"There is power that is showy and fierce. And there is power that is grown slowly, and stronger for the time spent braiding its ancient strength.”
So What’s It About?
Imprisoned by her dictator brother, Malini spends her days in isolation in the Hirana: an ancient temple that was once the source of the powerful, magical deathless waters — but is now little more than a decaying ruin.
Priya is a maidservant, one among several who make the treacherous journey to the top of the Hirana every night to clean Malini’s chambers. She is happy to be an anonymous drudge, so long as it keeps anyone from guessing the dangerous secret she hides.
But when Malini accidentally bears witness to Priya’s true nature, their destinies become irrevocably tangled. One is a vengeful princess seeking to depose her brother from his throne. The other is a priestess seeking to find her family. Together, they will change the fate of an empire.
What I Thought
If you’re looking for fantasy books about morally complex lesbians and colonialism you now have a few series to choose from - off the top of my head there’s Seth Dickinson’s Masquerade series and C.L. Clark’s The Unbroken, as well as The Jasmine Throne. I think this one is really, really good, guys.
I think this book’s shining strength is how complex the relationships between all of the characters are. Everywhere you look there’s another nuanced dynamic: Pramila hates Malini because she survived the burning when Pramila’s daughter didn’t, while part of her genuinely believes that they both should have burned, while Priya and Bhumika resent each other and struggle to get along despite -or perhaps because of -being two of the only temple children left. Ashok genuinely thinks he is justified in hurting Priya for the greater good; Bhumika almost loves the husband who sees her as nothing more than an ornament and a vessel for children.
The most interesting relationship is of course the fraught dynamic between Malini and Priya, and it is a very juicy one indeed. Malini manipulates and seduces to survive and she does this to Priya, using her out of desperation and necessity. Priya resents how much she is attracted to her and abhors her manipulation when she discovers it, struggling to trust her and know what is real. At the same time Malini is, in fact, real with Priya in a way she isn’t with anyone else, and when she fears her own capacity for cruelty Priya insists to her that she is one person who will not be hurt by her - who sees her at her worst and still cares. It’s a really fascinating dynamic and I am so looking forward to seeing how their relationship develops from here.
There are a few minor weaknesses to some of the aspects of characterization, although I clearly feel that the characterization is a strength by and large. I think Malini’s grief over her maids’ death could have been a little more at the forefront, but she’s also drugged and struggling to escape her prison for most of the book so maybe that’s not super practical. I’m also not totally convinced by the explanation given by the book for Bhumika’s marriage to Vikram - it says that her family’s political clout was used to erase her past as a temple child, but I don’t know if I buy that. I wasn’t sure about Ashok’s decision not to drink the deathless water while on the brink of death and speaking of death, Prem’s demise was not deeply emotionally resonant to me. My final nitpicks are that all of the characters speak in a very similar elegant style and I wish their voices had been a bit more distinct, and that a few of the one-off POV characters felt a little bit cumbersome.
As far as the book’s take on empire, one of my favorite things is that there are so many differences of opinion among the different rebels. Ashok wants complete freedom for Ahiranya and will achieve it through any kind of brutality, while Bhumika initially views resistance through the preservation of culture and scholarship to be the most important thing and abhors Ashok’s methods. Meanwhile Rao and his cohort simply want Chandra off the throne and Aditya on it without caring for the people or fate of Ahiranya at all, looking down upon them and seeing no fundamental problem with the empire. When Ashok leads a bloody attack, Priya only sees the retribution that will occur while Ashok believes that he has to prove his point by any means necessary.
The book also reflects on different kinds of power, concluding that oppression and hierarchy are not the only kind of power that exist - community and protection and safety are their own kind of power. There is the power of direct force pitted against the power of manipulation and the strength of playing at weakness and showing different faces to different people. Finally, there is the terrible cost of attaining power and how its attainment measures up against the good you can do with it once you have it and the things that you have to do to keep it.
The magic and world-building are intriguing, with the deathless waters and the yaksa possession, the mysterious emergence of the rot at the same time as the new generation of temple children, the mothers burning themselves to stop the Age of Flowers and whatever the heck is happening with Chandra at the end. My one quibble here is that an explanation of the deathless waters and why only Priya can find them comes about halfway through the book, and I think it could have come earlier. It works well to have the flashback to the night of the burning followed directly by Priya finding the deathless waters again, but I think that the book could have explained that the waters are hidden/constantly moving and Priya has a special connection with the temple much earlier to spare readers some wondering.
As far as pacing goes, it’s definitely true that the first half is much, much slower than the second half, which ramps up in intensity and features an onslaught of very exciting scenes one after the other (in addition to lots and lots of travel that gets skimmed over). If you can’t tell from what I’ve said already I found so much to enjoy here. This is an intelligent, thoughtful and absorbing epic fantasy and I am truly eager for the next book.