What do you think?
Rate this book
The Spellbound Sisters #2
The Witching Moon Manor
The magical Quigley sisters return to bargain with fate once more in this follow-up to the “charming, uplifting, and utterly enchanting” (Lana Harper, New York Times bestselling author) national bestseller The Crescent Moon Tearoom.
The Crescent Moon is thriving after a much-needed expansion, with the ladies who step through its doors continuing to seek comfort in the glimpses of their futures found in the swirls at the bottom of their teacups. Anne is leading the city’s witches as Chicago’s Diviner, Beatrix is swept away on a book tour across the country, and Violet has found her place with her feet swinging through the air above the circus crowds. That is, until the Quigley sisters find themselves stumbling on their chosen paths, and they are drawn back home in search of refuge in each other’s company.
As Anne struggles to balance her growing responsibilities, Beatrix fears she has lost her gift for storytelling, and Violet is shaken after an accident at the circus, the future the sisters had drawn for themselves feels murkier than ever. And, when the threads of fate begin to unravel, Anne must lean on her sisters and team up with a mysterious—and oddly infuriating—necromancer to save the city from an uncertain destiny and help old friends find a happy end.
With all three Quigleys back in the warm comfort of the Crescent Moon, they set out to bargain with Fate once more. But will the sisters find the courage to embrace who they have become while returning to what they left behind, or will the future unfold in a way that even a Quigley couldn’t have predicted?
The Crescent Moon is thriving after a much-needed expansion, with the ladies who step through its doors continuing to seek comfort in the glimpses of their futures found in the swirls at the bottom of their teacups. Anne is leading the city’s witches as Chicago’s Diviner, Beatrix is swept away on a book tour across the country, and Violet has found her place with her feet swinging through the air above the circus crowds. That is, until the Quigley sisters find themselves stumbling on their chosen paths, and they are drawn back home in search of refuge in each other’s company.
As Anne struggles to balance her growing responsibilities, Beatrix fears she has lost her gift for storytelling, and Violet is shaken after an accident at the circus, the future the sisters had drawn for themselves feels murkier than ever. And, when the threads of fate begin to unravel, Anne must lean on her sisters and team up with a mysterious—and oddly infuriating—necromancer to save the city from an uncertain destiny and help old friends find a happy end.
With all three Quigleys back in the warm comfort of the Crescent Moon, they set out to bargain with Fate once more. But will the sisters find the courage to embrace who they have become while returning to what they left behind, or will the future unfold in a way that even a Quigley couldn’t have predicted?
336 pages, Paperback
Published October 7, 2025
181 people are currently reading
21124 people want to read
About the author
Stacy Sivinski
3 books333 followersStacy Sivinski was raised in the Appalachian mountains of Virginia and now is a writing and literature professor in the Midwest. She holds a PhD in English from the University of Notre Dame with a specialty in sensory studies and nineteenth-century women’s writing. In her fiction, Stacy focuses on themes of sisterhood, self-discovery, and magic. The Crescent Moon Tearoom is her debut novel.
Ratings & Reviews
Friends & Following
Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!
Community Reviews
Displaying 1 - 30 of 283 reviews
October 13, 2025
4 Stars
One Liner: Read book #1 first!
The expansion has done Crescent Moon Tearoom much good. The place is thriving with the three sisters (triplets) moving on with their respective lives. However, Beatrix is worried she has lost her gift of storytelling. Violet is troubled by an incident at the circus. Anne is leading the city’s witches as Chicago’s Diviner and has much to deal with.
Once again, the Quigley triplets have to lean on one another and the Crescent Moon to sort out the issues and become who they are destined to be.
The story comes in the third-person POVs of the sisters and the omnipresent POV of the house.
My Thoughts:
I was delighted to find out that The Crescent Moon Tearoom would have a sequel, and we would get to meet the triplets again. When I got a widget for a book that’s not exactly my genre, I decided to try my luck by asking for this one. My thanks to the person who responded with a widget in just a few hours!
Although the book is being marketed as a standalone, I recommend starting with the first one. We don’t receive much background information, so you need to know what certain terms mean. Also, the character arcs continue from the previous book.
The house is my favorite once again, and this time, there might be more than one such building! Its ideas for expansion are rather cute and funny. Imagine living in a house that decides to add a couple of rooms when you are asleep!
This book is cozier and feels like it has much lower stakes. Yes, there is still a massive threat that needs to be averted. But the narration and pacing take the edge off the urgency. You cannot rush through the book. You have to let it lead it at its own pace. This may make it slower and boring in the middle. I didn’t mind since I knew a similar thing had happened in the previous book.
The initial setup takes quite a while. One of the main characters (a new entry) is not properly introduced until quarter way through. Once we meet the character, things get better. I do wish the arc was a bit more layered.
Scents and teas are once again intrinsic to the narrative. Every chapter starts with a tiny symbol and its interpretation, which aligns with the content. I love these little bits of knowledge, though I don’t know how much I would actually remember!
The book deals with themes like sibling bonds, family and relationships, learning to seek help, relying on loved ones, forgiveness (self and others), and remembering that passion for what we love cannot become a dead weight around the neck. It’s a reminder to accept help, to take a breather, and to accept that mistakes happen.
The ending is beautiful and hopeful. Did I want a bit more development in certain tracks? Yes! However, I still got what I hoped for, so I can’t complain much. A little more depth and structuring would have helped, though.
To summarize, The Witching Moon Manor is a cozy and warm continuation of the story of the Quigley sisters and how they handle the new changes in their lives. It is a slower and gentler novel, so pick it up when you want something soothing and touching.
Thank you, NetGalley, the publicist from SS Marketing who responded to my email, and Atria Books, for the eARC. This review is voluntary and contains my honest opinion about the book.
#NetGalley #TheWitchingMoonManor
One Liner: Read book #1 first!
The expansion has done Crescent Moon Tearoom much good. The place is thriving with the three sisters (triplets) moving on with their respective lives. However, Beatrix is worried she has lost her gift of storytelling. Violet is troubled by an incident at the circus. Anne is leading the city’s witches as Chicago’s Diviner and has much to deal with.
Once again, the Quigley triplets have to lean on one another and the Crescent Moon to sort out the issues and become who they are destined to be.
The story comes in the third-person POVs of the sisters and the omnipresent POV of the house.
My Thoughts:
I was delighted to find out that The Crescent Moon Tearoom would have a sequel, and we would get to meet the triplets again. When I got a widget for a book that’s not exactly my genre, I decided to try my luck by asking for this one. My thanks to the person who responded with a widget in just a few hours!
Although the book is being marketed as a standalone, I recommend starting with the first one. We don’t receive much background information, so you need to know what certain terms mean. Also, the character arcs continue from the previous book.
The house is my favorite once again, and this time, there might be more than one such building! Its ideas for expansion are rather cute and funny. Imagine living in a house that decides to add a couple of rooms when you are asleep!
This book is cozier and feels like it has much lower stakes. Yes, there is still a massive threat that needs to be averted. But the narration and pacing take the edge off the urgency. You cannot rush through the book. You have to let it lead it at its own pace. This may make it slower and boring in the middle. I didn’t mind since I knew a similar thing had happened in the previous book.
The initial setup takes quite a while. One of the main characters (a new entry) is not properly introduced until quarter way through. Once we meet the character, things get better. I do wish the arc was a bit more layered.
Scents and teas are once again intrinsic to the narrative. Every chapter starts with a tiny symbol and its interpretation, which aligns with the content. I love these little bits of knowledge, though I don’t know how much I would actually remember!
The book deals with themes like sibling bonds, family and relationships, learning to seek help, relying on loved ones, forgiveness (self and others), and remembering that passion for what we love cannot become a dead weight around the neck. It’s a reminder to accept help, to take a breather, and to accept that mistakes happen.
The ending is beautiful and hopeful. Did I want a bit more development in certain tracks? Yes! However, I still got what I hoped for, so I can’t complain much. A little more depth and structuring would have helped, though.
To summarize, The Witching Moon Manor is a cozy and warm continuation of the story of the Quigley sisters and how they handle the new changes in their lives. It is a slower and gentler novel, so pick it up when you want something soothing and touching.
Thank you, NetGalley, the publicist from SS Marketing who responded to my email, and Atria Books, for the eARC. This review is voluntary and contains my honest opinion about the book.
#NetGalley #TheWitchingMoonManor
April 12, 2025
The Witching Moon Manor is the second book in the Spellbound Sisters series. However, this book can be read as a standalone. It is full of magic, cozy feels and perfect for Fall vibes! I really enjoyed the storyline, characters, friendships and romance in this book! It has a whimsical feel throughout the entire book. I found it to be engaging and felt joyful after reading it! I highly recommend this book to anyone that is looking for a cozy fantasy read! I rate this book a 4 out of 5 stars!
Thank you to NetGalley, author Stacy Sivinski and Atria Books publishing for this digital advanced reader’s copy in exchange for my honest review! All thoughts and opinions are my own.
This book is expected to be released on October 7, 2025!
Thank you to NetGalley, author Stacy Sivinski and Atria Books publishing for this digital advanced reader’s copy in exchange for my honest review! All thoughts and opinions are my own.
This book is expected to be released on October 7, 2025!
June 29, 2025
I couldn't get enough of The Crescent Moon Tearoom when it came out last year. I loved the cozy, magical story of the Quigley sisters, and I ended up reading this book several times last fall. I was thrilled to discover that there was a sequel, and this book does not disappoint. The Witching Moon Manor has all of the cozy fantasy that I enjoyed in the first book while continuing the Quigley sister's journey. I loved seeing each of the sisters' stories continue as they worked together to find what was causing magical disturbances throughout the city. There was also a little more romance in this book that I adored. This book left me with happy tears, and I hope this is not the end of the Quigley sister's journey.
The Witching Moon Manor is out October 7th.
Thank you to NetGalley and Atria Books for the opportunity to review The Witching Moon Manor. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
The Witching Moon Manor is out October 7th.
Thank you to NetGalley and Atria Books for the opportunity to review The Witching Moon Manor. All thoughts and opinions are my own.
March 31, 2025
The Witching Moon Manor was just as magical as the first! I absolutely adore the Quigley sisters and couldn’t put this book down. The story was enchanting, the atmosphere was perfection, and I’m hoping for more adventures with these characters. If you love witchy reads, this one’s a must! ✨🌙📖
Thank you to NetGalley and atria books for the free ARC in exchange for my honest review.
Thank you to NetGalley and atria books for the free ARC in exchange for my honest review.
January 1, 2026
It was so good to be back with the Quigley sisters in this heartfelt story. With all the cozy vibes I hoped it to be. and a magical story to embrace this season.
*many thanks to Atria Books, S&S audio and Netgalley for the gifted copy for review
*many thanks to Atria Books, S&S audio and Netgalley for the gifted copy for review
September 7, 2025
A cozy, witchy, mystical read with a touch of romantic tension! 3.5 stars!
This story follows three sisters- Anne, Violet and Beatrix.
The sisters are witches and have recently found themselves with a new challenge at hand. They must complete the life task of another witch who has passed away, in order to stop his magic from causing strange happenings around the city and exposing the magic world.
They do this while each grappling with their own unique life problems.
This book is part of a series, and is second to the title “The Crescent Moon Tearoom”. While I have yet to read book one, it did not really impact my ability to understand this one. Though, I do think it would be good to read the first one to get a bit more background information on the characters and to build more of a connection to them!
I thought that this story was okay!
It was cute, and I really liked the mystical feeling. It has very similar vibes to the 90’s television show “Charmed”.
If you like cozy, magical fantasy this one might be for you! This would probably be a good winter read.
I also really liked the romantic tensions we encountered with a few of the sisters! I would be quite interested to see how things play out for them, and if they're all able to get their happy endings.
With this being said, I did not personally connect with any of the characters that much, which sort of effected my ability to enjoy to the story. None of the three sisters really stuck out to be as having really unique personalities.
I also thought the the story was also a bit too slow.
I think what would have made this a lot more enjoyable for me- would be the addition of more ghostly happenings/communications. (I think I just tend to lead more toward stories with a heavier paranormal theme.)
I do however see the potential in it, and I would give it a try if you really love cozy magic.
Thank you to Netgalley, Atria Books and author Stacy Sivinski for providing me with the eARC of “The Witching Moon Manor”, in exchange for my honest review!
Publication date: October 07, 2025
This story follows three sisters- Anne, Violet and Beatrix.
The sisters are witches and have recently found themselves with a new challenge at hand. They must complete the life task of another witch who has passed away, in order to stop his magic from causing strange happenings around the city and exposing the magic world.
They do this while each grappling with their own unique life problems.
This book is part of a series, and is second to the title “The Crescent Moon Tearoom”. While I have yet to read book one, it did not really impact my ability to understand this one. Though, I do think it would be good to read the first one to get a bit more background information on the characters and to build more of a connection to them!
I thought that this story was okay!
It was cute, and I really liked the mystical feeling. It has very similar vibes to the 90’s television show “Charmed”.
If you like cozy, magical fantasy this one might be for you! This would probably be a good winter read.
I also really liked the romantic tensions we encountered with a few of the sisters! I would be quite interested to see how things play out for them, and if they're all able to get their happy endings.
With this being said, I did not personally connect with any of the characters that much, which sort of effected my ability to enjoy to the story. None of the three sisters really stuck out to be as having really unique personalities.
I also thought the the story was also a bit too slow.
I think what would have made this a lot more enjoyable for me- would be the addition of more ghostly happenings/communications. (I think I just tend to lead more toward stories with a heavier paranormal theme.)
I do however see the potential in it, and I would give it a try if you really love cozy magic.
Thank you to Netgalley, Atria Books and author Stacy Sivinski for providing me with the eARC of “The Witching Moon Manor”, in exchange for my honest review!
Publication date: October 07, 2025
October 13, 2025
This book was absolutely incredible. Better than the first if possible. This story forced me out of my head and allowed me to relax which doesn’t come easy. The characters are so well written. All of the stories tying together so beautifully. I love all 3 of the sisters and cannot wait to see how the next story unfolds for them.
March 21, 2025
I received an eARC of this book, so here is my formal review.
I was so excited to see the ARC of this book was already available because I just finished the first book last month. I love the sisterly dynamic, the cozy fantasy vibes, and the tea room. The first book ended on such a high note, that I couldn't wait to see how it continued.
Continuing on with the story, there was still an amazing sisterly dynamic, great characters featured from the last book, and even some new characters that really added to the story. This felt like such a fast and quick read, but that's because the sisters were involved in so much more than the tea room.
Watching Anne take over as the city Diviner, there were a lot of responsibilities for her to take care of in addition to the tea room. It was fun seeing her deal with her newfound abilities that were increasing over time and I feel as if the book centered around her solving the Task of our old friend Mr. Crowley from book 1. I enjoyed this journey the most, especially because Vincent added a lot to the storyline. I really don't like the miscommunication trope (my least favorite EVER) and it felt like her and Vincent were flirting with that most of the book, which was a little frustrating. However, I really enjoyed their journey.
Beatrix was my favorite character in book 1 and I'm so glad she was featured a lot in this book again. I loved her reading journey, her little spark of romance, and her storyline at the enchanted bookshop.
Poor poor Violet. I feel like her story was hardly featured in the book. Obviously she had a storyline, but compared to Beatrix and Anne, I feel like she was rarely present. She had hardly any developments and it felt like she was forgotten about until the end, where she had some quick and massive changes. That was the main reason I dropped it to four stars to be honest. I felt like there was better balance in the first book and I missed having equal time with each character. If there wasn't going to be equal time, her story should have at least been featured more throughout the book instead of just featured at the end.
Overall, I really enjoyed this cozy fantasy. These sisters are great, their magic is so fun, and I love this little world they are in.
I was so excited to see the ARC of this book was already available because I just finished the first book last month. I love the sisterly dynamic, the cozy fantasy vibes, and the tea room. The first book ended on such a high note, that I couldn't wait to see how it continued.
Continuing on with the story, there was still an amazing sisterly dynamic, great characters featured from the last book, and even some new characters that really added to the story. This felt like such a fast and quick read, but that's because the sisters were involved in so much more than the tea room.
Watching Anne take over as the city Diviner, there were a lot of responsibilities for her to take care of in addition to the tea room. It was fun seeing her deal with her newfound abilities that were increasing over time and I feel as if the book centered around her solving the Task of our old friend Mr. Crowley from book 1. I enjoyed this journey the most, especially because Vincent added a lot to the storyline. I really don't like the miscommunication trope (my least favorite EVER) and it felt like her and Vincent were flirting with that most of the book, which was a little frustrating. However, I really enjoyed their journey.
Beatrix was my favorite character in book 1 and I'm so glad she was featured a lot in this book again. I loved her reading journey, her little spark of romance, and her storyline at the enchanted bookshop.
Poor poor Violet. I feel like her story was hardly featured in the book. Obviously she had a storyline, but compared to Beatrix and Anne, I feel like she was rarely present. She had hardly any developments and it felt like she was forgotten about until the end, where she had some quick and massive changes. That was the main reason I dropped it to four stars to be honest. I felt like there was better balance in the first book and I missed having equal time with each character. If there wasn't going to be equal time, her story should have at least been featured more throughout the book instead of just featured at the end.
Overall, I really enjoyed this cozy fantasy. These sisters are great, their magic is so fun, and I love this little world they are in.
July 19, 2025
The Witching Moon Manor is the kind of story that wraps around you like a warm blanket on a crisp fall evening. Magical and cozy in all the best ways, it’s a perfect seasonal read filled with charm and a touch of whimsy. I absolutely loved the characters and the storyline. Also, the book cover is so cute!
Would I recommend this book to you? Yes
Expected Release Date: 10/07/2025
Thank you to NetGalley, the publisher, and the author for the early access. All thoughts in this review are my own.
Would I recommend this book to you? Yes
Expected Release Date: 10/07/2025
Thank you to NetGalley, the publisher, and the author for the early access. All thoughts in this review are my own.
Want to read
September 23, 2025Thank you to NetGalley and Atria Books for an ARC in exchange for an honest review.
October 21, 2025
Have you ever stumbled upon a book that feels like a warm cup of tea with a shot of supernatural intrigue? Stacy Sivinski’s “The Witching Manor” is exactly that—a magical brew that will have you completely entranced from the first page.
Imagine Chicago’s magical underbelly, where the Crescent Moon tea shop isn’t just a café, but a portal to extraordinary destinies. Meet the Quigley sisters: Anne, the city’s Diviner drowning in responsibilities; Beatrix, a writer wrestling with a creativity-crushing block; and Violet, a circus performer shaken by a near-fatal accident. They’re not your typical witches but real women grappling with unfinished business, wrestling with grief, and learning the delicate art of letting go.
The narrative delves deep into the emotional landscape of loss and healing. Each sister carries the weight of unresolved past experiences, their magical gifts intertwining with very human struggles of grief and personal transformation. When life throws curveballs that would shatter most, these sisters pull each other back from the brink. And just when you think you know where the story’s heading, enter a necromancer who’s equal parts infuriating and intriguing, turning Anne’s world upside down.
Sivinski crafts a world that’s cozy yet charged with tension. It’s not about grand magical spectacles, but the quiet, powerful magic of sisterhood, resilience, and finding yourself when everything seems lost. The narrative dances between personal struggles and supernatural challenges, keeping you glued to every page.
Audiobook Insights: Narrator Nikki Massoud delivers a virtuoso performance, transforming Sivinski's prose into a living, breathing narrative. With pitch-perfect character differentiation, Massoud captures each Quigley sister's essence, navigating the story's emotional landscape from magical tension to sisterly warmth. Her nuanced delivery transforms the audiobook into an intimate, living narrative.
For those who crave fantasy that feels like a heart-to-heart with your closest friends, “The Witching Manor” is your next obsession. It’s a reminder that sometimes the most powerful spells are the ones we cast with love, understanding, and an unshakeable belief in ourselves especially when learning to let go of what no longer serves us.
Grateful to Atria Books and Simon & Schuster Audio for my advance copies for review. All opinions are my own.
Imagine Chicago’s magical underbelly, where the Crescent Moon tea shop isn’t just a café, but a portal to extraordinary destinies. Meet the Quigley sisters: Anne, the city’s Diviner drowning in responsibilities; Beatrix, a writer wrestling with a creativity-crushing block; and Violet, a circus performer shaken by a near-fatal accident. They’re not your typical witches but real women grappling with unfinished business, wrestling with grief, and learning the delicate art of letting go.
The narrative delves deep into the emotional landscape of loss and healing. Each sister carries the weight of unresolved past experiences, their magical gifts intertwining with very human struggles of grief and personal transformation. When life throws curveballs that would shatter most, these sisters pull each other back from the brink. And just when you think you know where the story’s heading, enter a necromancer who’s equal parts infuriating and intriguing, turning Anne’s world upside down.
Sivinski crafts a world that’s cozy yet charged with tension. It’s not about grand magical spectacles, but the quiet, powerful magic of sisterhood, resilience, and finding yourself when everything seems lost. The narrative dances between personal struggles and supernatural challenges, keeping you glued to every page.
Audiobook Insights: Narrator Nikki Massoud delivers a virtuoso performance, transforming Sivinski's prose into a living, breathing narrative. With pitch-perfect character differentiation, Massoud captures each Quigley sister's essence, navigating the story's emotional landscape from magical tension to sisterly warmth. Her nuanced delivery transforms the audiobook into an intimate, living narrative.
For those who crave fantasy that feels like a heart-to-heart with your closest friends, “The Witching Manor” is your next obsession. It’s a reminder that sometimes the most powerful spells are the ones we cast with love, understanding, and an unshakeable belief in ourselves especially when learning to let go of what no longer serves us.
Grateful to Atria Books and Simon & Schuster Audio for my advance copies for review. All opinions are my own.
April 24, 2025
Stacy's Crescent Moon Tearoom blew me away last year and her second instalment we are reunited with the Quigley sisters again. I'm so happy that we got to return to the warmth and spooky world Stacy's painstakingly created for readers. The amount of highlighted moments I have for this is book is outstanding. The descriptions are vivid, the world expands, and the reasons I fell in love with Book One continue in Book Two.
I'm going to be a bit greedy and ask for a third book. I just don't want the adventures to end! Stacy's created such a beautiful world that just ensnares me. The perfect read on a cold night in the fall, The Witching Moon Manor delivers! Thank you so much Atria Books for the digital arc.
I'm going to be a bit greedy and ask for a third book. I just don't want the adventures to end! Stacy's created such a beautiful world that just ensnares me. The perfect read on a cold night in the fall, The Witching Moon Manor delivers! Thank you so much Atria Books for the digital arc.
June 19, 2025
The Quigleys return in another wonderful entry into the Spellbound Sisters series that delves into the themes of self doubt, trust and grief. Not only is there magic in the way the spells are crafted, but also in love and connection that lives within all of us. Sivinksi's prose is full of beautiful and specific imagery while still dosed with a familiarity that is hard to deny. I was excited with every turn of the page, and I am looking forward to more stories from this author.
Thank you Simon & Schuster for sending an ARC copy.
Thank you Simon & Schuster for sending an ARC copy.
April 6, 2025
4.75
I received this eARC in exchange for my honest review. All opinions are my own.
While I really enjoyed the first book the second was absolutely enchanting.
The story felt more cohesive from start to finish. I also found the balance of the sisters stories throughout the was quite well done and that we got a better look into their individual personalities and the bond they share. I loved that this time they felt like a team working toward the same goal, and we saw more of the love between them.
I adored this enchanted world, beautiful imagery and the message of how stories & love are stronger than death.
A wonderful cozy magical read✨🫖
I received this eARC in exchange for my honest review. All opinions are my own.
While I really enjoyed the first book the second was absolutely enchanting.
The story felt more cohesive from start to finish. I also found the balance of the sisters stories throughout the was quite well done and that we got a better look into their individual personalities and the bond they share. I loved that this time they felt like a team working toward the same goal, and we saw more of the love between them.
I adored this enchanted world, beautiful imagery and the message of how stories & love are stronger than death.
A wonderful cozy magical read✨🫖
September 23, 2025
I enjoyed The Crescent Moon Tearoom and the Quigley sisters' shenanigans in the first book. This book can be read as a standalone but I would recommend reading the first book before this one to have some background. I did not feel the connection to the sisters as I did in the first book, but it was still a cozy, witchy Fall read. The Quigley sisters have come back home to the tearoom and the magic in the town is going a little haywire. The need to figure out what is going on so they can fix it but they also all have their own problems going on in this book.
-"We've all learned that what first seems like a curse might become a blessing."
-But, like the Quigleys, it was learning that sometimes the best thing you can do for those you love is simply remind them that they are not alone.
-"We've all learned that what first seems like a curse might become a blessing."
-But, like the Quigleys, it was learning that sometimes the best thing you can do for those you love is simply remind them that they are not alone.
October 15, 2025
Some days, I just want to curl up with a book and a cup of tea and totally escape reality, and this book is perfect for that. There’s mystery, magic, emotion, and a dash of romance. I haven't read the first book in the series, but I had no trouble diving into this one. I enjoyed it so much that I plan to go back and read the first installment.
The characters are well-developed and endearing, and I loved the strong, heartwarming bond between the sisters. I also appreciated how each sister faced her past and forged a new path for herself.
The world-building is fantastic and vivid, creating a setting that truly came alive for me. I also enjoyed the tea references and all the autumn vibes. This lighthearted witchy story is cozy rather than scary, and it will charm you!
Thank you to Atria Books for the gifted copy
The characters are well-developed and endearing, and I loved the strong, heartwarming bond between the sisters. I also appreciated how each sister faced her past and forged a new path for herself.
The world-building is fantastic and vivid, creating a setting that truly came alive for me. I also enjoyed the tea references and all the autumn vibes. This lighthearted witchy story is cozy rather than scary, and it will charm you!
Thank you to Atria Books for the gifted copy
September 5, 2025
Sivinski masterfully weaves a spellbinding story about the Quigley sisters, their struggles to find their place, and the powerful bond of sisterhood that draws them back to the warm comfort of The Crescent Moon.
Just like with her first novel, I was completely enchanted from the first page. This book is rich with magic, emotion, and a high-stakes challenge that had me on the edge of my seat. I’m a huge fan of this author!!!
The way the sisters must confront their pasts while forging new paths, all while teaming up with a certain infuriatingly charming necromancer, makes for a truly unforgettable read. This is a five-star tale of destiny and self-discovery that I highly recommend!
Thank you to NetGalley, Simon & Schuster Canada, and Atria Books for a temporary e-ARC!
Just like with her first novel, I was completely enchanted from the first page. This book is rich with magic, emotion, and a high-stakes challenge that had me on the edge of my seat. I’m a huge fan of this author!!!
The way the sisters must confront their pasts while forging new paths, all while teaming up with a certain infuriatingly charming necromancer, makes for a truly unforgettable read. This is a five-star tale of destiny and self-discovery that I highly recommend!
Thank you to NetGalley, Simon & Schuster Canada, and Atria Books for a temporary e-ARC!
December 31, 2025
2.5/5
More magic shenanigans than the first book but somehow felt even slower. It was nice to see Anne come into her powers but I felt the sisters were once again holding themselves back. You would think that their experience in book one would make them wiser and that being raised as diviners would make them more intuitive to signs but alas they're still fools. I also felt like one of the romances was forced, it didn't feel like the couple had chemistry it felt like a situation where the author just HAS to pair a man and woman together because they're in close proximity 😒 Have we lost the ability to write and appreciate friendships? Overall I don't care for this series I found the Quigley sisters to be foolish, the story to be slow, and in the end a couple there just to be there. 2.5/5
More magic shenanigans than the first book but somehow felt even slower. It was nice to see Anne come into her powers but I felt the sisters were once again holding themselves back. You would think that their experience in book one would make them wiser and that being raised as diviners would make them more intuitive to signs but alas they're still fools. I also felt like one of the romances was forced, it didn't feel like the couple had chemistry it felt like a situation where the author just HAS to pair a man and woman together because they're in close proximity 😒 Have we lost the ability to write and appreciate friendships? Overall I don't care for this series I found the Quigley sisters to be foolish, the story to be slow, and in the end a couple there just to be there. 2.5/5
May 12, 2025
Thank you to the publisher for the earc of this book!
Stacy Sivinski has yet again created a wonderfully cozy world to slip into. Just like the first book in the series, I love how this sequel explores themes of sisterhood, friendship, and what we owe to each other. I especially enjoyed the authors use of scent to draw out a unique kind of magic in this book.
The only critique I have is that, while this is marketed as a stand alone novel, I believe the first book needs to be read before this one in order to fully appreciate this new cast of characters.
This will be a perfect fall read when it comes out in October. Very exciting!!
Stacy Sivinski has yet again created a wonderfully cozy world to slip into. Just like the first book in the series, I love how this sequel explores themes of sisterhood, friendship, and what we owe to each other. I especially enjoyed the authors use of scent to draw out a unique kind of magic in this book.
The only critique I have is that, while this is marketed as a stand alone novel, I believe the first book needs to be read before this one in order to fully appreciate this new cast of characters.
This will be a perfect fall read when it comes out in October. Very exciting!!
October 21, 2025
I read this book in the heart of October, and it brought a sense of autumnal coziness I was wanting. Yet it offers more than comfort—the prose has a quiet elegance that lifts the story to another level, making it both heartwarming and beautifully written.
Want to read
July 2, 2025I got invited to another arc! Thank you so much to Netgalley, Atria Books, and the author!
May 16, 2025
Like its predecessor, The Witching Moon Manor leans heavily into cozy fantasy—and while the coziness factor is very high (maybe even higher than Book 1), the pacing once again made it hard for me to stay engaged. It's slow-moving, and for much of the book, I found myself thinking, “nothing is happening.” I'm starting to realize that cozy fantasy may just not be my genre.
The plot had potential, but it ultimately felt frustrating and a bit contrived. A formerly beloved character is hinted at as a possible villain, but then he is…not. Without a clear antagonist or meaningful stakes, the story sort of fizzles out. While I appreciated the quiet charm and the beauty in the details—especially the sensory writing and the way everyone is described with distinct scents—I was left wanting more in terms of narrative momentum.
That said, the house is one of my favorite elements. I love stories where the setting becomes a character itself, and Sivinski gives the Quigley house a literal personality that adds a lot of magic to the atmosphere.
In terms of romance, I was especially hoping for development between Bea and Jennings. We get Violet’s romantic arc in Book 1 and Anne’s in this installment, so it felt natural for Bea’s to come next. But instead, she and Jennings are just suddenly together at the end without any build-up. It was disappointing and felt unearned. Vincent, a new addition to the cast, was the most compelling character to me. When he appeared, the book finally picked up pace—but even he didn’t get the depth or development I hoped for.
Though this is marketed as a standalone, I’d recommend reading the first book before this one to fully appreciate the ensemble cast and their relationships. If you’re looking for an ultra-cozy setting with low stakes and detailed world-building, this might be for you.
Thank you to NetGalley, Atria Books, and Stacy Sivinski for this free, advance copy in exchange for an honest review.
The plot had potential, but it ultimately felt frustrating and a bit contrived. A formerly beloved character is hinted at as a possible villain, but then he is…not. Without a clear antagonist or meaningful stakes, the story sort of fizzles out. While I appreciated the quiet charm and the beauty in the details—especially the sensory writing and the way everyone is described with distinct scents—I was left wanting more in terms of narrative momentum.
That said, the house is one of my favorite elements. I love stories where the setting becomes a character itself, and Sivinski gives the Quigley house a literal personality that adds a lot of magic to the atmosphere.
In terms of romance, I was especially hoping for development between Bea and Jennings. We get Violet’s romantic arc in Book 1 and Anne’s in this installment, so it felt natural for Bea’s to come next. But instead, she and Jennings are just suddenly together at the end without any build-up. It was disappointing and felt unearned. Vincent, a new addition to the cast, was the most compelling character to me. When he appeared, the book finally picked up pace—but even he didn’t get the depth or development I hoped for.
Though this is marketed as a standalone, I’d recommend reading the first book before this one to fully appreciate the ensemble cast and their relationships. If you’re looking for an ultra-cozy setting with low stakes and detailed world-building, this might be for you.
Thank you to NetGalley, Atria Books, and Stacy Sivinski for this free, advance copy in exchange for an honest review.
April 8, 2025
The Witching Moon Manor is charming, atmospheric, and full of heart—but also a little hard to follow at times. Stacy Sivinski really knows how to build a magical world that feels cozy and mysterious, and I genuinely enjoyed spending more time with the Quigley sisters. Each of their paths—Anne, Beatrix, and Violet —was interesting in its own right, and their reunion had that warm, nostalgic energy I love in sibling-centered stories.
That said, I found myself getting confused more than once. Some transitions felt abrupt, and there were moments where I wasn’t quite sure what the stakes were or how certain magical rules worked. The plot juggled a lot—necromancy, romance, looming danger—and while it was ambitious, it sometimes left me feeling like I missed a page (or five).
Still, the writing is lovely, the themes of identity and sisterhood really shine, and there’s a certain magic in the way Sivinski writes about healing and homecoming. I just wish I’d had a bit more clarity along the way.
If you liked The Crescent Moon Tearoom, you’ll probably enjoy this one too—just maybe bring a notebook.
That said, I found myself getting confused more than once. Some transitions felt abrupt, and there were moments where I wasn’t quite sure what the stakes were or how certain magical rules worked. The plot juggled a lot—necromancy, romance, looming danger—and while it was ambitious, it sometimes left me feeling like I missed a page (or five).
Still, the writing is lovely, the themes of identity and sisterhood really shine, and there’s a certain magic in the way Sivinski writes about healing and homecoming. I just wish I’d had a bit more clarity along the way.
If you liked The Crescent Moon Tearoom, you’ll probably enjoy this one too—just maybe bring a notebook.
June 11, 2025
This one was not nearly as captivating nor entertaining as the first. Disappointed.
October 8, 2025
Thank you Atria Books for my #gifted ARC and thank you Simon Audio for my #gifted advanced listening copy of The Witching Moon Manor! #atriabooks #AtriaInfluencer #AtriaPartner #simonaudio #TheWitchingMoonManor #StacySivinski
𝐓𝐢𝐭𝐥𝐞: 𝐓𝐡𝐞 𝐖𝐢𝐭𝐜𝐡𝐢𝐧𝐠 𝐌𝐨𝐨𝐧 𝐌𝐚𝐧𝐨𝐫
𝐀𝐮𝐭𝐡𝐨𝐫: 𝐒𝐭𝐚𝐜𝐲 𝐒𝐢𝐯𝐢𝐧𝐬𝐤𝐢
𝐍𝐚𝐫𝐫𝐚𝐭𝐨𝐫: 𝐍𝐢𝐤𝐤𝐢 𝐌𝐚𝐬𝐬𝐨𝐮𝐝
𝐏𝐮𝐛 𝐃𝐚𝐭𝐞: 𝐎𝐜𝐭𝐨𝐛𝐞𝐫 𝟕, 𝟐𝟎𝟐𝟓
Are you looking for a book to cozy up with in a warm blanket this fall (with possibly a cup of tea)? The Quigley sisters are back for the second book in The Spellbound Sisters series. If you have not yet read The Crescent Moon Tearoom, I definitely think you could read this one as a standalone, but it was such an uplifting and cozy fall read, I would definitely recommend grabbing that one too!
I loved the sisterly dynamic between Beatrix, Violet, and Anne, the witchy vibes, and the touch of romance in this one! The way Sivinski paints a picture of the enchanted world is unparalleled and you truly feel like you are right there with the three sisters the entire time. I was on the edge of my seat for parts of this one, and I loved how the sisters were challenged to confront their past to move forward to create new paths. With strong themes of friendship and sisterhood, this was the perfect fall read!
🎧Massoud did such a great job differentiating between the three sisters and I loved how she was able to showcase the cozy vibes of the book through her narration. This was such a fun read on audio and I cannot recommend this one enough!
𝐓𝐢𝐭𝐥𝐞: 𝐓𝐡𝐞 𝐖𝐢𝐭𝐜𝐡𝐢𝐧𝐠 𝐌𝐨𝐨𝐧 𝐌𝐚𝐧𝐨𝐫
𝐀𝐮𝐭𝐡𝐨𝐫: 𝐒𝐭𝐚𝐜𝐲 𝐒𝐢𝐯𝐢𝐧𝐬𝐤𝐢
𝐍𝐚𝐫𝐫𝐚𝐭𝐨𝐫: 𝐍𝐢𝐤𝐤𝐢 𝐌𝐚𝐬𝐬𝐨𝐮𝐝
𝐏𝐮𝐛 𝐃𝐚𝐭𝐞: 𝐎𝐜𝐭𝐨𝐛𝐞𝐫 𝟕, 𝟐𝟎𝟐𝟓
Are you looking for a book to cozy up with in a warm blanket this fall (with possibly a cup of tea)? The Quigley sisters are back for the second book in The Spellbound Sisters series. If you have not yet read The Crescent Moon Tearoom, I definitely think you could read this one as a standalone, but it was such an uplifting and cozy fall read, I would definitely recommend grabbing that one too!
I loved the sisterly dynamic between Beatrix, Violet, and Anne, the witchy vibes, and the touch of romance in this one! The way Sivinski paints a picture of the enchanted world is unparalleled and you truly feel like you are right there with the three sisters the entire time. I was on the edge of my seat for parts of this one, and I loved how the sisters were challenged to confront their past to move forward to create new paths. With strong themes of friendship and sisterhood, this was the perfect fall read!
🎧Massoud did such a great job differentiating between the three sisters and I loved how she was able to showcase the cozy vibes of the book through her narration. This was such a fun read on audio and I cannot recommend this one enough!
October 29, 2025
Thank you to Atria Books and Simon & Schuster Canada for the eARC; all opinions are my own.
The second book in a series about three sisters who are also witches is lovely and gentle. It's definitely slow paced and I found myself wanting the plot to move along a bit more quickly, which it started to do towards the ends. The relationships between the sisters is the heart of the story, and how they come together, are vulnerable together, trust one another, and challenge each other to grow.
I was particularly enthralled with Beatrix's plot line. She's an author who is struggling to write her next book, isn't willing to tell other people that she is struggling and therefore isn't asking for help. However, help and support continues to show up and once she learns to accept in and rediscover her love of reading, she is able to write again. The setting for her in an old bookshop filled with magic sounds splendid, and is a lovely addition to the Crescent Moon Tearoom, a magical/sentient building that thrives on the energy of the people within it.
While Beatrix and Violet have important roles in this book, it is probably Anne who takes the lead as she must complete a Task that a witch left unfinished when he passed. She must learn to trust herself and others in order to complete the Task, do what is right, and be able to save the witch community in Chicago.
Absolutely lovely and I will be looking forward to more books in this universe!
The second book in a series about three sisters who are also witches is lovely and gentle. It's definitely slow paced and I found myself wanting the plot to move along a bit more quickly, which it started to do towards the ends. The relationships between the sisters is the heart of the story, and how they come together, are vulnerable together, trust one another, and challenge each other to grow.
I was particularly enthralled with Beatrix's plot line. She's an author who is struggling to write her next book, isn't willing to tell other people that she is struggling and therefore isn't asking for help. However, help and support continues to show up and once she learns to accept in and rediscover her love of reading, she is able to write again. The setting for her in an old bookshop filled with magic sounds splendid, and is a lovely addition to the Crescent Moon Tearoom, a magical/sentient building that thrives on the energy of the people within it.
While Beatrix and Violet have important roles in this book, it is probably Anne who takes the lead as she must complete a Task that a witch left unfinished when he passed. She must learn to trust herself and others in order to complete the Task, do what is right, and be able to save the witch community in Chicago.
Absolutely lovely and I will be looking forward to more books in this universe!
September 1, 2025
Thank you to NetGalley and Stacy Sivinski for my ARC copy of this book in exchange for my honest review. This book series will continue to be my whole personality for the foreseeable future, thank you very much.
I genuinely don't know how Stacy Sivinski did it, but this installment of The Spellbound Sisters series is even more cozy, mystical, and magical than the original! I couldn't put this book down and I want to live in this world forever. The plot is engaging and moves at just the right pace that allows you to luxuriate in each moment and get everything out of it that you want without lingering for too long and being overkill. I attribute this mostly to Sivinski's beautiful and lyrical writing style that had me highlighting various quotes throughout the book.
The Quigley sisters continue to grow and explore their own journeys while still being present and supportive of each other and committed to their relationship as sisters first and foremost. The relationship they have is reminiscent of the March sisters in Little Women, but maybe a little less dramatic.
The second installment in this series expands even further outside of the Crescent Moon and I loved the new locations we explored - there is one specific location that I can't say much about, but it would be my dream hangout forever and I had so much fun in this area.
I genuinely don't know how Stacy Sivinski did it, but this installment of The Spellbound Sisters series is even more cozy, mystical, and magical than the original! I couldn't put this book down and I want to live in this world forever. The plot is engaging and moves at just the right pace that allows you to luxuriate in each moment and get everything out of it that you want without lingering for too long and being overkill. I attribute this mostly to Sivinski's beautiful and lyrical writing style that had me highlighting various quotes throughout the book.
The Quigley sisters continue to grow and explore their own journeys while still being present and supportive of each other and committed to their relationship as sisters first and foremost. The relationship they have is reminiscent of the March sisters in Little Women, but maybe a little less dramatic.
The second installment in this series expands even further outside of the Crescent Moon and I loved the new locations we explored - there is one specific location that I can't say much about, but it would be my dream hangout forever and I had so much fun in this area.
October 3, 2025
A heartfelt thank you to @stacy_sivinski and @atriabooks for the #gifted e-book, as well as to @simon.audio for the amazing #gifted audiobook.
This enchanting sequel to the Spellbound Sisters series brings back Beatrix, Violet, and Anne, diving deeper into their captivating world and sisterly bond. I was utterly spellbound and found it impossible to put this book down!
Returning characters add depth, and the introduction of new ones elevates the story even further. The enchanting house, alive with the sisters’ emotions, radiated a magical aura that bound them together in a profound connection. The pacing was exhilarating, as the sisters navigated experiences far beyond the tea room, making every page come alive.
The Quigley sisters continue to evolve, each pursuing her own journey while being unwaveringly supportive of one another, truly embodying the essence of sisterhood.
The narrator delivered an extraordinary performance, breathing life into each character with remarkable differentiation, truly capturing the spirit of the Quigley sisters.
The story itself is a delightful tapestry of enchantment, with a perfectly crafted atmosphere. I can’t wait for more adventures with this beloved cast of characters. If you adore witchy tales, this book is an absolute must-read! Don’t miss out when it releases on October 7, 2025.
This enchanting sequel to the Spellbound Sisters series brings back Beatrix, Violet, and Anne, diving deeper into their captivating world and sisterly bond. I was utterly spellbound and found it impossible to put this book down!
Returning characters add depth, and the introduction of new ones elevates the story even further. The enchanting house, alive with the sisters’ emotions, radiated a magical aura that bound them together in a profound connection. The pacing was exhilarating, as the sisters navigated experiences far beyond the tea room, making every page come alive.
The Quigley sisters continue to evolve, each pursuing her own journey while being unwaveringly supportive of one another, truly embodying the essence of sisterhood.
The narrator delivered an extraordinary performance, breathing life into each character with remarkable differentiation, truly capturing the spirit of the Quigley sisters.
The story itself is a delightful tapestry of enchantment, with a perfectly crafted atmosphere. I can’t wait for more adventures with this beloved cast of characters. If you adore witchy tales, this book is an absolute must-read! Don’t miss out when it releases on October 7, 2025.
April 3, 2025
4.5/5! I loved this even more than the first one! Sivinski returns with their beautiful writing, descriptions, and enchanting characters. While this book can be enjoyed at any time of year, it is perfect for winter. It has such wonderful, immersive winter imagery. I loved being back with the Quigley sisters! Each of them has their own distinct voice, magic and obstacles to overcome. At the heart of this story though, the sisters are all struggling with one thing: getting their spark back. I love all the sisters but Beatrix has to be my favorite. Her magic is so unique and one that writers and readers will relate to. I loved being back with the sentient house but fell in love with the enchanted book shop! Sivinski is a master at sensory imagery. The descriptions of scents in particular make their writing so immersive and enchanting. The story has so many beautiful messages to it, but the one that stuck with me the most is the power that memories hold. The sequel was even more heartwarming than its predecessor. This series is such a warm, cozy, and comforting read. I would gladly read more from this world and look forward to what’s next for the author!
*Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for an ARC in exchange for my honest review!*
*Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for an ARC in exchange for my honest review!*
June 17, 2025
Thank you to Atria Books for providing me with a gifted ebook copy of The Witching Moon Manor through NetGalley. All opinions are my own.
The Witching Moon Manor is the perfect Fall read, and I definitely recommend reading The Crescent Moon Tearoom first, which is the first book in The Spellbound Sisters series. Sivinski's writing is so descriptive and it delivers the coziest of vibes in these books. If you're looking for books that you could curl up in, then these are the ones you're looking for!
Anne, Beatrix, and Violet are great characters, and I really love their sister relationship, and their individual personalities. There are some new romances happening in this book, and I loved seeing how each one of them unfolded. The unfinished Witch's task adds a great mystery element to the story and brings in some heartwarming feels. And I have to say that one of my most favorite characters in both books is the Quigley's house...it is the coziest of cozies!!
𝐖𝐡𝐚𝐭 𝐓𝐨 𝐄𝐱𝐩𝐞𝐜𝐭:
* Teacup Readings
* Magic & the Afterlife
* Sibling Relationships
* Coming Home
* Feel Good, Cozy Vibes
𝐈𝐬 𝐈𝐭 𝐒𝐩𝐢𝐜𝐲?
🥶 (No)
If you love cozy, witchy stories with romance, supportive siblings, comforting vibes, and magic and mystery, then I highly recommend adding The Witching Moon Manor to your TBR.
The Witching Moon Manor is the perfect Fall read, and I definitely recommend reading The Crescent Moon Tearoom first, which is the first book in The Spellbound Sisters series. Sivinski's writing is so descriptive and it delivers the coziest of vibes in these books. If you're looking for books that you could curl up in, then these are the ones you're looking for!
Anne, Beatrix, and Violet are great characters, and I really love their sister relationship, and their individual personalities. There are some new romances happening in this book, and I loved seeing how each one of them unfolded. The unfinished Witch's task adds a great mystery element to the story and brings in some heartwarming feels. And I have to say that one of my most favorite characters in both books is the Quigley's house...it is the coziest of cozies!!
𝐖𝐡𝐚𝐭 𝐓𝐨 𝐄𝐱𝐩𝐞𝐜𝐭:
* Teacup Readings
* Magic & the Afterlife
* Sibling Relationships
* Coming Home
* Feel Good, Cozy Vibes
𝐈𝐬 𝐈𝐭 𝐒𝐩𝐢𝐜𝐲?
🥶 (No)
If you love cozy, witchy stories with romance, supportive siblings, comforting vibes, and magic and mystery, then I highly recommend adding The Witching Moon Manor to your TBR.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 283 reviews