I greatly appreciated the very funny satellite dish joke in this volume, which is a direct and accurate jab at the general quality of high school drama costuming. That’s the sort of universal experience this manga could use more of.
Scant as they were, I also really loved the appearances of Sae’s besties, who make their usual interjections on the course of Sae’s love life. I swear I don’t need yuri content in everything, but I kind of wish the two of them would get together. They have great chemistry.
Certainly they have more than our leads, who spend yet another volume slowly, slowly, slowly inching forward when this could all be resolved by a single conversation. I have low tolerance for ‘talk and it’s over’ manga, but this offers nothing to fill the gap.
Actually, the problem here is that these two are written like old people trying to date. And I’m not sure if that’s just deliberately trying to stay within the lines of basic shojo tenets, or if it’s the mangaka just writing their age.
Their movie date is okay, it’s not like I hate the two of them together, but they’re about as well matched as an ocelot with mange and a catalytic converter. Why put these two together?
(As weird as I felt the Spider-Man knockoff movie was, I would love to know how those raptors factored in too…)
Then the cardinal sin of manga romance is committed and it’s hard not to imagine the better version of this as result - Yota, the rival, is infinitely more interesting than Koki, our ostensible male lead.
Like, when he talks about growing up in a small town and somebody’s outdoor washing machine being attacked by a bear (this series is oddly fixated on bears)? Give me that story! It’s better than anything Koki says or does ever.
Yota and Sae also have an actual vibe going on and Sae finds him easy to talk to, so that means she says actual dialogue rather than just bottling herself constantly with self doubt. This is the story I want to read.
I get that you love who you love, however, which means we’re therefore mired firmly in Dullsville (retro 50’s slang is cool again, right?). There are also the unfortunate interjections of Sae’s classmates, who feel like encouraging this budding pairing.
I’m absolutely on their side, but it regrettably doesn’t take Sae’s feelings into consideration. So you get to wait for those embers to die out while the wet rags go on a date.
Look, it’s fine in a bland way. I’m kind of annoyed that this is getting an anime because there are literally a dozen shojo that would make for a better choice (would that Hatsu*Haru came out during this renewed interest in shojo anime).
This is so by the book that it could have been written at the dawn of civilization on a cave wall. You’re getting the basic experience and little garnish to elevate the dish. The friends and Yuto’s backstory are solid, but neither is around enough.
3 stars - bog standard. Emphasis on the standard. And probably the bog too, since it’s mired in the past and feels it.