
However, I will also say that having gotten to the end of the book, and appreciated it, I then found this: 'Successful tampering with the processes of biological fitness and adaptation is probably beyond our ability to master, although some of our present actions are certainly having a negative influence on the fitness and adaptation of humans.' The rest of that paragraph echoes some of my own beliefs about the, 'effect of our actions is to undermine the fundamental process of evolution in which only the fittest survive.' Such an agreement with a belief of my own certainly should cause me to wonder if my own objectivity is to be questioned here.
Then also there was this line: 'Unless human overpopulation is controlled soon, the planet will suffer irreversible degradation and humanity will experience a continued increase in poverty, starvation, and virtually all of the other ills that presently concern us.' Again, I cannot agree with this enough.
Which is only to say, that I could be a biased reviewer, as I seem to share some fundamental beliefs that agree so strongly with the authors stated opinions.