Jump to ratings and reviews
Rate this book

The October Girl

The October Girl Book One

Rate this book
A moody, coming-of-age tale for fans of Miss Peregrine's Home for Pecular Children and Nimona, filled with fairies and ogres and magic galore.

Autumn Ackerman grew up believing in fairies and magic and princesses who defeated dragons, but now that she’s eighteen and facing a future stuck behind the counter of her small town’s coffee shop, she’s starting to wonder if this is all there really is to her life.

But then she meets her childhood imaginary friend, Barnaby, in the alley behind the coffee shop one night. Autumn’s entire world is turned upside down.

Drawn into the strange and mysterious world of the Night Folk, fantastic creatures that inspired all of humanity’s myths about gods and monsters, Autumn is about to discover that there is more to her world than she ever dreamed of as a little girl, and that world is far more dangerous than she could ever have imagined. With the help of Barnaby and Evan Fade, the tragic young boy who inherited the local bookstore, Autumn has to protect herself from the coldly terrifying Mr. Balloon long enough to discover the truth about the Night Folk and her own past.

184 pages, Paperback

First published October 21, 2025

Loading...
Loading...

About the author

Matthew Dow Smith

243 books16 followers

Ratings & Reviews

What do you think?
Rate this book

Friends & Following

Create a free account to discover what your friends think of this book!

Community Reviews

5 stars
29 (8%)
4 stars
122 (35%)
3 stars
137 (39%)
2 stars
56 (16%)
1 star
3 (<1%)
Displaying 1 - 30 of 84 reviews
Profile Image for Dave Schaafsma.
Author 6 books32.3k followers
October 31, 2026
I picked this from library's YA Graphic Novels shelf because of the bright cover and the simple, whimsical artwork. It's the first volume of a series about a girl, Autumn Ackerman, who grew up believing in fairies and magic and princesses who defeated dragons, but now that she’s eighteen and facing a future stuck behind the counter of her small town’s coffee shop, she’s feels stuck in a certain accepted rendering of "reality," One day her imaginary friend from her youth, Barnaby, comes back, , not clear why, and over time, the fairies come back. The Night Folk. And guess who is part of this community? Her mum.

So why did it all go away, and why is it coming back? Dunno. This is a set-up first volume, so all your questions are valid. Story to follow, I am guessing. Not many Goodreaders seem to like it so far, but I like this Autumn, this October Girl, and the guy she welcomes as a friend, and all these quirky, fantastical characters. Set in a small town where life as many may know it goes on, but is for her increasingly populated by the supernatural. In other words, you don't go to a fantasy world in this story; it is all around you.
Profile Image for Lindsey.
Author 1 book13 followers
December 28, 2025
potential is there
in the artwork and story.
but this is just the barest outline of a story
most of it is the main character uttering "tell me what's going on!"
honestly it seems like a light light light skim of a American Gods by Gaiman.

I'll pass if any other installments come along. there is no story here to follow up with.

I don't recommend either.
Profile Image for Allison Pickett.
610 reviews6 followers
January 16, 2026
October Girl reminds me of when our teachers in school would make us brain storm a story. Create an outline. Write down some key points, but not flesh out the details yet. I was not enthralled.
Profile Image for Annemieke / A Dance with Books.
1,023 reviews
August 1, 2025
Thank you to Mad Cave Studios and Netgalley for the review copy in exchange for an honest review. This does not change my opinion in anyway.

The October Girl is a graphic novel with a cover and title that grabbed my eye.

Real life can really suck when you are stuck in a small town and you can't do what you really want to. Gosh don't I know it. Autumn is feeling this a lot as she tries to help our her mom with money after her dad left. Life just isn't all its cracked up to be. But when her childhoods imaginary friend suddenly shows up, it cracks her life wide open, learnign things about her past that she never could have thought. Is that what she wants?

Netgalley calls this a moody coming of age tale and I agree. It has that melancholy feel to it with our main character Autumn who is just going through the motions really. But the fantasy elements with all of the fae give a contrast to that melancholy feel of real life. It brings a bit of excitment and color to her tale. It is an interesting mix.

I found this start a good solid start. We meet some of our characters that will play a role. There is of course Autumn, our main character. Her mother. Her imaginary friend Barnaby. And the local book shop owner Nick. We find out why she is of interest to the fae and why her life is the way that it is. There is enough here to draw my attention and read on.

The art itself works quite well. It fits with the melancholy feel. You can see it in the cover. The yellow back color with this character in blue. She radiates a bit of gloomy and/or melancholy feel and that continues throughout this volume.
Profile Image for Boooks with Tokyo.
199 reviews9 followers
August 4, 2025
3’8/5⭐️ First of all, thank you to NetGalley, the publisher and the author for an arc of “The October girl”. Since I haven’t read the synopsis of this book before starting it, I didn’t expect the fantasy elements, so they were a pleasant surprise! I think the art style suits very well the main character and the story. I found this graphic novel quite refreshing.
Profile Image for Matt Harrison.
396 reviews3 followers
March 28, 2026
A good introductory collection, with lots of great ideas. The story feels a little underdeveloped as a whole though, with the climax itself feeling somewhat underwhelming.

I really like the artwork, and the central characters are engaging so am sure I’ll be back for volume 2 when it comes out.
Profile Image for Radwa.
Author 1 book2,326 followers
September 15, 2025
I love going into graphic novels not knowing much about them, because that way I'm surprised, sometimes pleasently, as is the case with this one.

It felt a bit short and could've used a bit more world-building, but the internal thoughts of Autumn were great, and for once, I wasn't annoyed by a young protagonist.

Autumn is a girl living a bit of a mundane life thinking about entering college and working in a coffee shop, that is until her world is turned upside down when she encounters some supernatural things and her view of her world entirely changes.

It was a fun read, and I'm hoping for a second volume, because that ending was too clean.
Profile Image for Ryan Miller.
1,823 reviews7 followers
January 28, 2026
This isn’t bad … it just feels more like the outline or rough draft of an epic, rather than a story in and of itself. It seems odd to say about a book that seems intentionally sparse, but I could have used another 150 pages of backstory and depth. I’d read more. In fact, I want to read more as I think the concepts are worthy. The story just isn’t here yet.
Profile Image for Nichole Thornton.
419 reviews19 followers
February 10, 2026
Read this at work. It's a beautiful graphic novel for teens. Designated as YA, but fine for middle grade.
Profile Image for Valerie Patrick.
1,047 reviews24 followers
April 29, 2026
"there's good and there's bad, but most of them just need help"

this was an interesting story that was very fast paced, but I wish the main character didn't just go along with things without knowing anything. I really liked the artwork and how, mostly, realistic the main girl was as a teenager. The conflict was resolved pretty quickly, but I definitely feel like it's not over and that's why it was brushed over. I'm excited to keep up with this story and see how it can develop
Profile Image for Nicole.
3,966 reviews21 followers
May 14, 2026
This was...fine. I like the art. The premise of the story is pretty basic...nothing really new here. I don't think this is anything I will remember or a story I feel compelled to continue after this one. I didn't DISLIKE it...but I also can't really think of any reason to recommend it either.
Profile Image for Tory.
1,513 reviews47 followers
May 14, 2026
I liked the art and that was about it. Didn't seem to go anywhere and our MC felt more like 13 than 18.
Profile Image for Bonnie.
1,644 reviews4 followers
April 2, 2026
An interesting premise that really does not reach its full potential. There's a lot of "What's happening" and only a little exploration into what IS happening and why.
Profile Image for Marianne.
275 reviews
February 26, 2026
A magical world with fairy tale friends and dangerous creatures. Looking forward to book two.
Profile Image for Ashlie Chatagnier.
128 reviews
January 4, 2026
this was like several comics in one, rushed and gave you no time to attach or care about characters things happened too. I like the idea but the pacing..
Profile Image for Patty.
885 reviews1 follower
December 27, 2025
This is a perfect graphic novel for the beginner graphic novel reader. The comic boxes are larger and simply drawn yet well illustrated with facial emotions and bright colors. The main character and her mother are someone you can relate to and the mysterious fantasy is about the "Night Folk". The main characters are introduced and explained in the back of the book. There are several new characters described there, so I'm looking forward to Book #2.
2,652 reviews12 followers
December 30, 2025
Although the illustrations are my favorite, the storyline is engaging and the format is intentional. I'm looking forward to the next book in this series and will purchase this one.
Profile Image for Jack Goff.
276 reviews75 followers
August 30, 2025
What would you do if one day you woke up and suddenly realized everything that you thought you knew about your family and how the world worked was wrong? Autumn has a pretty normal life-- job, school, family troubles-- but all of that changes when she finds her imaginary friend is real, and he's not the only thing that turns out to be real.

The cover of this graphic novel is what really drew my attention. I love the bright yellow and the blue and red of our main character's outfit. The art was really nice. I love the sort of simple, sketchy style that it has as well as cool color palette.

This is a set-up book. So there is a lot of reveals kind of right after each other. A lot that we as the readers and Autumn herself have to accept. I do think that the story went a bit fast and wish there was a bit more detail, but this is only volume one. It's meant to be a sort of appetizer to get you interested in the world and want more. I am definitely going to read more in this series and hope that we get a lot more details about the world and all the magic within it.

Thanks to Maverick for the DRC!

Profile Image for Tamara.
672 reviews8 followers
October 30, 2025
Thank you to Mad Cave Studios for this free eARC in exchange for an honest review.

Autumn is an eighteen-year-old on the cusp of adulthood and has no idea what to do with her life. She is done with high school and fallen into the drudgery of a daily job as a barista. She seems to be content with not having any goals, but also confused about what she should be doing, which seems like a typical young adult who is caught between childhood and adulthood.

Her life gets twisted upside down when she discovers that she is the granddaughter of the October King, who is from the fairy realm. Also, there's a guy named Balloon Man who wants her powers.

She has powers, you say? Yeap. Glowing light from her hands that can heal and do some other stuff.

Overall, the book itself isn't too impressive. It is setting up a sort of "Chosen One" trope and the idea that there's a hidden world that Autumn was never aware of. It is the first book in the series, so it is setting up the worldbuilding. The rest of the series could have potential, but this first book falls flat.
Profile Image for Monika.
202 reviews16 followers
September 3, 2025
Perfect story for the autumn mood about a girl called Autumn.

Autumn doesn't know what to do with her life. She's supposed to go to college soon, but she knows her mother cannot afford it. She works part-time in a coffee shop thinking about her life and being a moody teenager. Everything changes when she sees her imaginary childhood friend. It turns out Autumn isn't a normal teenager.

The October Girl is beautifully illustrated, the art perfectly fits the story. I loved the colours and the way they conveyed Autumn's feelings.

My only complaint is how chaotic the story was and how everyone ignored Autumn instead of explaining everything to her. But otherwise I can recommend this comic book.

Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for providing me with a digital copy of this book.
Profile Image for Julia.
216 reviews
August 1, 2025
Autumn thought she’d be living the same boring life, school, work, school, work, but when her not so imaginary childhood friend shows up telling her she’s in danger life might not be so boring after all.

I really enjoyed this, the art was very distinctive and the colours really popped off the page. Autumn is a relatable and overwhelmed character (as one would be when put in her situation) she still rises to the occasion and tries her best to find the best outcome for everyone and is a great character to be following.

Can’t wait to see what more is to come for these characters.

Thank you Mad Cave Studios and NetGalley for the ARC
Profile Image for Tasnim.
402 reviews
September 24, 2025
The title 'The October Girl', the vibrant yellow cover and the character names, giving the graphic novel an autumn vibe. But its filled with more. Autumn our FMC's ordinary life gets mixed with mystical mysterious creatures known as Night Folks. A whimsical start of a series of events to be followed. As the first volume it is okay. I wished it had more depth in the plot building rather than a rushed plot in the end.
Profile Image for Niche.
1,240 reviews1 follower
November 23, 2025
A girl struggles with the ennui of adulting only to discover the world of the fae (the Night Folk) are real. The heroine finds out she has powers and a baddie wants them, he threatens her, they fight, the end.

The art was kind of bland and felt kind of like rough draft sketches that were colored. The story also felt like it rushed the climax. All-in-all, it was just okay, but I'll give it a rating bump for having boy-girl friendship that wasn't required to be romance.
Profile Image for Amille.
108 reviews4 followers
August 6, 2025
How I wished I like this one.
While the beginning was interesting it became very cartoonish almost. The bad guy being cartoonishly bad, the side characters were there and not there at the same time. Plus I’m not even sure what the whole glow-thing is.
Thankyou #netgalley and #MadCaveStudios for a free copy for reviewing.
Profile Image for Blair.
264 reviews7 followers
September 26, 2025
A beautifully drawn world of fae creatures hidden in plain sight as Autumn wrestles with things she never knew about her family.

It reads a little light on the hard-hitting emotions but has Rainbow Rowell energy. A solid read for magical realism.

Thanks to Net Galley and the publisher for a review copy.
Profile Image for Peacegal.
12k reviews102 followers
November 21, 2025
Eighteen-year-old Autumn isn't sure what comes next in life, but she was not expecting to learn that she is a heir to a hidden world of magical folk. Now she is on a collision course with an evil entity who wants to sap her powers.

This one will probably please YA audiences who love magic-tinged tales, but I just didn't find the story or artwork very engaging.
Displaying 1 - 30 of 84 reviews