This used to be that time of year when Lee Child would publish his annual outing with one of my favorite fictional heroes, Jack Reacher. Those days are gone and the transition from big brother to younger brother has completed with Andrew now fully in control of the Reacher novels while Lee focuses his attention on the popular Amazon Reacher streaming series.
With Andrew responsible for the novels, some things have remained the same while other things have changed. Andrew is definitely not Lee (in fairness, nor should he be), and his changes haven’t always been subtle to the millions of Reacher fans. In my personal opinion, it’s taken Andrew several books to develop his own rhythm with the character and his behaviors. The result is that Andrew’s version of Reacher is not necessarily Lee’s Reacher. As a reader, you can choose to like that or not. It’s just the reality of the situation. Just like the authors who continued popular series by Tom Clancy, Robert B. Parker, Vince Flynn, and Stieg Larsson, there are always tradeoffs involved and it’s is no different with Reacher.
This year, Andrew has delivered his sixth Reacher novel - “Exit Strategy”, which continues much of the same approach, style, and plotting as his previous two to three Reacher adventures. For me personally, there continues to be some more incremental improvement with each one of his outings. Reacher’s intelligence from earlier books has returned, as well as his sarcastic banter. In addition, Andrew’s plotting has gotten stronger and more complex, providing a better overall story. That isn’t to say that there aren’t some trade-offs in style and a few problems that I continue to struggle with, but I will save that for later.
“Exit Strategy” starts off with Reacher stepping a coffee shop in Baltimore. He just wants some a coffee and some refills before moving on. However, it wouldn’t be Reacher if he didn’t witness an interesting interaction that bothers him and by the time he leaves, he becomes involved in two separate instigating events that propel the novel forward.
One outcome finds Reacher on the wrong side of a local gangster by disrupting his ongoing scam operations that involve ripping off seniors. Word is sent out on the streets to find Reacher so those better skilled can come take care of him.
The other outcome and even more important involves a note that a stranger was somehow able to slip into Reacher’s pocket. That takes a rare skill and has Reacher’s attention. Even more so are the words in the note, which plead with him for help because the writer’s life is in serious danger, and sets a time and place for them to meet. The last word written in shaky letters really peaks Reacher’s interest – “please.
When Reacher meets up with the note’s owner, it kicks off a mystery that our hero cannot help trying to solve, especially when he feels justice needs to be done. Before he knows it, Reacher will find himself chasing down a conspiracy that involves illegal shipping and transportation, compromised political alliances, and military sponsored actions that could lead to unforgiveable international chaos...
Just another day in the life for Reacher…
Like the last three books, this was an easy and fast read. In some ways too fast. Most of that is because this book is only 304 pages in length (and larger font size to hit that mark). I’ve noticed that Andrew’s novels are definitely shorter in length, his writing style more focused with shorter sentences and fewer words, and less time spent on transition moments and scene descriptions.
For me, the plotting and pacing were good, most of the time. Andrew captures much of the same plot development style and flow as his brother, Lee. Andrew’s plots have become more complex and intricate over the last three books. He ties thing together well, peeling the onion in layers, and every time you think that you have things figured out, he’s usually one or two steps ahead of you.
However, at the same time, I still feel that Andrew comes across as a bit too clinical and mechanical in instances throughout the novel, making Reacher feel like a caricature of himself. In some ways, there are chapters that read like a detailed outline – what needs to happen – rather than a fleshed out immersive scene, activity, or chapter. I appreciate that Andrew walks us through each of Reacher’s fights and has him talking more, but some of the action sequences come across so clinical that it takes any sense of emotion.
And let’s be honest, with Andre’s books, I never get the sense that Reacher is truly in danger or going to get hurt. I don’t fell like he’s truly tested or challenged much, no matter what the opposition is. I don’t think there’s ever been a moment in his six Reacher novels that I ever felt Reacher was at risk. He’s turned into a version of Superman that makes me feel like he’s too invincible, and that’s contributed to him losing his edge a bit for me.
This is why it’s important to realize that Andrew writes Reacher differently than Lee. That is reality and it isn’t going to change anytime soon. Andrew’s Reacher is focused more on his physical skills and instinctual strengths. I especially appreciated in this book how Reacher used his analytical skills more, which reminded me more of Lee Child’s writing, and I really enjoyed the “smart” Reacher working through the clues and figuring things out before the other characters did.
Another component of this one is that it feels like Andrew favors smart bad guys rather than imposing bad guys. There’s nothing wrong with that, except in this case once it comes down to the final confrontation, it felt a little weak and took away from the adversary being as compelling and strong as I would have preferred. It wasn’t a bad ending, but the bad guy turned out to be rather whiny and weak when it mattered most. Mechanically Andrew got all of the pieces connected, but emotionally, it still felt a little bit lacking when it came to experiencing a strong payoff.
That being said, we, I continue to come to terms with my understanding that Andrew is not Lee and cannot be Lee. He is his own writer. I fully understand that some Reacher fans will learn to enjoy Andrew’s version of Reacher and others will never be satisfied with Andrew, choosing rather to pick it apart. Although it probably doesn’t feel that way after reading my review, I am probably somewhere in the middle. Lee was certainly burnt out on writing Reacher. That was clear in his later interviews, so it was time to move on.
For me, the bigger problem that we face with Reacher is different. It’s not so much a change from Lee to Andrew as authors, as much as it is the aging and saturation of Reacher. “Exit Strategy” is the 30th Reacher novel. Let me repeat that. The 30th Reacher novel. That’s a lot of books, folks, covering a lot of adventures, storylines, plot twists, mysteries to resolve, and bad guys to defeat. My problem is really less about Andrew’s style and more about trying to keep Reacher fresh, finding worthy adversaries, and conflict that challenges him both physically and mentally. That’s a lot harder to do when you’re writing book number 30. Lee Child himself decided he was done after 24 books because he quite honestly ran out of ideas. When readers complain the series has lost something, I tend to think the truth actually lies less with Andrew and more with the fact that having 30 books published makes it awful hard to maintain momentum and quality.
If that is the case, in addition to taking over a well-loved literary character, the task of coming up with new ideas becomes a tougher task than an easier one for Andrew. To me, that is the real challenge. Keeping Reacher fresh and exciting while not deviating too far from his well-established mythos is a really hard thing to do. It is the same problems that writers face when carrying on the works of authors who have passed away, like Spenser, Jack Ryan, Mitch Rapp, and Lisbeth Salander. Talk about an impossible challenge.
The reality is there’s already a lot of Reacher novels and stories. The good news is that Andrew has been there with Lee since day one of the creation and birth of Reacher. If anyone has a chance of keeping Reacher relevant and worth reading, he’s our best chance. For me, I am going to appreciate the ride as long as I can, because like Reacher, I am aging too. I’m in my 60’s now and reflection has become a bigger part of my life. My thought is, let’s enjoy it while we can.
For me, “Exit Strategy” was a steady 3-star read for me and we’ll see what the future brings with a sense of skeptical optimism.