Belladonna by Adalyn Grace meets A Study in Drowning in this sizzling gothic romantasy that follows the forbidden romance between a young nurse and a mysterious young man imprisoned by a dangerous occultist.
After receiving a strange summons, eighteen-year-old nursing student Molly O’Rinn finds herself the private live-in nurse for a wealthy young man in his haunting Hudson Valley mansion. But after arriving at his secluded estate, Molly discovers that her handsome employer is not what he seems, and most surprising of all is what rests deep inside the mansion’s walls.
Perhaps not what, but who…
A young man about Molly’s age—at least in appearance—is a prisoner of the estate, locked behind magical barriers. Nin is royalty, the son of a legend. He is not human, not of this world…and not like anyone Molly has ever met.
Molly should stay away from him. But Nin is a terrifying yet strangely attractive being, and soon both Molly and Nin find themselves drawn to each other, sparked by a connection neither of them can deny. But as the two become entangled in a forbidden affair, outside forces start to press in.
Because Nin’s legendary father is looking for his son, and he’s not the only one.
To keep Molly safe, Nin must find a way back to his realm or suffer the consequences. Even if it means choosing his princely duty over love.
Jenn Bennett is the author of over a dozen books for children and teens, including: ALEX, APPROXIMATELY; STARRY EYES; and GRUMBONES. She also writes romance and fantasy for adults. Her books have earned multiple starred reviews, been Goodreads Choice Award nominees, and have been included on annual Best Book lists for both Kirkus and Publishers Weekly. She lives in a haunted house near Birmingham with one husband and two dogs. Visit her at www.jennbennett.net.
If you enjoy an atmospheric read with creepy vibes, an interesting mystery, and a romantic subplot that will leave you breathless, this is the book for you!
A great book for your Fall TBR!
The Prince of Mourning started a bit slow, but around the 30% mark things started moving and I found it hard to put it down. One more chapter, turned into nearly finishing the book in a single sitting.
I think this book shines in the unique magic and folklore of its world, and I found myself wanting to know more about the Nightlands and Nin’s mother! I do think this isn’t quite a true romantasy and feels more like a fantasy with a heavy romantic subplot. The romance that IS in the book is fantastic and I wanted more of it!
What’s to love… - gothic vibes and plenty of atmosphere - interesting magic and folklore - strong independent FMC and a sad boy MMC - mystery and unknown to keep you turning the pages - reveals I didn’t see coming - ghosts, witches, demons, occult, and gods - perfect for spooky season
What’s not to love… - too light on the romance for me to call this a romantasy. I’d probably say the romance is a heavy subplot. - A little slow to start but does pick up around 30% - overly descriptive at times, but the vibes are pretty great so its worth it - ending was a bit rushed
Parting Thoughts…
The ending feels like it is open for a sequel but also maybe not? Those that like things wrapped up neatly might not find this book satisfying in the end.
ᴍʏ ᴛʜᴏᴜɢʜᴛs: I didn't enjoy this book, but I wasn't disappointed either. It was just really unexceptional.
The main character is named Molly and she's a female nursing student who has the power to see ghosts. She's a little annoying and many of her actions feel a little bit unreasonable (like I'm screaming internally "why would you do that!”)
I think the synopsis is a little misleading, as it discusses a "handsome employer" who ends up being pretty irrelevant to the romance of the story (mainly because he's bed ridden with tuberculosis). However Nin, the prisoner, seems pretty sweet and acts very much like how he’s described in the synopsis.
I think this book really tried to give off creepy vibes and it kind of succeeded? There's plenty of mention of ghosts, witches and the occult throughout the book. I still didn't feel super chilled though (and I get scared pretty easily), maybe others will find it spookier and enjoy the book more.
The Prince of Mourning by Jenn Bennett Fantasy NetGalley eARC Pub Date: Oct 28, 2025 Simon and Schuster Ages: 14+
Learning to become a nurse, Molly roams around the hospital at night, secretly trying to learn everything she can because women aren't allowed to do anything but change bandages and administer medicines. But a few weeks after assisting the doctor, she was summoned to the mansion of a wealthy young man who was impressed by her and requested her to be his live-in nurse because he was dying of consumption.
Molly didn't want to go because she had a secret; she could see ghosts, and had never met anyone else who could until that night helping the doctor. It seemed as if the wealthy young man had looked directly at the ghost of a nursing student who followed Molly around the hospital, but Molly didn't feel as if she could trust him.
Encouraged by the school because of a large donation by the gentleman, Molly goes to the estate only to find something is going on because there is a boy chained in the basement, a boy whom Molly had seen over the years, but he has never aged.
This story was slow to start, but I was curious about Molly's search for knowledge and her ability. Sadly, though, some things felt too hurried here and there, especially during her first meeting with the wealthy man.
But when Nin was introduced, chained in the basement, it reminded me so much of 'Sandman.' And while the story did differ, there were still a lot of similarities.
As for the ending, I'm torn. I was liking it until the final few paragraphs. So there is a little opening for a possible second book, but I have no interest in reading it.
Not a bad story, and I can say that overall it did keep at a steady pace, but some things felt rushed and not really explained. There is violence, but not graphic, and the romance aspect is minimal, so it is suitable for readers fourteen and older.
This cover is deceptive. Not in a nefarious way, but I think it gives the reader a misconception of what the book will be about. This story is about The Prince of Mourning, but he is not the main character, or even A main character for half the book, and he never wears a mask. However, this novel IS a book of mystery, which I think the cover conveys nicely, and the prince is integral to the plot. I do wish the main character, Molly, and the ominous manor were portrayed on the cover, though.
The Prince of Mourning is a thrilling, mysterious fantasy with a sweet romantic side plot. There's occult magic and gods and ghosts. I liked how, from the get-go, we knew Molly had an abnormal ability to see ghosts and how that connected her to the prince. I liked how Molly was taken out of her comfort zone and to the manor. I liked exploring it with her and trying to decipher who we could trust. I really liked learning about the prince and his world. This was a solid story with atmospheric writing and a great main character!
But I did have some gripes with the story. Molly sneaks around the manor a lot, and there weren't many stakes with that. She must be reallyyyyy good at sneaking. Also, the romance's pacing was a bit off to me. Aaaand there was too much going on in the end without real consequences for some of the characters. I did really enjoy the Epilogue, though.
Overall, I was surprised by how fun and engaging I found this story. The mystery elements kept me reading, and I'll definitely read the sequel if there is a book 2! Thank you to the publisher for providing me with an arc in exchange for my honest review.
I love the New York in the 1800s setting. I also love the different perspective of the Irish immigrant in the US at that time. The FMC is a nurse that can see ghosts but the story ends up being so much more than that. The spooky mystery vibes were definitely hitting. This was a pretty solid time.
While I thought the premise of the story was perfect for the fall season; a gothic, spooky romance set in the 1800s. It ultimately did not catch my attention as much as I thought it would. It was good but, not great. I didn’t find myself really wanting to pick it back up when I would set it down. I did love our main character, Molly, I thought she was so headstrong in herself and would have really thrived in today’s world. With that being said, I do think some of the modern day language being used in a story set way back in the day threw me off. At what point our main character really asked someone “what their beef was” and I was so taken aback that I had to reread the sentence to make sure I didn’t make it up. Overall, I thought this was a good book to read if you want a spooky and gothic atmosphere.
Thank you to Simon Teen for the opportunity to read this eARC.
haunting and gorgeous i want to thank simon teen so much for the arc! i saw it in an email from you guys of some upcoming releases and ran to netgalley to see if i could request it. thank you, i was so excited to read this one! the cover and blurb immediately drew me in, i knew i needed this book immediately. i LOVE gothic and paranormal romance and this was freaking stunning. gorgeous atmosphere and outstanding characters, they were all perfectly crafted with such a visually captivating setting, with a plot to die for. i adored this book and i loved molly and bethany so much! their friendship was so sweet and unique. molly was strong, smart and charismatic. Nin was EVERYTHING, he is my new book boyfriend for sure, i loved him. the slow burn between him and molly was scrumptious. the master was scary and interesting and that twist at the end was awesome, absolutely fabulous book. my only complaint is that of some of the language used? maybe i’m wrong but i figured this was set around the 1800s considering the gas lamps, manors, chamber pots, carriages etc. so i was a little confused when the FMC used the phrase “what’s your beef?” and i think she also said “booked it” as well, which took me out of the story a bit because those are more modern terms and phrases. so i’m hoping that was fixed in the final draft! other than that, fabulous book
I like to thank NetGalley and the publisher for allowing me a read.
I chased after this book because the cover had me thinking it had something to do with masked character (it doesn't). To be quite honest, I have no idea what the cover has to do with the story I read. But hey, it sucked me into reading it.
Unfortunately this book suffers from a lack of staying true to the time period and a plot that meanders and doesn't quite make sense in the details.
It takes place in the late 1800's but he dialogue and the things the female says at times is absolutely ... not quite from that time period. I get that we're reading a YA book that has fantasy elements, but it still takes place in the U.S. , and with characters that come from Europe as well. I expect some conformity to the times.
As for the fantasy elements, the author decides to grab versions of 'death' throughout the world and give them a spot in this story. The reason that the female lead can see ghosts / dead is not really gleamed, and if there is a sequel to this (since the ending screams it) then we might get some explanation. Otherwise, her affinity for doing so is confusing and basically is used as a tool to hook the Death prince and her up.
The plot revolves around her being a live in maid for a man who is acting absolutely nutty after the death of his sister, and is dying of an incurable illness. Meanwhile, secrets abound in this creepy half closed off manor, and the Death prince in the basement make her suspicious of her being there.
There is gothic theme to the story and I guess that's where the two stars come from. I like gothic stories, and true to form, gothic stories should not quite have a clear idea of who to trust and where the story is going... However, I did not expect that to be the case quite literally.
All in all, a lemon of a book - pretty cover but story ain't much to write about, and if it gets a sequel I have no idea what is in store.
I am a big fan of Bennett. I really enjoyed this story - I'm not sure why others didn't. This was a different genre for Bennett, a bold attempt that worked in my opinion. The story was unique, characters well fleshed out, and writing and pacing were on point. The cover art is not appealing, however.
I’ve always enjoyed Jenn Bennett’s style, which is where I think most of the 3 Stars come from, but the book as a whole didn’t really work for me. The gothic atmosphere, descriptions and tone, carries a lot of the weight. Beyond that, it was slow to get going and somewhat misleading. The first half didn’t really mesh well with the second half, almost like two plot ideas that had been mashed together but not integrated. The pace meandered and I wanted to just get to the point already.
The really irksome part is that I could SEE the potential in every page and turn. There are solid ideas and characters shining through. I just wanted to lean harder into the fantasy elements throughout or remove them altogether and just rely on vague spooky supernatural phenomena.
Overall, I’d still call it okay. But I don’t think I’ll continue with it if a sequel comes along.
3.75 ⭐️ read for me. I really enjoyed the FMC, which as we know makes or breaks a book. i love that she has a good head on her shoulders and had good instincts for the most part. Didn’t make her feel helpless and in need of “saving”. I absolutely loved the 1800’s NY setting it was such a fun place to read about and adding the hospital setting at the beginning was a nice touch. Always love “humanizing” a “god” moment and the MMC was an interesting character. I really enjoyed meeting him at his lowest with flaws already there. I wish the final battle scene felt a little more intense with the brothers fighting but I did love all the twists towards the end. I actually really loved the ambiguous ending as well. Would read a book 2 if it continues but it was a satisfying end otherwise.
This entire review has been hidden because of spoilers.
Molly O’Rinn becomes a private live-in-nurse for Charles Voss, a wealthy individual, reeling from the recent death of his sister. Molly begins her new job with a lot of questions. How come the large mansion is understaffed, and why is she seeing a ghost from her past chained in the basement? Master Voss is not who he seems, to free them both, Molly will have to get to the bottom of the mystery.
Stating the obvious, but the cover art for this book is absolutely stunning. Mysterious and gothic, just like the story. I was immediately drawn in by the historical fiction, Molly and her ability to see ghosts, as well as the shadowy figure she calls The Black Groom. Nin, The Sorrowful, God of the Nightlands. I loved the interactions between them, he was an enigma, an otherworldly character, and it balanced out the historical to fantasy ratio well.
I also liked the occult magic and world building, I thought it was unique and quite interesting. It is a slower paced book, but I was not bored, in fact, I really enjoyed the pacing and how the story unfolded. The various supporting characters helped the story, I liked the ghost of Bethany and the odd friendship with Molly. I’m afraid it’s a standalone novel, though the epilogue left me wanting more. I am a big fan of the adult urban fantasy Arcadia Bell series by this author, so it was nice to read something new and more YA.
This story started off so strong with an atmosphere I absolutely loved. The eerie, isolated mansion and haunting supernatural mystery gave it perfect Crimson Peak vibes that were moody, romantic, and beautifully gothic. The beginning completely hooked me with its setting, tone, and sense of foreboding.
But as the story progressed, it shifted focus into a different plotline, and while that new direction was good on its own, it didn’t quite feel cohesive with the first half. It was almost as if two separate stories—one about the mysterious manor and another about Nin’s otherworldly legacy—had been combined. Both were interesting, but together they didn’t blend as smoothly as I’d hoped.
That said, I still found the book enjoyable overall. The writing, atmosphere, and emotional depth were all solid, and Jenn Bennett’s storytelling style made it easy to stay invested. I just wish the two main threads had meshed better, because each had so much potential on its own.
Spooky ghost book for spooky season. A live-in nurse was a unique plot point that I don’t see a lot, so it stands out to me. I liked the dark academia type vibes without the school aspect but still kept the lack of options the FMC had because she wasn’t in charge the same was in dark academia book with the characters being minors and such. Great power dynamic issues but a clear ability from FMC to make the decisions on her own to fix problems that no one else seemed to do for a long time lol. I loved to see her character between acting recklessly and then also doing all the right things and all that push and pull the entire book. The ending did feel rushed compared to the rest of the book, but it wasn’t that bad. I really liked this book, 4 out of 5 stars.
i received a digital review copy from the publisher as part of their influencer program. i am leaving this review voluntarily.
eighteen-year-old nursing student molly o’rinn finds herself in a strange situation following a mysterious summons to a haunting mansion. she is to be the private live-in nurse for a wealthy young man, who she soon finds out is not what he seems. she discovers a young man, seemingly around her age, imprisoned deep inside the mansion’s walls. nin is royal, attractive...and not human. these two become entangled in a forbidden affair, pressing nin to figure out a way to keep molly safe, even if it means placing his princely duties above love.
i’ve heard so much about jenn bennett, but i believe this is the first book of hers i’ve read! the chilling vibes made this a great book for the fall-turning-into-winter time of year i read this. the fantastical elements were pretty cool, from the different realms to the structure of the royal family. the romance was also so lovely, and i adored the dynamics between the independent molly and emo nin. overall, this was a great romantic fantasy read. i’d be interested in reading more from jenn bennett, especially if she continues writing in this genre.
This was a great young adult romantasy. I was immediately immersed in this gothic tale and I loved its atmospheric setting. I really enjoyed following Molly in this story as she trained to become a nurse as well as had the ability to see ghosts. I found Nin’s character to be interesting as well and loved learning more about him alongside Molly. I loved reading this one and it’s definitely a book that I recommend picking up this fall.
So…I liked this. I did. The vibes, the romance, and the story ITSELF were immaculate. I couldn’t put it down and I definitely wanted to know what was going on. It was super intriguing and had a lot of great moments.
However.
Molly has to be one of THE dumbest fucking protagonists in YA history. It was so infuriating how she never listened and then was pikachu surprised when something bad happened. She could literally see ghosts with her own eyeballs yet she had so much trouble believing in other fantastical things? Give me a fucking break.
As others have said, some modern language was thrown in and it really took me out of the plot. I would be really into a scene and then she would keep saying “hey” or that one “what’s your beef” line that we all hated. It was awful. She talked like she was fourteen at times and she was just so fucking childish.
I also didn’t love the mix of mythologies and the fact that there was SO MUCH information repeated on the next page as if they forgot they had literally just said that thing but then acted as if it were new. I can’t stand when editors can’t do their fucking jobs.
But if you go into this for the gothic vibes and Nin, you’ll have a great time.
The gothic, spooky, occultist vibes of this book are perfect for the fall season. I loved how headstrong the FMC, Molly, is and I loved her strong Irish roots. I also really enjoyed the mystery throughout the novel and found the world-building unique and quite compelling.
However, there were several instances of anachronistic phrases that completely took me out of the story, ie. "what's your beef with her?"
Ultimately, I think this book suffered from a bit of mis-marketing. The cover doesn't really relate to the story at all and the romance is almost completely absent from the first half of the book - which I didn't mind, but I wouldn't classify this as a "romantasy". I also wish the romance was developed more gradually as it felt rushed.
This story had a lot of potential, but I feel as though it feel a bit short. I would consider picking up the next book because I am curious how it'll play out.
Thank you to NetGalley and Simon and Schuster Children's Publishing | Simon & Schuster Books for Young Readers for the eARC!
Well I think calling this one adjacent to Belladonna is where this all went wrong. These two books are not on the same level.
I thought things started out fine and I was intrigued. There’s a good atmosphere and spooky gothic vibes throughout. That note did hit the best.
But a few things didn’t make sense. One of those being the dialogue. Some of it felt extremely modern and I get that it’s a young adult book but it threw me out of the story the way Molly would phrase somethings.
The cover lends itself to some kind of haunting ball vibes right? Those aren’t there either. The plot meanders and slows to excruciating lengths. Molly, “I’m a nurse I know what to do” (though she hasn’t even completed her training), wasn’t that fun to be around. And then adding in so many gods, possession, curses, etc. in the late second half had me quirking my head. It did not need all of that. Once again, the lack of focus for the story is when it really went off the rails.
It looks like there will be a sequel, but I don’t know how I feel about it or if I’ll read it [yet].
Overall audience notes: - Upper YA Fantasy Romance - Language: mild - Romance: vague fade to black - Violence: moderate - Content warnings: those dying of tuberculosis, loss of loved ones
4.5 I love Jenn Bennett's contemporary YA, so I was excited to try a YA fantasy from her. This was SO good. I loved the dark and gothic vibes. The setting was just spooky enough (ya girl does not do horror), and it fit the vibes of fall so well. Molly was a great FMC, and I loved the journey she went on from beginning to end. The reveals were captivating, too. I couldn't stop reading because I wanted to know what was going to happen next. The mix of ghosts, curses, and actual illnesses was a really interesting combination. This was a nice contrast of strong girl and sad boy vibes, which was fun. I did think the romantic elements were secondary, but I liked the plot, so I wasn't really all that upset about it. This was an enjoyable read, and I would definitely read more in this world or more fantasy from Jenn! Thank you to Simon Teen for the ARC to read and review.
This book was very spooky and atmospheric, and it was definitely appropriate that I found this during Spooky Season.
It is a slower paced, more molasses-y read, and that was kind of hard for me. Not anything wrong with the book, I just personally needed something that was moving a little faster.
I liked the premise of the book, and I think it was done fairly well. The ending felt a little rushed, and I don't know why I had it in my head that this was a standalone, because it's most definitely been set up to have a sequel.
I'm curious, and a little confused as to what's going to happen next and how things will play out.
Thank you to Simon & Schuster for this review copy. All thoughts and opinions expressed are entirely my own.
i had really high hopes for this, but unfortunately this fell very short for me. this was honestly just boring. i felt like i was constantly on the edge of excitement… and then it never came. it was truly a very odd feeling and something i’ve never experienced in a book before. i also found that the synopsis was somewhat misleading, which may have added to my confusion that i experienced during my read of this book. this was kind of creepy and unsettling and is what gets this book 2 stars, it definitely has that dark, gothic feel to it that i was hoping for.
I love everything about this book. Was I meant to find this as funny as I do? Unsure, but I totally recommend it. I've read Jenn Bennett in the past and have liked her books, but this is probably going to be my favorite of hers for a while.
Full review to come! Recommend this book for those who are looking for a historical fantasy with some mystery and gaslighting thrown in. Have fun, it's a wild ride!
This book is perfect for the spooky season! It's a girl who goes to care for a sick man in an old manor -- gothic at its core. Plus, it takes place in Tarrytown, where the legend of Sleepy Hollow comes from. Honestly, absolutely perfect for this time of year. There is a lot of mystery surrounding the family and this house, and the atmosphere is creepy once we arrive to where the main story takes place.
Add in that Molly can see ghosts -- this is definitely an omen of things to come. This book reads like a good old gothic horror novel from the very beginning. There are banned areas in the house, creepy servants...you don't know who to trust or what is going on.
I really liked the mystery aspect of this book, it was done really well. I did find the pacing to be a bit slow at times, which made when getting to the middle of the book little harder to get through. I just wasn't invested in the relationship between the main characters. I just felt that it wasn't...interesting? There was very little I felt convinced by.
I wanted to like this book more than I did, but I do think it will appeal to readers.
I really enjoyed this, I think I would have loved a sequel, although idk how they would have done that hahaha but I definitely would have enjoyed it more as a series that a standalone book.
Un inizio molto lento mi ha messo davanti al bivio: proseguo o non proseguo? Provo ad andare avanti che magari migliora o lascio perdere? Ero al 40% del libro quando mi sono posta per l'ultima volta questa domanda, poi le vacanze di Pasqua hanno ridotto il mio tempo per leggere e qui il miracolo, ripreso in mano il libro ho trovato un cambio di marcia e tutto è diventato scorrevole e dinamico forse un pò troppo a ben vedere.
Ho trovato trasporto ed interesse nella lettura nel momento in cui l'interesse amoroso della protagonista è arrivato, forse un pò banale la cosa direte voi ma in realtà il motivo è che solo con il sopraggiungere del bel tenebroso la protagonista fa passi in avanti ed inizia a capire e a farci capire che cosa sta succedendo, fino a poco prima avevamo semplicemente a che fare con un'infermiera testarda ma ingenua fino all'inverosimile (si stiamo parlando di una ragazza di 18 anni nel 1800 forse avrei dovuto tener nota di questi due dati ma parla come una ragazza di oggi quindi la cosa mi ha fatto alzare gli occhi al cielo un paio di volte).
Quindi la parte iniziale è un pò piatta ma poi la fortuna è stata quella di essere una testarda e di voler proseguire perché la trama si infittisce e si arricchisce e qui non abbiamo solo un romantasy abbiamo a che fare con una storia gotica a tratti inquietante con un pizzico di mistero e voler capire cosa stia succedendo e se tra i due ci sarà il lieto fine o meno tiene incollati alle pagine. Il finale dolce/amaro mi ha fatto sperare in un proseguo ma non ho trovato informazioni a riguardo al momento questo sembra essere un libro autoconclusivo.
Peccato l'inizio lento altrimenti avrei apprezzato maggiormente questa lettura.