I'm in a book club. I did not choose this book. Not one for watching TV, this was my first exposure to Iyanla Vanzant. I was not impressed! Maybe hearing her talk on talk shows is the secret rather than reading about her life in a book, because all I got out of it is that she is a phony! What she preaches to others is not how she even lives her own life. Phony! Why follow a supposedly expert's advice when they don't even walk that way in their own life? Phony! I personally don't want to take advice from someone is who messed up in their own personal lives.
Did she write this book because she was in desperate need of money yet again? I do commend her for doing so, because it opened up a whole can of worms of her leading a false life. It could had done nothing to help her with her career because it exposes her to her own bad relationships in her personal life. I also commend her for doing so, because it couldn't had been easy, not all at.
I have been told her by friends that she is a wonderful inspirational speaker in helping broken relationships, but how can you give advice when you don't have the same skills in your own relationships with your parents, husbands, or children? What I got out of her relationships is that she is a control freak and feels a need to control everyone around her.
Her life is one tragic episode after another starting from day one in childhood into adulthood. I was in shock, in disbelief that someone could have such tragic story after story and wondered how much can one person endure and suffer? It was heartbreaking and I cried. But, to be well into adulthood and continually blame her father, her grandmother, her mother is tiring and unfair. There comes a point when you have to say what happened in the past was in the past, it's time to move on and make a change. Yes, she says this many times, but she has a terrible habit of messing up over and over again, making one foolish decision after another, and it's ends up being the same pattern that she doesn't seem to see.
There were a few ahaaa moments, but very few. Her story really frustrated me. I was not a believer in God speaking to her and having actual conversations with her. I thought it was more like it was her voices telling her what to do rather than God's, because it was never the best advice, and it always fell apart. It was more of what was good for Iyanla at the time and then finding out it wasn't good at all.
In Chapter 5, when she was talking about the "soul", it came out of nowhere and I thought it was all just crazy talk. That did it for me. "I think it is because children hold on to some memory of what they heard God whisper into their souls". She goes on to say "souls have assignments and lessons". Even her husband tells her "you are not the only that the spirt speaks to, you know?" For her to reply "I am not doubting you, but I know that when the Holy Spirit is working, everything that is given to everyone involved lines up, and what you are saying to me does not line up with what I have been given". That makes me suspcious". It's because Iyanla, it's your inner voice telling you what to do, because it is what is good for YOU at that moment and yet again it ends up being another bad judgement on your part and not the Holy Spirit's talking to you as you claim.
By Chapter 10, I was really done with the book. I didn't want to pick it up anymore. I couldn't take reading more of her foolishness and her pretending to be one with God, while she was messing up her life yet again.
She didn't convince me ever that she was a better mother than her own or that she was a dedicated mother. I think she put her children on the back burner while her wants and everyone else's around her were the priority.
What exactly happened to her son that he went to jail for? It was never explained. There was no talk about her oldest daughter either. This book centered around Iyanla's and Gemma's lives. If I was her other two children and read this book, I would had been a mess. She makes it very clear that she favors her middle child.
The time she lost her jobs with Oprah & Barbara Walters, she ended up losing her rental home too. She is unable to find a place to live even though she was looking for months, and ended up living in a hotel room with her spouse, Gemma, her man & their son. "I was still the only one working full time, and sharing a hotel room with a 6 year old was wrecking havoc on our sex life". To only find out it was 2 weeks. Really? 2 weeks without sex and she describes it as "wrecking havoc on their sex life?" Oh gosh, I would understand more if it was months, but only 2 weeks, gasp!!! She has a tendency of contradicting herself a lot. That same time period, she tells Gemma it's about time she moves out on her own since she is 25, an adult and a mother. Even though Iyanla has been unable to find a place for months, Gemma finds a "beautiful apartment" within 4 days, but then to only move in with her daughter and family for 4 months. I thought what the heck? My mouth gapped open at that!
It seems I'm not the only one that felt she is phony because Gemma tells her and this quote is from her husband, "you aren't practicing what you are preaching" to turn around and admit to herself that "the voice I had accepted as Divine Guidance was actually the voice of my ego leading me right into destruction." You think?
I just thought she was so self centered because even when her daughter is diagnosed with cancer, Iyanla feels it's God punishing her for all the wrong she has done in her lifetime. "I just needed to know how was I responsbible for Gemma having cancer". Does this sound like a spiritual leader to you? Do you think God seriously works that way woman?
She always needs to interfere and assuming what people are thinking rather than asking them. Time and time again she does this.
I felt towards the end in Chapter 19, she was finally coming to terms with turning her life around, but then blows it in the next paragraph. Chapter 20 when she is praying and all of a sudden she's having a conversation with a woman's voice (which I presume is her dead daughter Gemma) is just too weird for me to take seriously. She has this happen (conversations) numerous times through the book. How many times must the reader be convinced she is going to turn her life around? I stopped believing many chapters before. She claims she is "finally ready to have a real relationship with myself, where I could stand on my own two feet without hidden agendas or needs that I did not put on the table..." Whatever Iyanla, whatever, I have lost my faith in you Iyanla. I am far from convinced that she had ever found any peace from the many broken pieces. I think she is far from healing. I think she wrote this book for the money.