This is a difficult one to review because I absolutely loved it. However, I did have some issues with it, so I hovered between 4 and 5 stars. But in the end, I’m giving it 5 stars because I did love reading about the dogs and their people. The individual stories are fabulous.
So this book. It’s an anthology, really, because every dog we meet is a single, complete story, so the book is perfect to keep track of. The chapters are perfect for every dog lover. All of them, bar one story, have a happy ending—and even that one cleverly gave three options for the ending so that we never find out which one was true, though I have my suspicions.
Another thing I really liked was that we got some of Noel’s POV regarding his ethics. I’m afraid that going into the book, I was one of those very people who felt that he didn’t always act in the best interests of the animal. I’m personally against using prosthetics on dogs in most cases because of their short longevity and the months of pain and rehabilitation they have to go through. I would rather put an animal to sleep than think of it suffering.
However, Noel puts his point across well. He tells us that he always puts the animal first. He will never operate on a dog he doesn’t think he can save. Or fix an animal, he may fail to give a full and happy life, with the ability to run and play like other animals. I massively respect that. His love and care come across so strongly—too strongly in parts. But I’d rather read about that than an uncaring vet who has become hardened to the job and loses sight of the animal underneath the bleeding.
In this book, he works with rock stars and the royal family. We meet several celebrities under pseudonyms, and some out in the open, all with their animal family needing urgent surgery and care. There are some lovely anecdotes about the late queen. It’s fascinating and every bit as much about the people as the dogs.
What I did struggle with, and almost docked a point for, was the way every dog in every story saved their owner’s life in some way. A rock star went to rehab to save his dog, so they saved each other. And the suicidal man whose dog’s love and dependence brought him down from the cliff.
The repetition of love, love, love, got a bit sickly two-thirds of the way into the book. And every single story was a runaway success. I’m sure for every one that worked beautifully, there was another that didn’t fare so well, but this book wasn’t about those. A good thing these days with so many people being ‘triggered’ by animal books. I’d have liked a more balanced story—but maybe then, this wouldn’t have been the book for overly sensitive people who maybe shouldn’t read a book from a vet’s POV in the first place if they can’t bear it.
Mostly, I adored this book. I told my other half, partway through, that it was the most enjoyable book I’ve read this year. On a particularly long journey, I read excerpts to him. So I stand by it. Despite parts being too sickly sweet and repetitive in the wording, this was my most enjoyed book of 2025.