I've read several of the Intrigue 3-in-1 books, and I usually find them pretty enjoyable.
Epiphany follows the lives and jobs of three Atlanta cops in the week before Christmas. In An Angel for Christmas, Angelica North's sister Gina is murdered and her young nephew, Stevie, witnesses the killing. Angelica and Stevie are put under the watchful eye of Max Malone, Angelica's ex-lover and an Atlanta PD detective, who needs to make sure that the man who murdered Gina doesn't come after the child who can identify him.
In Undercover Santa, a gang of jewel thieves are robbing high-end jewellery stores and killing the store owners. Rebecca Saxon's jewellery store is considered to be one of the most at risk, so Detective Trey Murphy is sent to guard it, and her. As the robbers have been breaking into the owners' homes as well as shops, Trey has to move in with Rebecca until the thieves / killers are caught.
In Merry's Christmas, Merry Randolph has survived a murder attempt by the killer who is (erroneously) called the Widow Maker. (In actuality, he preys on widows.) She's the only victim to survive, so Det Trevor Adkins is sent to guard her. This is hard for him, because Merry's pregnant and Trevor lost his unborn baby several Christmases ago, but he's determined not to lose Merry or her baby.
This was definitely a readable book, even enjoyable, but not anywhere near spectacular. Short stories are hard to write, particularly romances. It's very, very hard to get enough genuine emotion without making it seem like the characters fell in love without knowing anything about each other. Even for someone like me who believes in (and has experienced) love at first meeting, it's difficult to buy that people can fall in love - that lasting kind of love - in ninety pages. In addition, with such a short space allowed, it's difficult to create characters with enough depth for readers to feel for them, let alone any real kind of plot.
I was a little disappointed that there wasn't really any overarching story here. Most of the previous Intrigue 3-in-1's that I've read - Gypsy Magic, Boys in Blue and Desert Sons, all by Rebecca York, Ann Voss Peterson and Patricia Rosemoor - have each been one story in three parts, each part focusing on a different couple. Those overarching storylines have both held the books together, and solved the problem of trying to fit an entire mystery into ninety pages, so more time can be spent on developing the characters. Epiphany instead chose to attempt to keep the stories separate, without any crossover of characters or crimes, and subsequently three separate mysteries to be solved. This has been achieved with limited success - the characters are pleasant, but undeveloped, and the mysteries feel a little flat and lacking in closure. In Undercover Santa, in particular, I had questions that weren't answered - how did the robbers know the security code for Rebecca's house? And did Chief Wells have anything to do with any of the crimes?
That all said, I did quite enjoy reading these stories. They were light, forgettable fluff. I know I've read the book at least once before, but I didn't remember it at all. Most likely, I'll pick it up again in a couple years, not remember it, and enjoy reading it again. 3 stars.