Well, hmmm. I had so wanted this to be good, and my own hype regarding it has no doubt caused me to judge it harshly. I had read a few blog posts from Petite Anglaise's blog several years ago, and was delighted by the simple beauty of her prose. With richness, she spun anecdotes about her daughter, Tadpole, and her beloved adopted city of Paris.
What was enchanting in blog form feels both tedius and plain in book form. But the real problem is Petite herself. After suffering through the gross book, "Cleaving" (ala former blogger Julie Powell of "Julie and Julia" fame), I suppose I really wasn't in the mood to read about another selfish woman who drags her loved ones through page after page of adultery, and magically comes out with a six-figure book deal at the end.
I couldn't figure out if Petite purposely painted herself in a negative light (something she didn't do on her blog) or if this is how it happened and she simply didn't see herself as part of the problem? Either way, Petite's level of narcissism is stunning. She tries to justify it in the beginning, painting a picture of Mr. Frog as a workaholic and using phrases, like: "on a rare evening out" and "I was desperate for adult conversation," so we can feel sorry for her. But it rings hollow -- she's living in a city she loves, works all day (with her best friend, no less) because she couldn't imagine being "stuck at home," has money for a nanny and babysitter, gets endless weeks of vacation time, and also has the unwavering support of Tadpole's grandparents, who are eager to take the child for long weekends and vacations, offering Petite a break. It's hardly a sob story.
As a reader, you're supposed to sympathize with her when she goes out with a blog commentor and ends up having an affair with him (a mere two weeks later!). But you can't sympathize with narcissism. Such is her level of self-absorption, that when she finally breaks it to Mr. Frog that she's an adulterer, and in fact, is leaving him, she has the gall to criticize his reaction as unacceptable because "there hadn't been a single moan or whimper on *my* account..." Oh, but she's not too upset to run to her blog and write about it??
And to that I say, is this woman INSANE? And by the way, James sounds like a douchebag.